CHAPTER SEVEN
Obligations

TUESDAY MORNING

Dad usually went jogging early in the morning, but I didn’t hear him go out while I was getting ready for school. The light was on in his study as I passed the closed doors on my way to the kitchen. I almost knocked but decided against it.

“You’re up early,” Mom said as she shoveled a stack of chocolate chip pancakes onto my plate. She’d already made two dozen of them even though none of us—except Dad—usually made our way down to breakfast for another thirty minutes. “I hope you slept well.”

Yeah, with a pillow over my head.

“I have a meeting with Mr. Barlow this morning.”

“Mm-hmm,” Mom said. She was busy wiping down the already glistening counter. Her loafers reflected in the sheen on the linoleum floor. Mom had a tendency to get a little OCD when she was stressed. The harder things were for the family, the more she tried to make things sparkle. Like everything was perfectly perfect.

I poked my finger into one of the melting chocolate chips that formed a symmetrical smiling face in my pancake. Mom normally only made her “celebration pancakes” for special occasions. I wondered if she was trying to soften the blow for a discussion about Maryanne—prep us for one of Dad’s sermons about how death is a natural part of life and all. That is, until I saw the look of guilt in her eyes when she placed a glass of orange juice in front of me. The pancakes were a peace offering for her fight with Dad last night.

“Fresh squeezed.” Mom wrung her apron in her hands. “Or would you rather have cranberry? Or maybe white grape?”

“This is fine,” I mumbled, and took a sip.

She frowned.

“It’s great,” I said. “I love fresh squeezed.”

I knew right then that Dad wasn’t coming out of his study this morning. We weren’t going to talk about what happened to Maryanne. And Mom certainly wasn’t going to talk about their fight, either.

Last night Daniel had made me feel guilty for having a family that sat around the dinner table and discussed our lives. But now I realized that we never actually talked about anything that was a problem in our home. It’s why the rest of my family never mentioned Daniel’s name or discussed what happened the night he disappeared—no matter how many times I’d asked. Talking would be admitting that there was something wrong.

Mom smiled. It looked as syrupy and fake as the imitation maple drizzled on my breakfast. She flitted back to the stove and turned over a couple of pancakes. Her face fell into a frown again, and she dumped the barely over-browned batch into the trash. She still wore the same blouse and slacks from yesterday under her apron. Her fingers were red and chapped from hours of cleaning. This was perfection overdrive, big-time.

I wanted to ask Mom why she would hide her fight with Dad by making ten pounds of pancakes, but Charity came stumbling into the room.

“What smells so good?” she yawned.

“Pancakes!” Mom shooed Charity into a seat with her spatula and presented her with a heaping plate. “There’s maple syrup, boysenberry, whipped cream, and raspberry jam.”

“Awesome.” Charity dug into a container of whipped cream with her fork. “You’re the best, Mom.” Charity gulped down her pancakes and went for seconds. She didn’t seem to notice Mom practically scrubbing a hole into the skillet.

Charity grabbed the raspberry jam and then froze. Her eyes suddenly seemed glossy, like she was about to cry. The jar slipped out of her fingers and rolled across the table. I caught it just as it went over the edge.

I looked at the label: FROM THE KITCHEN OF MARYANNE DUKE.

“It’s okay,” I said, and put my hand on Charity’s shoulder.

“I forgot …,” Charity said softly. “I forgot that it wasn’t a dream.” She pushed her plate away and got up from the table.

“I was just about to start some fried eggs,” Mom said as Charity left the room.

I looked down at my plate. My smiling breakfast stared up at me and I didn’t know if I could stomach any more. I took another sip of my orange juice. It tasted sour. I knew I could convince Jude to give me an early ride to school, but I didn’t want to stick around and watch my mother’s display of perfection start all over again when he came down for breakfast. I wrapped a couple of pancakes in a napkin and got up from the table. “I’ve got to go,” I said. “I’ll eat on the way.”

Mom looked up from scrubbing. I could tell my not eating hadn’t helped alleviate her guilt. For some reason I didn’t care.

I walked the few blocks to school in the cold and donated my breakfast to a stray cat I met along the way.

LATER, BEFORE SCHOOL

The clock in the art room ticked its way to 7:25 a.m. and I cursed myself for giving Daniel only a five-minute window for lateness. I closed my eyes and prayed silently that Daniel would come, just so I could prove Barlow wrong about him. But with every tick of the clock I started to think I was the one who was going to be disappointed.

“Worried I wasn’t going to show?” Daniel flopped into the chair next to mine just in time. He wore the light blue woven shirt and khakis I’d left for him, but his clothes were crumpled like he’d had them wadded up in his pack until only a few minutes before.

“I don’t really care what you do.” I felt tiny pricks of red-heat forming on my neck. “It’s your future, not mine.”

Daniel snorted.

Mr. Barlow came out of his office and sat at his desk. “I see Mr. Kalbi decided to join us after all.”

“It’s just Daniel. No Kalbi.” Daniel pronounced his last name like a cuss word.

Barlow raised an eyebrow. “Well, Mr. Kalbi, when you become a famous musician or the Pope you can drop your last name. But in my class you will go by the name your parents gave you.” Barlow looked Daniel over like a critic appraising a new work in a gallery.

Daniel leaned back in his chair and crossed his arms.

Mr. Barlow clasped his fingers together on top of his desk. “You are well aware that your scholarship is contingent on your behavior. You will act and dress appropriately for a Christian school. Today was a nice try, but you might want to invest in an iron. And I highly doubt that is your natural hair color. I will give you until Monday to do something about it.

“As for my class,” Barlow went on, “you will be here every day, on time, and in your seat when the bell rings. Every AP student is required to compile a portfolio of twenty-three works on a specific theme and ten more projects to show their breadth. You are coming into this class late, but I expect you to do the same.” Mr. Barlow leaned forward and stared into Daniel’s eyes like he was challenging him to a game of chicken—daring him to glance away first.

Daniel didn’t blink. “No problem.”

“Daniel is quite proficient,” I said.

Barlow stroked his mustache, and I knew he was about to deliver the catch. “Your portfolio will consist only of work done in this class. I will monitor each of your assignments at the beginning, middle, and end of their progression. You will not turn in anything you have done previous to now.”

“That’s impossible,” I said. “It’s almost December and I’m not even a third of the way through my portfolio.”

“That is why Mr. Kalbi will be joining us every lunch period and will report directly to my classroom for one hour after school, each and every day.”

Daniel almost lost the staring contest but regained his composure. “Nice try, but I have a job in the city after school.”

“I’ve been informed that the school has given you a stipend for your living expenses. You are obviously in one board member’s good graces, but don’t expect any special treatment from me. You will be in this class every day after school, or you will not be here at all.”

Daniel grabbed the edge of the desk and leaned forward. “You can’t do this. I need the money.” He finally looked away. “I have other obligations.”

I sensed a twinge of desperation in his voice. The word obligations made my mouth go dry.

“Those are my stipulations,” Barlow said. “It is your choice.” He gathered up some papers and went into his office.

Daniel threw his chair aside and tore out of the room with the fury of a threatened bear. I followed him into the hall.

Daniel swore and smashed his fist into a locker door. The metal crunched behind his knuckles. “He can’t do this.” He punched the locker again and didn’t even flinch with pain. “I have obligations.”

There was that word again. I couldn’t help wondering what it meant.

“He wants me to be his trained little circus pup. I even wore this stupid shirt.” Daniel clawed at the buttons and tore it off, uncovering his whitish tee and long sinewy muscles in his arms that I hadn’t noticed before. He slammed his dress shirt against the locker. “This is total bullsh—”

“Hey!” I grabbed his hand as he pulled it back for another swing. “Yeah, those lockers really tick me off, too, sometimes,” I said, and stared down a couple of gawking freshmen until they hurried along. “Damn it, Daniel!” I reeled on him. “Don’t swear at school. You’ll get kicked out.”

Daniel licked his lips and almost smiled. He unclenched the fist I still held, dropping his blue shirt. I tried to inspect his hand, expecting his knuckles to be purple, considering the deep dent in the locker door. He pulled out of my grasp and shoved his hand in his pocket.

“This completely sucks,” Daniel said, and leaned against the abused locker. “That Barlow guy doesn’t get it.”

“Well, maybe you can reason with him. Or maybe if you tell me about your obligations, I can explain it to him for you….”

Yeah, could I be any more obvious?

Daniel looked at me for a long moment. His eyes seemed to reflect the fluorescent lights in the dimly lit hall. “You want to get out of here?” he finally asked. “You and me.” He held out his uninjured hand. “Let’s blow these jerks off and do something fun.”

I was an honors student, daughter of a pastor, citizen-of-the-month winner, and a member of the One for Jesus Club, but for the briefest nanosecond I forgot all of those things. I ached to take his hand. But that aching scared me—made me hate him.

“No,” I said before I could change my mind. “I can’t miss class, and neither can you. You skip one more day, and you’ll lose your scholarship. You still want to get into Trenton, don’t you?”

Daniel balled his hand into a fist. He took a deep breath, and his face shifted into a cool, unruffled façade. He pulled a crumpled slip of paper from his pocket. “So, precious, how do I get to geometry?”

I studied the list, relieved that AP art was the only class we would have together. “Room 103 is down the hall and to the left. Past the cafeteria. You can’t miss it. And don’t be late. Mrs. Croswell loves to give detention.”

“Welcome back,” Daniel mumbled. “I forgot how much I hate this sh—crap.” He smirked at me and laughed to himself.

“Yeah, welcome home,” I said. And this time I was the one who walked away.

LATER

I didn’t know how many people would remember Daniel Kalbi. He’d had only a handful of friends growing up, and he’d moved away from Holy Trinity before his sophomore year. Regardless, I expected the appearance of someone like Daniel to at least spark some controversy and gossip. However, there was another scandal sweeping through the halls of school that upstaged Daniel’s return tenfold: the sudden death and mutilation of Maryanne Duke, devoted Sunday-school teacher, childhood babysitter of many, and—despite her old age and meager means—volunteer at almost every school activity.

I was the recipient of many sidelong glances and backhanded whispers as I made my way from class to class. I was used to people talking about me. Watching me. It was just part of being a Divine. Mom always said I had to be careful about the clothes I wore, how late I stayed out, or what movies I was seen going into, because people would set their own behavior by what the pastor’s kids were allowed to do—like I was some kind of walking morality barometer. Really, I think she was more concerned about people having a reason to talk bad about the pastor’s daughter.

Kind of like the talk that was going on today. Except, it was Jude’s and Dad’s names that came up in conversations that halted as I approached. A lot of people had the decency to stick up for my dad against Angela Duke’s accusations of mistreatment, but stories spread fast in a small town. It was only inevitable that wild speculations about my family’s “involvement” in Maryanne’s death would be everywhere. Crap like, “I heard that Mike said that the pastor refused to take Maryanne to her doctor’s appointment and then he said he was going to kick her out of the parish if she didn’t …” Or this gem I heard outside the gym: “They said that Jude’s on some type of meds that made him go all nutso on Maryanne about being sick …,” which I’m ashamed to say made me break the rule I’d set for Daniel about not swearing at school.

But as sad and distraught—and prone to bad language and dirty looks—as I was, I could only imagine how Jude must have felt. April was the only person considerate—or clueless—enough to actually speak to me in person about all the things that had happened in the last twenty-four hours.

“Okay,” April said the second I sat next to her in art. “Number one: where the heck were you last night? Number two: what the heck is he doing here?” She pointed to Daniel, who sat with his feet up on a table in the back of the room. “Number three: what the heck happened to your brother, and is he okay? And number four: numbers one, two, and three had better the heck not have anything to do with one another.” She scrunched her lips and crossed her arms in front of her chest. “I want answers, sister!”

“Whoa,” I said. “First of all, I’m sorry I missed you last night. I got stuck in traffic.”

“Traffic? Around here?” She pointed her finger at Daniel. “You were in the city,” she whispered. “You were with him.”

“No, I wasn’t—”

“I know he lives downtown because I saw him by the city bus stop this morning.”

“That could mean anything….” But really, what was the point in lying? “Okay, I was. But it’s not what you think.”

“It isn’t?” April did this sassy little head shake that made her curly hair bounce like spaniel ears.

“No, it isn’t. I was just delivering a message for Barlow. It’s your fault, anyway.” I mimicked her feisty stance. “You’re the one who turned in his picture and made Barlow want him back in class.”

“Oh, no. Did I get you in trouble? I didn’t mean to. How did he know it was Daniel’s?”

“I told him.”

“What, are you crazy?” April’s eyes widened. She leaned in close and whispered, “You’re in love with him, aren’t you?”

“With Barlow?”

“You know who I’m talking about.” She looked back at Daniel, who was playing the drums on his leg. “You’re still in love with him.”

“I am not. And I never was to begin with. It was just a stupid crush.” I knew she was wrong, but I felt heat rushing up my neck. I grasped for the first thing I could think of to change the subject. “Don’t you want to hear about Jude and Maryanne Duke?”

April’s demeanor changed immediately. Her eyes softened, and she brushed her fingers through her hair. “Oh, my gosh. He looked so sad last night when I came looking for you at your house. And then this morning I heard Lynn Bishop—her brother is an Oak Park paramedic—talking about Maryanne Duke in the hall. I heard her say that Jude and your father had something to do with it. But I couldn’t tell what she was saying. And these guys in bio were going on about the Markham Street Monster.”

I shook my head. “You know the monster’s just a story, right? Besides, Maryanne doesn’t—didn’t—live on Markham.” I knew it was just a story—one I hadn’t heard since I was a kid—but it gave me chills to hear people talk about the monster again. And I also knew not living on Markham didn’t make one immune from strange happenings, either. I hadn’t been able to get the memory of my mutilated little dog out of my head since I’d heard about Maryanne.

“Yeah, but what happened to Maryanne wasn’t a story,” April said. “And why is everyone saying that Jude was involved?”

I glanced up at the window of Barlow’s office. Barlow was on the phone, and he looked like he was going to be a while. April seemed genuinely concerned, and I really wanted to talk to someone about what had happened. I lowered my voice so no one else (especially Lynn) could hear, and I told April about how Jude had found the body and how the Dukes blamed my father. I told her about the aftermath, too. How Jude had freaked out and how my parents had fought.

April gave me a hug. “It’s going to be okay.”

But how could she know that? She hadn’t felt how strange it was to eat dinner at the table by myself, or heard the way my parents shouted at each other. But I guess April would know how those things felt. She moved here when her parents split when she was fourteen, and her mom’s work hours had been getting longer and longer lately. I’d invited her to our Thanksgiving dinner so she wouldn’t have to spend the day alone.

None of that seemed “okay” to me.

Barlow came out of his office. He dumped a box of empty Pepsi cans on his desk and went to work without any instruction to the class.

“Do you want to go to the café for lunch today?” I asked April. “Jude totally wouldn’t mind if we just showed up. In fact, I think he could use the change.”

April bit her lip. “Okay,” she said. “He could probably use some consoling.” She half frowned, but trembled in that excited way of hers.

LUNCH

It usually took a lot of coaxing to get April to come with me to the Rose Crest Café. And the few times she had come, she’d hung back from the group with Miya, Claire, Lane, and a few of the other juniors who watched the seniors with nervous reverence. April was so like my old dog Daisy that way. She had a lot of yap and spunk when it was just the two of us, but she totally cowered in most social situations.

Except today she seemed like a totally different breed.

We had been there only long enough to order our food before she was the center of attention, talking animatedly about her trip to Hollywood with her dad last summer. Brett Johnson and Greg Divers were practically drooling at her feet, but when Jude came through the door, she ditched them and went to his side. Within a matter of minutes, they were sitting together in a corner booth. April patted his hand sympathetically as he spoke to her in low, confidential tones.

“Wow,” Pete said as he pulled up a chair next to me. “I can’t believe April’s cracked his stoic shell.” He tipped his soda can toward Jude. “I haven’t gotten a word out of him all day. In fact, he’s been acting strange for almost a week now.”

“I know what you mean,” I said, and picked at the uneaten sandwich on my tray.

“You doing okay?” Pete asked.

“Yeah. Just tired of being sad.” What’s weird is that the only time I hadn’t felt sad or hurt all day was the few minutes I’d spent with Daniel. But maybe that’s just because he’s so darn aggravating.

Pete tapped his soda can. “Well, I had fun the other night,” he said with a slight upturn in his voice like it was a question.

“Me, too,” I said, even though “fun” wasn’t how I’d describe Friday evening.

“I plan on calling in that rain check for bowling, you know.” Pete grinned. “It’ll give me a chance to prove I’ve got better skills than my ability to fix a car.”

“Good.” I glanced down at my tray. “But give me some time.”

Pete’s grin wavered. “Oh, okay.” He started to scoot away.

“Things are really crazy right now,” I said quickly. “You know, with Maryanne and Thanksgiving and everything. I just won’t have time for a … uh … date for a while.” I half smiled. “I am looking forward to it, though.”

“I’ll take your word for it,” he said.

“See you in chem.” I jumped out of my seat. “I’ll let you be my shoulder to cry on when we get our tests back,” I said, and went to collect my best friend from my brother.

FIFTH PERIOD

“Jude asked me out for coffee this afternoon!” April squealed as we crossed the street to the school.

“That’s nice.” I kept walking, my feet keeping pace with the chirping of the crosswalk meter.

“That’s it?” April padded up behind me. “You’re supposed to freak out and jump and down for joy with me.” She grabbed my sleeve. “Are you mad?”

“No.” Yes. “I am excited for you.” Not. “It’s just that …” You’re supposed to be my best friend. “Jude’s acting really weird lately. Now doesn’t seem like the best time for you to try to be his girlfriend.”

“Or maybe now is when he needs a girlfriend the most,” she said with a trill of excitement. “Come on, Grace. Be happy for me. You went out with Pete, and he’s one of Jude’s best friends.” She smiled all sheepish and innocent. “And it’s just coffee anyway.”

I smiled. “Just coffee, huh?”

“Okay, so the best freaking cup of coffee I’ll ever have!” April popped on her toes. “Come on, be excited for me.”

I laughed. “Okay, I’m excited.”

We got to class a few minutes before the bell. Daniel leaned back in his seat, tearing scratch paper into strips and rolling them into tiny wads. I had to pass him to get to my supply bucket. My back was to him when I felt something plink against my head. A paper ball landed at my feet.

“Hey, Grace,” Daniel stage-whispered.

I ignored him and rummaged in my bucket. Another paper ball hit my head and stuck in my hair. I nonchalantly dislodged it.

“Graa-ciee,” he intoned like a hyena calling its prey.

I collected my supplies and made my way back to my seat. He flicked another paper wad, and it bounced off my cheek. I kept my eyes averted. I wanted to be finished with him. I wanted to tell myself that I’d fulfilled my duty. I’d done what I said I was going to do. But really, I knew I hadn’t. Getting him back into this class was just the first phase of my plan. I still had to find out what had happened between Daniel and Jude so I could fix it. And since Jude wasn’t going to tell me, I knew I had to get that information from Daniel. But I couldn’t face him yet. I still hated the way he’d made me want to forget—even for a moment—who I was.

How could I help Daniel find his way, without losing mine?

AFTER SCHOOL

“So what are you going to do?” April asked as we hiked through the parking lot separating the school from the parish.

I unrolled my chem test and stared at the red D marked on the page, followed by a scribbled note from Mrs. Howell: Please have parent sign your test. Return after the holiday. “I don’t know,” I said. “Dad usually handles this sort of thing the best, but I don’t want to bug him right now. And Mom’s all hopped up in Martha Stewart mode, so if I show her this, she’ll probably make me drop art next semester.”

“No way,” April said. “Maybe you should sign it yourself.”

“Yeah, right. You know I can’t do that.” I rolled the test up again and stuck it into my back pocket. “He’s here!” April yelped.

Jude pulled up to the curb in front of the parish in the Corolla. He was picking April up here for their “coffee date.” I waved to him, but he didn’t wave back.

“Lipstick check.” April smiled so I could inspect her teeth.

“You’re good,” I said, not really looking. I watched Jude idling in front of the parish. He had that stony look on his face.

“Good luck with the test,” April said, positively shaking.

“Hey.” I reached out and took her hand. “Have a good time. And … watch out for Jude for me, okay? Let me know if he needs anything.”

“Will do.” April squeezed my hand and then bounded across the rest of the parking lot to the Corolla. I was surprised Jude didn’t get out to open the door for her—not very Jude-like at all. But at least his expression softened slightly when she hopped into the car.

As much as I wasn’t too keen on the idea of my best friend dating my brother, I hoped Pete was right about April—that she could crack Jude’s stoic shell when nobody else could.

AT THE PARISH

After Jude and April drove away, I pulled my rolled-up test out of my pocket and went down the alley between the parish and the school. I stopped at my father’s outer office door and tentatively listened for signs of life. I figured Dad was still the best bet for signing off on my grade, plus I wanted to check on how he was doing, but I had no idea if he had even ventured out of his study at the house yet. My question was answered before I could even knock on the door.

“I can’t do this anymore,” I heard someone say. The strained voice sounded somewhat like my father’s. “I can’t do it again.”

“I didn’t mean to,” someone else said. It was a masculine but childish voice. “I didn’t mean to scare nobody.”

“But you did,” the first voice said, and this time I was certain it belonged to my father. “This is the third time this year. I can’t help you again.”

“You promised. You promised you’d help me. You fix things. That’s what you do.”

“I’m done!” my father shouted.

I knew I shouldn’t, but I pushed open the door and saw Don Mooney throw his hands over his head. He wailed like a gigantic baby.

“Dad!” I yelled over Don’s cries. “What on earth is going on?”

Dad looked at me, startled that I was suddenly there. Don noticed me, too. He fell quiet, trembling in his chair. Fluid streamed from his nose and his great, swollen melon eyes.

Dad sighed. His shoulders slumped like the weight on them had increased tenfold. “Don decided to take his knife to work. Again.” Dad pointed at the hauntingly familiar dagger that lay on his desk. It was the same knife Don had once held to my father’s throat. “He scared off a bunch of customers, and Mr. Day fired him. Again.”

“I didn’t know he’d been fired before.”

Don cringed.

“That’s because I always smooth things over. Don screws up, and I fix it.” Dad sounded so distant, not with the normal kindness and compassion so characteristic of his deep, melodic voice. His face sagged with lack of sleep, his eyes shadowed by dark circles. “I try and I try to fix everything for everyone, and look where it’s gotten me. I can’t help anymore. I only make things worse. Both of them are on their own.”

“Both?” I asked.

Don wailed, cutting me off.

“Dad, this is Don we’re talking about,” I said, shocked at the sudden rush of feeling I had for the blubbering man—even with his knife so close by. “You weren’t trying to scare anyone, were you?”

“No, Miss Grace.” Don’s huge lower lip quivered. “Them people were already afraid. They was talking about the monster—the one that tried to eat Maryanne. So I showed them my knife. It’s pure silver. My great-great-grandpa used it to kill monsters. My granddaddy told me so. All my ancestors took an oath to kill monsters. I was showing the people that I could stop the monster before it—”

“That’s enough,” Dad said. “There’s no such thing as monsters.”

Don cowered. “But my granddaddy—”

“Don.” I gave him my best don’t push it look. I turned to my dad. “Don needs you. You said you’d help him. You can’t just quit because it’s hard. I mean, what ever happened to seventy times seven and all that ‘be your brother’s keeper’ stuff you’re always talking about?”

Guilt washed through me. How could I say all that? I mean, I was the one who wanted to give up on Daniel just because helping him had turned out to be difficult in ways I hadn’t expected. And I really couldn’t believe I was the one expounding scripture—however crudely—to my father.

Dad rubbed his hand down the side of his face. “I’m sorry, Grace. You’re right. These are my burdens to bear.” He put his hand on Don’s shoulder. “I guess I can talk to Mr. Day one more time.”

Don lunged and wrapped his arms around my father’s middle. “Thank you, Pastor D-vine!”

“Don’t thank me yet.” Dad sounded breathless from Don’s death-grip hug. “I’ll have to take your knife away for a little while.”

“No,” Don said. “It was my granddaddy’s. The only thing I’ve got of his. I need it … for the monsters….”

“That’s the deal,” Dad said. He looked at me. “Grace, put that thing in a safe place.” He led Don from the room, the latter gazing longingly at his knife as they went. “We’ll discuss its return in a few weeks.”

I put my test in my backpack—today was obviously not the right time to get it signed—and picked up the dagger. I held it out in my hands. It was heavier than I’d expected. The blade was stained with tarnish and other strange, dark-colored marks. It seemed ancient, valuable even. I knew where Dad wanted me to hide it. I tipped back the potted poinsettia on the bookcase and slid out the key it concealed. I unlocked the top drawer of my father’s desk, where he kept important things like the cash safe for the Sunday offerings and his first-aid kit. I placed the knife under a flashlight and locked the drawer.

I replaced the key and felt a pang of remorse. I knew what Don was capable of doing with that blade of cold silver, but I couldn’t help feeling sorry for his loss. I couldn’t fathom having only a single item to remember a loved one by.

“Hey.” Charity slipped into the office. “That was really nice, what you did for Don.”

“I did it more for Dad,” I said. “I don’t want him to wake up tomorrow regretting the things he did today.”

“I don’t think Dad will be back to normal tomorrow.”

I looked up at her. She seemed to be blinking back tears. “Why?” I asked, though I really didn’t want to know the answer. I’d been holding on to the fantasy that I would wake up tomorrow and everything would be the way it was supposed to be: oatmeal for breakfast, uneventful day at school, and a genial chicken-and-rice supper with the whole family.

“Maryanne’s daughters want her funeral to be tomorrow, before Thanksgiving, because they don’t want to cancel some big trip they’ve been planning.”

I sighed. “I guess I should have thought of that. Death is usually followed by a funeral.” Helping Mom prepare loads of rice pilaf and all varieties of casseroles for bereaving families was just another part of the pastor’s-kid gig, but I hadn’t been to a funeral for someone I was actually close to since my grandpa died when I was eight.

“That isn’t the bad part,” Charity said. “Maryanne’s family asked the pastor from New Hope to come over for the funeral. They don’t want Dad to do it. They still blame him.”

“What? That’s not fair. Dad knew Maryanne all his life, and he’s been her pastor for as long as you’ve been alive.”

“I know. But they won’t listen.”

I sank down in the desk chair. “No wonder he’s talking like he wants to give up.”

“You know the worst part? Pastor Clark heard about our duet from Sunday, and he wants us to sing it at the funeral because it was Maryanne’s favorite song.”

I opened my mouth to protest.

“Mom says we have to.” Charity sighed. “She says it’s our obligation or something like that.”

Obligation. I was beginning to hate that word.