b. An Indefensible Act: Impalings

 
To drive these points home, the O’Briens refer to one final set of incidents from Numbers 25:3–5 (citing the Jerusalem Bible translation):
“With Israel thus committed to the Baal of Peor, the anger of Yahweh blazed out against them.
“Yahweh said to Moses, ‘Take all the leaders of the people. Impale them for Yahweh here in the sun; then the burning anger of Yahweh will turn away from Israel.’ Moses said to the Judges in Israel, ‘Every one of you must put to death those of his people who have committed themselves to the Baal of Peor.’
 
The O’Briens mince no words in what they think of this horrible sentence:
If we are correct in our interpretation of impaling, this was the most barbarous, and inhuman, form of fatal torture known to man. Its description, let alone its practice, should have no place in a civilized document....
We cannot stress too strongly that by this one declaration of intent, Yahweh put himself beyond the pale of civilized behavior; all his cruel acts, all his murders, were insignificant beside this one, appalling judgement. It is true that, as far as we know, there is no record of the order being carried out; but the mere contemplation of such acts is as wicked as their execution. That they should fall within the repertoire of an advanced and self-styled compassionate Being gives reason for a very uneasy concern. And if I were given one wish — it would be that every priest who called on his congregation to worship the ‘Great Jehovah’ should be called before his Bishop, and instructed to place the real facts concerning this monster in front of his congregation.198
 
The O’Briens are also quick to take issue with Moses’ defense for Yahweh’s various actions: “Learn from this that Yahweh your God was training you as a man trains his child.”199 However, “it was not an apologia that we would find possible to accept: not sparing the rod is one thing, but wholesale slaughter is entirely different.”200
Genes, Giants, Monsters, and Men
titlepage.xhtml
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_000.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_001.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_002.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_003.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_004.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_005.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_006.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_007.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_008.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_009.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_010.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_011.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_012.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_013.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_014.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_015.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_016.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_017.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_018.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_019.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_020.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_021.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_022.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_023.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_024.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_025.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_026.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_027.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_028.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_029.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_030.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_031.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_032.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_033.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_034.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_035.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_036.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_037.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_038.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_039.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_040.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_041.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_042.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_043.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_044.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_045.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_046.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_047.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_048.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_049.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_050.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_051.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_052.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_053.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_054.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_055.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_056.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_057.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_058.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_059.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_060.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_061.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_062.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_063.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_064.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_065.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_066.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_067.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_068.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_069.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_070.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_071.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_072.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_073.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_074.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_075.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_076.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_077.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_078.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_079.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_080.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_081.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_082.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_083.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_084.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_085.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_086.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_087.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_088.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_089.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_090.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_091.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_092.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_093.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_094.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_095.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_096.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_097.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_098.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_099.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_100.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_101.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_102.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_103.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_104.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_105.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_106.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_107.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_108.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_109.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_110.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_111.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_112.html
Genes_Giants-nsters_and_Men_split_113.html