Chapter 27
ELLA
I quite remember how my sister first lost the
affection of the people, and she did so innocently and against all
the force of her strong will too. Contrary to her great
determination and prayers, she gave birth to Olga. And while Nicky
and Alicky soothed their disappointments by telling each other that
because their firstborn was a girl they wouldn’t have to give her
up to the people, good society and the rest of the Empire were not
entirely pleased with Alicky, not really. Nicky’s youngest sister
had been born to a seated and anointed Emperor, of course, but an
heir to the throne—which had to be male according to the Semi-Salic
laws initiated by Emperor Paul—had not been born in the purple for,
heavens, longer than anyone could remember, and we were all
awaiting this glorious event as a heavenly sign of Russia’s future
prosperity. But after Olga came beautiful Tatyana, and after
Tatyana came Maria, and after Maria came Anastasiya. By that time
of course Alicky had become so unpopular, not just in the highest
court circles but among the common people as well, with many
certain that she was a traitor to our nation for not producing a
boy. Then finally and at long last came our dear, sweet Aleksei,
and with the birth of the Heir Tsetsarevich, well, Alicky was in
some ways redeemed, for the dynasty could go on.
I thought of this sad lesson often in the days
after my venture beyond the Kremlin walls. I thought of it often
due to the great disharmony I had seen on the streets and the fear
that that poor wounded girl had expressed toward us members of the
Ruling House. Alicky had only barely repaired her image and
reputation, but I sensed Nicky’s present situation to be poor at
best, and his future prospects dim.
Hoping to prove myself wrong, I forced the issue
with the wounded officers at my hospital, begging them to overlook
my high rank and speak truly, and I gathered word of the street
from others as well, and as far as I could tell these things were
passed to me without corruption. In short time it was perfectly
clear that Nicky had lost completely the affection of his people,
and this broke my heart. And while Alicky had in some ways improved
her situation with the birth of the Heir Tsarevich, I knew only too
well that love for an emperor once lost—worse yet, betrayed and
shattered—was almost impossible to reclaim. And yet the power of
Nicky’s Throne was based upon this, upon love of God and Tsar, and
without this what would happen, what fate awaited us all? Without a
tsar to keep this vast nation glued together, then what?
Among other things, whatever the future had in
store for the Dynasty I sadly had to accept that Nicky and Alicky
would never again be safe in the midst of their people. There would
henceforth be a far greater fear of assassin’s bullet or bomb, and
ultimately, one had to admit, there would likely be a bloody deed
once again, for I knew only too well that our simple people could
be sweet and kind one moment but so very cruel and violent the
next. I had heard tell that there had been no fewer than ten
attempts upon Nicky’s grandfather, Aleksander II, before that
hideous success, and God only knew how many attempts had been made
against my beloved Sergei before he too was taken.
Oh, I cried and I prayed as much for my dear sister
and her huzzy as I did—no, I prayed even more—for my beloved
adopted homeland. What path had we gone down? Were we forever lost?
God help and guide us—that was my prayer morning, noon, and night.
How had this hateful current sweeping across the country been
awakened? Could prayer and love actually soothe its tempest, or
were we doomed? No, I told myself over and over, God would not
forsake this wonderful land.
Throughout all these dark days I heard regularly
from my sister, who wrote me at length several times each and every
day. Nicky and she dared not leave Tsarskoye, she told me, and so
in essence they continued to be trapped there behind the great
gates of the Palace. Simply unimaginable and what a disgrace! Alas,
because of the disruptions I received her letters only with
difficulty; they were brought to me not by post, which had ceased
to function, but by one of my countesses, who somehow managed to
travel back and forth between our two great cities, this despite
the railway strikes and the many dangers en route.
From Alicky I learned that through all of those
trying days, Nicky met constantly with Count Witte, whose past
policies had encouraged the industrialization of Russia and brought
such explosive economic growth. Too, Witte, a large, gruff man, had
just been sent to America to negotiate the peace with Japan, and he
had done such an admirable job that he made our defeat nearly
tolerable. Because of these successes, Nicky had him fetched to the
Palace each and every day to discuss and, God willing, find a
solution to the quagmire in which Russia was now stuck. They met
not in Nicky’s New Study, decorated in the Style Moderne, but in
the Working Study just next door. Nicky, I knew since years,
preferred meeting his ministers and councillors in this smaller
room, with its dark-wood paneling and Nicky’s L-shaped desk,
covered with family photos, appointment diaries, and folders. And
Alicky, trying to comprehend what was happening to our world,
recounted me at length of their meetings.
“Sire, it seems that there are only two ways open,”
said Witte, who was seated not on the nearby large divan but on the
wooden chair in front of the desk. “The first would be to find a
soldier with an iron fist who could and would crush the rebellion
with sheer force. If this is the course you choose, perhaps your
uncle, Grand Duke Nikolai Nikolaevich, would be the right person.
He has always enjoyed great respect amongst the soldiery.”
Nicky clearly understood all that this meant, and
replied, “By this you mean essentially establishing a
dictatorship?”
“Yes, Your Majesty, I’m afraid so.”
“That would entail rivers of blood, and in the end
we would be where we had started.” Nicky sighed and glanced over to
the wall at a portrait of his father, Aleksander III. “If Papa were
still alive, that is of course the path that he would follow. And
there are many members of my family who would encourage me to do so
as well, to hang each and every revolutionary.”
With a sad shrug, Witte replied, “Unfortunately,
the unrest is so widespread that to hang them all would require
many lampposts—more, I would venture, than would be tolerable.
Perhaps even more than exist in the whole of both Sankt Peterburg
and Moscow.”
“Yes, I’m afraid you are correct on that. Of
course, the other way out would be to give to the people their
civil rights—the freedom of speech and press and so on. This is
what is being asked of me . . . and, as you know, some are
demanding such things even for the Jews.”
“This I understand all too well. And virtually
every faction is demanding that all new laws be conformed by the
new State Duma, which Your Majesty has promised to convene.”
Just that past August, of course, Nicky had issued
an Imperial ukaz declaring that a State Duma, a kind of
parliament, be organized. And while that had been well received
amongst many, many others agitated that it wasn’t enough. In short,
Nicky’s manifesto hadn’t been sufficient to quell the unrest. The
people wanted more. They wanted this Duma to have real power, real
oversight, which, of course, would mean the complete finality of
autocracy in Russia.
“In essence,” said Nicky, “we are talking about a
constitution. ”
Witte bowed his head. “Most definitely. And this is
a path I defend most energetically. As I have said, if this is
agreed to and my actions are not interfered with, then, Sire, I
will be pleased to accept the Presidency of the Council of
Ministers.”
But of course a constitution was quite intolerable
to both Nicky and Alicky. It was not simply a matter of the giving
up of power, for I knew for a fact that Nicky would have been only
too glad to walk away from this business of ruling. A farm or an
estate in a distant province, that was his sincerest wish. But God
had laid upon Nicky’s shoulders the heavy burden of Throne, and a
constitution would mean the abandonment of the pledge he had sworn
to the Almighty. And if the Tsar abandoned God, would not God
abandon him? And what, then, of the Heir Tsarevich, who was so in
need of a miracle? Even worse, would God next not abandon Russia as
well? Most of all, Nicky and Alicky feared what would happen to
their subjects if he turned his back on God, for Nicky had solemnly
sworn to protect and lord over his people and lead them to
prosperity. That was his oath, sworn to before God and man at his
coronation. So many criticized Nicky this way and that, but I knew
firsthand what others might not, that there was no one more
dedicated to the Motherland.
In all her letters, Alicky was so concerned, so
worried for the future of her country, so distraught at the thought
of handing over a weakened Empire to her son, this boy who was the
hope of the Dynasty yet who himself was not of strong health. And
yet she wrote me that there were only two who tried to convince
Nicky to hold steadfast the Throne and not bow to pressure—and
these two were Count Ignatiev and Court Minister Fredericks, the
dear old sweet. All the others whom Nicky consulted were of the
same opinion, that there was no other course. Within the family I
even heard it said that Nikolasha—Grand Duke Nikolai
Nikolaevich—threatened to blow his brains out with a revolver if
Nicky did not sign. For days on end Nicky and Witte discussed every
option at great length, and in the end, invoking God’s help, Nicky
signed. It was, I knew in my depths, a difficult decision for
Nicky, one that he nevertheless took quite consciously.
“In the end,” he later told me, “I had no other way
out but to cross myself and give what everyone was asking
for.”
Yes, quite. And with a single signature the
autocracy, which Holy Mother Russia had known for time on end, had
capitulated.
But Nicky’s ukaz, granting liberties of
speech and gathering and press, not to mention rights to the Duma
itself, seemed to satisfy no one. In short time a handful of Grand
Dukes and nobles started grumbling, saying they continued to
believe in the autocratic principle, and claiming over and over
that the peasant masses needed a master to rule over them, that
Russia was far too backward and uneducated for such drastic
reforms. Sadly, most everyone else felt the Tsar hadn’t gone far
enough, some spouting for a republic, others saying we needed a
constitutional monarchy modeled on that of England. To everyone’s
surprise, the workers were like greedy children, the more they got,
the more they wanted. Indeed, these new freedoms seemed to do
nothing but make matters worse, for the common people, so naïve and
ready to believe anything, began clustering here and there at will,
listening to the revolutionaries, who were speaking any number of
provocative and disgraceful things. As if this weren’t enough,
telegrams began arriving from across the Empire about attacks upon
the Jews. Just appalling, and it was no wonder that word came
around, too, that many of them were taking their few possessions
and fleeing to America.
May God bless Russia and send her peace, that was
the prayer we uttered with every breath. It was anyone’s guess what
the future would bring. One could only hope that the Lord had not
and would not abandon us. I was only happy that my Sergei was at
peace near God and had been spared this awful time.
Towards December, when the revolutionaries grew
particularly violent and began setting up barricade after
barricade, it became perfectly obvious that Nicky’s government was
teetering on the verge of total collapse. Finally, our troops began
appearing in the streets, and though at first we all feared that
they would cross over to the other side, they were somehow rallied
and fought back with great force, even using machine guns and
artillery. Still, the outcome was anything but certain. As the days
fell one darker than the last, as the sounds of bullets shattered
the moments and our nerves, it seemed that nothing could forestall
the gathering storm, and the revolutionaries abandoned any pretense
and began calling openly for total revolt. The cry for blood could
be heard everywhere.
Only those who were there know the horrors through
which we lived. How the Empire managed to survive was anyone’s
guess.
And yet for me there was one bright spot that
burned brighter and brighter with divine clarity. This idea of
mine, which had, I supposed, been brewing for quite some time,
years even, burst forth with great intensity soon after the death
of Sergei and became completely clear by the end of that year. Yes,
I had longed to do good for people, but it was true I had long been
constrained as much by my husband as by my high position. The
tragedy of the past year, however, had torn my reality to shreds,
freed me for a truer calling, and in this way my duty and my future
were more easily seen than ever before. My plans occupied my every
waking moment.
One day I beckoned Varya, who had become my most
devoted lady’s maid, requesting simply, “Please see to it that
virtually every one of my jewels is brought into my boudoir.”
Varya, a kind soul, not tall of stature and of
plain face, hesitated, and then asked, “Your Highness, what . . . ?
I mean, is there a particular piece that Your Highness is searching
for? Perhaps your Mistress of the Robes could be more helpful in
this matter than I. I could fetch her, if you like.”
I smiled gently. Those closest to me had expressed
such kind concern these past months, worried by the sad look in my
eyes, the way I seemed detached and uninterested in my customary
doings. I could see on their faces their misgivings for me, and I
was aware to a degree how my people had been watching out for me
and trying to cushion me from the difficult events beyond the
Kremlin walls. It was true, my thinking had not been entirely
logical since the death of my husband. However, in the decision I
was about to make I was entirely certain, and in a most odd way
there were but few whom I trusted more than this maid, whose modest
soul, I knew, was of complete purity and honesty. Indeed, she was
one of a handful I gladly kept on, for in recent months I had
greatly reduced my quantity of servants and the size of my court,
kindly pleading to most of my ladies that their services were no
longer required.
I repeated, “I would like all of my jewelry brought
from the glass-topped cabinets of my dressing room. Please bring
these things into my boudoir and open the cases and the velvet bags
in which they lie. And please do not be alarmed, Varya, this is all
of good intention.”
“Da-s, Your Highness,” she said with a
polite curtsey.
It was no secret in proper society—let alone
amongst the petty dish rags—that with the death of Sergei, I was
now the richest Grand Duchess in the Empire, for I had been
Sergei’s sole legatee. Of course, I still had use of the 100
million gold rubles that upon my marriage Alexander III had placed
on deposit for my use, but now I had inherited so much more—when
presented with the figures, even I found them staggering. But in
truth I did not see myself as owner of so many grand palaces, or
these vast estates with their villages and thousands of peasants,
or the priceless works of art and so on. No, I viewed myself a
steward. And now I was a steward with a calling. It was odd. Once I
had cared for nothing more than fine gowns and jewels, fancy balls
and extravagant entertainments, not to mention the admiring eyes
that followed me—more than once it came to my ears that the two
most beautiful women in Europe were the two Elisabeths, myself and
Sisi, the Empress Elisabeth of Austria-Hungary. However, costume
and dress and dance, for which I had been so well known in the best
society all across the Continent, were gone from me now, things
virtually not of interest, not any more. Where once I had found joy
in merriments that lasted until dawn, now at sunrest I found
complete and utter peace there on my knees and at prayer before an
icon. Yes, at the end of my day I longed for nothing more than to
pop into the chapel to bid Sergei good night.
In an hour’s time my devoted Varya informed me that
all had been done as requested, and it was with a rush of
excitement that I made for my boudoir. Over time I had come to
understand what my Grandmama had not, that the jewels of Russian
women were not prideful decoration alone but also a symbol, an
emblem, of the power and riches of our great Empire. In short word,
nowhere on earth was there a more lavish display of gem than here.
Of course Alicky had a collection be fitting the Empress of Russia,
and the jewels of Minnie, the Widow Empress, were equally blinding.
My collection followed soon thereafter, perhaps just after Grand
Duchess Maria Pavlovna, the senior, who herself ranked third of
ladies in the Empire. In any case, Sergei had built my collection
quite admirably, taking as much pride in their beauty as he did in
knowing that my jewels were famous beyond our borders.
And while I had always loved my accessories,
opening my chamber doors now and seeing the sheer quantity of
jewels laid out before me, I was filled with a kind of joy I had
never experienced. My bed, my bureaus, the chairs and divan were
covered with sparkling and glistening goods, more than I realized
or could have imagined, and certainly enough to fill the entire
inventory of the finest London jewelry store. Upon the bed sat a
handful of tiaras, one of white gold set with 250 diamonds of the
first water, another of platinum from Cartier set with perfectly
matched freshwater pearls and 15 diamonds each of 15-carats,
another with seven large emerald cabochons, and on and on, a blaze
of wealth that even I found astounding. In one glance to the left I
saw a stunning necklace of magnificent sapphires and cut diamonds,
a diamond choker and earrings in the fashion of rose petals, a
complete parure of aquamarines and diamonds, a stunning ruby brooch
of 110-carats surrounded by white diamonds, and ropes of pearls
measuring several arms in length. Turning the other way, I saw
diamond clasps, pearl buttons, a number of stunning brooches by
that Swedish jeweler Bolin, one a 60-carat emerald brooch
surrounded by rose-cut brilliants, another a butterfly of rubies
and diamonds and sapphires. Pearl-drop pendants in white gold,
bowknot brooches, diamond-studded posy holders, stomachers,
chokers, hairpins—they were all spread out before me, a simply
dazzling and near-priceless array of the very finest jewels.
My eyes lit up and my physical self surged with a
kind of energy that I had not felt in month upon month. For the
first time ever I saw these treasures not in terms of their beauty
and show, but in value of gold rubles and pound sterling—a
veritable fortune!—and never had I appreciated them more. Oh, what
plans I had!
“Varya,” I said, “also fetch my Fabergé pieces—the
frames with diamonds, the golden egg with sapphires, and anything
else of significance. Search everywhere, high and low, at
once.”
“Yes, Your Highness, but—”
“At once!”
I had been named after one of my ancestresses,
Saint Elisabeth of Turingen and Hungary, known for her humility,
her piousness, and her dedication to the poor. Upon the death of
her husband, she had been cruelly forced from her royal home,
whereupon she led the life of a wanderer yet remained ever true to
her charitable intentions. And it was from my mother as well as
this namesake that I had always taken good intention. Now from the
both of them I drew not simply strength and determination but great
conviction. Further, I had to admit that somewhere inside I also
felt a keen desire to make right, if possible, some of my Sergei’s
transgressions—his impatience not only with me but others, his
intolerance of those not pure Russian, and his inability to reach
down to those in need.
Oh, I thought then and there with this great
fortune of jewels glittering before me, it was hard to believe that
I alone, without any outer influence, had decided these steps,
which I was sure many would think an unbearable cross. Perhaps one
day I would either regret this, throw over, or break down under,
but I would try and I knew that He would forgive me my mistakes. In
my life I had had so much joy—and in my sorrows such boundless
comfort that I longed to give a little of that to others. Oh, this
was not a new feeling, this was an old one which had always been
with me. Simply, I longed to thank Him.
To this pile of jewels Varya brought in tray after
tray of Faberg é bric-a-brac, bejeweled knitting needles, guilloche
pens, gold frames, and the such, all glorious and precious items.
As she did this, I surveyed everything. Yes, I knew from whence
came each and every gem—that large sapphire and diamond brooch from
Sasha and Minnie upon my engagement, that stunning diamond and
emerald tiara for our wedding. Yes, and that Siberian amethyst
brooch from Sergei for our anniversary, and those gorgeous
emerald-and-diamond earrings had belonged to Sergei’s mother, and
that lovely 50-carat ruby brooch was a present from dear Kostya,
and . . . and . . . and . . .
Sometime later I looked up and saw dear Varya still
staring upon me, awaiting further command.
It was true, I was almost in a state of delirium,
or so it felt, and to Varya, who was by chance the first person I
was to tell, I confessed, “I will keep Ilyinskoye for my purposes
of rest and replenishment, but all of my other palaces and
properties I will give to Dmitri, just as Sergei would have wished.
As for Maria, I will build an appropriate dowry—I will see to it
that she will have no concerns for the rest of her life. As for all
of these jewels before me now, I mean to divide them into three
unequal parts. Those things that were presents from the Imperial
Family will be returned to them and, where appropriate, to the
State Treasury. A second lot, a much smaller one, shall be
collected for gifts to my dearest ones—perhaps the emeralds to my
brother and sisters abroad. And the third part, the largest, I
shall sell.”
“Oh, my!” gasped Varya, clapping a hand to her
mouth. “But, Your Highness, all . . . all of it?”
“Yes,” I said, with a surge of joy that filled my
heart. “Absolutely all of it!”
But there was one more piece of fine jewelry not
laid out. Looking down at my own slender hand, I saw that in the
months since Sergei’s death my skin, neglected, had grown drier,
and my nails were no longer those of a fashionable lady. And yet
glistening on that hand was something quite gorgeous of platinum
and brillianti, the thing that had bound me in holy pledge
to my husband: my wedding ring.
Oh, it was time, and I was eager to leave those
dazzling days behind, for my new calling was ever so much more
important . . .
I hesitated not a moment, for I knew that the value
of this single item alone could accomplish much. In a rapturous
moment, I pulled from my finger the ring I had worn for more than
twenty years, setting it firmly on my bed.
And with the joy of both liberation and
anticipation, I proclaimed, “Yes, I will sell everything that I
possess, for I have the absolute conviction to follow Christ’s
Commandment: ‘Sell that thou hast, and give to the poor.’ Further,
I have decided that I will pension off my servants and close
entirely my court. You must help me sort these things, Varya, for I
intend to dispose of every last one of these jewels, and with the
proceeds to realize my great dream. On the other side of the Moscow
River, down along Bolshaya Ordinka, I have found an impressive
piece of property. It is upon these premises that I intend to build
an obitel—that’s right, a cloister, a women’s
monastery—dedicated to prayer, labor, and charity.”