4

Cynthia said, “I had a hard day and I could use a drink. There’s usually scotch around here. How about you?”

Nim told her, “Count me in.” It was an hour since he had made love to Karen, who was now sleeping. He felt the need for a drink too.

Karen’s older sister had come to the apartment twenty minutes ago, using her own key. Nim had finished dressing sometime earlier.

She had introduced herself as Cynthia Woolworth. “Before you ask the question, no, my husband—unfortunately—is not connected with that wealthy family. I used to spend half my life answering that; now I get it out of the way at the beginning. Sloan was simpler.”

“Thank you,” he said. “I’ll never mention it again.”

Cynthia, he observed, was different from Karen, but also similar. Where Karen was blonde and slim, Cynthia was brunette, her figure full, though not excessively. Clearly, too, Cynthia’s personality was more forceful and outgoing, though perhaps, Nim thought, the misfortune which life had dealt Karen early, and their differences in life styles since, could account for that. What both had in common was a rare natural beauty—the same delicate symmetry of features, full lips, wide blue eyes, a flawless skin and—more developed in Cynthia—elegant, slim hands. It occurred to Nim that both Sloan girls had inherited their charms from their mother, Henrietta, in whom traces of an earlier loveliness still lingered. Nim remembered that Cynthia was three years older than Karen, which made, her forty-two, although she appeared younger.

Cynthia located the scotch, then ice and soda, and mixed two drinks efficiently. The quick economy of her movements showed she was used to managing for herself. She had demonstrated that from the time she arrived at the apartment, shook out her dripping raincoat and hung it in the bathroom, then following mutual introductions, instructed Nim, “All right, you sit down and relax—here, I brought the evening paper—and I’ll do what’s needed for my sister.”

She had walked into Karen’s bedroom, closing the door so that Nim could hear a murmur of voices, but no more.

When Cynthia came out fifteen minutes later, moving quietly, she announced that Karen was asleep.

Now, seated facing Nim, Cynthia swirled the liquor and ice in her glass and informed him, “I know what happened here tonight. Karen told me.”

Startled by the directness, all he could think of in response was, “I see.”

Cynthia threw back her head and laughed. She pointed an accusing finger. “You’re scared! You’re wondering if I’ll be the avenging elder sister. Or if I’ll call the cops maybe, and holler ‘rape!’”

He said stiffly, “I’m not sure I want, or need to discuss with you …”

“Oh, come on!” Cynthia had continued to laugh; now suddenly she stopped. Her face became serious. “Look, Nimrod—if I can call you that—I’m sorry if I embarrassed you, and I can see I did. So now let me tell you something. Karen thinks you’re a kind, sweet, gentle, loving man, and the best thing that’s ever happened to her. And if you’re interested in an outside opinion, I feel the same way.”

Nim stared at her. As he did, he realized that for the second time tonight he was seeing a woman cry.

“Damn! I didn’t mean to do that.” With a tiny handkerchief Cynthia wiped her tears away. “But I guess I’m as happy and satisfied as Karen is herself.” She regarded Nim in frank approval. “Well, almost.”

Nina’s tension of a moment earlier dissolved. Grinning, he acknowledged, “I can only say one thing. I’ll be damned!”

“I can say more than that, and will,” Cynthia said. “How about another drink first?”

Without waiting for an answer she scooped up Nim’s glass and replenished it, along with her own. Returning to her seat, she sipped the scotch before continuing, carefully choosing her words.

“For your sake, Nimrod, as much as Karen’s, I want you to realize something. What happened between you and my sister tonight was wonderful and beautiful. You may not know this, or understand it, but some people treat quadriplegics the way they would a leper. I’ve seen it happen sometimes; Karen sees it more. That’s why, in my book, you come out as Mr. Nice Guy. You’ve never thought of her, or treated her, as anything but a woman … Oh, for God’s sake! … Here I am crying again.”

Cynthia’s handkerchief was clearly inadequate. Nim handed her his own and she glanced at him gratefully. “It’s the little things you do … Karen told me that …”

He said humbly, “It all started, you know—my coming to see Karen—accidentally.”

“Most things do.”

“And what went on between us tonight … well, I didn’t plan it. I didn’t even think …” Nim stopped. “It simply happened.”

“I know that,” Cynthia said. “And while we’re about it, let me ask you something else. Did you—do you—have any guilt feelings?”

He nodded. “Yes.”

“Don’t! I read something once, when I was finding out how I could best help Karen, by a man named Milton Diamond. He’s a medical professor in Hawaii who made a study of sex and disabled people. I may not have the words exactly right, but the sense of what he wrote was: The disabled have enough problems without having conventional guilt-laden values forced on them … private sexual satisfaction takes precedence over public approval; therefore any guilt is wrong … and sexually, for disabled people, anything goes.” Cynthia added almost fiercely, “So don’t you have any guilts either. Wipe them out!”

“I’m not sure,” Nim said, “if I can take any more surprises tonight. Just the same, I’m glad we talked.”

“I am too. It’s a part of learning, and I had to learn about Karen, just as you have.” Cynthia continued sipping her scotch, then said meditatively, “Would you believe me if I told you that when Karen was eighteen and I was twenty-one I hated her?”

“I’d find it hard to believe.”

“Well, it’s true. I hated her because she got all the attention from our parents and their friends. Some days, at home, it was as if I didn’t exist. It was always, Karen this, and Karen that! What can we do for dear, poor Karen? Never, What can we do for healthy, normal Cynthia? It was my twenty-first birthday. I wanted a big party but my mother said it was ‘inappropriate’ because of Karen. So we had a little family tea—just my parents and me; Karen was in the hospital then—a lousy tea, and a shoddy, cheap little cake. As for my birthday presents, they were just tokens because guess where all the available money was going, every cent. I’m ashamed to say it, but that night I prayed for Karen to die.”

In the silence which followed, even through drawn drapes, Nim could hear wind-driven rain against the window. He had understood what Cynthia had told him, and was moved. Yet, in a corner of his mind he thought: Glorious rain! To a utilities man, rain, sleet or snow meant stored-up hydroelectric power for the dry season ahead. He pulled back his thoughts and spoke to Cynthia.

“So when did your feelings change?”

“Not for years, and even then slowly. Before that I went through my own guilt period. I felt guilty because I was whole and Karen wasn’t. Guilty because I could do the things she couldn’t—play tennis, go to parties, neck with boys.” Cynthia sighed. “I wasn’t a good sister.”

“But you are now.”

“As much as I can be—after taking care of a husband, house and kids. It was after my first child was born that I began to understand and appreciate my little sister and we became close. Now the two of us are dear, loving friends, sharing ideas and confidences. There isn’t anything I wouldn’t do for Karen. And there isn’t anything she doesn’t tell me.”

Nim said drily, “I’d gathered that.”

They talked on. Cynthia told him more about herself. She had married at twenty-two; one reason was to get away from home. Since then her husband had held a succession of jobs; his present one was as a shoe salesman. Nim surmised that the marriage was barely adequate, if that, and Cynthia and her husband stayed together for lack of an alternative and the sake of their three children. Before her marriage, Cynthia had taken singing lessons; now, four nights a week she sang in a second-rate nightclub to supplement her husband’s meager pay. Tonight was a non-singing night and Cynthia would stay with Karen, her husband taking care of their one child still at home. Cynthia had two more scotches while they talked; Nim declined. After a while her voice became slightly slurred.

At length Nim stood up. “It’s late. I have to go.”

“I’ll get your raincoat,” Cynthia said. “You’ll need it, even going to your car.” She added, “Or you can stay if you want. There’s a couch makes up into a bed.”

“Thanks. I’d better not.”

She helped him on with the coat and, at the apartment front door, kissed him fully on the lips. “That’s partly for Karen,” Cynthia said, “partly for me.”

Driving home, he tried to push the thought away as being predatory and disloyal, but it persisted: So many attractive, desirable women in the world, and so many available and willing to share sexual pleasures. Experience, instinct, her own unmistakable signals told him: Cynthia was available too.