Chapter 28

It had taken over a week to get this event
together, but it was still one of the fastest I’d ever
accomplished—and I’d put together a lot of them, all over LA.
With the help of my excellent staff and volunteers,
plus a hint to that obnoxious reporter Corina Carey, I’d gotten out
the word about the HotRescues pet adoption fair in memory of Efram
Kiley—and worded it with the tact of a politician up for
reelection, without rubbing his dead face in the fact he had been
involved with a horrendous puppy mill.
No, I wasn’t the world’s most despicable hypocrite.
I was using Efram for my own purposes, just as he had abused
animals for his. My intent was to get each of the people I
suspected of his murder to appear, to at least feign grieving, and
hopefully to say something that revealed the truth and exposed him
or her as the killer.
I’d gotten all required permission to hold the
event in O’Melveny Park, one of the largest in LA, which happened
to be in Granada Hills not far from HotRescues. My team and I had
brought a dozen dogs and nearly as many cats, mostly in crates.
They included Honey, since the people who’d expressed interest in
adopting her hadn’t yet followed through, poor baby. Or maybe it
was just as well, if those folks were so unreliable.
The animals we’d carted here also included Sweety
and Missy, from Efram’s puppy mill. They were just exiting
quarantine and doing amazingly well, thanks to Carlie and lots of
TLC at her veterinary clinic and HotRescues. Soon, they’d be ready
to rehome. It didn’t hurt to display them to potential new owners
now.
Naturally, the dogs didn’t stay in crates. We’d
constructed holding areas surrounded by portable fencing, so a few
pups were loose inside—the better to put their noses to the barrier
and look wistful enough to attract possible adopters. Plus, our
volunteers displayed them, one at a time, by taking them for walks
through this area of the park, like models flaunting their assets
on a runway.
I intended to go on some of those walks—later.
Right now, I sat at a shaded table nearest the parking area, the
better to see who joined us, at least from the area most likely to
entice visitors. Fortunately, all my wounds had healed well enough
by now that I barely felt them.
Nina was beside me. We’d brought along plenty of
applications for people who were interested in adopting. Plus
brochures that would tell them about HotRescues, our achievements,
and our goals. We also had some bags containing pet food samples
and other goodies from—where else?—HotPets.
We had called on a lot of our regular volunteers to
join us, so they could ask our standard questions of potential
adopters. I still needed to personally approve each adoption.
Although it happened sometimes at our pet fairs, none would be
finalized that day. But we often had success in getting people to
become excited about animals they met at this kind of event and
start the adoption process.
“This is such a good idea, Lauren.” Nina’s pleasure
was contagious. Or maybe I just felt really proud of myself,
killing two or more birds with one of this park’s stones. With
luck, some of our residents would find new forever homes, thanks to
this event.
And with even more luck, I’d get myself off the
hook as a suspect in Efram’s murder.
“Thanks,” I said to Nina. “I just hope we’re really
successful.” In all ways.
I decided to practice my intended routine on Nina.
I did, after all, still maintain a page on her in my suspect file.
Even though she was one of those I wanted in the worst way not to
be guilty.
“I hope it’s not too tacky making this a memorial
for Efram,” I said. I hadn’t expressly discussed it with my second
in command before. I’d just told her that this was what I intended
to do, then expressed my desire for her to help with it. “But my
hope is that it’ll show what he himself never seemed to grasp: pets
need to be taken care of, not harmed, and not left in shelters
without someone to love them.”
“That’s what I thought you meant.” Nina’s face
looked as bright and enthusiastic as I’d ever seen her. Her long
brown hair was pulled back in a clip, emphasizing the leanness of
her cheeks. Her curviness filled out her HotRescues T-shirt. I’d
wondered often if she ever considered dating again. Despite my
recent moments with Matt, I rarely did, and my miserable excuse for
an ex-husband hadn’t abused me.
“I’ve thought long and hard about who could have
killed him,” I continued. “Of course murder’s a heinous thing,
especially since whoever did it is apparently willing to let me
take the rap. But I can certainly understand why someone was angry
enough with a man like him to wish him harm, don’t you?”
She looked at me with a defeated expression that
suggested she thought I was about to accuse her. Which I wasn’t . .
. directly.
“You know I do,” she said quietly. “I hated him
because of what he did to animals, and because he threatened me for
telling you about the puppy mill rescue. I wasn’t as sad as I
should have been about what happened to him. But . . . I couldn’t
have done it, even if I’d wished I could.”
“Of course,” I said.
An older couple approached our table, which sent a
wave of ambivalence through me. This conversation was over, at
least for now. And although I realized that Nina could be lying, I
didn’t think so. I’d learned enough about her over the year she’d
been working for me to get a sense of when she was fudging the
truth.
I sent her off with the couple, who seemed
emotionally overwhelmed about seeing so many homeless animals here.
I had the impression they’d never visited a shelter. Did they want
a pet? Maybe they would now, even if they hadn’t considered one
before.
The area was crowded now with people who didn’t
stay on any paths but approached the dog enclosures and cat crates
with oohs and aahs I could hear from far away. Surely some of them
would fall immediately and madly in love—hopefully good people
who’d pass our adoption scrutiny. At least the weather was on our
side, which it usually was in LA. Not too hot and not too cold;
just right for attracting people to stroll around and, hopefully,
fall for the pets of their dreams.
Our animal shrink, Dr. Mona Harvey, was there,
flitting from one enclosure to the next. I was able to chat with
her along with our vet tech, Angie Shayde, giving them similar
spiels to what I’d talked with Nina about. They hadn’t liked
Efram—or at least what he’d done—any better than I had. Admit here
to killing him? Not quite.
I saw Captain Matt Kingston approaching from the
side of our festival. He was another person I’d intended to sound
out about how he felt about a memorial for Efram—and whether he
could have been involved in the event that generated it.
He, even more than Nina, seemed to have no alibi
for the night Efram was killed, or for the ensuing dangerous
situations at HotRescues. He clearly had despised Efram as much as
I had. But kill him?
Well, someone had, and the thing I was surest of
was that it wasn’t me.
Matt had come in his official Animal Services
uniform—khaki shirt, green slacks, and jacket with appropriate
badge and patch.
He stopped long before he got to me and knelt
outside one of the fenced-in areas. I stood. As I’d thought, that
was the place that the animals from the puppy mill were now
enclosed. I guessed he was doing his official duty and making sure
they were well cared for.
Motioning to Bev, who’d just finished walking a
sheltie mix, to take my place at the table, I headed toward Matt.
He was still on his knees, his hand inside the enclosure where
Missy and Sweety vied to sniff it. He turned his too sexy grin from
them toward me.
“Glad you could make it,” I told him. “There’s been
some interest in adopting those guys, but it’s too soon. I’ll let
you know if anything comes of it.”
“Great.” He stood to face me. I’d noticed before
how much taller than me he was, but he now seemed to marshal his
height and stare down. “What’s this really about, Lauren? A
memorial for a guy you despised?”
“It’s intended to send a message,” I said coolly.
“That even if he couldn’t be rehabilitated while alive, at least
there can be happy endings for some of the animals he abused. You
know HotRescues would love to take in more of the moms, dads, or
pups that were saved from the puppy mill, when Animal Services is
ready for them to leave.”
“Right.” Matt cocked his head slightly, watching as
if attempting to read what was actually inside my brain.
I could give him a hint . . . “Don’t you think that
might be what the person who killed him intended? I mean, to teach
not only him, but others who abused animals a lesson.” My turn to
scrutinize him for a reaction.
“Sounds like a stretch,” he said. “But even so, I
hope you’re successful here today.”
Me, too, I thought—in both of my endeavors.
Matt’s attitude and words had neither made him more
of a suspect or less. I still had to mistrust him, for reasons
including the Animal Services paperwork found near the back
entrance on the day the pit bull had mysteriously appeared, but I
didn’t really want to.
A tall, thin guy in shorts and sleeveless T-shirt
jogged up to us. His dog, too—a leashed and panting Border collie.
“Hi,” the guy said, addressing Matt. “What’s going on here?”
Matt quickly explained the adoption event while I
bent and petted his companion. She looked up at me, and I smiled
back. This obviously was a loved dog, and I sensed she understood
how much better she had it than her enclosed cohorts around
here.
As the two loped off, I watched, then realized Matt
was watching me. “Cute,” I said. “And smart.”
“Border collie,” he responded. I nodded, hoping my
wistfulness didn’t show. There was something about that kind of dog
that spoke to me without saying a word. If ever I were to adopt a
dog again myself . . . but not now.
Matt began to walk away, glancing back as if he
assumed I would follow. I didn’t—mostly because I’d just spotted
another of the people I’d hoped would be here that day, Ed Bransom
of EverySecurity. He didn’t look as if he was there in any official
role for his company, since he wore an LA Dodgers T-shirt over
jeans. Since I’d seen him most often in his dark green uniform, I
was a little surprised to see that he had well-toned muscles. I
supposed that made sense for someone who was in the business of
keeping customers safe.
It also moved him higher in my suspect assessment.
The knife that had killed Efram was sharp, but even so, the person
who’d wielded it needed strength behind it. Plus, it had taken some
strength to move those pet food bags around for the Honey
incident.
Whatever his reason for being there, it apparently
wasn’t because he intended to adopt a pet. Nor had I called him to
help with any security here.
“Hello, Lauren,” he said. “What the hell is going
on? I’ve heard from our main office that Dante DeFrancisco is
considering other security companies for HotPets and your little
shelter. Is that your doing?”
Yes, I’d finally had a conversation with Dante.
Despite his long-term friendship with the EverySecurity CEO, he’d
promised to consider alternatives . . . under the
circumstances.
“I think it’s a wise course of action,” I told him.
“You seem to have the idea that everything your company should have
prevented at HotRescues was my doing. It wasn’t. A parting of the
ways is more than appropriate.”
I still hadn’t heard a viable explanation or excuse
for the slipup in the Honey matter—except to blame me. Plus,
Bransom also blamed me, vocally, for the unwelcome pit bull visit.
Even if he was innocent of everything that had happened, he
couldn’t have been surprised that I wanted his company gone. But
the fact that Dante so far was on my side and was looking at other
options for his entire business empire? That might have annoyed
this dismal excuse for a security advisor, more than a
little.
Another reason for him to become an even weightier
suspect. Yet why would he have killed Efram in the first place?
Just because the guy had shown up at HotRescues in the middle of
the night? Bransom didn’t appear to care whether someone was
abusing animals, unless he was paid to pretend to give a damn. But
to protect his own butt, or his job . . . ?
He took a step toward me. Maybe I should have acted
cowed and stepped back, but I didn’t. I stared him right in the
eye.
“You’d better watch what you say. We’ve had this
account sewed up for a long time, and you’re not going to ruin
it.”
“I think that you’ve managed to do that yourself,”
I said, then turned and walked away.
And practically felt the daggers from his glare
piercing my back like the HotRescues feed knives.
Oh, yes, this man was one person I definitely
suspected.

I took a quick potty break and returned to the
adoption area near the far side, where that very pit bull was in a
nice, roomy crate—all by himself, of course. Si was near him,
sitting on a folding chair. As I approached, he jumped to his
feet.
“Lauren, I’ve been hoping to get you over here. I
want to show you my progress with Perry.”
“Perry?”
“I thought that Perry the pit bull mix would sound
cute and not especially scary.”
“Got it.”
As Si bent to open the crate and leash Perry, I
looked around. The park was still full of visitors. I crossed my
fingers, hoping that Perry wouldn’t attack anyone else. Including
me.
I noticed Matt watching from a distance. He hurried
in our direction as Si brought the nearly all white dog out. I
appreciated Matt’s concern. Was it for me or for everyone here, as
part of his Animal Services responsibilities? Probably both.
Whichever, it made me feel good.
Si noticed him, too, and glared. “Please stay
back,” he said. “Everything’s under control.”
And it was. Si put Perry through an amazing array
of commands, from the usual “sit” and “down” to “shake” and even
“beg.”
“You did this in a week?” I said in
amazement.
“He knew some of it. Whoever his owner may have
been before, he’d apparently had some training. I’ve found that the
more I work him out, the less aggressive he is. He’s not for a
household with kids or other pets, but he’s a good candidate for
adoption.”
“One more test.” I’m not usually wimpy when it
comes to being around any kinds of animals, but Perry had been one
nasty canine to me before. I approached him slowly, my hand out in
a nonthreatening manner, but half expected him to go back into
snarl and growl mode.
He didn’t. In fact, his tongue flopped out of his
mouth as I petted him.
As I stepped back, I smiled at Si and gave him a
brief hug—making sure that Perry didn’t take it as a threatening
gesture toward his new master. “You’re fantastic!” I told Si.
“Don’t you think so, Perry?”
The dog I’d feared so much previously just seemed
to smile.
I visited the cat area next and was thrilled to
learn from Nina and a couple of our volunteers that half of the
kitties we’d brought here were likely to be rehomed, once I
approved the applications. I wanted to hug them all in
congratulations. But that was when I spotted two more people I’d
hoped would show up that day, thanks to my e-mailed invitations:
the Shaheens.
Patsy and Bradley looked bemused when I greeted
them, then showed them the two parent dogs from their puppy mill.
“We haven’t found new homes for them yet,” I told the couple I
despised. “Too soon. But we will when it’s appropriate.”
Patsy again put on her act of loving them all and
missing them. And blaming Efram for everything.
I again thought how convenient, since he was dead.
Possibly at her hands, or her husband’s.
We were joined then by Efram’s stepmother and
girlfriend, whom I’d also invited. Apparently the Shaheens knew
Mandy Ledinger and Shellie Benudo. Maybe they’d met Efram’s
stepmother and girlfriend at his funeral, if not before.
Smiling a lot and keeping my digs at them
ambiguous, I told them my reason for holding this adoption event in
Efram’s honor. Did they buy it? Maybe.
The Shaheens still seemed affronted that I would
equate their actions with Efram’s supposed really bad animal abuse
in throwing puppies into a storm drain. After all, they’d merely
tortured dogs and their offspring by untenable conditions.
Mandy and Shellie seemed to accept the situation
with more grace, although they still maintained that Efram had done
nothing wrong. Holding an event like this to help counter anything
he had allegedly done was insulting to his memory.
Had any of them killed him? A definite maybe,
considering their respective attitudes—although they seemed more
angry with me than with Efram. Could any of them have tried to
cover it up by the ensuing shenanigans that had taken place at
HotRescues? Yes, if Efram had demonstrated how to get in and
circumvent the security, including the cameras.
But no one yet knew where Perry had come from or
how he’d gotten loose on the premises. That could be the key.
Or not.
Later, we returned to HotRescues with all the
animals, including those who were likely now to be adopted. I
helped to get them into their enclosures once more, then started
the administrative work to sign them each back in again.
We’d had a fairly successful day, with quite a few
potential rehomings—although I would definitely follow up as
quickly as possible with visits to make sure the adopters were as
kind and caring as they’d professed on their applications and in
person. I’d also make sure they had the suitable facilities they’d
described for their new pets.
I realized several things as I returned to my
office and collapsed.
A few people I’d hoped to see there, including
James Remseyer, Efram’s attorney, hadn’t shown up. That didn’t gain
him any brownie points with me. He was still a suspect.
The other thing that I found particularly
interesting—and disturbing? Well, I’d heard stories of how Dante’s
lady friend, Kendra Ballantyne, the lawyer, had solved quite a few
murder cases. She’d done it in odd ways, setting things up, often,
to have animals she was pet-sitting involved in the
resolution.
I’d done something similar today. I’d hoped for an
equally good result, determining once and for all who’d murdered
Efram.
But despite such a good day in so many other ways,
especially for some of our former HotRescues animals, I still felt
no closer to determining the killer.