Introduction
Psychology began to arrive in the
Middle East in the early twentieth century. However, some countries
advanced more quickly and have developed professional psychology
more than others. For example, there are large differences among
the various countries in the Middle East in the numbers of
psychologists. This chapter provides an overview and description of
the current state of clinical psychology in the Middle East. The
Middle East is a region that runs from Egypt in the southwest to
Turkey in the northwest to Iran in the northeast and Oman in the
southeast.1
Descriptions are mostly based on an informal survey of
professionals which included communications with professionals in
each country via email and Skype; we assume that the clinical
psychologists surveyed here reflect general perspectives about the
field in each country, but we could not verify the information
obtained. For each country, we describe (where available): (1) the
field’s historical development with the country; (2) clinical
psychologists’ training, academic and professional requirements,
and employment settings; (3) the numbers of psychologists employed
in the mental health sector (according to a survey conducted by the
World Health Organization in 2014 (World Health Organization,
Substance Use of Mental Health, 2014) and according to our informal survey
results); dominant theoretical orientations used in the country,
and religious and cultural context in each country. Given the
similarities in responses that we received about stigma and
cultural/religious context of dealing with clinical psychology and
mental health issues in Arab-speaking countries and Iran (all of
whom are majority Muslim countries), we start by reporting a review
of these issues and follow with a review of the specifics of
clinical psychology in each country. Finally, this chapter
discusses the obstacles and challenges that face the discipline and
may potentially affect the future of clinical psychology in the
Middle East.
Culture, Religion, and Mental Health
Cultural and religious beliefs
influence the manifestation and treatment of mental health in most
countries in the Middle East. As a result of these beliefs, there
is a lack of awareness regarding the profession of clinical
psychology and what it can offer, and a negative attitude towards
seeking professional help instead of seeking help via religious
clergy, friends, or family members. Social
stigma regarding mental illness and
its treatment is common in these countries. This stigma likely
exacerbates negative attitudes and reactions towards individuals
with psychological disorders in the Arab communities and affects
the health and well-being of these individuals. For instance,
individuals with mental illness are often socially rejected,
experience more divorce, and have a tendency to not get married
(Dalky, 2012). Often, this stigma
prevents individuals from seeking treatment (if they do decide to
obtain help, they do so secretly) because of the belief that
undergoing treatment for mental illness is shameful or fear that
the individual seeking treatment may be perceived as “going crazy”
(Almazeedi & Alsuwaidan, 2014).
However, in some countries, such as in Iran, mental illness has
recently become less of a stigma because of the increasing belief
that life experiences (traumatic events and life stressors) can
cause mental disorders.
Besides stigma, other cultural and
social factors impact the perception of mental
health in Arab countries. For instance, in Kuwait, concerns about
breaches of confidentiality, the Kuwaiti people’s perception that
mental illness is shameful, and the way people tend to spread
rumors about mentally ill individuals in Kuwaiti society all
seem to negatively impact the experiences of those individuals who
seek treatment (Scull, Khullar,
Al-Awadhi, & Erheim, 2014).
Similar to social factors, religion
appears to play an important role in
Muslims lives. Mental disorders may not
be accepted among individuals due to the belief that mental health
issues result from religious (Okasha, Karam, & Okasha,
2012) and traditional sources such
as spiritual forces (Jinn),
contemptuous envy (Hassad),
and sorcery (Sihr). For
example, the Arabic term waswas is used in both psychological
and religious contexts in reference to obsessions. Waswas refers to
“insinuating whispers” of the shaytan (Devil). According to the
Islam, the devil tries to control the believer and make the
individual doubt the existence of Allah (God), as well as other
basic religious beliefs in religion. Thus, there is a form of
intrusive religious thoughts that are described in Islam, and the
typical adherent will seek treatment or advice by clergy. This
phenomenon is close to the intrusive, heretical thoughts that can
characterize scrupulosity, a religious form of obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) .
There are suggestions in the literature
that Islamic practice and rituals may
interfere with therapy , and it is
unacceptable to replace the time of prayers with any other activity
such as psychotherapy. For example, cleaning rituals are practiced
by conservative religious Muslims for the purpose of praying
(Baidas, 2012), and this may
elevate the likelihood of OCD manifesting in such a way. This
religious outlook could affect therapeutic alliances and compliance
and, in turn, affect clients negatively (Alqahtani & Altamimi,
2016; Miller & Thoresen,
2003). Other Islamic rules
, such as not
allowing a male stranger in the same room as a woman, could
decrease acceptance of clinical psychology given that most
psychologists are women. Although allowing another mental health
professional to be present usually solves this problem,
confidentiality could then become an issue (Alqahtani &
Altamimi, 2016; El-Islam,
2008). There have been suggestions
in the literature that cultural practices such as wearing a hijab
could limit the therapy outcome and affect the therapeutic alliance
negatively. For example, wearing hijab and covering the face could
prevent the therapist from understanding facial expressions and,
therefore, the client (Alqahtani & Altamimi, 2016; Inhorn & Serour, 2011). While there have been recent attempts to
integrate religion and psychology, more collaboration is needed
between mental health providers and religious leaders to emphasize
the important role of psychologists (Ahmed, 2004; Amer, 2013). On the other hand, religious thoughts may
have a positive impact on psychological treatment as it can
facilitate the development of coping skills during treatment and
even attendance. For example, religious
counseling is associated with psychotherapy treatment in the
United Arab Emirates (UAE). In addition, using CBT techniques in
therapy could be beneficial for Muslim clients because these
approaches combine religious invocation and traditions with thought
restructuring (Haque, Thompson, & El Bassuni, n.d.; Knaevelsrud, Brand, Lange, Ruwaard, &
Wagner, 2015).
Given the impact of culture and religion on views
of mental health and its manifestation, treatments are often
culturally adapted to the needs of clients to comply with their
beliefs and values (Soueif, 2001).
On the other hand, awareness about psychology and psychiatry has
increased in Arab societies over the past decades. Regardless of
the effort to recruit clinical psychologists and create job
opportunities, local professionals report that the field is not yet
adequately developed in those countries. Raising awareness about
the important role of psychologists in society and providing better
training can help improve mental health services (Amer,
2013). Also, creating anti-stigma programs by
providing mental health at the primary health care level may reduce
mental health stigma (Almazeedi & Alsuwaidan, 2014; Dalky, 2012). Offering affordable mental health
services and collaboration between clinics and governmental
organizations can help promote clinical psychology and motivate
individuals to seek treatment, especially in financially unstable
populations such as refugees (Amer, 2013). Recently, the Kuwait Center for Mental
Health established clinics staffed with psychiatrists and
physicians at community health care centers; partnership and
combined efforts may be the right way to increase mental health awareness (Almazeedi &
Alsuwaidan, 2014). Despite these
complications, today clinical psychology is beginning to be viewed
as an honorable and respected profession in these countries,
suggesting that there is potential for progress.
Bahrain
Clinical psychology in Bahrain
originated in
the twentieth century when the first training programs were
established in colleges. In 1966, the first program was initiated
at the Teacher Training College; later, other institutions started
introducing psychology courses (e.g., introduction to psychology,
educational psychology, and developmental psychology). In 1978,
psychology was represented as a separate division at the College of
Arts, Science, and Education. Other psychology departments were
established later at various universities, including the College of
Education at
the Bahrain University, the University of Gulf Polytechnic, and the
University of Bahrain (Aluhran, 2002).
Recently, a growing number of
psychology programs have developed in Bahrain, including the
psychology department at the University College of Bahrain, which
launched its first postgraduate degree in counseling psychology in
1994 and currently offers a master’s degree. This program is
dedicated to providing education for students and preparing them
for careers as professional psychologists and in both academic and
applied settings including research positions in governmental
organizations, psychological institutions, clinics, and hospitals.
The University College of Bahrain also provides training for
professionals, which is usually completed by attending workshops
and training courses led by specialists. Despite of this, the
country does not have legislative requirements for training
(Aluhran, 2002).
Egypt
The foundation of psychological
psychotherapy practices was established in Egypt in 1929, and
20 years later clinical services were available for adults,
adolescents, and children. To promote psychology as a profession,
pioneers started to practice psychotherapy (Ramadan, 2004). For instance, Abdel-Aziz El-Koussy
launched a psychological clinic for young adults at the Higher
Institute of Education in Cairo, in 1934. Other pioneers included
Mostapha Zewar, Somaya Fahmy, Marcus Gregory, and Mohammed Fathy
(Amer, 2013). The first attempt to
make psychology into an academic profession occurred with the
launch of the Egyptian Journal of Psychology
in 1945. In this period, psychologists started to use therapeutic
approaches including psychoanalysis and humanistic and behavior
therapy .
These models were brought to Egypt by psychologists who were
trained abroad (e.g., the United Kingdom, France, Switzerland, and
the United States; Amer, 2013). Dr.
Sabry Girguis introduced clinical psychology to Egypt in the early
1950s when he established an outpatient clinic called Helmeya in
Cairo. This hospital still exists, and today it is one of the
Ministry of Health Hospitals. The first attempt to establish
official requirements and regulations for psychologists in the
country occurred in 1956, when a law was passed declaring that
psychotherapy practice required a license from the Egyptian health
authorities in addition to training and a degree. Clinical
psychology as a profession started in the 1960s and 1970s; in 1974,
the first independent department of psychology was established
(previous psychology departments were combined with philosophy
departments) at Cairo University by Professor Moustafa Souief and
at Ain Shams University by Professor Moustafa Zewar (Ramadan,
2004). In the 1970s and 1980s
other universities around the country also established psychology
departments. In 1986, the Egyptian Ministry of Health established a
policy to engage psychologists in mental health practices and work
with psychiatrists within these institutions (Soueif,
2001).
As of today, more than 200 clinical
psychologists are working in Egypt in addition to many more who
serve as general psychologists. Psychologists mainly work in public
hospitals, private practices, government and military institutions,
schools, and community centers (Ahmed, 2004). Egyptian universities offer undergraduate
and graduate degrees in psychology. Students usually complete a
bachelor’s degree in 4 years, a master’s in 2–4 years,
and a doctoral degree in an additional 3–4 years (Amer,
2013). To become a psychologist in
Egypt, students are required to complete a 4-year Bachelor of Arts
program with a major in psychology, complete four accredited
courses and a 2 year internship at a psychiatric hospital to
qualify for work with clients. Another option is for students to
complete master’s and doctoral degrees in clinical psychology. This
training and accreditation is required to receive a license from
the Ministry of Health . Some individuals acquire a license
automatically by having a PhD and serving as a faculty member at a
university (Ahmed, 2004). Some of
the theoretical orientations that clinical psychologists practice
in Egypt include psychoanalysis, cognitive behavioral therapy
(CBT), group therapy, family therapy, art therapy, and dialectical,
interpersonal, supportive therapies. However, most clinicians
perceive CBT as the dominant approach (Amer, 2013).
Iran
The early twentieth century also
brought psychology to Iran: in 1933, the first psychology
laboratory was opened, and in 1938, psychology courses were first
offered at Tehran University. In 1965, the first academic program
of clinical psychology was established in Tehran University’s
Department of Psychology; in 1966, Dr. Saeed Shamloo published the
first book on clinical psychology in Persian. In 1970, the first
clinical psychology master’s program was developed at the Rouzbeh
Psychiatric Hospital, and later other master’s programs were
established, such as the program at the Welfare and Rehabilitation
Sciences University (Behrooz, 2013).
The clinical psychology programs
in Iran are
accredited by the Board of Clinical Psychology. To become a
clinical psychologist in Iran, individuals are required to obtain a
master’s or doctoral level degree. The academic requirements of a
master’s in clinical psychology include completing 32 course
credits, a thesis, and practical training. The doctoral degree
requirements include completing 42–50 credits of course work and a
1-year internship as well as submitting a dissertation and passing
an examination. Clinical psychologists are licensed by the Iranian
Psychology and Counseling Organization, which also oversees the
work of clinical psychologists and provides exclusive rights for
clinicians and clients. Licensing requirements for clinical
psychology in Iran involve an interview and an examination.
According to the 2014 data reported by an interviewee,
approximately 7500 master’s clinical psychology students and 160
doctoral students were enrolled in Iranian universities.
Clinical psychologists in Iran often
work in private practices, academic settings, and community
services. The various theoretical approaches they use in their work
include CBT, psychoanalysis, rational-emotive therapy, and
humanistic approaches as well as family therapy, short-term
psychotherapy, couples therapy, group therapy, and schema therapy.
Since the late 1980s, however, CBT has become the dominant approach
for most clinical psychologists and training programs in Iran. CBT
was first introduced in Iran in 1975 and appears to play a critical
role in the development of master’s programs in clinical
psychology, as the first programs at Tehran University and Roozbeh
Hospital focused on CBT. Many Iranians perceive CBT as compatible
with their culture because the approach associates thoughts with
emotions, and the Iranian culture encourages one to be particularly
conscious of one’s thought process and internal emotional state.
This explains the increase in the interest of CBT over the past decades.
Training in CBT is provided by private, governmental, and
nongovernmental organizations, and it is used to treat various
mental and physical disorders and problems (e.g., eating disorders,
addictions, asthma, and chronic pain; Behrooz, 2012).
Iraq
Clinical psychology was first
introduced in Iraq in 1955 through the Psychological Research
Center in Baghdad. The degree obtained at the center is provided by
the Al-Mustansiriyah University, College of Arts. In 1998, clinical
psychology was first accepted as a separate profession through the
collaboration and effort of professionals and students in the
discipline. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) report
in 2006 (WHO-Aims Report on Mental Health System in Iraq,
2006), 16 psychologists worked in
mental health services and two students graduated from a psychology
program.
Iraqi hospitals and university do not
have a clinical psychology specialization; therefore, no clear
distinction exists between clinical psychologists and other mental
health professionals such as social workers and counselors. Most
psychologists in Iraq have a master’s degree and some training.
Some of the academic requirements to be recognized as clinical
psychologist include pursuing a master’s degree in clinical
psychology. The master’s program involves completing courses (e.g.,
advanced courses, theories of personality, neuropsychology,
research methods, and general and abnormal psychology) and
2 years of practical training at a mental health hospital. The
main theoretical orientation practiced by psychologists in Iraq is
CBT, although many professionals practice the psychodynamic
approach and others receive training in trauma therapy (e.g., Eye
Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing; EMDR) to treat
traumatized clients. Most psychologists work in government mental
health services and in academic settings, as private
practices do not yet exist in Iraq.
Israel
Psychology
was first introduced in Israel in 1920
when a group of psychoanalysts immigrated to the country with the
encouragement of Sigmund Freud. The growing interest in the
psychoanalytic approach in that period led to the establishment of
the Jerusalem Psychoanalytic Institute and
Society in Jerusalem. The first time psychology was offered
as an academic subject was in 1933, at the Hebrew University of
Jerusalem. A year later, in 1935, the Professional Counseling
Institute was established in three locations: Jerusalem, Tel-Aviv,
and Haifa. The first psychology program was established at The
Hebrew University of Jerusalem by Professor Enzo Bonaventure, in
1939, but he was killed in an attack on the way to the university
in 1948. The psychology program was formally reestablished in 1957
by Professor Saul Kugelmass. Because of rapidly growing interest in
counseling and the need to develop mental health care, in 1944 the
Hadassah Institute for Counseling was established to encourage
individuals to engage in mental health practices, and in 1950 the
first educational psychology services
were launched by the Ministry of
Education. In 1957 the Israel Psychological Association was
established. In 1960 the first clinical psychology department was
launched at The Hebrew University, and, a year later in 1961, the
second was founded at Bar Ilan University in Tel-Aviv. Five years
later, in 1966, psychology programs were established at Tel Aviv
University, Haifa University, and Be’er Sheva University. The first
psychotherapy training program was established at Tel Aviv University in 1971 to
train and accredit mental health professionals in the analytical
approach.
In 1977 the Psychologist Act, which
regulates the profession and oversees the licensing process of
clinical psychologists in Israel, was passed as a government
statute. According to this legislation, in order to practice
psychotherapy, every psychologist is required to enroll in the
psychologist register, an organized register managed by the
Ministry of Health that documents all psychologists working in the
mental health sector in Israel. Israel is currently undergoing a
major mental health reform in which health maintenance
organizations are taking over responsibility for most outpatient
services from government supported community mental health centers.
The role of clinical psychologists was central in the community
mental health centers in terms of both service provision and
training, and there are great unknowns about how the reform will
impact clinical psychology. To become a clinical psychologist in
Israel, an individual must have at least a master’s-level degree in
clinical psychology (which includes a thesis and practicum),
complete a 4-year half-time internship in a clinical setting, and
obtain a license by passing an oral exam. In order to sit for the
exam, one must have administered a certain number of assessments
including the Rorschach, an intelligence test, and others measures
(often other projective tests). For many years, 20 batteries had to
be administered in addition to treating patients for 3 years
in an outpatient setting and for 1 year in an inpatient setting in
half-time internships. Recently, there have been moves to reduce
the number of assessments and expand the repertoire of tests to be
more guided by the referral question and reductions in the numbers
of Rorschach and IQ tests required.
At the end of 2014, there were 11,500
psychologists in Israel, and today there are
more than 3800 clinical psychologists . For the population, this is the highest number
of psychologists per population in the world. According to our
calculations, there are approximately 144 psychologists per 100,000
people in Israel. In comparison to the WHO 2014 data, the next
highest number of psychologists per 100,000 in the world is in
Netherlands (90.76), and then Finland (56), (World Health
Organization, Substance Use of Mental Health, 2014). In the United States, the number per
100,000 is 29.63. Thirteen colleges and universities offer a
bachelor’s degree in psychology; eight also offer master’s degrees,
and five offer doctoral degrees. Clinical psychologists in Israel
work in private practices, hospitals, academic settings, the army,
and government organizations, to name a few. The main theoretical
orientations are psychodynamic (including a wide range of
orientations including interpersonal, self, object relations, and
more) and CBT; the psychodynamic approach is
dominant among clinical psychologists in Israel, but there is
growing interest in CBT . Systems
approaches are used at times with children, often with integration
of other orientations. The client-centered/humanistic approach is
less common and not formally recognized in Israel in terms of its
status compared to other orientations.
Culturally
, Israel is an extremely diverse country.
The population includes multiple religions and many different
cultural and ethnic backgrounds. Therefore, it is difficult to
describe any single adaptation that would need to be made to
treatments. Overall, the population of Israel includes people of
multiple religions (Judaism, Islam, Druze, Christians, Bahai, and
others). The largest population is Jewish, with 20% of the Jewish
population being Ultra-Orthodox. In addition, there are many first,
second, and third generation immigrants from around the world,
approximately half from Europe and half from other parts of the
Middle East and Africa. Each community has a different relationship
to clinical psychology. Ultra-orthodox Jews, Arab-Israelis , and Ethiopian
immigrants tend to have greater stigma about mental health and
seeing mental health professionals because of their more
traditional religious beliefs. There is more openness to treatment,
though still significant stigma in the secular and modern religious
communities which make up more than half of the population. There
have been a number of articles written on the manifestations of
psychopathology and how to adapt treatment to various populations
within Israel (e.g., Bar-El et al., 2000; Dwairy, 2009; Greenberg & Witztum, 2001; Hess, 2014; Huppert & Siev, 2010).
Jordan
Psychology was introduced to Jordan
in 1970, when
psychology departments were first established. In 1980, the
National Center for Educational Research was founded to promote
interests and a wide range of research in the field (Gielen, Adler,
& Milgram, 1992). In 1986 a
mental health policy was created in Jordan and in 2011 the policy
was updated. The aim of the updated policy is to offer mental
health services with an emphasis on cultural adaptations, employing
mental health professionals, and reducing mental health stigma (WHO
Mind Mental Health in Development, 2013). In 1990, clinical psychology was brought
to the country by number of clinical psychologists who had studied
abroad, but the profession was officially accepted in the beginning
of the twenty-first century. In 1994, a national mental health
program was developed to increase mental health awareness and
provide professional training, and in 2003 mental health
legislation was introduced (Mental Health Atlas, 2005). Currently, undergraduate and graduate
programs in
psychology are offered at universities in Jordan such as the
University of Jordan in Amman, Yarmouk University in Irbid, and
Mutah University in Kerak (Gielen et al., 1992).
Currently there are less than 20
licensed clinical psychologists in Jordan. According the
regulations, to become a clinical psychologist is Jordan, an
individual is required to have a master’s level degree in clinical
or counseling psychology and 2 years of clinical experience. The
main therapeutic approach among clinical psychologists in Jordan is
CBT and they often work in private practices and public practice
and centers. In 1995 Jordan established a professional association
called the Jordanian Psychological Association
(JPA) , based in Amman. The aim of the association is to
support and protect professionals and increase mental health
awareness in community. Some of JPA’s contributions include holding
conferences and conducting workshops to train professionals and
creating guidelines in partnership with the ministry of health
in
Jordan.
Kuwait
Psychology in Kuwait emerged in the
early 1950s, and during that period some psychological services
were offered to the public. In 1966, the first psychology and
education department was established at Kuwait University, and in
1980, the university announced that the Psychology and Education
Department would split to become independent departments. At first,
the university offered graduate and undergraduate degrees, but in
1975 it started offering only graduate programs. In 1972, the
Department of Psychological Services was initiated, which offered
psychological services and engaged graduate students in the mental
health sector (Gielen et al., 1992). Mental health in Kuwait is included in the
primary health care system. In 1957, a mental health policy was
developed in the country, and 40 years later, in 1997, a
mental health program was created (Mental Health Atlas,
2005).
In 1998, Dr. Vincenza Tiberia, an
American clinical psychologist was the first to be brought to
Kuwait to train and supervise Kuwaiti psychologists. Some of Dr.
Tiberia’s contributions include implementing and teaching ethics
according to the American Psychological Association (APA)
guidelines, establishing procedure manuals, and promoting training
programs with the help of other psychologists. There are no
guidelines for becoming a psychologist in Kuwait. However, most
psychologists have a doctoral degree (including at least
2 years of training) and additional training after the degree
is completed. Also, psychologists in Kuwait are not required to
receive a license before starting to work, and only a small number
are licensed. Due to the lack of regulation, there is a
misconception regarding who can be a psychologist, and many people
decide to call themselves psychologists even if they do not have
formal qualifications.
Clinical psychology is in the early
stages of development in Kuwait , with few government services in some
parts in the community. The need to create a professional ethics
code and the desire to establish a national association to promote
mental health in the Middle East led to the founding of the
Middle East Psychological Association
(MEPA)
in 2010. This organization is based in Kuwait and recognized by the
APA. Some of MEPA’S responsibilities include emphasizing the
importance of the psychologist’s role, offering professional
training, and creating psychological services for the
community.
Lebanon
The history of psychology in Lebanon
goes back to
the mid twentieth century. Between 1950 and 1960, various
therapeutic approaches were introduced in Lebanese medicine,
including family and adult therapy. Later, mental health
institutions were established to promote mental health care, such
as the psychiatric hospital of the Red Cross; the Institution for
Development, Research, Advocacy, and Applied Care (IDRAAC); and the
Medical Institute of Neuropsychological Disorders (MIND). Dr.
Mounir Chamoun first introduced clinical psychology as a discipline
at Saint Joseph University in 1980. In 2003, the Lebanese Psychological Association was
established, and in 2011 Dr. Brigitte Khoury founded the Arab
Center for Research, Training, and Policy Making at the American
University of Beirut (Khoury & Tabbarah, 2013).
There are approximately 200 students
with master’s-level degrees in psychology or clinical psychology in
Lebanon .
Currently, there is no clear licensing process or set of guidelines
for clinical psychologists in Lebanon because no official legal
entity exists to oversee the discipline. In the past, psychologists
were classified as clinical psychologists based on the university
they attended and its regulations. At this time, the Lebanese Psychological Association , in
collaboration with the Ministry of Health, is working on a decree
to define requirements, roles, and responsibilities of clinical
psychologists. The Lebanese Psychological Association recently
declared new requirements for clinical psychologists, including a
master’s-level degree in clinical psychology and 400 h of
clinical work. The clinical program established in the American
University of Beirut’s psychiatry department is the first program
to provide a 2-year training and supervision practicum.
Clinical psychologists’ employment
settings include private practices, private hospitals, private
schools and universities, and non-governmental organizations.
Often, practitioners teach and provide training, conduct
assessments, and deliver treatment. Clinical psychologists use two
main approaches in their work: psychoanalysis modeled on the
methods used in the French system (e.g., Lacan), and CBT. CBT’s
development and acceptance has recently been recognized in Lebanon:
the Lebanese Association of Cognitive and Behavioral Therapy was
established in 2002 and today is recognized as a part of the
European Association of Cognitive and Behaviour Therapies (EABCT).
As of today, there is no official program for training in CBT;
however, training is available at hospital psychiatry and clinical
psychology departments. CBT pioneers in Lebanon have been
collaborating with experts from around the world to develop
workshops and seminars to better educate and train candidates.
Official governmental organizations are working with CBT pioneers
to increase awareness of CBT and provide official academic and
professional training for candidates (Karam, 2015).
Oman
In the late 1980s, the first
department of psychology was established at Sultan Qaboos
University in Muscat with the help of some Egyptian psychologists
(Baker,
2012). The department’s mission was
to provide psychological services and training for students and
teachers, and the department’s staff consisted of academic
professionals from abroad (e.g., Egypt). Also, at that time a
behavioral science program in the medical college that included
psychology was offered to educate medical students; because of a
shortage of qualified and credentialed professionals, the
psychology courses were taught by the academics in the college
(Al-Adawi et al., 2002). Psychology
training in Oman was provided by the medical school and at the
College of Education at Sultan Qaboos University (Al-Adawi et al.,
2002).
Mental health care in Oman is a part
of the primary health care system. A number of mental health
resources are available in the Omani community. A mental health
policy was established in 1992 with the mission of providing
treatment for various psychological problems. A substance abuse
policy was created in 1999 to provide treatments for abuse
problems. A national mental health program was founded in 1999 to
offer mental health services in the community and train
professionals (Mental Health Atlas, 2005).
Most clinical psychologists in Oman
have master’s degrees, but very few psychologists hold a doctorate.
Clinical psychology is not yet fully established in Oman; the
profession is not defined, and there are no required academic or
training requirements to become a practitioner. Some of the
theoretical orientations practiced among clinical psychologists in
Oman include
CBT and acceptance and commitment therapy
(ACT) . Clinical psychologists in Oman provide therapy and
conduct assessments, and they often work in private practice or in
public centers and clinics.
The field of psychology in Oman is not
as developed as it is in other countries. Some of the limitations
of practicing psychology in Oman include the need for formal
training programs, defining academic requirements, and establishing
legislation and rules to better define the role and
responsibilities of clinical psychologists (A. Sultan, personal
communication, January, 2014).
Owing to the lack of psychological services and an increase in
psychological problems among the Omani people, through the efforts
of national psychologists, the psychiatry department at the Oman
Medical College is currently offering psychological treatment in
addition to the other services (Al-Adawi et al., 2002).
Palestinian Territories
Dr. Mubarak Awad, considered one the
main pioneers of psychology in Palestine , first introduced
psychology in the Palestine Territories in 1983. One of his major
accomplishments was initiating the Palestine Counseling Center, the
first institute to provide psychological service. The organization
offers training for students and therapy for clients (Nashashibi,
Srour, & Srour, 2013). In
1987, national and global organizations were established to treat
individuals’ symptoms resulting mostly from traumatic events. Some
of these institutions include the Gaza Community Mental Health
Program and Medicines Sans Frontiers (MSF). In 1996, the Ministry
of Health established the first psychology programs at
universities; the aim of these programs was to integrate
psychologists into educational institutions (Nashashibi et al.,
2013).
There are no distinctions between
clinical psychology , general psychology, and social work in
the Palestinian territories. Moreover, distinguishing clinical
psychology from social work and counseling psychology is quite
challenging; individuals who obtain an undergraduate degree in
psychology or social work call themselves clinical psychologists.
Professionals with bachelor’s, master’s, and PhD degrees have the
same responsibilities and work in the same settings. In 2015,
Al-Quds University initiated the first effort to establish a
clinical program by offering a community mental health program with
a concentration in psychotherapy. In the Palestinian territories,
there are five universities with psychology programs, including
al-Quds, An-Najah, Birzeit, Bethlehem, and the Islamic University
of Gaza. Because clinical psychology is not yet developed enough in
the Palestinian territories, psychologists from Palestine search
for training opportunities outside the country to gain the
appropriate experience (Costin, 2005).
Much of the focus of psychologists in
the Palestinian territories is on the treatment of trauma symptoms;
some of these approaches include eye movement desensitization and
reprocessing (EMDR) and expressive therapy (Nashashibi et al.,
2013). Other approaches are
common, as well. For instance, some organizations provide training
for psychologists (mainly in CBT) based on organizations’
requirements, but there is no clarified registration regulation for
psychologists. The Gaza Community Mental Health
Program (GCHP) was founded in 1990 to provide therapy and
training. Psychologists who desire to work at the Ministry of
Health must
obtain accreditation as a psychologist or social worker, but most
professionals prefer to work at non-profit organizations.
Nongovernmental organizations also provide training for graduate
students (Nashashibi et al., 2013). Most psychologists and social workers
work in nonprofit organizations, while some work at schools
(limited budgets prevent greater employment in schools), community
centers, and hospitals (social workers more than psychologists).
Social stigma is associated with seeking treatment, and negative
generalizations are made about people who receive therapy or
counseling. People with mental illness are often stigmatized and
perceived as “crazy”; therefore, there is shame in seeing a
psychologist (Costin, 2005).
A wide gap in mental health care
exists between Palestine and other countries. Our interviewees
suggested that authorities need to establish an official entity
that defines the roles, responsibilities, and requirements of
psychologists. Recently, there is an aim to raise awareness of
mental health and promote psychology in the workplace; the
Palestine Authority’s National Mental Health Centers are developing
community health care plans and services by modifying Western
methods for Palestinian culture to respond to clients’
psychological needs (Costin, 2005).
Qatar
In 1973, psychology was first
announced as an independent discipline in Qatar . In 1977, Qatar
University was established and introduced two psychology
departments: the Department of Psychology and the Department of
Educational Psychology. In 1980, the Center for Educational
Research, where a variety of research is conducted, was founded at
Qatar University (Gielen et al., 1992). In 1980, a mental health policy was
created to promote treatment. Later, in 1986, a substance abuse
policy was established, and 1990 saw the introduction of a national
mental health program that centers on providing health care and
regulating counseling services (Mental Health Atlas, 2005).
As in Kuwait, clinical psychology is
being developed in Qatar and some services are offered in the
community. Clinical psychologists in Qatar face problems concerning
insurance and professional risk because there is no official
governmental licensure. This issue may pose a challenge to clinical
psychologists in that they aim to work ethically and wish to
receive government support.
Saudi Arabia
The establishment and development of
clinical psychology in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) occurred
in the early 1980s. In 1982, Dr. Othman Altoal, who served as the
director of mental health in the KSA at that time, first introduced
clinical psychology to the country. Later, Dr. Saeed Wahass,
considered the pioneer of clinical psychology in the KSA, initiated
the opening of clinical psychology units at hospitals in the
kingdom.
In Saudi Arabia, clinical psychology
is considered part of the liberal arts. The shortage in professions
and services led to the launch of a new clinical psychology program
for students who obtain a Bachelor of Science at the Princess Noura
University, College of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences. The
academic requirements of the program involve completing 137 credits
of course work and a 1-year clinical internship. To become a
clinical psychologist, students are required to pursue a bachelor’s
degree in psychology and train for at least 3 months at a hospital.
Recently, the aim has been to require a more advanced degree to
become a clinical psychologist; therefore, the first master’s
program in clinical psychology was established at the University of
Dammam . In
addition to academic development, the Saudi Commission for Health
Specialty has established accreditation regulations for clinical
psychologists. This is considered the first effort to create an
official training guideline. According to the Saudi Commission for
Health Specialties, Professional Classification and Registration of
Health Practitioners Manual (6th Edition, 2015), students can specialize in clinical
psychology if they have a bachelor’s degree in psychology and
3 years of clinical work under supervision (Guidelines of
professional classification and registration for health
practitioners, 2015). Because the
protocols have only recently been established in 2014, it is
difficult to obtain accurate numbers of professionals who fit the
category, but there are more than 1500 psychologists (mostly
holders of only a undergraduate degree), of whom only about 30
individuals are highly trained. As in many other countries in the
Middle East, CBT is the dominant therapeutic approach. Some
hospitals have maintained family therapy programs for 7 years
now. Clinical psychologists often provide psychotherapy, administer
neuropsychological assessments, and teach courses and workshops.
Their employment settings include working in public and private
hospitals, private practices, and academic settings. One example of
the discipline’s rapid growth in the KSA is the establishment of
the clinical psychology department at King Fahad Medical City,
which has integrated clinical psychologists as mental health
providers (Chur-Hansen et al., 2008).
Syria
Psychology emerged in Syria around the late 1940s
when psychology courses were taught as a part of the philosophy and
education departments. Thirty years later, in the 1970s, psychology
departments were introduced at universities, offering undergraduate
degrees in psychology. The pioneers who helped develop and promote
the growth of this field are H. el-Gahli, Sami el-Dorroby, and F.
H. Akil (Gielen et al., 1992).
In Syria, stigma regarding
psychological distress and illness is prevalent; it is not
acceptable for men (but is for women) to express and reveal
emotions because it is considered a sign of weakness. Also, as in
other Arab countries, mental illness is perceived as shameful
because of the risk of being labeled “crazy.” Combining mental
health services with more acceptable services such as primary care
could reduce the stigma associated with mental health care in the
Syrian community and improve the quality of life of individuals
with mental disorder (Hassan et al., 2015). Given the current civil war in Syria, it
is hard to describe the current services provided there.
Turkey
The history of psychology in Turkey
started in
1915, when psychology was first recognized as a discipline
(Poyrazh, Dogan, & Eskin, 2013). The first psychology courses were
introduced as part of university philosophy departments in 1930. In
1970, early psychology studies centered on the Freudian approach,
and the first clinical courses were taught based on psychodynamic
methodology. In 1980, Isik Savasir founded the first cognitive
behavioral program in Hacettepe. This program was one of the
leading training programs for clinical psychologists and had a
major influence on the discipline because it led to the
establishment of other clinical psychology programs in Turkey such
as those at Ankara University and Middle East Technical University.
In 1984, the Institute for Higher Education recognized other
psychology courses, leading to major developments in clinical
psychology. In 2011, clinical psychology was first accepted as a
separate profession in Turkey, and a law was created to make
explicit the requirements, roles, responsibilities, and work
conditions of clinical psychologists. The Ministry of Health
accomplished this by working with representatives from academic and
professional psychology fields and with leaders from the Turkish
Psychological Associations. Despite this achievement, as of today
Turkey does not have a law that defines the profession of clinical
psychologist.
As of today there are approximately
3000 clinical psychologists in Turkey; however, the country does
not have a registration system, and providing accurate data can be
challenging. Based on the Ministry of Health law, clinical
psychologists are required to complete at least 6 years of
education and training in both psychology and clinical psychology.
Currently, about ten graduate programs exist in clinical psychology
in Turkey (Poyrazh et al., 2013).
The academic requirements include an undergraduate degree in
psychology and a master’s degree in clinical psychology. Students
also can pursue an undergraduate degree in counseling psychology
and a master’s and doctoral degree in clinical psychology.
Clinical psychologists in Turkey
practice
different theoretical orientations, but their specific orientation
depends on their training. The main approaches are CBT,
psychodynamic, and humanistic. Despite this variety, CBT is the
dominant oreintation. CBT is used to treat various adult and child
mental disorders including anxiety disorders, depression, eating
disorders, schizophrenia, and bipolar disorder as well as sexual
and addiction problems. The Turkish Association of Cognitive and
Behaviour Psychotherapies (TACBP) is the only CBT organization in
Turkey. It was initiated in 1995 and currently has hundreds of
members. TACBP provides training in CBT for professionals by
offering courses, seminars, and workshops according to the European
Association Behavioral Cognitive Therapies (Sungar, 2010). Clinical psychologists in Turkey work in
hospitals, government organizations, and private clinics. Some of
their responsibilities include conducting assessments and testing,
offering treatments and interventions (both group and individual),
providing training and consultation, and working in research or
academic settings.
In Turkey, religious beliefs and ideas
are thought to have a positive influence on clinical psychology by
helping clients to manage their traumatic symptoms in treatment.
Nonetheless, in the past, cultural and social factors negatively
affected clinical psychology. Individuals previously viewed the use
of medication to treat mental illness as a stigma. Recently,
however, more people have become aware of the fact that mental
disorders could develop as a result of life events and experiences
and have come to view seeking pharmacological treatment as
acceptable. Despite these developments in clinical psychology, a
need exists to create more master’s programs and train clinical
psychologists in Turkey (Kayaoğlu & Batur, n.d.).
United Arab Emirates
Psychology was first introduced in the
United Arab Emirates (UAE) in 1971 at UAE University, and in 2004 it
was first recognized as a separate discipline. The first accredited
graduate program in clinical psychology was established at the
United Arab University (UAEU) in 2011, and later on another
undergraduate program began at the New York University Campus in
Abu Dhabi.
The core of this program is based on
research and the goal of training students.
Until 2012, no clear requirements
existed for clinical psychologists; individuals with any psychology
degree could refer to themselves as clinical psychologists. In
2012, new legislation was created to define the academic and
professional requirements and employment settings of clinical
psychologists. Clinical psychologists are required to obtain
master’s degrees in clinical psychology and complete clinical work
(Amer, 2013). Two government bodies
are responsible for the regulation of clinical psychology in the
UAE: Dubai Health Authority (DHA) and the Health Authority of Abu
Dhabi (HAAD). These two units have almost similar guidelines. The
main requirements include a doctoral or master’s degree and
completion of an internship and a written exam.
According to Hague and his colleagues,
32% of psychologists have master’s degrees in psychology in
comparison with 33% who have doctoral degrees. There are a variety
of theoretical models practiced among UAE psychologist; 74% of
psychologists use eclectic theoretical models, 19% use cognitive
behavioral therapies, and only 3% use the psychodynamic approach
(Haque et al., n.d.). Clinical
psychologists in the UAE are engaged in clinics, schools, and
hospitals.
Yemen
Yemen’s first academic clinical
psychology program was established in 2003 by the Ministry of
Health and the Yemeni Medical Board. Two levels of degree in
clinical psychology are available in Yemen : bachelor’s and
master’s. The Ministry of Health’s department for psychology is
responsible for providing academic involvement, and the Yemeni
Medical Council grants clinical training. There are more than 14
departments of psychology in Yemini Universities (Saleh,
2008a, b).
In 2009, 300 psychologists (1.5 per
1,000,000) worked in Yemen; out of this number, 135 are employed in
academic institutions, 75 in mental health services, and 45 in
social work (Cite). Data from the Yemeni Health Association (YMHA)
showed the numbers of degree holders in psychology from 2002 to
2006: 51 held doctoral degrees, 159 held master’s degrees, and 3370
held bachelor’s degrees. Most of these psychologists were employed
in academic settings, governmental organizations, and social work
services (Saleh, 2008a,
2008b). Some of the services they
provided include psychotherapy (in both private and public
settings) and counseling at mental health services. In Yemen, the
focus of the National Mental Health Program and Non-Governmental
Associations (NGOs) is similar to that of other mental health
services: to create official organizations that emphasize the role
of psychologists. The mental health telephone counseling program
initiated in 2000 by the Yemeni Mental Health Association, and Aden
University has attempted to raise the awareness of psychologists’
values and responsibilities. The Hotline for Psychological Aid
(Aden) represents the first resource of it is kind in the Arab
world. According to 2007 data, more than 4000 calls were received
reporting mental disorders and psychological problems (Saleh,
2008a, 2008b). Later on, many other hotline and
psychological counseling services were established, including the
Hotline for Psychological and Legal Support (Sana’a), the education
and psychological counseling center at Sana’a University, the
student counseling center at Taiz University, and the Hotline at
the Mental Health Cultural Health Center Sana’a (Saleh,
2011).
Some of the obstacles clinical
psychologists face in Yemen includes the need for academic program
training and accreditation. The mental health field is growing
rapidly in Yemen, and the establishment of the different
psychological services and organizations contributes to the success
of programs to deal with violence and increase the awareness of
mental health in the country to make the profession more accepted
and honorable (Saleh, 2008a,
2008b; Saleh and Makki,
2008).
Conclusion
The Middle East marks the meeting
point between East and West, where the various countries create
diverse and wide-ranging cultures and traditions. It is the
birthplace of the three major religions: Judaism, Islam, and
Christianity. Islam is the dominant religion, and Islamic
traditions and values are practiced in most Middle Eastern
countries. For this reason, the Middle East is viewed as
traditional in comparison with other regions around the world.
However, there does not seem to be a relationship between
traditions and providing psychological treatment, because
psychology is an acceptable and common field in some countries,
such as, Israel, Iran, and Turkey (Table 1). Notably all three of
these countries have histories of being run by secular governments
for a significant period of time, which may have provided more
support for the entry of psychology into their societies. Some
other countries are realizing the importance of introducing
psychology, and are working to develop culturally adapted concepts
that are acceptable to the wider public. However, stigma toward
mental health is prevalent among Middle Eastern societies, and it
appears to negatively affect those seeking treatment (and also
prevent many from seeking treatment). Therefore, there is a need to
decrease stigma and increase mental health awareness to improve the
health and mental well-being of individuals. Given the important
role of Islam in most of the Middle East, it seems important to
work on developing culturally adapted models of clinical psychology
in order to facilitate the introduction of clinical psychology at a
greater scale in the Middle East. It is difficult to obtain
systematic information about clinical psychology in the Middle
East, and therefore we based much of our report on individuals who
were surveyed. We are aware of the limitation of reporting in such
surveys; thus, a more systematic investigation is needed to better
describe the status of clinical psychology in the Middle East and
to make more specific policy recommendations on how to advance
clinical psychology in the Middle East. Due to the many conflicts
currently occurring in the Middle East, there is a clear need to
promote clinical psychology throughout the region.
Table
1
Number of psychologists working in the mental health sector in the
Middle East.
Country
|
Population 2014 (in million)
|
Psychologists working in the mental health
sector (2014)
|
---|---|---|
Bahrain
|
1.3
|
9
|
Egypt
|
89.5
|
107
|
Iran
|
78.1
|
3959
|
Iraq
|
34.8
|
31
|
Israel
|
8.2
|
11,502
|
Jordan
|
6.6
|
18
|
Kuwait
|
3.7
|
77
|
Lebanon
|
4.5
|
74
|
Oman
|
4.2
|
15
|
Palestine Authority (West Bank and
Gaza)a
|
36
|
|
Qatar
|
2.1
|
26
|
Saudi Arabia
|
30.8
|
425
|
Syria
|
22.1
|
26
|
Turkey
|
75.9
|
1085
|
United Arab Emiratesb
|
8.7
|
45
|
Yemenb
|
24.2
|
41
|
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank all of the
respondents from various countries who took the time to answer our
survey and follow-up questions.
References
Ahmed, R. A. (2004).
Psychology in Egypt. In D. Weddings & M. J. Stevens (Eds.),
The handbook of international
psychology (pp. 387–403). New York, NY:
Brunner-Routledge.
Aluhran, J. (2002). Bahrain
national tour. In D. Wedding & M. J. Stevens (Eds.),
Psychology: IUPsyS global resource
[CD-ROM], International
Journal of Psychology (vol. 44). Hove, Psychology
Press.
Alqahtani, M., &
Altamimi, N. (2016). Code of ethics and professionalism in light of
cultural competency: A guideline for Saudi psychologists,
supervisors and trainees. Psychological Studies, 61(2), 103–112.CrossRef
Amer, M. M. (2013).
Counseling and psychotherapy in Egypt: Ambiguous identity of a
regional leader. In R. Moodley, U. P. Gielen, & R. Wu (Eds.),
Handbook of counseling and
psychotherapy in an international context (pp. 19–29).
London, UK: Routledge.
Baidas, A. (2012). Psychology
in the Arab world. The British
Psychological Society, 25, 448–449.
Baker, D. B. (Ed.). (2012).
The Oxford handbook of the history
of psychology: Global perspectives. New York, NY: Oxford
University Press.
Behrooz, B. (2012).
Cognitive-behavioral therapy in Iran. Advances in Cognitive Therapy,
12, 6–8.
Behrooz, B. (2013).
Counseling and psychotherapy in Iran: A flourishing perspective. In
R. Moodley, U. P. Gielen, & R. Wu (Eds.), Handbook of counseling and psychotherapy in an
international context (pp. 361–370). London, UK:
Routledge.
Costin, A. (2005).
Psychology in Gaza and the West Bank. The British Psychological Society,
19, 282–283.
El-Islam, M. F. (2008). Arab
culture and mental health care. Transcultural Psychiatry, 45(4), 671–682.CrossRef
Gielen, U., Adler, L., &
Milgram, N. (1992). Psychology in
international perspective. Amsterdam, NL: Swets &
Zeitlinger.
Greenberg, D., &
Witztum, E. (2001). Sanity and
sanctity: Mental health work among the ultra-orthodox in
Jerusalem. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.CrossRef
Haque, A., Thompson, M.,
& El Bassuni, F. (n.d.). Clinical psychology in United Arab Emirates:
Prospects and challenges in private practice. Retrieved from
http://www.academia.edu/15950768/Clinical_Psychology_in_UAE_Prospects_and_Challenges_in_Private_Practice
Hassan, G., Kirmayer, L. J.,
Mekki-Berrada, A., Quosh, C., el Chammay, R., Deville-Stoetzel, J.
B., … Ventevogel, P. (2015). Culture, context and the mental health and
psychosocial wellbeing of Syrians: A review for mental health and
psychosocial support staff working with Syrians affected by armed
conflict. Geneva, CH: UNHCR.
Huppert, J. D., & Siev,
J. (2010). Treating scrupulosity in religious individuals using
cognitive-behavioral therapy. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice,
17(4), 382–392.CrossRef
Inhorn, M. C., & Serour,
G. I. (2011). Islam, medicine, and Arab-Muslim refugee health in
America after 9/11. The
Lancet, 378(9794),
935–943.CrossRef
Karam, A. (2015).
Cognitive-behavioral therapy in Lebanon. Advances in Cognitive Therapy,
15, 5–6.
Kayaoğlu, A., & Batur,
S. (2013). Critical psychology in Turkey: Recent developments.
Annual Review of Critical
Psychology, 10, 916–931.
Khoury, B., & Tabbarah,
S. (2013). Counseling and psychotherapy in Lebanon: Towards a
Lebanese framework of psychology. In R. Moodley, U. P. Gielen,
& R. Wu (Eds.), Handbook of
counseling and psychotherapy in an international context
(pp. 383–392). London, UK: Routledge.
Knaevelsrud, C., Brand, J.,
Lange, A., Ruwaard, J., & Wagner, B. (2015). Web-based
psychotherapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in war-traumatized
Arab patients: Randomized controlled trial. Journal of Medical Internet Research,
17(3), e71.CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
Nashashibi, R., Srour, A.,
& Srour, R. (2013). Counseling and psychotherapy in Palestine:
Between occupation and cultural colonialism. In R. Moodley, U. P.
Gielen, & R. Wu (Eds.), Handbook of counseling and psychotherapy in an
international context (pp. 393–403). London, UK:
Routledge.
Okasha, A., Karam, E., &
Okasha, T. (2012). Mental health services and research in the Arab
world. Acta Psychiatrica
Scandinavica, 98(5),
406–413.
Poyrazh, S., Dogan, S.,
& Eskin, M. (2013). Counseling and psychotherapy in Turkey:
Western theories and culturally inclusive methods. In R. Moodley,
U. P. Gielen, & R. Wu (Eds.), Handbook of counseling and psychotherapy in an
international context (pp. 404–414). London, UK:
Routledge.
Ramadan, A. (2004).
Psychology in Egypt. In D. Wedding & M. J. Stevens (Eds.),
The handbook of international
psychology. New York, NY: Routledge.
Saleh, M. (2008a).
Experience of Mental Health Association in Yemen. Journal of Social Sciences, Aden
University, 22,
55–62.
Saleh, M. (2008b).
Psychology in Yemen. Psychology
International, 19(2).
Saleh, M., & Makki, M.
A. (2008). Mental health in Yemen: Obstacles and challenges.
International Psychiatry,
5(4), 90–92.
Saleh, M. (2011).
Telephone hotline for
psychological aid, a paragraph in “Mental health revolution- making
things happen” edited by Porsche Poh. Singapore: System
printing co..
Saudi Commission for Health
Specialties. (2014). Guidelines of
professional classification and registration for health
practitioners. Retrieved from
http://www.scfhs.org.sa/en/registration/ClassAndRegister/Reregister/Documents/Professional%20Classification%20manual%20for%20Health%20Practitioners.pdf
Saudi Commission for Health
Specialties. (2015). Guidelines of
professional classification and registration for health
practitioners. Retrieved from
http://www.scfhs.org.sa/en/registration/ClassAndRegister/Reregister/Documents/Professional%20Classification%20manual%20for%20Health%20Practitioners.pdf
Scull, N. C., Khullar, N.,
Al-Awadhi, N., & Erheim, R. (2014). A qualitative study of the
perceptions of mental health care in Kuwait. International Perspectives in Psychology:
Research, Practice, Consultation, 3(4), 284.
Sultan, A. (2014). Executive
summary: Psychological services in the sultanate of Oman, an
evaluation and recommendations.
Soueif, M. I. (2001).
Practicing clinical psychology in the Egyptian cultural context:
Some personal experiences. International Journal of Group
Tensions, 30(3),
241–266.CrossRef
Sungar, M. (2010).
Cognitive-behavioral therapy in Turkey. Advances in Cognitive Therapy,
10, 6–9.
The World Bank, World
Development Indicators database (2015). Retrieved from http://databank.worldbank.org/data/download/POP.pdf
World Health Organization.
(2005). Mental health atlas
2005. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/globalatlas/pgrms/mentalhealth/
World Health Organization.
(2006) WHO-Aims report on mental
health system in Iraq. Retrieved from
http://www.who.int/mental_health/evidence/iraq_who_aims_report.pdf
World Health Organization,
Global Health Observatory Data Repository. (2015). Substance Use of Mental Health [data
file]. Retrieved from http://apps.who.int/gho/data/node.main.MHHR?lang=en
World Health Organization,
Department of Mental health and Substance Abuse, Mental Health
Policy and Service Development. (2013) WHO mind mental health in development.
Retrieved from
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/92504/1/9789241505666_eng.pdf
Footnotes
1
The countries include: Bahrain, Egypt,
Iraq, Iran, Israel, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, Saudi
Arabia, Syria, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen. We also
included the Palestinian territories which are self-administered
and have their own health system. There are disagreements about
whether Cyprus is included in the countries of the Middle East, but
given that they are mainly Greek-speaking and part of the European
Union, we did not include them in our review.