CRIME OF FASHION
TERRI CLARK
For readers with a passion for fashion (or a good
makeover), the passages where the outfits Cinna designs for Katniss
are described in meticulous detail are some of the most enjoyable
parts of the Hunger Games. For readers without such interests—and
Katniss herself—they may feel more like torture. If you’ve been
skipping over these pages, though, you’re missing out on one of the
most important themes in the series. Great fashion, Terri Clark
points out, does more than look good in the Hunger Games trilogy:
it saves Katniss’ life, and sparks a rebellion. As Peeta says to
Tigris in Mockingjay, “Never underestimate the power of a
brilliant stylist.”
Dress shabbily and they remember the dress;
dress impeccably and they remember the woman.
—Coco Chanel
By its very definition, “fashion statement”
means our clothes speak for us. When a person thinks of that
phrase, they are most likely to picture someone whose conscientious
choice of attire stands out and evokes a strong response. Right
now, Lady Gaga is the poster child for making provocative fashion
statements. Who else would don a raw meat dress designed by Franc
Fernandez and say it was in protest of the Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell
policy? Yet, if she yanked on a pair of tattered sweats and a Hanes
t-shirt among friends in the privacy of her own home, that too
would articulate something about her. Because even when we’re not
trying to draw focus to ourselves, what we choose to wear
still makes a statement.
Our clothing tells other people who we are, whether
we value comfort over frivolity, brand names over money-saving
knockoffs, timeless styles over trendy couture, loud patterns over
the invisibility muted colors offer. Look at Katniss when we first
meet her. She normally dresses in trousers and a shirt, her hair
braided beneath a cap, with supple leather hunting boots molded to
her feet. Kat’s unintentional fashion statement is one of
practicality and function. She doesn’t care about what she wears
past its usefulness, because she is too concerned with survival.
Her clothes reflect these values, and what has made them necessary,
including her low social status and her frequent
hunting expeditions. That she wears her father’s old hunting
jacket communicates her love for him and his influence on her life.
Like it or not, what we dress in is a direct reflection of who we
are personally, socially, and historically.
Sometimes, though, we make a conscientious decision
to use our attire to convey a certain image or message to others.
Muslim women demonstrate their religion by wearing hijabs, scarves
that cover the head, ears, and throat. A recent high school
graduate might proudly exhibit his college acceptance by wearing a
Dartmouth sweatshirt. A teen girl can shout her allegiance by
wearing a Team Jacob t-shirt and a man can tell everyone who he’s
rooting for in the Super Bowl with his Denver Broncos ball
cap.
And of course, sometimes, we choose to convey an
image that isn’t true. A fifty-something woman can wear low-cut
jeans and a cropped top to look younger while she trolls the clubs.
A man can put lifts in his shoes to appear taller. A young actress
can stuff her bra to get a director’s attention. Every day, in a
million ways, we share information about ourselves, whether true or
false, through our appearance.
No one better understands the philosophy of fashion
than Suzanne Collins’ fictional character, Cinna. All of the
Capitol stylists are well practiced at polishing and presenting
their contestants, but Cinna takes this craft to a new level. Not
only is he genius at creating provocative, memorable costumes, he
utilizes his fashion artistry as a political platform that subtly
plays on his audience’s sensibilities. He gives the people of Panem
a heroine to root for, plucks at their romantic heartstrings, and
fires up their indignity over injustice, and he does it all through
fabric.
Thanks to this gifted and courageous designer,
Katniss Everdeen heralds her arrival to the Hunger Games in
stunning, unrivaled fashion and exits, as its most controversial
winner, with equal power and aplomb.
Initial Spark
We know Katniss’ understated stylist, whose only
concession to personal modification is metallic gold eyeliner that
compliments the like-colored flecks in his green eyes, actually
chose District 12 for his debut as a designer. From the start he
had an image in mind for the humble huntress. He would turn her
into ... the girl on fire.
Perhaps Cinna was inspired by the first impression
the nation receives of Katniss as a brave young woman, dressed up
for the reaping in her mother’s hand-me-down, soft blue dress and
matching shoes, willing to sacrifice herself to keep her younger
sister Prim safe. It had been decades since someone in District 12
dared to volunteer him or herself as a tribute, but Kat’s fierce
surrender and her district’s silent salute to her fearlessness and
singularity awes viewers from the outset.
It is customary for the Capitol stylists to create
costumes for the contestants that, as Cinna says, “reflect the
flavor of the district” (The Hunger Games): agriculture for
District 11, fishing for District 4, and factories for District 3.
In past years stylists had taken the coal-mining angle for District
12 and tried to make it sexy. Unfortunately, for the opening
ceremony, this meant creating skimpy outfits with headlamps or, the
very worst, having the contestants completely nude except for black
body powder used to represent coal dust. Fortunately, Cinna is an
out-of-thebox thinker and takes the traditional coal dust/miner
angle one step further. What do you do with coal? You burn it. The
theme of Cinna’s makeover for Kat during the Games is based first
on this idea and then later on the small golden mockingjay pin she
wears as a token. Fire becomes symbolic of District 12, including
Peeta, but the mockingjay belongs to Katniss alone.
Of course, we’ve seen the power of fashion outside
of fiction. In 2000, a certain Bronx-born singer/actress, who
wasn’t well known at the time, made viewers gasp in admiration and
abhorrence at the Emmys when she wore crystal-encrusted panties
beneath a plunging, leaves-little-to-the-imagination, sheer chiffon
jungle print Versace dress, magically held together by a single
jeweled pin just below her navel. Jennifer Lopez might’ve lost Best
Dance Recording to Cher that night, but it wasn’t Believe
everyone spoke about after. It was J-Lo.
By donning that one “look at me, remember me, root
for me” dress she became an overnight sensation. Pictures of her
flooded the internet and were plastered on the front page of every
magazine. At the water cooler, people dared to wonder how she kept
the dress on, while the Today Show’s Matt Lauer and South
Park’s Trey Parker spoofed her cutting-edge couture by donning
copies. The infamous garment has even garnered a spot in Los
Angeles’ Grammy Museum. Like Troy Patterson said in his “Best of
2000: Rock Frock” article for Entertainment Weekly, “She
turned herself out as the fly girl hyperversion of postfeminist
power, flaunting her control by toying with the threat of excess.
In consequence, her star went supernova.” Without question, the
dress cemented Lopez in the cultural consciousness and allowed her
to strut out of the Bronx, break social barriers, and step through
previously barred doors. Ultimately, one dress told the world, “I
may have come from nothing, but I’m something now.”
Kat’s metamorphosis first begins with her being
mercilessly waxed, tweezed, scrubbed, and polished before donning
what she calls “either the most sensational or the deadliest
costume in the opening ceremonies” (The Hunger Games). The
simple black neck-to-ankle unitard and knee-high shiny leather
boots are a silent contrast to the vibrant, fluttering cape and
headpiece ablaze with red, orange, and yellow streams. Cinna also
makes a
deliberate choice to keep her face fresh of makeup, with her hair
braided in its signature style, so she is recognizable to the
audience as that brave girl from District Twelve. When Katniss and
Peeta finally ride out on their chariot, colorful capes and
headdresses burning with synthetic fire, their faces are
illuminated by the dazzling flames. Stylistically it is a stunning
first impression that captures the crowd with its “look at me,
remember me, root for me” daring.
From the get-go it is Cinna’s intention to curry
audience favor and thereby increase the couple’s chance of survival
through sponsorships. His audacious opening-ceremony outfits tell
the audience these are two fiery competitors to be reckoned with.
Combine that with his unprecedented directive for the rival
contestants to hold hands and demonstrate a united front, and he
accomplishes his goal by literally burning Kat and Peeta into
viewers’ memories, while establishing them as a couple and creating
an instantaneous fan following. At the same time, he brilliantly
makes his mark as a debut designer by managing to do what other
stylists couldn’t: he makes District 12 look electrifying and
mighty instead of grimy and ineffectual. It’s during his couple’s
singular introduction to the crowd that we realize Cinna’s no
ordinary stylist and fashion can be a powerful force to be reckoned
with.
Fanning the Flames
Once Cinna turns the spotlight on Kat, he has to
keep it there. With that in mind, he carefully designs a look for
her pre-game interview that invokes power, while still highlighting
her girlish attributes. Fire has long been a symbol of destruction,
purification, illumination, and change, and Cinna
appears to recognize these imposing qualities in his young charge,
even when she does not. President Snow later tells Kat, “Your
stylist turned out to be prophetic in his wardrobe choice. Katniss
Everdeen, the girl who was on fire, you have provided a spark that,
left unattended, may grow to an inferno that destroys Panem”
(Catching Fire).
To make certain the rest of the world sees what
Cinna does, he gives every last detail of Kat’s interview look a
defining touch. Flame-painted nails, stenciled skin, artfully
braided hair, huge dark eyes, full red lips, and shimmery gold skin
complement his dress of jeweled flames. Reflective gems of red,
yellow, white, and blue give the impression Kat is “engulfed in
tongues of fire” when she gives a flirty twirl (The Hunger
Games). From her fierce cosmetics to the flame theme that’s
carried through from fingernails to skirt, Cinna suggests to the
audience that Kat is strong enough to withstand the heat of
competition. The craftmanship of his outfit inspires oohs and aahs
amongst the spectators, while Kat’s honest charm wins their hearts.
In the end, she is “made beautiful by Cinna’s hands, desirable by
Peeta’s confession, tragic by circumstance, and by all accounts,
unforgettable” (The Hunger Games). It is the perfect way to
begin the Hunger Games.
Flashover
In an irony that couldn’t have been foreseen
(except, of course, by Suzanne Collins), the competition becomes as
monumental as Cinna’s designs—demanding attention, pushing
boundaries, and forever changing the future. When Kat defiantly
divides a handful of poison berries between her and Peeta, denying
the Capitol’s desire for a solitary champion, her ingenious ploy
forces the Gamemakers to announce two
victors in the Seventy-fourth Hunger Games. Her civil disobedience
makes her a rebel hero in Panem, while branding her a political
enemy of the Capitol.
Cinna’s primary strategy for Kat’s survival up to
this point has been about gaining favor for her as a contestant,
but at the close of the Games her inimitable spirit and refusal to
bow before the government means Cinna must find a way to protect
her from President Snow’s wrath. So what’s a spunky girl supposed
to do in her post-game interview after she’s survived, but become
the enemy of her nation’s leader? Why, act the demure, vulnerable
lady, of course.
This certainly isn’t a new strategy. Hul-lo,
celebrity court. Courtney Love, Paris Hilton, Nicole Ritchie, Lil’
Kim, Lindsay Lohan—any number of female celebs have cleaned up
their acts and traded in their titillating attire for demure suits
and good girl decorum when called before a judge. The fun-sized
singer, Lil’ Kim, was especially known for her provocative,
outrageous fashion choices: itty-bitty, pink cashmere bikini,
orange plastic superhero suit, and most famously, her skintight
purple pantsuit by designer Misa Hylton-Brim, which left one breast
bare except for a seashell pastie and motivated Motown legend Diana
Ross to cop a feel, on the air, during the 1999 VMAs. Yet, when
Lil’ Kim was indicted for perjury, conspiracy, and obstruction of
justice, she showed up in court looking chic and reserved in a
khaki pant suit, tailored jacket, and charcoal skirt. It was an
attempt to persuade the judge and jury she was more than the
provocative persona she put on for the cameras and deserved a
break. Her conservative courtroom clothes clearly contradicted her
public image. Did her attempt to change people’s perceptions of her
by cleaning up her appearance work? Not so much. The diminutive
diva served ten months in jail.
Next take Lindsay Lohan and her many, many, maaany
courtroom visits. This trash mag queen has always tried to tame her
image with classy clothes. In July 2010, when she appeared in court
for violating her probation, she actually changed her outfit THREE
times during the one-day hearing! Her final outfit, a black
cowl-necked jumpsuit, modest white cardigan, and peeptoe platform
heels, did little to dissuade the judge from sentencing her to
ninety days in jail. Really, it’s a shame LiLo’s stylist, assuming
she had one, didn’t have Cinna’s attention to detail or she
might’ve noticed the expletive painted on her client’s
sherbet-colored fingernails and prevented the fashion fauxpas that
made international news and almost got Lindsay a contempt of court
charge. Clothes might make the woman, but it takes long-term
remodeling to permanently change an unfavorable impression.
Otherwise you’re just putting lipstick on a pig and hoping its
snout looks smaller.
Fortunately for Katniss, Cinna knows just how to
present his champion for her crowning and she doesn’t have an
established reputation with her audience as a bad girl to overcome.
In a calculated move that temporarily confuses Kat, her stylist
skips sophistication for soft, innocent beauty. From Kat’s flat
leather sandals and loose hair to her clear-polished nails and
seemingly simple yellow dress, Cinna creates the image of a tender,
harmless girl. The stylist, knowing what grave danger Kat has
inadvertently placed herself in, presents her as a sweet innocent
child who is as far from a political revolutionary as possible. At
the same time Cinna gives the audience, who has come to love her, a
girl who is a direct, relatable reflection of it: someone just
trying to do her best under terrible circumstances, someone who has
suffered great loss, someone who dares to hope for love and a
brighter future. The sheer fabric of
Kat’s magical dress glows softly like candlelight, reminding
everyone she is still the girl on fire but giving her a more
delicate, non-threatening edge. The golden glow also adds a
romantic touch as Kat and Peeta, hands entwined, watch their tragic
love story unfold onscreen with the rest of Panem. For Kat’s final
television interview with Caesar, Cinna sticks with the same theme
of angelic simplicity and dresses her in a gauzy white dress and
pink shoes.
Her softened image further instills her in viewers’
hearts but, like the real-life celebrities we’ve discussed, her
fashion aboutface does little to sway the person who most matters.
President Snow isn’t affected by her fashionable plea for mercy in
the least, nor would Cinna expect him to be. But because Cinna has
done his job so well and the audience clearly adores Kat, Snow
chooses to bide his time.
The Fire Spreads
Back in District 12, Kat toggles back and forth
between wearing her preferred hunting gear and Cinna’s clothes,
which her mother believes are more appropriate to her status, but
as Kat heads out on the Victory Tour she is once again placed at
the mercy of her stylist and his team.
During the tour, she sees her mockingjay emblem,
her token from the first Games, everywhere. Katniss’ pin, which
depicts the bird in flight connected to a ring by its wingtips,
mocks the Capitol. As the unintended offspring of the Capitol’s
genetically enhanced jabberjays and wild mockingbirds, the
mockingjay is a symbol of strength, adaptability, and triumph over
oppression, the perfect representation of the bold and defiant
District 12 tribute.
It’s also the perfect representation of a nation
ready for change, and after Katniss wins the Games, the little bird
adorns belt buckles, watches, silk lapels, tattoos, and more. Some
likely wear the symbol only because it is associated with their
heroine. For others, however, it shows they’ve joined the
rebellion. Unlike most other fads—Snooki’s poof, I <3 Boobies
tees, and Silly Bandz—the mockingjay trend holds a powerful message
of political solidarity. The public tells Kat, “We’re behind you.
We believe in you. We’re ready to follow, and continue what you
started.”
When Katniss is forced to return to the arena for
the Quarter Quell, she knows Snow plans to get rid of her. Once
again, Cinna steps in to make a fashion statement. Kat’s opening
ceremony outfit is meant as a warning to the President. Despite his
wishes, Kat will not go quietly; Snow shouldn’t underestimate her a
second time, and the other tributes should fear her. To convey
Kat’s indomitable strength Cinna bypasses the softer touches and
subtle messages in her opening ceremony outfit. Her makeup is dark
and shadowed and her fitted black jumpsuit glows like burning
embers. The pièce de résistance is a crown, marking her as a
victor, which burns an angry red. Seeing herself in a mirror, she
thinks, “Katniss, the girl on fire, has left behind her flickering
flames and bejeweled gowns and soft candlelight frocks. She is as
deadly as fire itself” (Catching Fire).
Initially Cinna’s designs are meant to capture the
audience’s attention and turn them into avid Kat supporters.
Further down the line, the importance of that goal intensifies as
Kat’s involvement in the Games turns political in nature. When it
comes to melding fashion with politics, no one better understands
the power clothes hold than Michelle Obama and Sarah Palin.
Fashion insiders analyzed, criticized, and praised
their campaign wardrobes the way pundits did the candidates’ views
on hot
button issues. Obama was praised for wearing youthful, affordable
designers. By staying away from the staid, conservative look so
many first ladies bow to, she not only looked spectacular, she
seemed a tad rebellious for bucking the age-old tradition in a way
that also complemented her husband’s message of change. On the
other side of the runway, Palin was crucified in the media for her
exorbitantly priced attire. From her rimless glasses to her
designer power suits, her carefully constructed image was meant to
project smarts and strength, marking her as a worthy running mate
for John “Maverick” McCain. Instead, her lavish threads marred the
small-town, “Joe Six-pack” everywoman reputation she’d tried hard
to cultivate. After all, how many average American women can afford
to spend $150,000 on clothes? For both ladies, matching their
clothes to their message was the difference between success and
failure, and their outfits spoke louder than words.
After the Quarter Quell announcement and a few
weeks before the Games begin, Cinna has the foresight to design a
black uniform that Kat describes as being “at first glance utterly
utilitarian, at second a work of art” (Mockingjay). The
carefully crafted outfit keeps Kat safe with its layers of body
armor and reinforcement over her heart, but the precise tailoring,
swoop of the helmet, curve of the breastplate, peek-a-boo sleeves,
and hidden weaponry make this final outfit by Cinna starkly
attractive as well. But the most important outfit Cinna designs in
his short career, the one that propels Panem into rebellion and
signs his death warrant, is Katniss’ Quarter Quell interview
outfit.
Coco Chanel once said, “In fashion, you know you
have succeeded when there is an element of upset.” Cinna more than
succeeded with his greatest creation. When the victors give their
pre-game interviews to Caesar for the Seventy-fifth Games,
many of them voice their upset at being chosen to compete again.
Their heartfelt pleas wreck the crowd. Then comes Kat’s turn.
Dressed in her bridal gown as dictated by President Snow, she tells
the audience she’s so sorry they won’t be able to watch her
wedding, but she’s pleased she can, at the very least, share the
dress with them—a dress that, unbeknownst to Kat, Cinna has
secretly modified. The white silk gown with floor-length sleeves
and millions of pearls was voted on by the people of Panem. Now it
stands as a tragic, romantic symbol of star-crossed lovers who will
never have their happily ever after, a frilly testament to wishes
never fulfilled, a painful reminder to every Panemian of what they
too have lost. As the audience contemplates her sad fate, Katniss
begins to twirl and her dress catches fire! She spins faster and
faster as smoke and flames engulf her. Pearls clatter to the floor,
silk darkens and burns away. When she finally stops turning, the
dress has been transformed. The design is the same as her wedding
gown, but Kat now stands covered in coal-colored feathers. Her
draping sleeves resemble wings, her veil a crown of down. She
stands before the audience as a beautiful mockingjay. The ultimate
symbol of resistance. Without words, Cinna fans the spark of
defiance Kat’s single act of insurgence in the first Games lit in
the districts. Her fiery transformation from broken bride to mighty
mockingjay is a call to arms, a battle cry for independence, and a
stand against oppression. With lace and feathers, pearls and veil,
a war is begun.
“Don’t worry,” Cinna tells Kat in Catching
Fire, fully knowing what he has done and what it will cost him.
“I always channel my emotions into my work. That way I don’t hurt
anyone but myself.”
Despite the danger his daring design places him in,
Cinna makes his voice heard. Perhaps writer Eric Hoffer said it
best
when discussing creativity, “Discontent is at the root of the
creative process ... the most gifted members of the human species
are at their creative best when they cannot have their way, and
must compensate for what they miss by realizing and cultivating
their capacities and talents.” Discontent with the Capitol leads
Cinna to commit a crime of fashion. Without question it also brings
about his creative best. Through his work he helps rid the world of
Snow’s dictatorship, and like many renegades, he dies for his
cause. In the end, Kat shouldn’t be given all the credit for
starting the revolt. She might be the flame, but Cinna is the
torch.
TERRI CLARK feels blessed to demonstrate
her passion for young adult fiction as both a teen librarian and
author. For as long as she can remember she’s been fascinated with
the paranormal, so it’s little wonder her stories are a bit edgy
and twisted. Sleepless (HarperTeen) is about a teen who is
stalked in her dreams by a killer and her short story in the
Breaking Up Is Hard to Do (HoughtonMifflin) anthology delves
into mind-reading. Terri was also a contributor to the non-fiction
anthology Flirtin’ with the Monster (BenBella Books). Her
next paranormal, Hollyweird (Flux), will be released in
2012. You can visit Terri online at www.TerriClarkBooks.com and at
www.facebook.com/terriclarkbooks.