Central Park
THE BOOK OF DAYS
In soul-baring confessional writings (maximum
honesty with regard to oneself), the third-person form is
better.
—Max Frisch, Sketchbook
(1970)
In God We Trust. She notes these words
inscribed on a five dollar bill she sticks in her pocket, heads for
the park. Odd, how she no longer sees the motto on twenties and
tens, on every coin in her purse. Did she ever believe in that
trust? When the patrician voice of the president declared a date
that will live in infamy; when her brother was drafted during
the conflict in Korea; perhaps held that tarnished belief when she
marched with thousands against the wars in Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos.
Even then believed, though her trust was in the marching, not
God on a dull penny, in the slogans and songs, trusting
something worthy would come of her effort, more than camaraderie or
the glow of self-satisfaction. Her picture had been snapped with
the hippie academics. She’s in the tie-dye T pushing through the
police barrier, storming onto campus when Governor Reagan punished
children who stepped out of line, said oh no you don’t teach your
dispiriting lessons against the war, not on my watch. These days
she would not be sure of her footing if herded into the courthouse
in Santa Barbara to be charged with unlawful assembly.
The Sixties were so performative! This
contribution from her daughter who lives nearby.
What does that mean?
Well, she can no longer march. In Central Park she
walks the short distance set by her failing heart, delights in a
warm day, an amber wash of Indian Summer.
She would like to know who proposed the motto In
God We Trust, and when unseasonable days were first called
Indian Summer, as though knowing might steady her flip-flop pulse.
These are almanac questions with almanac answers available on an
Internet service. Suppose, just suppose, this time round the easy
answers will not heal by way of distraction. I am outraged.
She repeats this phrase in the lilting, stage center voice that
entertained students in the classroom and readings of her work in
years past. I am outraged. What crimes are they committing at
their Black Sites? Delivered to her husband, her brother, to
Cleo and Glo—whoever will listen, and they are outraged, too,
repeating the day’s dreadful news. We have not been given the
full count of the injured. She is caught up in gestures of
dollars and cents where In God We Trust came into her
story—on green-backs, coinage in the pocket of her old black coat,
though it’s her credit card that registers the small donations of
her protest. So it goes.
She is still in her bathrobe at noon, her flighty
gray hair unwashed, strange crust on her cheek, a new hillock of
puffed flesh on the wrinkled map of age. She turns from the mirror.
Not much for mirrors anymore. Let the body play out the days with a
handful of pills adjusting the heartbeat, thinning the blood. Till
well after noon she stays in her back room writing the last of her
seasons, Fall with its showy splendor. She predicts year’s end may
be her end, but that’s one of her stories. Her body will float on a
bier of books and first drafts down the Lethe, or bob in Olmsted’s
Lake, which appears at a distance, an elegiac vision she may have
to revise, a cold wind ruffling the glass surface. Seldom given to
self-pity. Consolation is across the street in Central Park with
its Bridle Path, Pinetum, Reservoir Track, all that prospect of a
healthy, if halting, afternoon walk, thus the five dollar bill in
her pocket for the needy or a threatening encounter. She loses her
glasses, forgets her cell phone and what’s for dinner, repeats her
riff on outrage, remembers in some detail disturbing events of the
past filed away under Wars I have known, one scene oddly
persistent in recent days.
As a freshman in college, she stayed up late with
her new friends. It must have been the first weeks of October.
Three little girls at school with no bedtime, few rules. What
stories did they have to swap? Empty vessels. She is harsh as she
thinks of them in their flannel nightgowns, their French grammars
and Lattimore’s monumental Greek Tragedies thrown aside for
idle chatter. The woman came to their door, which stood open a
crack. Looming, mysterious, she waited in the dim night light of
the hall for a long moment, then invited herself in. The girls made
tea on an electric hot plate, the red coil dangerously close to a
curtain her mother had sewn to make life homey away from home. She
figures how old their guest was, a graduate student from Austria
studying Government, as they called Political Science then. Perhaps
in her mid-twenties—big breasts, heavy thighs, the pulsing of her
neck as she told her story. The plait of honey hair she drew round
the fullness of that neck was a noose snapped free to reveal a
silver cross. The three girls were children who listened obediently
to the woman’s steady guttural voice with now and again a German
word translated for them to English. The salty odor of sweat from
the Austrian woman’s ragged ski sweater. They were all sitting on
the floor of this room in a dormitory for mostly privileged young
women. The rug was lumpy, braided of rags by the mother of the old
woman who was then a girl listening to a story she could not
comprehend, how their visitor’s father was taken away, the brother,
too. Tap, tapping her cross, the woman said the Cardinal came to
lunch. Her father had thought His Eminence’s visit a good sign. She
knelt to kiss the Cardinal’s ring which smelled of laundry soap.
They might find that the strangest part of her story. Come the next
year, a knock on the door in Innsbruck and they were gone, the
father, the brother taken by brutal men these girls had seen in
newsreels and movies. More tea, and though they had not asked, the
Austrian student with a woman’s body said as the war was coming to
its end a soldier spoiled her. Schande. Never saw him, her
face covered with a pillow. Soon after, the Russians came.
For years the woman who lives across from the Park
recalled the shame of her relief when the foreign student left her
college room, shame at her inability to feel nothing more than
embarrassment, to wonder at—the harsh soap of suet and lye embedded
under the princely ring as though the honored guest in the magenta
beanie joined in a humble washday task. Had the woman found other
children in the dead of night to listen to the calm recitation of
her story? Today the warm dormitory room appears again with the two
friends who went their separate ways by the end of that year, the
poster on the wall—Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose—Sargent’s
little girls in white summer dresses, their Japanese lanterns
illuminating a garden beyond lovely. And there on the floor, the
discarded textbook in which the Greek chorus mourned what had come
to pass as in the chant—We are outraged—or warns what will
come to pass, but tragedy had gone out of business. Her own
initials were incised on her tea mug, MK—a gift from her father—a
gruff, sentimental man, who never wanted her to grow up, leave home
with new clothes—a lumpy rag rug, gauzy curtains fluttering near
the hot coil of the burner.
Not much for mirrors, and not happy with my
attempt at third person. In my book, confession begs for
absolution, but my sins are not wiped away like sweat when you’ve
run too fast or too far; and now I can’t run at all. Today I am
outraged by the use of camouflage in the desert. Disguises nothing,
you’ve noticed? With sophisticated surveillance devices, there’s no
need for blotches simulating mud and sand. Camouflage of a sort is
worn by the Cheerleader, his business suit, navy or gray. You’ve
seen him bounce down the steps of Air Force One, sprightly, airy.
Crossing the tarmac, he waves us off, the palm of his hand denying
access as we watch the evening news. Thumbs-up, he gives us the
finger; his tight-lipped smile, mum’s the word. The boy who painted
our fence has gone to his war—a kid who worked in a toy store at
the mall, had no future in that line and asked what I worked at
since I am seldom at the little house in the country. I showed him
a book. He took it in his hands. Bewildered, he laughed as though
at a useless brick, slick and lighter than the ones that edge the
front path but do not keep weeds out of the garden. It’s a book
with false moves written at the turn of this century, not this
sketchbook, album, field notes of the past and passing days.
I’m comfortable with first person, don’t mind
drawing back the velvet curtain, coming onstage. I was born in the
city of P. T. Barnum, the impresario who never feared facing his
audience even when the music was too highbrow or the freak show
failed to amaze. On Good Morning America, a marine amputee
is learning to walk on metal stilts to carry on in our three-ring
circus.
I have my troupe, my regulars, bring them center
stage as they are needed, one by two by three, duets and line
dancing, solo turns throughout the seasons, not lives of the
saints, yet not lives of the sinners. The improbable mathematician,
his lapsed artist wife, the foreign student with the heavy rope of
hair who appeared one night vowing never to return to Innsbruck
where she grew up in extraordinary comfort. Call them my cast: in
shameless imitation of Papa Haydn and Vivaldi’s Four
Seasons, I give you Sissy, a waif with golden hair and a bad
habit; the Jesuit cousin—godless man of god; Audubon, who killed,
stuffed and gave life through his art to our American birds; my
parents in their molto adagio, who have long been defenseless. And
you, brilliant in your supporting role, flipping the calendar back
to take as good as you get, as though we are still in our prime. I
look forward to your corrections, to my reply as I turn to the next
blank page.
You advise me against bringing the Cheerleader into
play, writing of here and now, allowing editorials to seep into my
stories, spoiled fish wrapped in yesterday’s Times.
Let’s not get into shelf life.
You say: Outrage is a bumper sticker, one of
many sentiments parked side-by-side in Kmart Plaza. Proud parent of
an honor student at Monument Valley High. Honk if you love
Borges.
There’s a picture of Charles Dickens sitting at
his desk. He’s not writing, not addressing his next
cause—illiteracy, pollution, tax laws, copyright, child labor: the
list is long. His biographer tells us he’s imagining. Time out to
conjure a story. His characters paper the walls, enacting their
memorable scenes. A miniature girl sits on his knee; asking what
next, she looks to her maker. Will she marry after many trials, or
be awarded the famous deathbed scene? This picture of Dickens is on
a card which reads ALL GOOD WISHES OF THE SEASON, a bland greeting
he’d never put his name to, yet I have recently posted it above my
desk to remind me how inadequate my dreams. Boz, partner me in a
pantomime. Hold me aloft in a cold season. You’d be outraged at our
accidental killing of Arab girls in a cement block school. Dip into
the ink pot, Lover, imagine more than my bitter words. Write a gay
or plaintive story about your desk to be auctioned this year,
proceeds for the children’s hospital in Great Ormond Street to
which you contributed ten pounds, a theatrical skit, and your
precious time.
Today I forgot the name Panofsky but remembered a
review I wrote a long time ago in which I took issue with
Slaughterhouse-Five, a war novel that became famous, much
praised. Vonnegut was imprisoned in Dresden during the firebombing,
carnage unfathomable, just months before the Allies won that
war. I could not begin to understand how the writer worked his
story in a somewhat comic vein. Wall of flame, overkill, body
count, his banal refrain—So it goes. In honesty, I was still
something of that girl, flannel nightgown buttoned to the neck,
listening one night to the seductive report of a survivor, to a
foreign student who could not guess my . . . emotional
incapacity.
In God We Trust: the national motto was
first used during the Civil War, when religious sentiment was
running high. The Secretary of the Treasury responded to pleas of
the devout that it be printed on our currency.
Indian Summer: a few days of blessed warmth after
the cold weather has set in; or the time when the Indians harvested
their crops; or a time before frost when they attacked European
settlements storing their food for winter. The settlers retaliated
with cumbersome muskets. So it goes.
I live in the city. I share the garden across the
street. If you would like to know with maximum honesty about my
loves or further shame, my faltering heart, it’s none of your
business. My brother is switching channels, expecting the bombed
mosque in Mosul will be shown in more detail. Was it them? Or us?
No matter, he is outraged. We all are. My husband, who works with
numbers—market up, market down—figures to the nth dollar the
military contracts dealt out to the Cheerleader’s friends doctoring
the books, the outrageous rip-offs. There will be a candlelight
vigil. We will stand with our homemade placards: WAR IS NOT THE
ANSWER. Song, piety, mulled cider in the Park. It will only be
effective if we wait till the sun has set, well after dark.
Daybook, October 8, 2007
1929, the year of my conception. What were they
thinking of, bringing another hungry mouth into the world? Perhaps
not thinking—her red hair aflame on the pillow? I must not make a
drama of that cool October night, perhaps Columbus Day, in the
little house with its peaked gin gerbread roof and curlicue hasps
on the door. The cottage had just been built for our middle class
comfort, for a night of their fumbling and fondling under the
blanket in the front bedroom that faced North Avenue. In the throes
of discovery they were blessedly not thinking. Who am I to say
fumbling at this very late date, casting my mother in the role of
shy schoolteacher rescued from spinsterhood by the brash boy
detective? I have portrayed them too often, Loretta and Bill, made
them my subjects.
I throw down the book I was reading, nothing to do
with an October night in Bridgeport at the start of the Great
Depression. The false memory of my begetting was a digression, an
off-bounds stop on the way to a disturbing story. This very day I
had searched the pages of a novel I’d written as though checking an
old bankbook to reckon where I spent foolishly, what interest
accrued that I might go on with and ended up broke, wishing
dramatically to have never been born. I was attempting to make some
connection, this daybook with my rants against the war to the book
thrown aside. To my discredit, that love story was of the Second
World War, yet all I called up, attempting to balance the account,
was to switch the scene to my parents’ bedroom, muslin curtains
flapping in a welcome breeze while I read War and Peace in a
creaking wicker chair. Why was I allowed to invade their space
through the long Summer days while I read Tolstoy’s great work? I
was fourteen years old.
Today I can no longer look at my war story, the
novel with the gold medallion on the cover declaring my prize. I
put on an old black coat with the buttons dangling, as though
covering tattered jeans might conceal the shame of conjuring my
parents’ embrace on the four-poster. Is the coat needed on this
warm day?
Your topcoat, Mimi. Better safe than
sorry.
I put words in my mother’s mouth while Bill strikes
a match, cups his hand around yet another Lucky. In this way we
keep track of each other, though they’re long gone.
If egg whites are stiffly beaten, the meringue
never falls.
Just brought the fellow across the state line
into the jurisdiction, don’t get a hold on your lefty complaint.
This rendition? I set myself up for their corrections, begging
their care, their tolerance, my indulgence of the past, I suppose.
The picture of him in the Bridgeport Post, Bill, plump,
choirboy handsome, the jaunty brim of his felt hat casting a shadow
on his smile. Handcuffed to a mobster of note: Simple police
work, extradition.
May Day 1978
I write to you on his birthday, the wrong day
for my father to be born. He voted Conservative down the line. You
pulled the Socialist lever long after McLevy was thrown out of the
Party. The one blip in your near perfect pairing? There’s no
evidence to the contrary. In any case, thank you for having
me.
—A note never sent to my mother,
her mind fleeting, soon gone
her mind fleeting, soon gone
So in the old black coat I headed to the Park
across from our apartment house designed in ’29, a year of public
and personal disaster. I aimed to cancel my debit column with fresh
air, bracing city views. Just a walk, yet, waiting for the light to
change on Central Park West, I felt I was off on a redemptive
journey. Turning to see our apartment house as though for the last
time, I noted the familiar storybook façade—the lofty terraces,
crenellated towers, fake balconies and dungeon gridwork of each
window. Do you recall the grande dame at a meeting in the lobby
after we’d all bought our co-op shares and could now think of the
golden concrete bulk with silvery doors as our property? In a voice
steady with the assurance of old money, she brandished her cane,
protesting any alteration to the building that would not be a
landmark till 1985. Most particularly she defended the casement
windows that screeched open on their hinges quite easily enough for
men who’d lost everything in the market to jump to their deaths on
Black Tuesday. Not accurate, for it would have been, at the
earliest, the winter of ’31 when the first tenants moved in, but
she was grand with a blue rinse permanent wave and bright lipstick
of a past era. And who knows if it was only a story made up in
defense of our iron windows, which, though not sturdy, are handsome
to this day?
You said: There’s no one among us to challenge
her. The small triumph of the survivor.
I walked into the Park slowly, as advised, and
headed straight for the slope running up to the Reservoir newly
enclosed with a black iron fence, replica of the Calvert Vaux
original. There was not a ripple on the water. The ever present
gulls squatting on the pipe that spans the Reservoir appeared two
dimensional, so many ducks in a shooting gallery. For a long moment
no one in sight, all the better to cherish my melancholy brought on
by eavesdropping on my parents’ bedroom with its crisp dresser
scarf and the wicker chair in which I spent most of a summer
reading War and Peace for the love story, skimming the pages
of Napoleon’s retreat from Moscow, understanding less of that
carnage than I did of the Bridgeport Post mapping the D-Day
Invasion, or the White Russian Division advancing on the Germans.
That war progressed on the nightly news my father listened to, head
tilted toward the speaker of our bulbous mahogany console, while I
set the table in the kitchen. When I finished my chore, I’d come
into the living room to hear the roundup; then my father took his
place at the head of the table and softened the bloody events of
this day for my mother, who absorbed the news in silence, then took
off her apron to serve our supper. One night, with adolescent
bravado, I declared that the defeat of the Soviets at Minsk was
much like the fall of Napoleon’s Grand Army in the very same city,
history repeating itself as our table talk mixed tidbits of
neighborhood gossip, my brother’s mastery of Latin declensions and
my father’s unpatriotic grumble at his paltry serving of
meat.
Now, Bill. How often she’d sneak her chop or
chicken thigh onto his plate.
Taking up my route round the Reservoir, I
determined to leave behind these girlish memories of war, more
honest than my invention of Nazi espionage in the novel I’d thrown
aside. Looking to the first lap of my forbidden journey, I saw the
runners coming upon me, a full cadre of men and women in red
jerseys training for some competition. Their leader swiveled his
gleaming shaved head to check on the pack falling farther and
farther behind. It is only in recalling the moment of the runners
straining to catch up with this lean man wound tight, clearing me
out of his way, that I clung to the fence, saw in the tranquil
Reservoir a mirror image of the bright sky that banished all
thought of my troubling intrusion on the lives of Loretta and Bill,
subject to my telling their tales. In a Chaplinesque strut, sure to
leave my fraudulent war novel behind, a love affair trumped by
betrayal, I began my route around the Reservoir Track. The body
took hold with its thoughtless demands. The level course is rimmed
with limp mullein in this season and untidy wild asters. I’m not
part of the jogging scene. The heart that’s failed me improvises
its bebop arrhythmia. I take caution as ordered, slow to a stroll,
but never give in to a bench, not even as I approach the bridge
joining track to parkland, where a gathering of athletes, maybe
just neighborhood friends, pay court to the old runner, Alberto
Arroyo. He’s at his post every fine day, some not so fine, the gold
medal dangling from the patriotic ribbon round his neck. In running
gear, silk shorts this crisp day. I catch sight of the swollen blue
veins in his legs, fanning out on the weathered cheeks the
handlebar mustache white as his gleaming halo of hair. His gestures
exuberant as always, though by his side the steel cane, rubber
grips on its claws. It’s said he ran the first New York Marathon,
indeed was a founder. Who knows if that story is true or with time
became legend? The time before the old legs gave out, before he
sported the Mylar toga each cold day, conserving body heat at the
end of no particular race, before he became a figure of reverence
at the South Pumping Station, fashioning himself as local patron
saint, grandee of the Running Track.
A mere walker in down-at-heel tennis shoes, I
thought how neat to be of that company, to know I might scramble up
to the Reservoir, pay homage to the old runner, listen to his words
of wisdom or enjoy the gossip of the day to set me free of the
reading chair which this day brought me back to the place of
origin, my voyeuristic tale with its many variations—how on an
Autumn night when the barberry hedge was not yet planted in the
patch of front yard to absorb the noise of traffic, with the green
linen shade drawn against the streetlight, my parents felt their
way to each other in the dark. Felt their way with what purpose? I
heard the footfall behind me, the huffing breath of the next
trotter. All passed me by. As though I was stuck on a treadmill,
the Fifth Avenue side of Central Park with its swirl of Guggenheim
Museum seemed no closer. Soldiering on in my invalid pace, this
day’s outing was a strategic maneuver against the assault of
memory.
This stretch of track is more carefully tended,
though the ornamental cherry trees have dropped their end of season
pips and, sloping down to the police barracks, ferns flopped,
yellow and limp. Tourists had found their way into the Park with
museum shopping bags and guidebooks in hand—Germans with camera
gear; Japanese lovers delicately holding hands; a party of Brits,
the Union Jack on their sweatshirts. Clouds swept in, a sudden
surface rippling, and a mallard, floating free of the rushes,
ruffling her wings, was joined by a male with brighter plumage by
far.
Name of the laike? Sharp Cockney
diphthong.
Walking on I called out: Reservoir.
Can’t they see it’s man-made? The wonky
circumference distorted by a hydraulic bulge on the south side. The
slight undulations of this carefully plotted shoreline bear no
resemblance to nature’s random design. Turning, not to be rude to
visitors, I called out again, Reservoir. The Japanese man
put an arm round his girl as though to protect her from my shrill
cry. The Germans had set up a tripod for a picture of our Fall
blazing an Oktoberfest across the shimmering expanse of water. That
shot can be bought from a vendor outside the Guggenheim, but it
would be their own view, recall a hike in New York. Yes, they
carried burled walking sticks as though to conquer an alpine
height, but our Track is level, the water piped in, no racing
streams, no cascade. My breath came short, unsteady as I turned
round again to call out another correction.
Jacqueline Kennedy!
Reservoir, I meant to repeat, but the Brits
had gone their way. She would have recalled the old Croton
Reservoir piping water down to the city after the raging fires that
consumed Lower Broadway long before the Civil War. Keen on
preservation, she might have winced then, aware of history’s
erasures, accepted the memorial renaming with grace. On a slick
little map, I’d seen the blot of blue water Lake Jackie, too
familiar by far, yet she’d know her name would convey to the
Germans, the Brits, even to the private school kids who replaced my
Japanese lovers, kids awkwardly entwined on a bench, a lacrosse
stick balanced between them.
Drawing back from the heavy breath of his ardor,
the girl shrugged him off. I was their embarrassment, old lady in
tennis shoes, buttons dangling.
Needle and thread, Mimi. Don’t let yourself
go.
Old party pretending to look away, not to admire
the girl’s mane of long honey hair, the neat muscular knots in her
legs. She’s baiting this guy. The awkward gesture of his hand
hovering in limbo above her bare knee; his face, broad and earnest,
Slavic perhaps. The affront of his rejection sends me back to the
creak of the wicker chair in my parents’ bedroom as I settled each
Summer day into the romance. How inevitable of Natasha, that
enchanting child, to love the careless Prince, not the worthy
suitor, Pierre. But worse, morally worse in my view: when Tolstoy
finally marries her to the good man, she plays their last scenes as
a frump, a plump housewife and mother.
Still reading your book?
Yes; they fed horse flesh to the Turks, did you
know? Proclaimed at the dinner table to alarm. They, the
French or the Russians? I was uncertain, but the shocking tidbit
was mine. Which we may be eating now.
Rumor that Kunkel, the butcher on Capital Avenue,
minced horsemeat in with the beef. Now that recall does stop me;
the supper table lesson on the bloody retreat of Napoleon’s Grand
Army. The lacrosse player, lolling on the bench not two feet from
the Track, was the girl. The bright blue jacket of her team thrown
open, breasts on display. Let me make that clear: nipples, erect in
chill Autumn air, poked a T-shirt which read, EVERYONE LOVES A
CATHOLIC GIRL.
So untrue. I could tell her stories along that
line. We were not embarrassed by each other.
Me—reading her chest.
She—slouching in a phony embrace, humiliating that
boy. Then, ditching the flirtation, she ran off, lacrosse stick
cradling air, boy trailing after. Dismissed from their after school
tryst, I felt a sharp pang of shame, the lot of a voyeur. Had I
invented my parents’ embrace in the four-poster, then hovered over
these hapless kids to dismiss my guilt? I had manipulated history
to write a love story. Printed and praised, there could be no
erasure. Playing a shell game—that war, this war, did I hope for a
reprieve with the feeble cry of my outrage at the Cheerleader, at
the coaches directing his boyish strut as he comes to the podium on
the White House lawn? We are audience to his grotesque performance
at halftime, his bounce, joy in atrocities. Whatever happened to
Civil Disobedience? The essay not assigned in college. Fellow grew
beans, lived by a pond, nothing as fine as Central Park, what we’ve
got here.
When I turned back to see the distance I’d come,
the Germans were still in the photography business. Finding the pin
oaks dull at end of day, they’d set up a white screen to reflect
what was left of sunlight on tarnished bronze leaves. Give it a
week. Our grand finale will knock your Birkenstocks off. My
heart beat a fierce catch-up thump. I was breathless as I came to
the open view at last, the point of full exposure. Clear across the
Reservoir loomed the house I fled a half hour ago. From this
vantage point, the trees, still leafed out, erased all other
buildings on Central Park West. Our turrets caught the last glitter
of this day in false gold.
Yes, the El Dorado. The presumptuous name of the
house where we live with ancient plumbing and electric circuits
updated with vigilance, with those casement windows sanded and
painted against rust and the mural in the lobby of a phantasmagoric
pilgrimage to a futuristic city of heavily varnished gold. And in a
back room where the sun never shines, my failed book thrown
aside.
Get out in the sun, Mimi. Take your bike for a
ride.
My secondhand Raleigh, tires gone flat while I
turned the pages of Tolstoy’s very long story renewed and renewed.
I feel the hard surface of its indestructible library cover (dark
green), title stamped in the spine. And see, as of this day, the
slick dust jacket of the war story that garnered my prize.
REVISION
I could but dream the whole thing over as I
went—as I read; and bathing it, so to speak, in that medium, hope
that, some still newer and shrewder critic’s intelligence subtly
operating, I should have breathed upon the old catastrophes and
accidents, the old wounds and mutilations and disfigurements,
wholly in vain.
—Henry James, The Art of the Novel
On the flap of the book which bears a gilt
medallion on its cover, The Normandy invasion of the Second
World War is rendered in cinematic detail. Flap copy performs
its duty. With detailed care the writer illuminates (!) the
baby face of a soldier who figures in the opening pages as
disfigured beyond recognition. The dog tag hanging round the kid’s
neck with a Star of David recalls his bar mitzvah, Torah in hand,
that side story set in a clap-board temple on an unlikely back
street in the Berkshires, but then it’s all unlikely—the body count
of those left behind on the sands of Normandy fails to elevate a
misbegotten romance. The boy soldier—he’s well out of it, out of
the plot. His commanding officer had studied physics with
Heisenberg at the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute whereby hangs an
operatic tale. Liebestraum, my story of an American
Captain’s puppy love for a soprano he occasionally slept with in
Bayreuth, the Führer’s favorite Art Site, is searchingly
honest. Blurb on, elicit kudos from readers before they turn
the first page. Too late to be sorry. Terrible thing to do, conjure
that kid out of a squat brick high school, flagpole at the ready in
a dusty playground. Note of pathos, fakes his age to fight the
Nazis. Stunning body count of the D-Day landing, the Captain’s
doomed foreign affair, his postwar prize of suburban survival. Was
that last bittersweet chapter all I learned from Tolstoy’s true and
dark story? That war, this war. I think now of the boy who painted
our fence in Monterey, Mass. He waited some months till he was the
age to enlist, but writerly ambition stirred my plot line years
before he quit the toy store, that job with no future. He is now
serving his third deployment in Iraq.
Today, reading in my airless back room, the landing
gear grunting onto the shore of Omaha Beach, my soldier boy—jaw
shattered, chill waves pulling him under—ticked off the memory of
my father turning up the volume of the Philco on the evening when
all America, so the story goes, listened to Roosevelt call a
benediction upon our troops, the pride of our nation. My
mother coming from the kitchen to hear we shall return again and
again, while I stood by the console. The clatter of knives and
forks when I dropped them during the President’s prayer.
Mimi! My father scolding.
History demoted to domestic anecdote, the
uncontrollable urge to bear witness, write myself into the
scene.
Where was I when the first mushroom cloud rose in
its ghostly threat on the black-and-white screen?
The sun parlor, where my father had set up a
twelve-inch set to watch the Yankees.
When Kennedy slumped into his wife’s lap?
London, a rented flat in Chelsea. The neighbors
we’d never met came to the door with flowers.
Bobby bloodied on the kitchen floor of the
Ambassador Hotel?
Walking my daughter to first grade, streets
strangely empty. The assassination posted on the school
door.
Let me unscramble time. In the personal almanac: my
solemn attention to the landing of Allied Forces in Normandy, June
6, 1944, was broken by the kettle shrieking on the stove. I let go
forks, knives and dessert spoons to savor rice pudding still warm
from the oven. The following week, the school year ended, I turned
to the opening pages of War and Peace. Mastering the
difficult Russian names, I pursued the romance, admiring the
wealthy landowners, suspecting the impoverished royals might be up
to no good. In my parents’ bedroom I settled into the creaking
wicker chair by a side window. On the few dark days, I read under
the soft light of a silk-shaded lamp. Scraps of my mother’s old
skirts and my father’s worn trousers had been braided into a lumpy
rug at the Women’s Art League, wool gathering history. On their
Victorian dresser, her soft chamois nail buffer in its ivory case
lay beside the empty leather holster for the County Detective’s
gun. I am no longer sure why I plotted, or why they tolerated, this
incursion into their room.
The next year, watching the first A-bomb do its
unspeakable thing, I was reading nothing at all. That summer was
one long orgy of desire at Fairfield Beach. I blistered my fair
skin parading in front of a wheezing asthmatic boy mustered out of
the army. He never took notice of me—Everyone loves a Catholic
girl—his name irretrievable, while I bear the near-invisible
scars where the basal cells were removed from my chin. Looking
across the Reservoir to the El Dorado, I stopped on the track
remembering the good doctor who zapped the offending growths with
such skill, Bernie Simon, who lived in the north tower of our
building. He had worked with the team of plastic surgeons when the
Hiroshima Maidens were brought back to New York, twenty-five Keloid
Girls mostly kept out of sight by their families. Nine years after
the bomb, they arrived at La Guardia, June 1955. Their disfigured
faces and limbs were to be reconstructed. Many of the maidens were
billeted with Quakers, peace-loving people. By October some had
discarded kimonos. Others posed for the camera in saddle oxfords,
twinsets, cultured pearls, the costume of American college girls;
others wore prim secretarial suits cut close to the body. In the
photographs, taken at a distance, you can’t really see the thick,
dead flesh on their hands and faces.
Today, the mighty block of Mount Sinai hovers over
the eastern skyline of the Park, but it was in the old hospital at
100th Street and Fifth Avenue where the A-girls were slowly,
painfully transformed into something like normal—that can’t be the
word—poster girls for an act of reparation, cruel footnote to
history. Dr. Simon lost a spirited maiden on the operating table,
though he massaged her bare heart with his hands. Tomoka had wanted
to wear summer blouses with short sleeves, not much to ask. The
year before his death, Bernie worked out in a loping run, an easy
stretch on the Bridle Path, the flesh of his legs and arms
burnished with a healthy tan. As though to figure in my story by a
masterful computation or throw of the dice, an honored
mathematician, Peter Lax, lives other side of our building. When
called to Los Alamos, the Project he worked on seemed to the young
lieutenant “like science fiction. There were all these legends
everywhere.”
Here’s a true story you might recall if you’re
getting on in years: This Is Your Life, a popular show,
bottom of the TV barrel, in which the unsuspecting party is brought
onstage and confronted with someone long lost who “made all the
difference.” A programmed occasion for faked embarrassment, tears
of joy, shrieks of disbelief: Oh, my God! Which is exactly
what the pilot and bombardier of Enola Gay, the plane of
infamy that dropped the bomb on Hiroshima, cried out, Oh, my
God! upon viewing the shadowy forms of two Keloid Girls hidden
behind translucent screens, lest the audience of 40 million be
disturbed by their Bar numesque disfigurement. The pilot died this
past year, ever sure of his mission. Well, that’s the story folks,
entertainment trumping science fiction.
I managed to make my way huffing, puffing to
midpoint in the eastern stretch of the Track. Windows high above
Fifth Avenue flashed the bronze setting of the sun. I will never
understand how that brilliant display, mostly blocked by the
apartment houses on Central Park West, leaps the Reservoir’s
expanse. And do not care to understand, demanding magic from this
forbidden journey, though the simple refraction of light at end of
day may be grammar-school science. Breath coming short, halfway
home, no use turning back. Feeling my considerable age, I settled
into a simple touch of the blues. Not a jogger in sight, as though
an official blew the whistle—ending play. Loping on, heart racing
ahead, I was alone on the loop that leads to the North Gate House,
thinking the tennis courts would soon come into view, might still
be open at dusk with the plunk-plunk of balls and the mercy
of a public drinking fountain. But there, under the flickering
cover of trees, were two figures, still as statues until they heard
the slow shuffle of my feet, then the woman put out her hand. With
a swift gesture demanded I stop.
Perched above—an owl. In the lens of his unblinking
golden eyes, the bird possessed us.
The quiet, spooky at first, was then pleasantly
prolonged, the owl joining our conspiracy of silence. The woman’s
attention consumed her. The man lowered his binoculars to feast on
his wife’s pure pleasure as she wrote in a little book. I presume
wife. Now I place gold rings on the birdwatchers’ fingers. Matched
beyond their Nike jackets and billed caps, they became one in their
attention to the bird. It’s only now I frame them as young lovers
in a chill season, intent on their pursuit of nature; not shepherd
and milkmaid tumbling in the hay, stockings in telltale disarray. I
presume they are blessed with each other beyond this bucolic scene.
Or not blessed, for he withdrew a few steps, looked somewhat
paternal, admiring the quick strokes of her drawing, the ardor of
her attention. For a moment he took me in—disheveled old lady with
no claim to bird lore—then flashed me a smile as if to say,
We’re not among the converted.
His wife would know, without benefit of my Audubon
Guide, the long-eared owl to be ubiquitous in the Northeast. She
drew us to our observation again. A sudden movement in the
undergrowth broke the spell. We waited, we three, for something
tremendous, the owl’s dive for its victim, a chipmunk or Reservoir
rat. The bird would not perform. Then, in that still, suspended
time, thump-de-thump declared itself, the heavy off beat of my
heart. Random, the turbulence does not follow fast moves or
exertion, drops in like a petulant neighbor with its complaint. I
waited for the fibrillation to tap its way back to something like
normal. When I skipped off from our hushed encounter as best I
could, then turned back, the birdwatchers had also left the scene.
The flat Track seemed uphill all the way, the North Gate House much
farther than recalled. As it finally came into view, I heard a
creature’s high screech of death, and the owl’s cruel
laughter—hoo-hoo-hooting, having deprived us the thrill of the
kill.
Clouds moved in with surprising swiftness, dusk
turning twilight. I approached the dreary granite of the North Gate
House, or houses—two on the Reservoir shore—straight and tall like
giant rooks abandoned in a game of chess. Their black iron doors
bolted, double padlocked. I take the notice personally: KEEP OUT.
As though I would trash, pollute the works, while in the backwater
sloshing between the towers my fellow citizens have deposited
plastic bottles, deflated soccer balls, dead sneakers. Skeletal
ribs of an umbrella float in thick green scum. This debris seemed
placed here to call the city to mind—its waste, fumes, and general
congestion of the grid in which Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert
Vaux staged their pastoral drama, drew up plans for a park with
hills and vales, rusticated nooks, and the folly of a castle to be
viewed from the grandeur of Bethesda Terrace. The people of New
York, high and low, would take pleasure in this otherworld that
would never admit crumbled cigarette packs, milky condoms, a
dismembered iPod jauntily floating in a tangle of weeds. Just
beyond this detritus, the water was clear across to the South
Pumping Station. The gulls, drained of color in the approaching
night, held their post all along the pipe that dissects the
Reservoir. I’d always thought a pipe’s a pipe. Not at all, when the
water’s low you see their perch to be handsomely paved with stone.
Above, the moon was translucent, a nibbled host in a starless sky.
The programmed lights shone brightly on the tennis courts for
players who would not give up on the day.
Home before dark, Mimi.
Take care.
Repossessed by their warning, I found myself, dark
end of day, round the block on French Street—its empty lot with
shanties, idle men out of work. Our mother never called them
tramps.
Watch out for the Gypsies your father runs out
of town, rabble that follow the circus. Duck the Commies at
Workmen’s Circle. Steer clear of Benny the Drooler.
I can take care of myself.
As I crossed the Bridle Path, the last child in the
playground struggled against his mother’s embrace. The fiberglass
hippos and jungle gym clung to their stations while the kid was
dragged off protesting. He did not want to go home, nor did I. How
I hate that antique locution—prissy, at arm’s length from my fear
the escape route ended where I began, the backward glance at my
storybook with its claims to a sorrow never felt for the reality of
a war and its aftermath I did not—may never—fully understand. With
the doctor’s warning and the day’s meds, I had accomplished the
loop, 1.58 miles, still subject to parental correction. Why the
twinge of disgrace, sharp as a stitch in my side? Why my childish
name? What’s more, they were right, I do not know how to take care
of myself, simply enjoy the day’s adventure, cut free of the past.
I’d been seduced by the contrived beauty and small adventures of
Central Park, hoodwinked by an owl, affronted by black iron doors.
My playground was closed for the night. I was home, Chez El Dorado,
elevator at the ready.
You were there, waiting. I passed you by in the
hall—rudely, I guess—ran to my workroom, made a note—Everyone
loves—lest I forget the self-serving legend of the Catholic
Girl, forgetting I’d had a Bic and small pad in the pocket of
the old black coat, two of its three buttons now missing.
I called to you, Put on the pasta pot.
By my reading chair, the book I threw aside. On a
knockout cover, a single Rhinemaiden swims for the gold. By the
sparkling stream, the author’s name is printed in Third Reich
Gothic. I had aimed at important: that took the prize.
Liebestraum, now reissued with a student guide, should have
a query on the writer’s plagiarized emotions: Does the note of
doomed love underwrite the inexhaustible horror of that war?
My journey down the well-trodden path into the dark woods of
National Socialism was pure Grimm. I cast myself as the clever
troll to lead the way.
But if, you suggested in a reality check way
back when, when I was in the heady spin of my misdirection, if,
before the war, that lieutenant you’re writing about studied
physics with Heisenberg, he should have been stirring the hot pot
at Alamogordo with our neighbor Peter Lax, not slogging through
enemy fire on D-Day.
Captain. I promoted him toward the end of
the war. Yes, or he might have been translating at Nuremberg
and not so easily betrayed by a Rhinemaiden bitch; but D-Day it was
for the sake of my PLOT, the nefarious name, in any flash upon
the fancy, so advises Henry James. As though calling upon the
Master would make amends for my patter of quick steps, the
forward march of my story. Did I then presume the glib balance of
an aphorism, sum up the argument: Memory prods History. History
corrects Memory. As in—
Where were we when Al Gore won the election?
In Seville, the Grand Hotel. We went to bed
happy.
This evening you appeared at the door of my
workroom, no longer costumed for the office. For the first time
this year, you wore your old wool vest, offered me a glass of wine.
You had news of the children and the world, urged me to take off my
coat.
Stay awhile.
The children, you told me, by which we mean
grandchildren, have moved on to pumpkins and plastic masks of
action figures unfamiliar to oldies, but the options are still open
about what they will actually be for Halloween. Transformed,
as we were, to tramps or ghosts in homemade costumes?
It’s only Columbus Day, a day off school, a
parade, no treats. Buy them too early, their pumpkins will
rot.
I noticed the scar on your nose which I lose track
of over the years, a perfectly round patch of slick keloid, large
as a dime. One day you had a chat with Bernie Simon in the lobby.
I’ll take care of that, he said, saving your life. In those
days we were cavalier about the ravages of time. Heart-burn,
toothache, a touch of vertigo—our vision of the future blurred by
cheap drugstore glasses.
Where’ve you been?
The Park.
As though just another jaunt, breath of fresh air,
not a reprieve from the heavy sentence of the book I’d thrown
aside. What might I have said that was truthful? That I too often
looked back, not to presume upon the day’s blessing, isn’t that how
my mother might put it? Channeling that cultured voice—Best get
on with your business, Mimi. Remember Lot’s wife.
Well, I do, I remember that wife is given no name,
no space in the story, and no say. She disobeys, turns to look at
the sinful city in sulfurous flames. Swift chapters in the good
book don’t miss a beat turning her into a pillar of salt. Whatever
the indulgences of body and soul in Sodom, she was leaving home
with nothing like the comfort of Central Park to run to.
You took Liebestraum, the offending book,
from my hand. Leave it.
Burn it?
You knew perfectly well what I’d been up to,
picking at the gold medallion on its cover like a kid with a scab
on my knee.
I said, Let’s give some thought to
supper.
The new flat-screen TV in the kitchen brought
cut-rate news. Corporate Greed, Celebrity Breakup, DNA Frees
Convicted Rapist, Dollar Drops Against Euro. As president flops off
mountain bike, I shed onion tears. High school bands march down
Fifth Avenue: NYPD, Mayor Bloomberg, Senators, Sons of Italy,
Knights of Columbus. Car Bomb in Haifa, Helicopter Malfunction in
Mosul. Five marines, their deaths verified. Sipping my wine—tears,
the real thing.
So tell me, what’s wrong?
The Knights of Columbus. My
grandfather.
Who made the money and lost it?
Nothing to cry about. Those kids.
Their photos: two in camouflage, three in dress
uniform. Tonight the oldest is twenty-three. I could see you didn’t
buy my tears for the cruel fate of those boys shipped home, RIP.
Onion knife in hand, I left you to go back down the hall to my
workroom. Behind the confusion of old postcards and printouts,
there’s the photo of my grandfather sitting on the steps of the
Knights of Columbus, an ample brick-and-shingle house spiffed up to
rival the Masonic Lodge. Bridgeport, 1918. He is broad-shouldered;
craggy forehead shelters his eyes from the sun, mouth rather too
generous with a twist of a smile. George Burns is remarkably
handsome, big hands clasped on his knees to ground him while this
picture is taken with the fraternal brothers, important men who run
Main Street, the harbor, City Hall. He is the only Knight in a soft
shirt and tweed cap that a worker might wear on a Sunday. The rest
of the Templars sport confident fedoras, stiff collars,
four-in-hand ties. All of them Irish, and it’s a wonder to me still
how these Paddys-come-lately tied up with Columbus when they had
little to do with Italians other than renting them tinderboxes in
the Hollow or granting the occasional loan. Burns built houses for
the men who worked on his crew, all Italians, paving roads in the
city outgrowing its limits. At sixteen, when the landscape firm
that bore Olmsted’s name extended the breakwater in Seaside Park,
he’d carted stones, scythed the bulrushes of Long Island Sound and
lost half a finger.
Back in the kitchen, I hand over the photo dulled
to amber photogravure. You’ve seen it often, yet I launch the whole
roundabout story while the water in the pasta pot boils away, tell
how I circumnavigated the Reservoir, hooting at tourists when I
came to that bend in the road, and end with the devalued holiday,
the grandfather I hardly knew, an old man bankrupt, shrunken,
silenced by age, dealing his grandchildren pennies from a jam
jar.
Thank Grandpa.
I’m small, with few words. He reaches out, strokes
my cheek with the stump, the slick flesh of that terrible finger.
I’m ashamed of my tears. Pennies clink as my mother drops them one
by one back into the jar.
Last night I told you of my slow progress round
the track, the reflection of clouds skimming the water, Fall not
yet in its glory as balm to my passing fit of despair, the fabled
Reservoir drained to the events of my day. Outwitted by an owl. I
did not mention shortness of breath, my heart’s marathon beat
pumping for the booby prize. It took the evening news in the
kitchen to connect me to Columbus Day, the great Christoforo aiding
and abetting my notion that history prods memory, serving up
fragments of postcolonial lore.
Not arbitrary like strands in my mother’s rag
rug, carefully chosen.
Plotted?
We’ve lived too long together. I feed you your
lines.
Yes, plotted, and on I went turning back to
serving my life sentence for the story I committed, that Nazi
soprano who betrays a smitten officer, his love doomed from the
first page, American innocence exposed as plain foolish but
always forgivable. Liebestraum (Love Story in
plain English); a touch of irony to leaven my story.
Come off it. Your tone not amused, not
indulgent.
I wound back to the comfort zone, the course of my
flight through the lobby of the El Dorado with its homey
grandeur—sofa, club chairs, flowers stiffly arranged—past the
kindest of men at the imperial front desk and the doorman who would
never comment on my coat with its last buttons dangling, bleach
spots of a misbegotten wash day splattering my jeans, then my
crossing to the park with the comfort of its stories. Waiting for
linguine to test al dente, I confessed I had not cried for today’s
boys blown up by the side of a dusty road.
I’d be awash in tears, every night’s news. I
cried for an old Irishman I hardly knew who stroked my cheek with
the thick flesh of half a finger, a Knight, mind you, of Columbus.
So, I cried for myself. Isn’t that a shame?
Take it down a peg, Mims.
I could barely distinguish between my mother’s
correction and your tolerant smile at pennies in a jar. I moved on
to the owl, claiming the bird as my discovery of the day, how he
tricked me into submission. You said, Watching the
pot?
Daybook, October 9, 2007
In the morning I phone my brother; he of total
recall.
As we talk, I pick at the medallion still stuck on
my book. When I have it off, Alberich comes into view, the gnarled
dwarf who grabbed the gold ring. The Rhinemaidens, all three
laughing at his plug-ugly body; at his rejection of love which set
Wagner’s whole Ring Cycle rolling on and on, fable begetting fable.
By family telepathy my brother gets the message. I’m in the dumps.
I protect myself with a pawn, tremor of uncertainty in my voice:
My Summer of War and Peace? That creaking wicker chair?
How come I hung out in their bedroom?
Don’t make a fuss. Grandma Burns came to stay.
She displaced you. They set up a cot in my room. I can still hear
you snore.
I don’t snore.
But yes, that Summer I set one more place at the
kitchen table. And the war news? Before supper we gathered by
the Philco.
The Magnavox.
Trust he’s right about the Magnavox, but I know for
certain that on D-Day FDR’s message of sorrow and hope was cut off
by the clatter of forks, knives and spoons.
Mystery solved: I dropped the good silver ’cause
Grandma came to stay!
My brother’s voice is strong today, sharp,
lighthearted: What are you on about? He gets it. D-Day?
Your prize story—rubbing salt in the wound of success? All that old
stuff.
Calendar stuff. Like Grandpa in a dinner jacket
at the Grand Knights of Columbus. They served oysters Rockefeller,
don’t you know. Santa María, remember?
That was my brother’s ship in a bottle. I recall
his concentration with glue, pincers, scraps of a linen napkin
dipped in tea for the sails, button-thread rigging. He remembered
pebbles brought home from the schoolyard, painted gold. The
treasure chest stuck to the balsa wood deck of the Admiral’s
flagship, Santa María.
All that glitters . . . Columbus, he’s
discredited.
Untarnished in grammar school.
You’re a day in arrears, Mimi, but give him a
try, one of your bios. They always set you up. Lives of the Rich or
Famous. Your calendarial Book of Days.
Calendaric.
Calendarial. Promote and demote, that’s what
history amounts to these days. Admiral of the Ocean Seas, prop the
old sailor up, easier than ship in a bottle.
I heard the Times flop down on the table
that lives by his side with amber bottles of pills for the daily
doses aiding and abetting stealth moves on his body. We compare
systolic over diastolic achievements, scoring low for the gold
star.
He knew, this brother who was there from the
beginning, that I was out of sorts, weighted with more than my
displacement to a wicker chair, what big eyes you have Gramma,
sleeping in my bed—all that old stuff. He groaned slightly as he
rose. I heard the slow squeak of his walker as he made his way
across to the bookshelf in his tidy study. Now he would pick The
Anatomy of Melancholy off the shelf, the book so heavy as he
flipped through its pages to find clever bits to amuse me. We had
been into Burton’s big book of a lifeline before:
Of Seasons of the year Autumn is most
melancholy. . . . Fools have moist brains and light hearts. They
are free from ambition, envy, shame and fear; they are neither
troubled in conscience nor macerated with cares, to which our whole
life is subject.
Stop!
It be, melancholia, a kind of dotage without a
fever.
Stop!
If there have been any suppressions or stopping
of blood at nose, at hemeroids or women’s months, then to open a
vein in the head or about the ankles.
Till he induces laughter. So, you think while
they listened to war news after the dishes were dried, I read
Tolstoy by lamplight? Flies batting the screen.
Stay on message, he says. Honor the
holiday, one of your brief lives, Columbus.
There’s nothing left to explore.
We’re still hoping for water on Mars. What about
your time in Genoa? Just writing your stories at that villa. No
grand tour.
I’d launched a piece on Columbus but it sniffed of
embalming fluid, seemed a replica of his statue commanding the
Piazza Acquaverde, the bus station in Genoa. We did tour the house
where Christoforo was probably not born, and in a nautical museum
viewed waxy simulacra of the Admiral with a first mate, and
selection of sailors costumed for the journey. His instruments of
navigation, the quadrant and the astrolabe, while never useful,
were beautiful, and in yet another funky museum, a plaster cast of
his hand. Why his hand? It’s so undiscovered, Genoa. The
well-worn joke . . . À tre scopertede . . .
Prego, not to tell it again. Do
Columbus.
Like the old days, I obey his command.
DEAD RECKONING
October 12, 1492—Cristoforo Colombo, Italian
Navigator, born near Genoa, discovers the Indes East of the
Ganges.
For some days Columbus noted in his log: weeds
in abundance with crabs among them; a whale, they always
keep near the coast; pelicans and a turtle-dove. On October 11
he sighted a flickering light in the distance as though from a
candle. That proved a mirage. The true sighting is attributed to
Martín Alonzo, who sounded the alarm at 2:00 AM, according to
orders. Columbus knelt on the shore of Guanahani to claim San
Salvador for the King and Queen of Spain in the name of Our Lord
Jesus Christ. He had reached the Indies. In the heat of his
discovery, his account flips from third to first person. The
natives are recorded as an inoffensive people. He gave them
glass beads, red caps and various trifles in exchange for parrots
and skeins of cotton thread. No need to say who got the better of
the bargain. These Indians had no fireboxes, no candles, no
weapons. The naked bodies of the men were decorated with red and
white powders in mysterious designs, but it seemed to the Admiral
they would make good servants and would readily become
Christians as they have no religion.
Adam with an agenda: he named each island in this
earthly paradise—Trinidad, Fernando, Isabella, Santa María de la
Concepción and so forth—bringing it all back home. Best that he did
not invoke the Lord in naming Puerto Grande, a sculpted harbor of
Cuba we know as our naval base, Guantánamo Bay with its history of
detention and “outrages upon personal dignity” (Geneva Convention).
On first sight, the vegetation of the islands recalled the beauty
of Andalusia, but deeper into the rain forest’s dense thickets of
vines and lush trees the humidity was overwhelming. The natives,
friendly and instructive, alas had no vein of gold. They offered
stone glittering with something like mica, and the story of a great
king who lived by an inland lake. Or perhaps the golden man was
lord of a distant island? Could he be farther up the dangerous
waters of the Orinoco, this godlike figure in some versions named
El Dorado, with coffers of the precious stuff in his city of Manoa,
enough to fill the royal treasury impoverished by holy wars to
convert infidels to the one true faith. Now Colón’s calling was to
be as much missionary as miner, persisting in his duties until on
the island of Hispaniola he might find the river of gold in the
waters of the Ciabo, might find enough glitter to show in Madrid
along with curiosities and his captives. He settled the crew he
left behind to set up shop. The book of Colombo’s discoveries was a
best seller; his tales wonderful and so wonderfully told they might
be the adventures of Marco Polo, which he read and reread in
Italian, his mother tongue, preparing for his discoveries and for
the writing of his own extravagant tale. After the success of the
first voyage, Columbus drew up a contract, The Book of
Privileges, in which Don Colombo demanded and received a title,
a coat of arms, and a share in perpetuity of the profits of
all the lands of his discovery. On the second voyage, he brought
chickens to this handsome race quick to learn words of a strange
language and the value of a farmyard egg. Prospects did not turn
out for the best.
The High Admiral of the Ocean Seas proved to be a
slack administrator of the greatest real-estate deal of all time.
He was unfortunate in choosing his lieutenants. Christoforo’s gift
was for mapping the sea, not transatlantic politics, not sorting
out quarrels between gold diggers and the indigenous people. Among
the curiosities brought back from his first travels—lemon seeds, a
necklace of fish bones, tobacco, cinnamon bark, corn—were strange
birds and slaves. He had assumed his captives would submit to this
arrangement, though the Queen found their possession a bad show
when they were put on public display—perhaps the beginning of his
fall from grace. And where in advertised abundance was the gold? At
the outset of his third voyage, he was becalmed in the Doldrums
under the sign of Leo, which, given his belief in astrology,
foretold the severity of his fate. When at last the Admiral landed
at Santo Domingo, the ungrateful settlers he had left behind
revolted. His powers dissolved, Columbus was shipped home in
chains.
In a homey museum just above Genoa, we discovered
him in two roles. A white marble statue portrays a pretty boy with
abundant curls, dreaming the glorious future, longing for
adventures at sea. This charming Christoforo sits on a shelf with
the crusty oil painting of a broken man, scant white hair, swollen
feet, tattered robes. Shackled below deck, you said, head
bowed to darkness. Upon his return to Hispaniola, the settlers
had not thanked him for their hunger, war with the natives, death
and disease. And yet again he returned. Now here’s the pity: the
Don came back that fourth voyage, sailing with his young son and
brother, to find the route to China described by Marco Polo,
confusing fiction with geography, presuming that the estuaries of
Panama might be the rivers of Cathay.
Cristóbal Colón, Colom. Or Colombo—an
Italian-Jewish name. A wool carder, weaver, boy sailor. Instructed
by his brother Bartholomew in cartography, he mapped the known
world. In Portugal and Spain, cartography was a Jewish profession.
According to Christoforo’s calculations, the world might be shaped
like a pear, and so he sailed round this fruity globe to bring back
spices and trinkets of the Caribbean. His true quest had been for
the wonders of China or Japan. He figured the world too small,
America lay in the way. It is said the Admiral, bitter and nearly
blind, passed his last years consumed with the defense of his
Privileges and his title. It is said the Genoese bankers
drew on his pesos d’oro in Hispaniola, which supported him
grandly. If true, he died rich. A devout Christian, he was deeply
religious yet a confessed mystic who communed with the stars,
though he never mastered celestial navigation. Five hundred years
after weeds and a pelican foretold the most promising landfall
known to man, a colossal statue of Christopher Columbus was refused
by five cities in the States and Puerto Rico. A Taino woman,
descendant of the people who first greeted Columbus, debunked the
memorial enterprise: To allow the ultimate symbol of mass
murder, genocide, oppression, colonialism . . . Enough! There
is never enough outrage to fully tarnish a symbol. We are left with
the navigator, son of the wool merchant, possibly illegitimate, the
bright ambitious boy who went to sea.
The public television documentary turns folio pages
from his log book, voice-over reading the translated text
on-screen; model of the Santa María; an animated map of each
voyage, with his fleets bobbing over the sea: the professors
disagree about the date and place of his birth, perhaps a hill town
above Nervi. A facsimile of the chart used on the triumphant voyage
of discovery is pegged as it was every four hours, pin-pricking the
distance achieved each day. The flow of sand in an egg timer
tracked navigational hours. A quadrant and an astrolabe are
displayed: the nifty new tools he carried on board. But the Admiral
could not fix his latitude; in bad weather could not site the North
Star. In a letter to the King of Spain, Columbus claimed he had
determined his latitude off Cuba by use of a quadrant. In truth,
his readings were off. He did not have the math, laid the
instrument aside, sailed the parallel by dead reckoning, pinprick
by pinprick, a ship’s boy, perhaps his son, turning the egg timer
until the last willful voyage was done. The astrolabe behind glass
case is not of his period, so the tag says in all honesty. When we
left that museum set in a park just down from the villa in
Bogliasco, we took a wrong turn into a boccie-ball game, old men,
old as we are, passing the time. They were welcoming to i
stranieri with museum pamphlets in hand. One with a grizzled
beard could not resist the old Genovese query, À tre scopertede
Genoa sono? I answered: pesto, banking, and America. We laughed
in bilingual accord.
Columbus Circle, newly refurbished with trees that
brave the exhaust fumes, stands at the southwest corner of Central
Park. The Admiral wears the familiar cloak of his best days, fur
trim and rich wool stiffly flowing. The puffy beret we remember
from a school play. Perched on a mighty pillar, he stands sentinel
to the traffic that circles round him, his back to the Park and to
the outsize pylon that bears the competing statue of Columbia
Triumphant as she heads toward Broadway in a golden shell. Layer
upon layer of gold leaf covers her body and windblown gown. She
commemorates our Victory in the Spanish-American War, 1898.
Columbia and Columbus join in our urban allegory of Empire as
empire sails on.
October 13, 1492. The fish so unlike ours that
it is wonderful. Some are the shape of dories and of the finest
colors, so bright that there is not a man who would not be
astounded, and would not take great delight in seeing them. There
are also whales. I saw no beasts on land save parrots and
lizards.
On shore I sent the people for water, some with
arms, others with casks; and as it was some little distance, I
waited two hours for them.
During that time I walked among the trees, the
most beautiful things I had ever seen. . . .—Don Cristoforo
Columbus
Among trees. On the Mall in Central Park, he stands
under American elms with the poets. Blinded by disgrace, the
Admiral could not see Literary Walk flashing green to gold on the
day marking the discovery, nor hear the distant blare of a
high-school band, so I backdate him to full possession of his
Privileges, walk him along Columbus Avenue a block west of
Central Park. In the neighborhood of the El Dorado, two restaurants
are Italian with inferior trenette al pesto, pandolce of
sorts. The Mass at St. Gregory’s on 90th Street is said in Spanish
and French, Salve, a poor parish of immigrants—Hispaniola,
San Salvador, Port-au-Prince—its school basement once the last
refuge of unruly priests who protested the Vietnam War. That war,
this war. Many of the indigenous on the avenue are dusky as those
once noted in his log. On this unnaturally warm day, a few men and
women display markings of mysterious designs on their naked arms
and legs. We might stop at the narrow shop with birds in the
window—zebra finches, parrots, canaries, the exotic creatures he
captured for the delight and edification of Her Majesty. Past the
flower shop with Peruvian lilies, maranta, Queen’s tears, a bouquet
gathered from his Discoveries. We will stop at 86th Street.
Two banks on the corner. That should amaze the Genoese sailor. His
swollen fingers fumble with the knot on his purse. The high ceiling
and terrazzo, all so familiar, but the deposit slot rejects his
pesos d’oro. . . . And that henceforth I should be called
Don, and should be Chief Admiral of the Ocean Seas, and that my
eldest son should succeed and so from generation to generation
forever. . . .
The woolen cloak heavy on his stooped shoulders,
strands of white hair poke out of the jaunty tam. Through infirmity
of eyes, he sees at last this Manoa, the strange land of his
discovery. We head east on 86th, back to the Park. Thanks be to
God the air is very soft like April at Seville; and it is a
pleasure to be here, so balmy are the breezes.
On the Promenade, a Hispanic peddler of gelato.
Limón, por favor. Pinprick by pinprick, back in time when
the world was fresh. Near blind. A small whale near shore? A
stalk laden with rose berries, in plain light of day birds flying
from winter. Heaven on earth awaiting his discovery of a flickering
mirage.
Daybook, October 20, 2007
We are plotting a surge. Our Republic—mine, yours.
It’s dumb to sign off on this country, like some old lefty still
humming “The Internationale.” Ten, twenty thousand troops will tidy
up, bring them round to our way of thinking. Not thinking,
just watching the reality show. It comes on after the weather,
which has been lovely, day after day of sun withholding the sharp
promise of Fall. I still speak of my outrage launched some years
ago. The edge has dulled, needs to be honed. Time was, we took out
the whetstone, sharpened the blade. In the past, wars beyond our
recall were taught in school. How the Civilized Tribes were sent
off on the Trail of Tears, that from these honored dead, that we
here highly resolve (each child in turn reciting by the
schoolroom flag); how during the Mexican-American War our town in
the Berkshires chose the Mex name, Monterey. This war, that war,
how the Austrian girl was instructed to kneel when she kissed the
Cardinal’s ring; how the Spaniards got rid of the Moors, a costly
operation, so Columbus shipped out for the gold. How the pilot of
the Santa María sang a chant marking time, first note to
last, forward to aft. Depending on wind and tide, on flotsam and
jetsam near shore, on words lost in the wind, Salve, the
ship would make harbor. How men have always been intimidated by
animals they fear, nothing new siccing dogs on prisoners. And did I
go on about Walter Reed, while deplorable, it’s nowhere near as
unsanitary as hospitals were in the Civil War. This war, that
war, my father deliced soldiers who survived the Battle of the
Argonne. Ran a hot rod up the seams of their clothes, much like the
iron instrument once used to curl hair.
You said: Take it down a peg. You’re
edgy.
I thought we hated that expression. You’re the
one warned me off here and now, how stale today’s incursion seems
tomorrow.
These treks across the street may not be the
best prescription, for your spirit, I mean.
You flapped the Wall Street Journal against
your thigh; a respectful review of a movie we might want to
see.
Elizabeth, The Golden Age. Biopic, right up your
alley.
Your instructive tone is troubling. It’s the Park I
have going for me, new material—tourism, birding, our looming
towers preserved in bourgeois splendor. I spoke then of my
Scheherazade mode, of watching the clock run down, of my balancing
act that’s solo, though often I depend on a fellow traveler.
Like Chaucer, don’t you know?
Whan that Aprille?
It’s Fall in Central Park.
Time Bends: The Student’s Tale
With all the senses of my body I have become
aware of numbers as they are used in counting things. But the
principle of numbers, by which we count, is not the same. It is not
an image of the things we count, but something which is there in
its own right. If anyone is blind to it, he may laugh at my words:
I shall pity him for his ridicule.
—St. Augustine, Confessions, X, 12
We had been best of friends, boyhood friends. A
possible way to begin? My profession, such as it is, does not lend
itself easily to words. Numbers are my game. At times I must
explain as I chalk the blackboard. Given x + y and
xy find x and y, simple stuff, but this is a
confounding story. Bertie, Chairman and CEO of Skylark, a
telecommunications empire—so his enterprise is called in the
business section of the Times—Bertie is charged with
conspiracy to commit fraud. I am waiting to take the stand as a
character witness, have been waiting for two days, as you well
know, since I deliver Cyril to school while you stay home with
Maisy, our congested girl once again prisoner of the nebulizer. But
this is not a family story. Cyril delivered, I head down to the
Federal Courthouse we’ve often seen on cop shows. The echoing
hallways are unfamiliar off screen, dismal. I have been called to
testify that Bertie is an upright player in the financial games of
this republic, in sum, a good old boy, has been since I first knew
him, eighth grade. He is charged with backdating his options,
tinkering with the books of his corporation so that gain became
loss, or vice versa, good tricks that would please my students,
many of them preparing for their future in the business
world.
I am writing in the small green notebook in which
you record our sightings of northeastern birds. It has been years
since I scribbled more than a quick note with pen on paper.
Attorney Thaddeus Sylvan informed me that Security might not look
kindly on my laptop, though my life and times are easily accessed,
from the incompleteness of my Yale degree to my credit rating to
the theorem I am attempting to work to its probable conclusion.
Your notebook slipped easily into the pocket of a gray flannel suit
worn to Wall Street by my grandfather. I rescued it along with his
pocketwatch, so that I might wear it when called to testify on
behalf of Bertram Boyce, who’s between a rock and a hard place.
Silenced, I resort to the shorthand of clichés; sequestered in a
small room with unforgiving metal chairs and a behemoth of a
scarred wood table. It seems, as I look over the page, that I write
in a retro voice much like my grandfather’s. Cyril O’Connor was a
gent who was formal at breakfast, who muted his affection at
bedtime and contained his exuberance when our Yankees won the game.
A shame you never knew him.
Bear with me, Lou. I will ease up. I’m attempting
to describe the occasion when I reattached to Bertie, who I must
claim as my good friend. You were along for the ride. It is best to
turn back to that day on which Bert and Artie found each other
again, embraced in a Judas moment, though who betrays, who saves
the day is yet to be determined. Should anyone audit this memory
bank or question its inventions, they must know you cannot testify
against me, insofar as you are my loving wife.
Field Notes: October 12, 2007, 3:30 P.M. U.S.
Weather Station, Central Park, 65°-70° (trusting to memory,
therefore guessing), possible afternoon shower.
A volley of shots in the distance. A thrasher
fluttered into the bulrushes. I faked a pistol with my hand.
Backfire.
A great egret flew to the island in Turtle Pond.
Displaying his annoyance, he chose not to perform his strut. In
something of a huff, you lowered your binoculars. We’d come for
songbirds stopping off on their migration to pleasant winter
climes. The day was unseasonably warm, as though the years flipped
fast forward and phoebes had long abandoned the sheltering grasses
round the pond.
Lou, there was nothing to fear on a Monday
afternoon in Central Park. Above—swift sailing puff clouds;
below—still water glazed in sunlight.
A second volley.
I know it’s backfire, you said, convincing
yourself no sharpshooter crawled the swampy undergrowth. Took me a
week to get you to come birding, never my great thrill, yours. I
wanted to see your pleasure at the green gold of the warblers,
observe your full attention sketching their pinstripe tails. I
wanted you to breathe easy, Lou, for a few hours of the day. Our
Sylvie, more than friend, who often looks after the children, had
gone off, a visit to her stepdaughter in sunny CA. You checked your
watch, opened this small spiral notebook to record our sighting of
the egret and the single thrasher in the reeds repeating his
mockingbird cry. This outing was going as well as could be
expected, given we had abandoned our children to a student of mine
with no experience in kid care other than a brood of brothers back
home.
Turtle Pond lies directly below Belvedere Castle,
once a stone shell, a hollow stage set built to enchant the eye.
All such notes, Lou, come by way of my grandfather, a would be
historian if life had not ordained his career on Wall Street,
allowing only an occasional Sunday walk in the Park to instruct a
boy. So, if I include the Delacorte Theater with its seats facing
an empty pit, we might have been a couple of lost ground lings from
a pageant of heroic legends. Tourists and a busload of
schoolchildren were on the viewing terrace above, looking down from
the battlements on the little body of water and the island both, as
their guide blasted through a megaphone, ENTIRELY MAN MADE. A
disappointment to his audience surely, but there we were by way of
entertainment, Louise Moffett and Arthur Freeman, playing our
observation of the birds for all to see. With the next volley of
earsplitting pops, you mimed fright. If these outlanders had simply
turned from us, looked down other side of the Castle, they might
have seen men in their Conservatory jackets attempting to deal with
a disabled tractor backfiring at the utility shed. I enclosed you
in the rough body hold of a protective embrace. How long had such
childish fun been in short supply? Shrugging free of me, your cap
tumbled down the embankment. Artie to the rescue. In a princely
gesture, I set it atilt on your head. Worry lines not permanently
etched in your brow were hidden in the shadow of the bill, but your
cheeks were ghostly pale in the bright light of day. You tucked in
the ponytail. That day plays a PowerPoint show in my head: Here’s
the moody egret, here a lone phoebe seeking shelter in the reeds
from the guide blasting Vista Rock with misinformation, here’s my
wife, gorgeous and plain. Mind if I put that down? You insist you
are a throwback to Household Mom in black-and-white reruns. I might
say a fading American rose. I still call you Miss
Wisconsin. Cheese, say cheese.
Pen poised above this very notebook, the stern set
of your mouth would not give way to a smile as you estimated the
great egret’s height. I brushed the wet grit of the embankment off
my khakis. Then, as though to amuse in a game of I Spy, I trained
my binoculars on the foot soldiers above. The schoolchildren, you
may recall, waved little flags—red, white and green—but the
tourists seemed puzzled or plain embarrassed by their bird’s-eye
view of us horsing around. What had they seen? A private moment,
always lovers in the Park, though not often caught in an act of
observation. Adjusting my lens, I dictated notes to you on the
enemy’s shaggy plumage, their slack mandibles and splintered
beaks.
They could not hear me describe them as goosey
gander, common tern, but no doubt heard you cry, “Oh, Artie.” The
high chirp of your laughter reached up to include them as they
watched our tussle, your love punch to my ribs and my gentlemanly
gesture, taking your arm as we climbed toward the Great Lawn, where
soccer practice was in progress, boys in the blue jerseys of
Trinity School. Next the Pinetum, where you hoped for a red crested
kinglet, then the Reservoir, expecting the arrival of grebes
basking in the sun. Again you checked the time. Our Maisy had the
first cold of that peculiar season, which did not deliver crisp
Fall days. I’m uncertain how much to recall of our encounter with
Bertram Boyce, not yet charged with backdating options of Skylark
shares, but I am certain I lured you away from the apartment with
Maisy’s congestion, with Cyril’s trembling tower of Lincoln Logs. I
offered you the consuming delight of birds in their citified
migration.
You hurried ahead, past dog walkers, babies in
slings, past the elderly taking the air, skateboarders—illegal on
the walkway. The pretzel salesman had resumed his Summer post. A
fat boy in a red shako, much gold braid on his breast and belly,
began a melancholy taps on his bugle—Day is done, gone the
sun—broke to drain spittle from his mouthpiece.
You were not amused by this touch of Fellini.
Checking your watch: Four-fifteen.
Columbus Day, I said. Parade long
over.
I wish they’d stop fooling with the
calendar.
The holiday stuck on to the weekend. Cyril had
wanted to go to school that morning, always wants to go to school,
where he outwits his class-mates less endowed. His cleverness is a
cross he will have to bear. Only now that I recall Bert Boyce and
Artie Freeman breaking through the Fifth Avenue crowd when Columbus
Day was kept in its place, the disruptive twelfth. Snotty nerds
lusting for the drum majorettes and their flock of twirlers from
the outer boroughs, those high-stepping girls far beyond our
reach.
In the Pinetum we did a swift look-see searching
for the red crest of the kinglet. There was only the resident clown
in a battered derby prompting his flea-bitten parrot—H’lo there!
’Lo there! Impatient, you took the Reservoir Track the long way
round. Not a merganser in sight as we headed to the crosstown bus
to get home to the children. Our pretense of pleasure seemed a
failed duty until you caught the noiseless swivel of an owl’s head,
flick of tufted ears.
The long-eared, napping till end of day, did not
deign to acknowledge our ogle eyes trained on him. Drowsy creature,
yet I believe he heard every step of our approach, listened to each
shallow breath of our silence, a comfort compared to the panting of
joggers. We had discovered him fully disclosed on his perch. If
he’d been in a story, he’d be wiser or at least crafty, the role
he’s often assigned. You wrote in this very notebook, the turn of
the page noiseless. Flipping back, I see with what care you drew
the eye stripe cutting a perfect V to the owl’s beak. In any case,
I had my prize for the day in your extended moment of delight,
which swept aside Maisy’s catarrh, the terrifying pops of an old
combustion engine, and the anxiety, never mentioned, that my work
was not going well. I might not find my way through the knots of
higher mathematics to the solution of one small problem. In clear
sight of the owl, the troubling world dropped away. Louise, confess
your thing about owls, starting with barn owls on the farm in
Wisconsin. The first prize you ever won, sketch of an owl perched
on a downspout, every night watching that bird from your bedroom
window until the dive for its prey, the death shriek of its
victim.
Our binoculars captured the Halloween mask of the
owl’s flat face. I must not deprive the bird of his owlness, see
him pompous and befuddled, like Owl in the book our son loves. An
uncertain shuffle brought the prolonged silence to a halt. Do you
remember the old woman huffing and puffing her way round the track?
You signaled her to stop? With a flip of your hand ordered:
Look, look up. A party of three sharing the vigil. In a
contest of wills, this urban owl might outlast us. Finally, the
shabby old girl broke the spell, shuffled toward the tennis courts,
her breathing audible—uneven. The sky had darkened, leaves rustled
underfoot. The long-eared was surely gloating as we headed toward
Fifth Avenue, his unblinking eyes on us. I preened at coaxing a
laugh at Turtle Pond, and for some time, long minutes of owl time,
you’d been lost to the world.
This is Bud’s story, Bertie’s. I was the only kid
allowed to call him Bertie and will use that boyhood moniker when I
speak of our friendship, rekindled that very day, the day of our
birding. My “guard” in the waiting room is a court attendant, Tim
McBride, gabby Irish, “been in the job since.” What follows is the
real dope on Jimmy Hoffa disappearing into a cement grave, not the
void, same year as bilingual signs here in the courthouse rest
rooms. “My case” will most likely not be called today. The parties
still in judge’s chambers. McBride releases me till after lunch.
My case, an odd way to refer to the troubles of Bertram
Boyce, far from mine. His are unfortunately dated. Bert took
liberties with time. My problem was clocked—will the
scholar-in-training triumph over the odds or fail to make the grade
in given time? That question troubles you, Lou, though the solution
is solely mine.
Released into the city at high noon, I could head
up, or downtown. History lies in both directions. Downtown is Wall
Street, where my grandfather went to the office every working day.
He invested, bought and sold, made money. We are living off him
now, Louise, though he’s gone these six years if I reckon
correctly, which I should be able to do, since he has willed me the
luxury of going back to school to pick up my love affair with
mathematics. So I had the choice of walking down the blocks to look
at the Stock Exchange that rang the market to my grandfather’s
attention each day, though not going as far as the Trade Center
wound or taking the route up to SoHo, where we lived our first
years together in your loft, the materials of your trade all around
us—paints, charcoal smudges in progress, canvases stacked against
the wall. I was in that empty waiting room at my request, the
privilege granted by the machinations of Bertie’s lawyer, who
believed I must fiddle on with statistics and correlations for my
class in applied mathematics. Furthermore, I did not want to spend
time under the surveillance of Attorney Sylvan, famous for finding
loopholes in the law. I had been coached by him, his every slick
word put in my mouth, thinking when the time comes I’ll say what I
have to say truly—my schoolboy adventures with Bertie, my larky
jobs at Skylark, more play than employment.
My choice was not to travel downtown for recess,
Lou, not to recall the dutiful life of Cyril O’Connor, not indulge
in Lower Broadway, where we were so gone on each other our nights
of love consumed us. I’ve loosened up, though consumed is
too heady a word, or too visceral. My tongue freed by a hot dog
with the works as I perused the discount junk on Canal Street, odd
lots of T-shirts with Goth symbols of the Reich, dog beds, doll
heads, faucets, copper wire, cruets labeled Oil and Vinygar, framed
posters of Che and the Eiffel Tower. Products in their mass graves
guarded by their keepers, who seemed to be doing swift business of
sorts, perhaps as subject to investigation as Bertram Boyce’s deals
at Skylark. Troubling.
You were well acquainted with troubles that day in
the park, your fears crossing the line from daily concern to manic
organic. Alar in the apple juice, bacteria flourishing in plastic
bottles, E. coli, tuna with its dose of mercury—all loomed
large as the national debt. A whiff of the super’s stogie in the
hallway, Asian flu, Teflon and faulty seat belts—right up there
with toxic waste. Nothing to fear but fear itself,
attempting the noble line, I fail to amuse. Along with your catalog
of horrors, there is Maisy’s persistent congestion, and the
uncertain course of my career. Love, in one of its many
distortions, allows you never to speak of my possible failure,
though I work hard, harder than I ever have in my life. Lou, there
is the one unspeakable word—talent, if in fact the gift of
numbers was ever mine to squander. No longer nimble, one step
behind the beat? Better to record the owl’s composure on a warm
October day.
That night when Cyril and Maisy were safely stashed
in their bunk bed, I discovered you were keeping an account of the
current war’s fatalities, though only our boys were admitted
to your file. You had copied each soldier’s name, age, rank and
hometown into a baby book, a present from your mother intended for
Maisy’s vital statistics—first tooth, first fever, first word. On
the cover a stork carts a swaddled newborn in its beak. I suggested
the death toll of Operation Iraqi Freedom is online, www.Iraqbodycount.org. Oh,
that’s only information, you said, transferring Private First
Class, 20, Linden, NJ, and Staff Sergeant, 34,
Shreveport, LA, from the Times to your register,
inscribing each name, your pen dipped in India ink. Kind of crazy,
the record made personal, and then Louise Moffett, once an artist
on the cutting edge, now invested in the role you embrace as
housewife and mother, costumed in apron and sensible shoes, closes
the baby book, takes up a mystery, British. Potboilers, you
call these murders set in the manse or vicarage. The gardener did
it or the village doctor you thought so kind. The night of our
birding, you challenged the sly smile of my bewilderment.
You know the satisfaction, Artie. Puzzles,
solutions.
Our pleasant ongoing argument in which I point out
that a problem chalked on the blackboard is without motive—no
adultery, sibling rivalry, not even greed to provoke a crime.
Ambition?
You win.
And fell asleep with the murder unsolved. I scanned
my preparation for class—harmless proofs completed, then lay your
book aside, turning down the page not to lose the place in that
story. Even in sleep you looked troubled, gone from me, but earlier
that day I had you back. As we headed along the sidewalk to 86th
Street, I was hopeful till worry surfaced in tightness around your
mouth, an audible sigh as you looked across Fifth Avenue at the
apartment house where I lived with my grandparents when I was a
boy, an orphan. You won’t go there, a slippery expression,
though you take care to avoid the wounds of my childhood, which I
believe long healed. I have hoped that Bertie, with his troubles,
all too real, might release you from conjuring the demons of my
past, and from free-floating angst that pursues you. OK pursues us
all, but we get Cheerios in the bowl before reading the morning
paper.
Some of us. Some do not.
I imagine how gently your might cut me off.
Backdating to that day of owl and egret, your ponytail slapping
air, for no reason at all, gave me hope. That night, the night of
our birding in the Park, while you slept I turned on the tube,
muted it to indulge in our nightcap addiction to the comic turns on
the dysfunctional state of our nation. The pantomime without clever
words and background laughter seemed as inadequate, to wing a
metaphor, as a Band-Aid on a suppurating sore. Or merely
electronic—a fleeting message held in our hand: pick up juice,
organic snacks at the market. We’d lost track of the sand
castle blown away in Desert Storm. So it’s ever been while Rome
burned, though have you noticed there’s no tune for this war?
Where have all the flowers gone? My mother strumming,
Long time passing. Long time ago.
I am writing in a new notebook with unlined pages,
bought at Pearl Paint, where you ordered supplies when you were
still invested in your art. Your little green notebook is, after
all, for the birds. When I returned to the courthouse, Tim McBride
presented me with a sealed envelope. Lawyer for the defense—that
is, Thad Sylvan—asked me to consider in my testimony the charities
of Bertram Boyce Jr. and the corporate goodwill of Skylark. And
what did I recall of the Boyce family holidays, and the religion of
their choice? I remember that the mother (divorced) went to Aspen
for Christmas, Bermuda at Easter. She took Bert along until he was
old enough to be abandoned to the Park Avenue apartment or sent to
visit his father, a mysterious tinkerer in Bethesda, Maryland, who
held patents on medical apparatus that paid the bills, saved lives.
I did not share these memories. Sylvan should do his homework. Why
not ask poor Heather Boyce who, in Newsweek, walked up the
courthouse steps arm in arm with Bertie, a couple properly suited
for good works. Their names are printed in programs of the
symphony, the opera—Bertram and Heather Boyce, right up there with
the heavy donors. Black tie at the Modern and the Met, drives you
crazy, Lou, their attention to couture. And Project Hope, the
llamas with big, soulful eyes, Heather supplying indigenous folk
with herds of the beasts for costly sweaters. Shearing, carding,
spinning for a week’s handout of rice and beans.
There’s this. I had a few beers during recess.
Observe, dearly beloved, that I was ever so slightly greased. Up
for the self-portrait, not the idealized Artie Freeman you once
sketched, boyish with a thatch of hair gone early gray. You demoted
my smile to an air of bemusement. Forever looking on, not part of
the show, the squint of my eyes at every sleight of hand, moral or
monetary. Jimmy Stewart, you suggested, one of those innocent
heartthrobs.
Clark Kent without glasses.
A wimp?
In disguise.
Back to Bertie, back to business. I have written
more of me and more of you than the subject of my deposition.
Testimony: corrected by Tim McBride when I attempt the legal
lingo. I put the two of us on the stand while the accused awaited
his day in court. Birding in the Park, the day we met Bertie, I now
understand as a confession. The only one I ever knew who confessed
was my grandmother, Mae O’Connor, the least sinful of women. She
was shriven, strange word, at Ignatius Loyola a few blocks from the
apartment. I waited on the church steps facing Park Avenue
expecting a hum of holy about her when she emerged from the blessed
darkness, but it was only Mae fumbling in her purse for the list of
groceries we must pick up at Gristede’s. A shame you never knew
her. I see this memory business, this getting it down, might be a
simple image that I use for my class. You can’t, Louise, fill up a
circle with circles that do not overlap, but if you allow the
overlap, then there can be many if not infinite circles which will
allow Mae O’Connor to take her place in my story.
Circles within circles as on that day heading out
of the park. Past five. Five, you repeated, in case I missed
the urgency in your voice. Across Fifth Avenue, the apartment house
where I lived as a boy was encased in scaffolding to update its
limestone façade. The window where my mother stood with her love
child (my grandmother’s version of the tale) was draped in
netting, misty as the occasion of my birth. As a boy I wanted to be
born on Krypton where, by improbable chance, my father lived, but
where was the dynamic logo, my soaring flight over Metropolis? Two
lapdogs nipping and nosing each other blocked our path. I stopped
you crossing as a siren cleared the way for an ambulance racing
down from Mount Sinai. A cab jumped the curb, an ordinary mishap in
the city. The electronic pedestrian, trapped in the stoplight,
raised his arm in a friendly salute. Safe, safely across. Chill
coming on, cloudy sky if memory serves. You checked your watch
again, five-fifteen.
Day is done, gone the sun. Now, why? Why did
I sing that funereal tune? From the hills, from the lake . .
.
To get the laugh, Oh, Artie.
Speaking of the old woman in the floppy black coat,
jeans shredded at the cuffs, I said, Wasn’t she a funny
duck?
We recalled her look of offense when you ordered
her to silence the heavy pit-pat of her tread. You suggested the
heavy gasp of her breathing put the owl off its kill.
Though she got into the bird . . . and the two
of us.
I question the two of us. In the past, our eyes and
ears were in accord when birding, specially in the city, my
admiration for you on display, the milkmaid walking with a
proprietary air through the whole spread of Central Park as though
tracking the back acres in Wisconsin. That day we were not in sync.
Our argument, could it be called that, had little to do with
sighting.
Kind of a washout, you said,
birdwise.
You’re missing Our Sylvie.
That must have been it, Sylvie, a legacy of my
grandfather’s, her love for the old man embracing us beyond blood
relation. Our kids’ Frau von Trapp. No need to recall the untidy
woman squinting up at the owl, coat stretched across her bum. Same
age as Sylvie, give or take a few years, yet in no way like our
friend, who is slim and stylish, the cap of white hair carefully
sculpted to her head, Like an angel, you said, ageless,
one of Fra Angelico’s darlings. And if Our Sylvie had been home
to take care of the children, you would have been free to enjoy a
few hours of the Fall migration in the Park. I hustled you by the
apartment where I lived with my grandparents, a motherless,
fatherless boy. Why fear him?
McBride believed the case—mine and Bertie’s—might
be deferred. Have I made it clear that Tim came round now and again
for a chat with the professor doing his math? I hadn’t the heart to
correct him. He admitted me to the empty room, then went off on his
assignments, slapping at his hip, searching for lost authority in
the black holster of Security. I’m not dangerous, so left on my
own. Or dangerous only to myself, writing not one word in defense
of my old friend, but these many words of self-incrimination,
backdating my limited options to the incident of birding, recording
only personal discoveries of that Columbus Day, avoiding our chance
meeting with the accused.
At the bus stop: teenagers comparing test scores in
shrill, competitive voices. I can’t forget one sad striver with a
mini-tattoo on her wrist, silver stud in her nose, concave chest
weighted with schoolbooks. You stepped off the curb to see if the
bus was coming while I took measure of the distance I ran from my
grandparents’ apartment to the museum. “Take measure” is a Cyril
O’Connor phrase, prudent, unlike these pages written for you. I
stood at the corner judging the distance I crossed to the Temple of
Dendur, ran up the steps of the museum, through the massive door,
cut right to the Egyptians. So familiar to the guards they never
stopped me for my pass, sharp kid eager to show them my ill-drawn
barges to the underworld circa 2 B.C. Not so strange after
all, my obsession with the Pharaohs and their vast company of
underlings to serve them in their tombs. Even Bertie, conspiring
with me in all plots against the popular faction at school, was not
privy to my devotion to Isis. My fix on the goddess was a
reasonable accommodation to my mother’s death, a way to believe in
the afterlife, not as my grandmother believed in the apparatus of
heaven with angels surfing the clouds, saints in cumbersome robes.
Reviewing my route to the tombs fitted out for the long run of
afterlife with the comforts of home, I maintain it was not the
worst idea, writing to my mother in hen-scratch hieroglyphics. So
why does it trouble you when my clever tactics for survival are
long packed away? True, I wasted time searching for the phantom
father, now only the loose end of a story. Never fear, Lou-Lou
Belle, the grief of my childhood is not a genetic disease.
The crosstown came toward us. I stepped free of the
students, drawn into a circle of noisy flirtation. You called to
me, frantic. Waving your cap, hair flying, you stood by the open
door of a limousine, its extravagant length blocking the bus stop.
Passengers decamped in the middle of the street. Slowly, yet
grandly, an emaciated version of Bertram Boyce stepped out of the
long black car that established his importance. In the courthouse,
I should have been figuring the next problem built on the last, but
this business of writing without chalk or computer is rewind—back,
I go back in time while Tim McBride stops by, hand automatically
patting his missing piece. I replay the scene, Bertie helping a
woman with babe in arms to collapse a stroller. He steers her up
into the bus. The private school kids observe Mr. Wonderful with
teen irony; then the boss, once my boss, takes me in hand, settles
me in the beige leather of his limo. The old authority in his order
to the driver: Downtown.
You said, A ride across the Park will do us.
Something like that, cryptic.
Bert did not introduce us to the girl with a cell
plugged in her ear, a spill of mahogany hair veiling her face. We
spoke softly, not to interfere with her compelling business.
Bertram Boyce, dry as a pod with a terminal tan. He
seemed an endangered species in a fringed . . . serape? Poncho? We
watched Bert stroke the girl’s leg up to the black leather skirt
that ended far above her knee.
He said, Long time no see. Better part of a
year?
Christmas. Ah, the holiday visit. Bert’s
family in suburban splendor. You will not forget the extravagant
gifts. Bert, dispensing goodwill of the season, offered a priceless
claret, Lafite-Rothschild: Some prefer ’85. He found ’86
more than OK. A fete out of the nostalgia manual—Dickensian goose,
Bud with the girth of St. Nick. Better part of a year for that
rotundity to scale down to skin and bones.
You surely remember Heather Boyce flashing Santa’s
watch ringed with diamonds. Boyce children, bored with our kids,
dismissed to their Game Boys.
Heather, So what can you do? The holidays.
Something like that, putting words into her mouth as I’ve put them
into yours. Isn’t that the idea of writing it down? Call back the
day, things said in passing or by intent, translation from the
foreign film of memory into the subtitles of here and now.
Hear her? See her? Heather, who has never shed the
yearbook smile of savvy innocence, the pleasant efficiency with
which she packed away your offerings to Fern and Bertram III?
Sketch pads, Chinese brushes, from ye olde curiosity shoppe with a
bell over the door. The Christmas invite, an awkward duty for both
parties.
Court dismissed for the day. My keeper, McBride:
See you tomorrow.
Same time? Same cubby?
Cubby brought a scolding. I did not value the
privilege, Attorney Sylvan having procured this cell to prepare my
schoolroom assignments. Had Thad slipped McBride a gratuity?
Tim ran his hands over the digs and stains of the
table. This room, interrogation room, used to be.
Did money change hands so that I might sit among
the ghosts of the guilty? Released for the day, I drew circles
within a circle on the Broadway Line. Students will guess a
scribbled infinity at one glance, though this simple visual has
nothing to do with their progress in Math for Business Dummies,
everything to do with my notebooks, with this spill of words
written in ballpoint on paper, circles within circles. I could not
run word count on the inked page, that’s only information,
closed up shop on the Broadway Line listening to the muffled beat
of my neighbor’s music, having written not one word in defense of
my friend.
I am reminded of Einstein’s letter to someone
famous in which he confessed that images ran in his head long
before the difficult search for language. The notebooks stored in
my backpack with their weight of words seemed . . . well, wordplay
skirting some image central to the story that is mine as much as
Bertie’s, as though we are still competing as we did first day in
the schoolyard. Let the image be the soccer ball with its patchwork
of pentagons he shot my way, and my penalty kick these many years
later, roughing him up in my version of our story. We were tough on
each other, always outside the varsity game in progress.
Gina! As though I could forget the fourth party in
the limo. Her commanding presence, uncomfortable at best. She swept
back the red hair. On second glance, not a girl.
You’re Freeman, the boyhood chum.
Backdating, Bert filled her in on the apartment
where I lived with my grandparents. Where we picked them up, a
block from the old homestead. Grandpa was Wall Street, last of the
ticker-tape honchos.
Gina stayed in the present. You’re the guy
working on knots.
Your Ghostly Honor, I may have actually joined the
prosecution in my estimate of that leathery woman, she of the great
legs who tossed off what might, or might not, be the subject of my
dissertation when she apparently hadn’t a clue that we, the
Freemans, had for some years moved uptown? Why get into it, Lou?
She seemed well aware that I was a Boy Scout tangled in a stubborn
knot of string theory. This Gina sneaking up on the site in which
my theorem depended upon the work of others. She would know that
the problem was not mine alone, and further know we broadcast our
progress with a sense of camaraderie, as though still low on the
ladder, we might settle into a Viennese café, spell our answers out
on paper tablecloths, though the acrobatic dream of my climbing a
rung up while scribbling through cigarette haze may not work out,
not at all. You see how precarious it was, yet how available my
various routes to solvation.
Perhaps that Gina was even aware that Ernst
Gottschalk, our leader in the quaint Hall of Mathematics, is the
man I dodge even when he’s gone a-conferencing, not settled in his
endowed Chair, elegantly tailored beyond the three dimensions of
the world we inhabit in out-at-elbow Gap, worn student jeans. The
door to his office flung open, no appointment needed, as though we
play in time gone by—kindly teacher welcoming a confab with
befuddled adjunct in need, though mostly unavailable as he
publishes the next and the next paper, the only one that counted
back in ’78, the dark age of a quantum past. Gott, who still holds
with No. 2 pencils, red erasers, an ancient’s belief in the
contemplated mark on the page, the rubber crumbs of correction.
I slouch by his door each day. Idle fear, Louise, as though he
might catch me out in a miscalculation. Tut-tut shake of the
ponderous head with its unruly ruff of white hair. For now I will
call it a touch of paranoia connecting that Gina, Bert’s Munster
mom, to Gott, a legendary figure of fun and fear you have never,
may never, meet. Our leader does not frolic at math parties,
partake of our pizza sweating in the cardboard delivery box, sip
our tepid beer.
Gina, this is the professor. Her bangled arm
raised in greeting. Gina multitasks, nanos,
surveillance.
In the past, Bert claimed the title
Entrepreneur—telecommunications in Africa, oil in Belarus, gold in
Peru—seemed multi enough. At his emporium a job arranged for Artie
when in need, so I’d run the books on the screen, always this side
of the law, or play pixart, imaging whatever the boss imagined in
his climb to the heights. I trust you recall Skylark’s shot at a
weather channel, Bertram Boyce controlling the elements. Make it
rain, Freeman. Give us a blustery day. More often than not,
reality echoed my cloud cover or the mist of a Spring morning. Snow
fell softly on the tristate area, credit of Arthur Freeman. We
marketed the sun, the rain. The atmosphere in the limo that day was
heavy with a climate of restraint, a forecast of possible
grief.
The 86th Street transverse allotted little time for
my sorry tale. I was not and, as you feared, may never gain the
dimension of professor. The Park glowered above its stone walls,
trees and sky dimmed, blur of a dirty white cloud. Bert scrolled a
window down to admit a wave of fossil fumes, then, skeletal hand on
your thigh, made his move, the old one-on-one maneuver.
How’s the art business?
You sweetened your answer with a smile. I’m not
in business. Let it play out, the uncomfortable silence
enclosing us at the stoplight.
Then Gina on the wireless canceling out the old
friends of Bud Boyce. I’m on the board, to whom it may
concern, so I’ll go in that direction.
Feathering her nest?
Fast forward: Bertie is ushered up the courthouse
steps, spiffy with a silk handkerchief in his blazer pocket,
Heather tottering behind on perilous heels. Cameras that day. I was
ordered to keep my distance by the defense, T. Sylvan, Esquire, who
does not deserve his arboreal name. I am well aware of the unkind
view I’d taken as the case presented itself at the distance of
judge’s chambers. My day in court, I’d have said nice things,
believe me. Bert, devoted father and husband, simply lost his way
in the prevalent culture of greed. Why not skim off the cream? My
grandmother, Mae O’Connor, taught me about top o’ the milk when
milk came in a bottle, when children were instructed not to skim or
backdate, though everyone’s doing it. Mea culpa, another of
her lessons, came to mind as I opened the new notebook each day.
McBride brought me a mug of coffee, a friendly gesture. He sat with
me, took the weight off his legs. Phlebitis goes with the job.
Forty years he’s been at his post, forty! Knows how they swing, the
Scales of Justice. Tim feared a motion to dismiss. He looked with a
trained eye at the words covering this page as though to ask,
Where, Professor, are the numbers?
Topology, that’s a crowded field, Gina
said.
You remarked upon the jangle of her bracelets, her
assessment of your canvas jacket with Maisy’s spit-up on the
shoulder. In the gathering gloom of the limo, you rapped your
binoculars for attention: We don’t have much time away from the
children. Protecting me, not yet a postdoc, from this woman’s
superior smile and, as you noted, excessive eyeliner and smart
mouth, this Gina with tasks insufficient to keep her from
surveillance of Artie, the boyhood chum. So you rattled on,
abundance of species. A long-eared today. Owl, that is. You
attempted the great egret’s mournful cry, though he had been out of
sorts, silently strutting on pipe-stem legs.
Bud offered door-to-door service. You said, Just
drop us, we like the walk. That’s how I remember it, a
conjecture which need not be proven, strange when you’d been
counting the minutes to get home to the kids. Something desperate
about Bert’s air kiss aimed at you, corner of CPW, Gina’s ringtone
ordering him back to business in the limo. Tapping me with a
skeletal hand, Chairman of Skylark said: Don’t be a
stranger. Not an offhand remark, a plea. We faked one of those
embarrassing male embraces. Bert, transformed to dry skin and
bones. What was left of my friend’s solid state? There’s your
problem for topology. And why that woman?
Many questions, though on our way home in a taxi, I
simply asked, Can you believe it?
I believe it. Poor Heather.
Why the peasant costume?
Turista. Hides his wasted body.
You wondered about that—poncho? About the design
woven into the gray wool, a pattern circling in on itself, the
fringe of dangling strings with the weaver’s knots you thought
might be read, knots forming words, and the alarming sight of
Bert’s manicured toes peeking out of rough sandals. You never liked
Boyce. Till that day I did not know he once suggested the two of
you get it on, the boss and my wife riding downtown in the
old Boycemobile, fitted out with a screen tracking the commodities
market. And yes, I was pissed or at least affronted, but you
awarded the incident a girlish disbelief you can still call upon in
honesty. The current floating palace less office, more lounge of a
first-class hotel. Smoked glass of the windows mutes the city. Did
Gina get it on with Bert? He seemed too frail, flesh fallen
away under the floppy gray garment.
Such a find, you said, in the chili-bean
market, unwearable when you get it home.
Bud had looked a sad clown. You carried on about
that Gina, then disapproved of yourself as a prude. That woman
intimate with the small problem I worked on, suggesting I’d never
find my place in a crowded field. You haven’t much of a clue about
topology, only that my superiors are attempting to map the world,
beginning to end, without landmass or bodies of water. You remain a
tourist in this geography of abstraction.
Remember the logo? I called to mind the
wingspread on the web site. Skylark, on the annual report and the
simplified wings of my design woven into the corporate carpet.
Bird that never was.
Bird thou never wert, correcting your
husband, Humanities dropout, comic relief man chirping wert,
wert.
Oh, Artie, checking your watch again. How
long had we waited for the crosstown, then malingered in the
stretch while Cyril and Maisy were abandoned to my student, a
strange girl they’d never met?
Gone the sun from the river, from Riverside Park.
Darkness falling as I sorted through bills to pay the cabby.
All is well, safely rest, God is nigh.
Now, why? Why that melancholy tune? To beg a
smile.
If I relied on the memory of my laptop with its
stellar capacity, I’d not have the full story—day of our birding,
even less of the present. Could I have imagined Tim McBride’s
educated guess as he let me into the abandoned interrogation room?
The Boyce case might never go to trial. So why was I absent from my
classroom duties, simmering on a back burner? Why reconstructing,
as though with imaginary numbers, the events of a day on which we
sighted the long-eared who, noted in our communal notebook, would
not ruffle his speckled cascade of feathers? I had come in
good faith to speak my piece to judge and jury and find I am
defending myself, still telling the story of the Castle in Central
Park that now harbors the Official Weather Station, Your Honor, and
the timeline of that day, as in: It was well after six when my
student really could not, Professor Freeman, consider the money
pressed on her, and besides it was fun helping Cyril with his
homework. Cyril, who is five, does not have homework. And Maisy,
she was sorry to report, had been coughing, running a fever. A
well-brought-up girl, sweetly rejecting my offer to walk her home
in the dark.
It’s only six twenty-seven. Cyril, flashing
his digital watch, grown-up gift from Our Sylvie. The student was
gone with high fives for the children. A last gift of the
day.
That night I couldn’t get near the extra dimensions
that may, in a very long run, anoint me a professor. Don’t be a
stranger. Bert’s look searching me out was desperate, but we
were exactly that: strangers. He knew it, yet sent that woman,
whatever part she played in his life, to ferret out my small
problem. That Gina who seemed to know I was sulking in a corner of
string theory appropriately called flop-transition,as though
the tilted rubber ball of space named the failure of Artie
Freeman.
It was no go when I attempted to work on while my
family slept. That is how I think of it now, my family safely
tucked away. I logged off, took up the birdwatching diary, which
lay by your chair along with the discarded mystery. I have now
violated the green notebook with an account of my courthouse days,
flipping past the pages on which you recorded Columbus Day 2007.
Great Egret (Casmerodius albus) 4:30 Turtle Pond,
should be on its way south; your lovely sketch of our owl
(Asio otus) 4:50 Reservoir Track, lacking the
observation as to sex or probable age, though you had noted:
Boyce, a molting Goshawk, predator, 86th & 5th
Avenue. Wears a gray tunic to hide his wasted body. The fringe is
patterned with knots that must mean something if you can read them.
Is he sick, even dying? I left the book open, believing I was
meant to answer, then carried it to my grandfather’s desk, took a
pen from the secret drawer and wrote: Dying or trashing his
life. Lou, it’s numbers in those knots that dangle from Bert’s
gone-native garment, not letters that tell a story. Numbers, an
accounting or tracking of days tied in by a woman in the Andes, a
bit of pre-Columbian string theory I might at best master, at least
understand.
It occurred to me that night of our birding, not
for the first time, our family life in these rooms was inauthentic,
no need for our children to be stacked in a bunk bed, Maisy below
nestled in her plush menagerie, Cyril above clutching his
tyrannosaurus rex. No need for us to fear toppling his tower of
Lincoln Logs. Just behind me the hamster tumbled incessantly in its
cage. A cluster of shrinking balloons hovered on the ceiling. No
need for this pretense of student life. We should look to our own
migration, a refuge sustainable for more than a season of
uncertainty. I’d sold Cyril O’Connor’s apartment on Fifth Avenue,
glad of the take. You said we must move from the loft downtown, the
contaminated air of our injured city the first of all your fears.
So here we still are in cramped quarters, a little late for growing
pains self-inflicted. Is that what Bud, costumed as a starving
peon, was up to? He had stroked the leg of the all-knowing Gina as
though under a spell.
I opened the baby book with the stork on the cover,
flipped back to the day of our birding, first day you had not noted
each verified death in the war. The blank page was marked with a
postcard from Sylvie Neisswonger who is more than our friend. The
Oceanographic Institute in La Jolla sat firmly on its hill.
Waters rising! Love to all, natürlich. Sylvie’s hand
schoolgirl perfect, natürlich. What’s more, you did not read
a mystery that night, no body in the library, no clueless inspector
from Scotland Yard. Then, as I finally attempted to set the course
for the next encounter with my students, more pedagogical tricks
than math, you stood beside me, Maisy in your arms. You had affixed
a disfiguring nebulizer over our daughter’s face. Mucus sucked in
little blips from her nose and mouth.
I said: Now, this is the scariest
thing.
You shifted Maisy, left shoulder to right: Not
really.
Her temperature would be brought down by pink
sugary drops, nothing magic. I understood the pleasure of your
control, your soft lullaby voice. Do you remember the only thing
that mattered was to wait in silence for the even draw of her
breath, for the moment when Maisy pushed the plastic tube away?
Then we waited for the sleepy smile on her flushed, rosebud face.
Together we put her down with the bear and the lion, the tortoise
and speckled snake. I said, All that’s missing is an owl, an
attempt to keep our vigil light.
When Maisy breathed easy, I noted that you wore the
nightgown, the one I like, though it buttons to your neck with
difficult pearl buttons, the blue nightgown now dimmed in the wash.
And I saw, not the first time, streaks in your pale hair, dark as
dull bronze.
A full week of delays. Like that Gina, I opted for
the present, waiting for a judgment to be handed down; that’s the
feel of those courthouse days. Skylark in ruins, unlike the
midscale Buick that shares its name, more the frail body of my
equations towed to the scrap heap of rusted ambition. When it
finally came, the reprieve, McBride was proven right, proud of
himself predicting Bertie would not be charged with cooking the
books. The case was too flimsy, but the plaintiff is not off the
hook. Boyce must be a good lad, suffer a slap on the wrist, a
year’s public service. Skylark may never soar again, spread its
wings over the dusty pits of Peruvian gold or peck at the
infinitesimal grains of nano technology. In the first flush of
their victory, Bertie and Heather, losing their cool, embraced me,
but I had not testified that my friend discovered Freeman, the new
boy at school, inscribing hieroglyphics in his algebra text, that
he had a slim chance of besting me at chess, that the neighborhood
was ours, every alley, shop, embassy and elegant doorway between
Fifth and the Boyce apartment on Park, where we played games of my
invention on a primitive DOS system free of interference from
Bert’s socialite mom. Play—we had played hard and long—which kept
me from diving for salvage in my mother’s watery grave. Back, back
then Bert finally psyched out my trips to the Egyptian collection,
but the Opening of the Mouth was never revealed. Only now comes to
mind, Louise, the ritual I enacted in the back bedroom of the
apartment you dread, King Tut mumbo jumbo that might bring the
goddess to life so she might breathe, speak to her boy, play a song
on the lute. That was private, middle-of-the-night stuff. Still,
never-call-me-Bert was my buddy, and the alliance began in which I
was to play office boy as he rose to corporate power.
On the courthouse steps, we lingered in a light
drizzle, Bert, the pay-back kid, almost fully restored, as though
that desiccated version of himself reflected the misdemeanors of
the dated past. My walk-on lines were written out of the script,
though where, may I ask, was that Gina? Refurbishing her nest?
Bertie and loyal wife were escorted to a modest black livery by
their lawyer, licking his chops, swallowing the canary, brittle
bones and all. They turned back, suggesting a triumphal
lunch.
Can’t bring to mind how I begged off. Rain
check? Or work, I suppose, heavy duties of my professorial
life.
Justice was deferred, which brings to mind my
grandmother, who said something like that about our sins, most
particularly sins of omission, that we would face them come
Judgment Day. McBride in his various roles—prosecutor, defendant,
jury, judge—went on to his next case. I was free of the
interrogation room.
Tonight as I stood at the window looking through
the leafless trees to the Hudson, I saw a familiar boat not yet
stowed away for the season. It will sail downstream to safe harbor,
the 79th Street boat basin, I guess. A ship with a single mast, and
it was only then that I remembered skylarking. When we were
in high school, we came across the term in a computer game we
played too often, signing off on an early version of Myst. No
knights defending a phony castle, only the crew of a pirate ship.
Apparently Bert did not forget the perilous game played by these
black-hearted sailors. Climb the mainmast, latch onto the rigging,
swing out far over the sea. City boys making our mark in the
classroom, we never had the occasion to skylark beyond the virtual,
but we climbed too high, Bertram Boyce and Arthur Freeman.
That first day, post-courthouse, I returned to
campus, homecoming of sorts. Our leader, Gottschalk, caught me out,
called me into his office, a stage set, this proper old-fashioned
realm with wooden bookshelves to the ceiling, an oak desk of modest
proportions on which the sole computer looks a prop, screen saver
of dizzy double helix spinning. We know in Mathematics Hall that
this room with its arched windows looks on the livelier courtyard
of the business school sheathed in glass, endowed with
incorruptible steel. But it is here in Gott’s office, we confer
under the water-stained ceiling, the dim overhead light, and take
our course assignments from our Chair. Gott, attempting a youthful
look that day, had gelled his white hair (cockatoo in breeding
plumage), a double-breasted blazer overdosed with brass buttons,
the stud of some prestigious award in the lapel. Tap-tapping a
printout in hand. Tilted dumbbells of extra dimensions floated to a
decorative purpose. He turned to a back page. Under Also
Noted noted:
Fellow at MIT, Gott said, an elegant
paper.
Squared it away, so to speak, the very problem I
had been working on. Fellow at MIT beat me to it. We had stalked
each other. Had I not been at the courthouse, I would have known of
his triumph without our leader’s old news. So it’s a slice of
humble pie, happens all the time, Lou, fellow edged me out in the
crowded field. It was then suggested—Gottschalk’s no-nonsense
words—that I am “a live wire” in the classroom, perhaps not a
perfect fit with the theoretical, as though I wear a pinched shoe.
Then again, sequencing has taken an energetic turn in the
human-genome race, not to mention the tech market, nano coming into
play. At the end of the day, end of the story, I have been advised
to limp on to new fields.
You have computational skills,
Freeman.
Like Cyril, that’s our bright boy. Now, why
did I say that?
Not to get the laugh, though it was all quite
pleasant after the tight shoe dropped, Gottschalk suggesting how I
might recoup. Move on? Ein stein tells us that to move on, to take
the next step beyond the signs and images of numbers,
conventional words must be sought for. It is no consolation
to know that he never solved everything, though he sure tried.
Every last thing—how the universe got it together in this, our long
allotted space-time. Well, I’m no Albie, apparently not much of a
mathematician at all. But there is an endgame to the mystery that
may give you some pleasure. Why had I not known that the problem
was solved? Up there in Cambridge, fellow at MIT looking beyond his
successful calculations to a bright Autumn day on the Charles.
Because I had not accessed the information that a boy’s quest for
an answer had been, in fact, answered. In those courthouse days, I
became devoted to words written down, addicted to news of the past,
which suddenly seemed more pressing than the tabloid headline:
FREEMAN FLOPS TRANSITION. Early on, I had failed with
hieroglyphics, with demotic script invoking my mother. And in our
time, Louise, lost the scavenger hunt for my phantom father.
Perhaps, after all, Bertie’s troubles were a dodge and this is just
a family story. I see that these pages did not come easy at first,
then too easy—spilling off the backlog of our birding, the meager
discoveries of a day in Central Park. How I mocked your catalog of
fears, my possible failure right up there with e-waste, habitat
loss.
Conventional words, Lou: I am sorry.
One night not long ago, pre-courthouse, when your
mystery was neatly solved, we laughed as usual at the festering
state of the nation, unhealed by comic turns on TV. We looked
forward to the midterm election that might salvage what was left of
our honor. For a moment all was right with our little world. I
attempted to join in the fun, deliver my layman’s praise of your
recent work. The homey vision of your art—mind if I use the
word?—which you have all but abandoned. You’d been working ahead on
what Cyril calls Mom’s project—it’s cool.
I said: A turn on the kids’ refrigerator art,
Lou. Cyril’s precise launch pads and rockets, Maisy’s scribbles
freehand. I believe, post-courthouse, care must be taken honoring
your vision, so let me correct and revise.
Moffett’s paper memorial to our soldiers dead in
this war decorates the glass shelf over the stove in our kitchen.
The names of the dead are not memorialized in black marble, just
written in ink on fragile paper scraps stapled one to two, two to
three, three to four and so on. They were first recorded in a book
meant to track the weight, height, amusing words, and fevers of our
sickly child, but that record is long gone. Moffett’s memorial is
now inscribed on strips of brown butcher paper that winds between
the measuring cups and the copper stock pot that was my
grandmother’s prize, then circles back on itself and sweeps round
the broken coffee grinder. Where have all the young men
gone?
Bonifacio, Jerry L. Jr., 28, Staff Sgt., Army
National Guard; Vacaville, Calif.; First Battalion, 184th
Infantry
Escobar, Sergio H., 18, Lance Cpl., Marines;
Pasadena, Calif.; First Marine Division
Hodge, Susan M., 20, Specialist, Army National
Guard; Ridgeway, Ohio; 612th Engineer Battalion
Johnson, Leon M., 28, Sgt., Army; Jacksonville,
Fla.; Third Infantry Division Kimmell, Matthew A., 30, Staff Sgt.,
Army; Paxton, Ind.; Third Battalion, Fifth Special Forces
Group
Sneed, Brandon K., 33, Sgt. First Class, Army;
Norman, Okla.; Third Infantry Division
Though each link holds steady, as the months
pass, Moffett’s work is in need of repair. Gone to graveyards every
one, sadly forgettable names weep in the steam, which I believe is
what the artist has in mind. Looping down dangerously close to the
flame, it is eerily festive, her Möbius strip with no inside, no
outside, no end.
In our cottage industries of art and science, we do
move on, discovering the last stale breath in the shrunken bladders
of this year’s birthday balloons, the hamster replacement spinning
in his cage, Bert’s sentence called off pending our further
interrogation. Again, I place my updated notebook by your chair.
You will remember the owl, the cold eye of that Gina, our Maisy’s
congestion, your impatience one day in the Park, the ten dollar
bill pressed on my pretty student who couldn’t possibly, Professor,
a girl with no fear of the city dark, though big readable numbers
on Cyril’s watch told us 6:27, gone the sun, from the hills,
from the lake, safely rest. . . . That is the trouble with
memory: it sorts through the chaos, brings images to
mind—watchtower of a phony castle, Bert sniffing his claret, the
rough stuff of his poncho, rigging and mainmast, a gold dou bloon
for the scoundrel who takes a death-defying chance.
Louise, notebooks in hand, stands before her
husband, the plaintiff’s side of his desk.
“Our Sylvie,” she says, no need to say more. The
children are safe at home with Sylvie Neisswonger. Louise has
seldom been to Freeman’s office, a bleak room atop the curious
little temple, Mathematics Hall, a cast-off aerie he shares with
his aspiring pals—an acknowledged genius, boasting baby fat, who
brings cookies to the children when invited to supper, devours them
before the kids get a chance; an Indian woman who affects biker
gear to counter her astonishing beauty, her great reserve. Artie is
alone as Louise knew he would be, his schedule posted on their home
page, Works and Days.
“Your version of our birding? What you wrote, down
there in the courthouse?”
She begins her case against him, then turns to the
blackboard, of course. Of course there must be a blackboard screwed
to the wall. An elaborate problem covers most of its surface.
Underneath in the old wooden frame, some joker, or serious student,
has carved PYTHAGORAS SUCKS.
“You left these for me to read as though we can no
longer talk.”
“Lou-Lou.”
“Don’t Lou-Lou me.”
“Easy way out, writing it down.”
Artie comes round the desk, turns his wife to the
window. A spectacular Autumn day, the sky wiped new blue. Students
denying the chill in flip-flops and shorts litter the steps leading
down to the broad campus from Low. The view from this height trumps
that from Gottschalk’s office. Homer, Plato, Virgil, the usual
suspects inscribed in the limestone cornice of Butler Library catch
the late sun.
“Computation?” she says. “He’s got to be
kidding.”
“Gott doesn’t kid. Demographics, genomes. Think
small.”
“Not what you wanted, not ever.”
“Just different. I will not contribute. Love
that terminal squeak? The Big Bang, first or last, will blast off
without me. Fellow’s paper beating me out by a mile may be
published too early, pie in the sky, amount to nothing at
all.”
“Then why is it elegant?”
“You hear me talk solutions—beautiful, stunning.
Some friend of Ein stein’s said elegance ought to be left to the
tailor, the cobbler. Take Gott, for instance. The proof of his
pudding may amount to nothing more than his elegant labels—Gucci,
Armani, or so we students suppose.”
But she wasn’t listening—as she had so often—to the
tolerable lectures attempting to make his work real to her. When
they lived downtown in the loft, she had followed his every word,
or tried to. At the turn of the millennium, Louise understood
perfectly why the world would not end in a slippage of time, Y2K
snuff the soul out of our computers. With reparation we would move
on. Artie had called his return to mathematics the makeup class in
whatever the world might be made of, that his scribbled lineup of
symbols and numbers were the merest foot soldiers to a general
theory of everything, don’t you know? At times he would attempt to
draw strings coupling, or make visible the loop-de-loop of quantum
frenzy. She never quite got it but took the pencil from his hand,
shaded in, crosshatched to get the depth of possible dimensions.
Her own work had given way to house and children as though, much
like old Gottschalk, she wiped away the rubber crumbs of her art,
leaving the smudge of line and perspective unsolved.
On the South Lawn below, a card table flaps its
antiwar poster. No patrons to read the leaflets, sign the petition.
Too brisk, too bright a day, the message worn, ineffectual. Long
time ago, 1968, that war, the students had stormed the
president’s office, but that siege doesn’t come to mind; she just
wishes he had not used that gentle folk song in his account of her
work. She must tear down her kitchen art. The private notice of her
mourning seems foolish today, Art Speak to no listener other than
Artie. Once she had drawn the arrow of time for Freeman, a birthday
card, and once exhibited a cloudy solution in a bottle of water,
half empty, half full, a show playing with uncertainty, the assault
of time on the body, that’s all. Time passing as we know it, day by
day. Not mere numbers, he had said of the evaporating water
in a hand-blown bottle—his judgment kindly, self-effacing. Now as
she listened to his babble of knots and loops, she did not try to
understand, not this time. Perhaps she was never meant to. From the
rising pitch of his voice, she guessed he was going on about proof.
What matter whether the conjecture was true or false? Something
absurd, how he fell into the swamp of the excluded middle,
laughing, still foolin’ around.
He said: “Oh, Artie,” imitating the caress of her
incalculable scolds.
“Don’t,” she said, “don’t go there.” She held the
notebooks to her breast, his new one from Pearl Paint and the old
greenie with her bird notations, heard the shuffling of papers into
his backpack and the familiar snap of his laptop as he prepared to
walk Cyril to school each morning. Closing up shop, but she did not
think so, not now, perhaps never. He couldn’t give up playing the
numbers. On the way home, they would speak, a few words with a
bitter edge to be glossed over. Then they would talk for how many
years? They would move, though never far from a classroom, and she
would again have a studio. Change of direction might not suit them,
not again. They would honor the yearly trip to the farm in
Wisconsin. What mattered was here and now, the probable life just
outside the city, a garden perhaps, doghouse, sandbox, but never a
plastic feeder to fake out the hummingbirds with sugar in a bowl.
She would plant red flowers to lure them, though she could not yet
name them—cardinal flowers. Our Sylvie would discover her young
friends still within range of their starting line, Lower Broadway.
He would make light of Lou’s fears. She would endure his mixed
metaphors, his puns, the dated phrases of his grandfather, Cyril
O’Connor. The difficult pearl buttons at the top of every nightgown
would be snipped off for the hope of easy access on nights
reclaiming their eager bodies in the loft, skin to skin.
Nightclothes came with the children. She wished he had not used
that song. It belonged to his mother, to her mother, too. Or
perhaps he did not remember the appropriate line: Where have all
the young girls gone? Taken husbands every one. Though that was
not true, not true of his mother, who left him by accident to an
orphan boy life. He switched off the buzzing fluorescent light, the
room behind her in semidarkness now. She thought, how unfair: Artie
lost, Bertie won. Would they still go to Connecticut for the
Christmas goose, the tasteful Boyce glitter, snubs from their
spoiled children? She would not speak; the anger was still there, a
clutch in her throat that he’d never told her, that he’d written
his failure out as though it’s no more than a story. Put words in
her mouth. On the way home, she would relent, hand over the
notebooks, say good job to his account of their day in the
Park, entirely man-made, their birding, her fears. But that would
never do, for that’s what she said to the kids—good job—when
they showed her their brave efforts with Play-Doh, Legos, with
Magic Markers of their refrigerator art.
The sun at the window was still bright, almost
blinding. Squinting, Louise could see a Frisbee fly over the patch
of lawn on the campus designated for play, and a tour guide leading
prospective students and their parents up the steps into Low, where
they would be awed by the dome of the rotunda, for sure a temple of
learning. She could hear Artie scrape back the chair from his old
desk, funky like Gottschalk’s. As though there for a show at the
end of this day, birds flitted from tree to tree on Campus Walk.
She would not call them city pigeons. Pale mourning doves, she
named them in a coo. Colum-um-bidae. When she turned, her
husband was erasing the intricate problem on the blackboard. Chalk
dust fell in a haze. Not to steal his words, she waited for him to
say it.
“Clean slate.”
Daybook, October 25, 2007
The children, by which we mean grandchildren, have
carved a pumpkin for us, lest we forget. He—it’s a he—sits on our
front hall table. His snarling smile, jagged teeth, triangulated
eyes don’t scare us at all. Part of their pleasure was making the
mess. They are scheming, wacky tricks, I presume. We’re stuck in
the waiting game. The costume I’ve been wearing these many years,
middle-class woman in the last days of the Holocene, surely belongs
to someone else, though the plot as it plays out, remains the same.
Conception to the grave. The rest is filler.
In Tolstoy’s Death of Ivan Ilyich, read just
weeks ago, a posturing public servant reviews his life to discover
that his ambition has been a burden to his family. As it was to
Tolstoy’s, so we are told by Nabokov, spreading the guilt around.
Prompted by this confession, I swing toward you on my ergonomic
chair. You are at the door of my workroom. I speak of the years
you’ve put up with my scribbling.
Apology dismissed, you suggest we close the little
house in the Berks this year, As a precaution.
Caution on your mind these days. While I have a
formal gratitude for your care, what might happen if I throw it to
the wind? I mourn the loss of our wrangling, the way you screen my
fancy through reality check. We will miss the view of the garden
safe in its blanket of snow. Still, we are in perfect accord.
Not yet, not in October!
Settle into your books.
You closed the flue, discarded the ashes good for
the garden.
Here in the El Dorado the fireplace in our
apartment was sealed up before we settled in. A pretentious display
of marble. The mantel’s crenellations and brass rosettes refer to
some striver’s hope in the wake of the Great Depression.
Elegance—now you see it: now you don’t.
In any case, the little house is closed as a
precaution. I’m confined to the safety of our twin towers and the
Park, all stories within reach, legends of the season. I mean to
say: more than a magician’s trick, though plain as the nose on my
face, the decorative dead wood in the fireplace is not seen
anymore. The screen to protect us from hot embers, useless. Antique
Roadshow stuff—an astrolabe, highboy, cradle, Death of the
Virgin , Goya’s Disasters of War (second state).
Our Sylvie: A Fireside Story
And God said to Noah, I have determined to
make an end of all flesh; For the earth is filled with violence
through them; behold I will destroy them with the earth; Make
yourself an ark of gopher wood; make rooms in the ark, and cover it
inside and out with pitch.
—Genesis 11:13-15
Sylvia Neisswonger is strapped into her seat
heading east. To her right she sees the image of a plane on a small
screen. To her left, bright blue sky stretches above suds of cloud
as far as the eye can see. Perhaps that distance can be figured.
Martha, her stepdaughter, measures depths of the sea, so why not
the distance to beyond? The plane on the screen is trailing a red
line as it flies across America, eating up the distance from San
Diego to JFK. Sylvie can’t figure how to call this image up. She
looks to her seatmate’s screen. He’s a young man, young to her,
with a beak of nose on a fleshy face. To Sylvie he looks
assembled—floppy ears, receding chin, his body a soft bulk. He has
fallen asleep, thumb in the page of an airport thriller, not
thrilling enough, though a car bomb in the act of exploding a U.S.
Army vehicle is blazoned on Run for Cover. Soldiers in
splotched camouflage stand, thank heaven, safely aside. Carts with
salty snacks and beverage of choice have been wheeled down the
aisle. In the hum of the pressurized cabin, she hears the
occasional cough, a shrill cry, perhaps the baby who gave her a
grin when infants, the old and infirm were boarded first. She pops
the flesh-colored hearing aids out of her ears. The dumb show in
the cabin surrounds her.
Quite deaf, though not infirm, as the guards at the
Oceanographic Institute in La Jolla might tell you, tell that every
day of her visit, Mrs. Waite, as she is properly known, climbed
uphill to have lunch with Martha. They were more than welcoming.
“Gallant”: that’s the word she searches out, Perez and Bonfilio not
checking the visitor ID that hung round her neck, quick to escort
her up the steps, open the door as though the Institute were a
first-class hotel, not a temple of science. Perez has three
children. His wife’s name is Lola. Bonfilio is studying bookkeeping
at night. Calling out loud and strong—Beautiful day, Mrs.
Waite. How they did love to chat when she made it to the top of
the hill, breathed easy. Waite, her legal name on two documents
submitted at the airport in New York, is the name of her
stepdaughter, Dr. Waite, Martha. Checking through Security brought
back the memory of her first U.S. passport and the name she was
born with: von Neisswonger. Yes, her mother, Inga von Neisswonger,
had charmed the American consul in Toulouse. The papers he procured
were not fraudulent; her passport with the photo of a wistful girl,
stunned by the camera, hair braided tight, perfect little
snowflakes knit into her Tyrolean sweater.
My brother Otto had a sweater with the very same
snowflakes. Absurd, our father said,—snowflakes never match.
Each one has its own crystal network. Pleased with herself for
telling Martha that story with its bit of crystallography, for it’s
hard to find common ground, always has been, to come upon a moment
when she was not the woman with the trace of an accent, with words
sought for in plain English. When she was not that intruder—Call
me Sylvie—who came all of a sudden years and years ago to an
old house in Connecticut to take the place of Martha’s dead
mother.
My brother Otto . . .
Your brother Otto?
Yes, older by three years, already at the
gymnasium. Always showing off, explaining the workings of the
Jacquard loom as though our father would not know a thousand
snowflakes, if you like, might be programmed, woven exactly the
same.
Martha said: Most likely not woven, then
held forth on the invention of knitting machines, correcting Sylvie
not as sharply as Papa Neisswonger had corrected his son. Sylvie
understood about the Jacquard loom, that it didn’t knit sweaters.
She was ten years old at the time, some years older when her mother
told the story, the way Inga told family stories to her new friends
in New York, always leaving out the name of her son as though
Otto might scratch, a painful burr in her throat. It is
quite ridiculous, this loose strand of a childhood sweater that
will lead Sylvie where she goes too often this past year, to the
stucco villa in Innsbruck with its red-tiled roof, handblown glass
in the windows transforming the garden to a shimmering mirage.
Shuffling memories, laying out the cards.
Both von Neisswonger and his son were escorted out
the double front door to the purring Mercedes by Nazi officers with
thick Berlinerisch accents, Otto clutching his scuffed football
like a ruined globe in his hands. Sylvie had once planned to go
back to see the house, now a small hotel—how odd it would be to see
her room rented for the night, her little bed with its white
coverlet transformed to the vast comfort of king-size, the frieze
of twined edelweiss painted out. She had once thought to return
with Cyril, show her old lover the house on the river Inn, the
imperial squares of the city, the Alpine mines her father worked,
summer and winter. She will not go now, now that he’s gone, lies
with May, his wife of many years, leaving Sylvie the comfort of his
family. A wonder how they have sorted themselves out. As she packed
for the yearly visit to Martha, My trip to California must do
me, said to the neighbors who knew nothing of her abandoned
journey to Innsbruck but would look after the house in Connecticut,
take in the mail, overwater the plants. The house of Bob Waite, her
late husband, she had explained to one of Martha’s pals at the
Institute. Late. I have never understood that
expression.
Better late than never, the fellow said, a
rude remark now she thinks of it. They were a funny crowd, these
men and women who keep track of the wind, who search for holes in
the sea, who count time in the millions of years, a time when the
waters rose, a time before the Great Flood became a Bible story.
Now the deluge was all too real, happening fast in their
calculations of melt. A stargazer, declared a crank by these
scientists, believed he had found Noah’s Ark, what was left of it,
poking up in a satellite picture of Mount Ararat. The waters were
now rising, not receding, so what did he hope to salvage, they
asked—a blockbuster script? The animals, two by two, cast from the
San Diego Zoo? The Titanic in biblical dress? Sylvie had
thought to stop their laughter—The ark was sturdy, sealed with
pitch—then thought not, for she was their guest, the powdery
old lady listening in at the end of the table. Martha took her
side. Prehistoric sea creatures found at Yellowstone, so why not?
Plucking a hair from Noah’s beard, DNA coaxing—could be Jurassic
Park.
Sylvie believes that as soon as she left each day
after lunch, the scholars went back to talking their winds and
waves while she braved the freeway in her rented Toyota, found her
way back to Martha’s cottage. Still, they seemed to her quite
silly, these brilliant seashore observers laughing at last night’s
TV, making jokes of the State of the Union. Well, the State of the
Union was perilous, they well knew. She did not cut into their
play, though it was all too easy to translate White House blather
they laughed at to the German propaganda of the Reich. Heimat.
Vaterland. Ehre. As for Noah, the one just man, she searched
the shelves in the cottage wanting to read what God ordered by way
of an ark. Martha did not own a Bible. Sylvie is certain about the
pitch, the viscous caulk Bob Waite applied each Spring to his
trawler. The smell was god-awful, impossible to wash the black
stuff out of his clothes. Each year when he finished, that thrifty
man threw his ruined jeans and work shirt away.
Far as Sylvie can see, these lunch breaks at the
Institute and an occasional barbecue are Martha’s only life beyond
the lab. There’s her bicycling team on Sundays and a correspondence
with a professor at Woods Hole that seems to have gone beyond ice
cores and ocean sediment. Martha, well into middle age, is
flustered as she speaks of coming east to present a paper at a
conference organized by her—pausing for the appropriate word—her
mentor.
So mentor it is, though Sylvie hopes he is more.
She will call Martha when she gets home to Connecticut. Still early
in California, her big athletic girl with clipped gray hair will
answer on the cell even if she is in the midst of climate
calculations or e-mailing her prospective lover of an event some
million years ago. What she remembers of Martha’s industry, what
she told the scientists at lunch one day, was the story of when
this Sylvie was brought to the house on a hill, Bob Waite’s
unwelcome surprise. She took his children to the shore, the rim of
sand on Long Island Sound, that small puddle, and the girl she did
not yet know dug, dug until the water seeped up from China, saving
the pebbles and a necklace of slimy seaweed to examine at home.
Martha’s future, Sylvie told these men and women plotting the fate
of the Pacific coast, was written in the sand.
And she sleeps as the red line makes its way across
New Mexico up to Denver, till chicken or beef, hard to tell, though
she recalls cupping her ear to hear the selection. She eats only
the bland cookie, sleeps again, and when she wakes, the big screen
at the front of the cabin displays a young man with a smirk on his
face driving a mountain trail, a treacherous journey, though
Sylvie’s seatmate is laughing—the hearty ho-ho of that
Mitteleuropa actor in the old movies, jowls shaking in joy
or despair. She imagines the thrill of the chase, the tough words
of a cop who looks fierce . . . well, not really. Laughter across
the aisle as the clown drives off the cliff, a well-known clown,
and next thing he is jumping the cables on the set, flubbing his
lines for the retake. Oh, they are only making a movie. Sylvie
enjoys the pantomime, easily guesses the stuntman’s flirtation with
the script girl, then nods off again, a dreamless sleep without
fear, without longing—and when she wakes, the little plane on the
small screen’s heading toward western Pennsylvania, and the long
descent toward New York and home.
Her seatmate comes on friendly—I’m in
sales—though she’s not asked, can’t hear the name of his
product.
Resets the digital devices in her ears.
Sales?
Heavy equipment. Farming, construction. Nurse
the infrastructure of developing nations . . . Jed does not
offer a last name. He’s Jed; she’s Sylvie. Developing
nations—you’ve got your Asians, your South of the
Border—will continue to need his backhoes, cranes. Jed flies
business class. Coach this trip, personal time.
But suppose, Sylvie suggests, suppose the
fields in Asia are underwater.
Wall-to-wall rice paddies? That’s a good
one. On his laptop he brings up pictures of his daughter, a
piglet with her father’s floppy ears, blessedly not his beak.
Lovely bright eyes. Sylvie says, Not rice
paddies. Where there is now landmass, we may experience
seeping salt water, estuaries. I have been visiting my
stepdaughter. Sylvie attempts a quick course on the Gulf
Stream, temperature twelve degrees above normal, while in
the Pacific we may experience—finds herself tangled in alien
language—short cycles of stability. From Jed’s indulgent
nod, she suspects he’s heard it all, figured it into sales of his
products—mapping the deluge, the snowless peaks of Kilimanjaro as
seen on TV. She retreats to the airline magazine. Jed finds his
place in Run for Cover. Sylvie flips the pages with many
items the efficient traveler might need—inflatable hangers, golf
bags, foldaway tents, bug zappers, ponchos for rainy adventures.
Home is addressed in doormats, tea cozies, safety grips for the
bathtub, electric heaters. Martha has said to come live with her
for the warm weather, said it so cheerfully Sylvie barely detected
the duty in her stepdaughter’s voice; and then she thinks of the
chill Waite house in Connecticut, carpenter ants chewing hand-hewn
beams to sawdust, mildew in the basement, but the pearwood mantel
is sturdy and there’s the fanlight over the front door. Sunshine or
shadow, each morning as she comes downstairs, the delicate tracery
puts on its show, a subtle retort to squared-away Yankee
design.
Still, the Federal house is not her home; and the
broad stucco villa on Lundstrasse is not home, though she can tour
every room with portraits of ancestors, all men with trim whiskers,
several with military honors of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. The
Dürer woodcuts were hung between mirrors in the dining room. So
predictable, Inga said to her new friends in New York, and so
dreary—Death of the Virgin. Passion of Christ! Well,
Inga would rather not partake of Melancholia with her
schnitzel, Danke schön, and one day said as much to her
husband, whose home the villa was in every detail. The famous
etching of that brooding angel with her mystical apparatus and a
sleeping dog at her feet remained in its place. Each room replays
with its legend, how her father turned the incident of the Dürers
to his benefit when an emissary of Cardinal Innitzer came to lunch.
Otto was allowed to sit at the table while Sylvie had been
instructed to kiss the Bishop’s hand, then sent belowstairs. Yes,
Albrecht Dürer was son of a goldsmith, his iconography decidedly
Protestant. Now his art graced the walls of a Catholic silver-mine
family, a step down in the metallurgical table. An amusing story
told by Neisswonger and retold by Inga with a mocking smile. Later,
much later, Sylvie would understand the anecdote was not about the
Master of Nuremberg or his works, gloomy though great, but about
the slights a country girl of no account often suffered having
married the honorific von with a sloping Hapsburg jaw, about how
Inga dare not speak in the presence of the prelate come on behalf
of Innitzer, who folded when the Germans appended Austria, about a
move already in process had she looked up from her Apfelstrudel to
advise the Jews to pack up, or simply noted the collapse of the
Empire in a fistful of marks dealt out for a loaf of bread.
When they were first in New York, her mother told
the Dürer story with a good deal of invention: Sylvie waited at the
door with maids and the cook for the Bishop’s departure with a
young priest who bestowed a final blessing on all. She was summoned
to watch the emissary drive off in the big black car flying the
Austrian flag—red, white, gold of the imperial eagle. Or that may
have been her mother’s invention, but this memory was Sylvie’s,
told at last to Louise: the day her father and brother were taken,
she had watched her mother dissolve in tears. Mommi, Mommi,
she cried, as her mother’s gray-green eyes blinded with sorrow. Her
full lips, ripe for laughter, puckered to a sore. Sylvie would
dream her mother’s face over the years, drowning in tears, gasping,
Otto. Otto. The last time Inga would speak her son’s name,
casting Sylvie off with a swift thrust of her arm to quickly
compose herself, Frau von Neisswonger on the phone with
arrangements, a forgiving smile for her girl who believes it was
this day when her mother, no longer Mommi, became Inga,
co-conspirator and pal. And they had lived on in the villa for some
weeks, eating like mice in the kitchen, spare meals brought in by a
loyal maid. Packing and unpacking their bags, would they need
lavender soap, warm hose or sturdy sandals? Inga, silent and calm
in preparation as though they were going to take the waters, splash
about in the refreshing Seebensee.
Flying over the vast expanse of America, Sylvie
indulges herself in this dream tour of a house, polished copper
pots in the kitchen, full canisters—Zucker, Kaffee,
Honig—while many were lucky for a potato, a crust of bread. No
good can come from this scrapbook of plenty. She stands at the door
of her father’s study where bound books lined the walls, each with
its gold title, and the atlas lay open to the map of the Austrian
Republic, 1918, the beautiful blue Danube fading on the lectern by
the window with a view of the untidy garden rippling in sunlight.
Now she enters the pretty bedroom of a small, scrappy girl, her
Steiff animals outgrown, her dolls abandoned at a tea party,
suitcase packed for the life of exile soon to come. Her father and
brother taken. Neisswonger had spoken against the Chancellor, who
stalled for time while Austria welcomed the invasion. Papa wrote
letters against that very Cardinal who played word games with the
Vatican, trifled with Mussolini, which gave a bitter twist to
Inga’s amusing story: how easily her Ulrich was swept away like so
much dross from his silver mines. And could he not see that
Catholic Austria was running out of time like the hourglass in
Dürer’s engraving? Melancholia, the hefty goddess with her
scientific apparatus, unable to figure life-and-death equations?
But why her son swept into the ashes of history? And what good to
never say his name? Otto.
No good at all figuring, not even as an
unburdening, though once the villa was revealed in detail to Louise
Moffett, who’s as close as Sylvia Neisswonger Waite will ever come
to having a daughter. No relation at all. Louise is the wife of the
grandson of her lover, Cyril O’Connor, which is more distant than
the second cousins twice removed recorded in the genealogy of the
Neisswongers, all those lofty connections. Louise did not mourn the
vanished Dürers, or a little girl’s room with a tea table and white
coverlet on the bed, or the anxious weeks out of time lingering on
in the villa, but cried for the spoiling, the word Sylvie chose to
convey her memory of the soldier’s rough hands on her body, the
harsh scrape of his brass buckle. He had not taken his tunic off,
only pulled down his britches to accomplish the act.
Beflecken, too often in recent days, the German word came to
mind, would not allow the plain English. She, who once had the gift
of tongues, a translator at the UN, German to English, English to
French. In telling of the soldier’s weight upon her, she lapsed
into the concealing hush of childhood, what must never be known.
She believed he had bristle-blond hair, that his eyes were ice
blue, though he covered her face with a pillow; then she heard his
boots stomping downstairs, coarse laughter. Whispering to Louise as
though Cyril stirring in the cradle might hear that her father’s
books were thrown off the shelves, his wine cellar desecrated, the
silver service carried off, and, most surely Melancholia and
The Passion of Christ wrenched from the dining room walls.
That night, when the soldier was through with her, she had wiped
herself on a soft linen towel embroidered with the von N. Then,
possessed of a miraculous will, she dressed in the inappropriate
velvet frock her mother had set out for their voyage, woke Inga
from a deep sleep, led her down the back stairs, out across the
terrace and neglected parterre through a hole in the garden wall,
thank God never mended. For years Sylvie would hate her small body,
shun intimacy, though later she slept around, as they used to say,
strictly unserious business, until she met Cyril O’Connor, but that
was another story not told to Louise Moffett, only that she was
loyal to her husband, Bob Waite, who took care with her, was
attentive and kind.
The lost city is no longer real, Innsbruck only a
setting for a fable told to her friend—the towering Alps at a
distance, the villa garden in disarray. Unnatürlich, her
father called the clipped box laid out in a stiff maze. The
handless statue of a goddess blessed a plot of roses gone wild.
Thorns and a dry fountain. She was allowed to play with a few
friends in this confusion while Inga poured tea à l’anglais
for their mothers.
On the terrace always, those ladies.
Lou listening to a story more mysterious than a
whodunit read before bedtime, a tale that would never provide the
desired solution with each strand folded into an end. Otto would
always be framed as a boy, lifeless as a studio photo; or the faint
human skull, a prop in Dürer’s staging of a depressed angel with
that skinny dog sniffing her feet. Two women together in a loft on
Lower Broadway, tea bags soggy in their mugs, not art history with
slides and a term-paper answer—Louise had cited Panofsky—to
demonstrate that reason is defeated by imagination, or was it the
other way round? In Melancholia, that is, not the insoluble
history of this afternoon’s tale.
And how my father disliked the order of that
garden, its geometric paths, labyrinth that tricked no one. He had
been, in his youth, a mathematician. But Sylvie took that no
further, returned to Inga working better millinery at Saks to pay
for their rented room before she assumed her glamorous refugee
disguise.
Inga, the farm girl with the stench of goats and
sheep still in her nostrils, was not much for nature, and not much
for pouring tea. Did she long for the shops and cafés of Vienna?
For the operettas and balls she presumed as her marriage portion?
Surely she had bargained for more than a husband who closed the
door to his study to read journals written in a language of numbers
and signs. The city on the river Inn no longer honored Ulrich
Neisswonger. His mines had been appropriated by the state, though
once he had walked with his daughter to the Silver Chapel, not with
Inga or Otto, just the two of them, an occasion so rare. It seemed
strange even then, walking through the old town, her father in his
British tweeds worn each day, now that he did not go to his office.
He tipped his Tirolerhut at merchants and bowed to a lady in
mourning along the way. Yet so informal with his daughter in tow,
the many smiles of that morning, Guten Tag. When he pulled
back the leather curtain at the door of the church—not the church
Inga took his children to on Sunday while he read of problems in
his mathematical journal—the altar shone upon them, a girl and her
father not come to pray. From our Alpine mines, he said
proudly, all of the silver latticework on the high altar before
them gleaming with Christ and triumphant signs of the zodiac.
Sylvie looked long at the prettiest figure, Virgo, the month when
she was born.
We were tourists in our very own city, that’s
what I believed, that he took me as a treat, a special day for his
girl. But that was not so. Or I believe his taking me along may
have given my father an ounce of protection. We seemed to be
waiting, just waiting, and then a priest came from the darkness
behind the silver altar. It was planned, you see, this meeting, and
my father took papers out of his leather pouch, the bloodproof bag
he carried when hunting. They spoke French, a language I had only
begun to study in school. Still, they turned from me, and for a
long while they spoke together. Then the priest, old, very old with
creases all round his dim eyes and purple spots on his hands, put
the papers in the folds of his cassock. He went back into the
shadows he came from, and my father said I should look at the crab
on the altar, how perfectly the scaly ridges were formed, and that
he, Ulrich Neisswonger, was a Scorpio, which meant he kept secrets,
did I understand?
But I never found those secrets, only guessed
them from movies, from novels. I know he was angry at the Cardinal,
who ordered the Nazi flag to fly over the chapel, and that I wore a
dirndl that day, costumed for a dark plot, not Sound of
Music.
A story told when she traveled to the loft to help
out with Cyril sleeping in that wooden cradle, the possession of
all those Waites on their hill in Connecticut. It was the one thing
she appropriated from their store of useful Yankee things. Now
Cyril was in school, and when it came cradle time for Maisy . . .
she recalls the apologetic sigh when Louise returned it, beautiful
certainly, no longer useful. Maisy lay in a padded Moses basket
woven of plastic straw, an ingenious contraption with many pockets,
zippers, and handles to haul her about. Louise had carried the
cradle down to Sylvie’s Jeep, parked illegally on Lower Broadway. A
packing-up day, the time of the Freemans’ move uptown to be near
the University so that Artie might go on with his studies, his note
of purpose redressing his truant past. On the day Sylvie told of
her childhood home in the Tyrol, she did not give the full tour of
her father’s study. Louise was invited to view the map of the
Hapsburg Empire well in decline, but her guide left out the
mathematical journals neatly stacked by her father’s reading chair.
To touch even their pale blue covers was strictly verboten by order
of the silver-mine master who turned through their problems at
night. The cradle was returned to its proper station by the
fireplace in Connecticut, an artifact for a phantom child.
Now Sylvie walks the aisles of the plane as
instructed by Bob Waite. So march she does up to the blue curtain
denying her entry to the superior classes. She takes in her fellow
passengers sleeping or enduring this time out of time. Seat-belt
signs on, she lurches through turbulence, gives way to the moment
of fear that Bob Waite laughed at, then delivered the stats proving
safety in flight. Jed has stowed his computer, put up the small
screen with the plane consuming the red line through eastern
Pennsylvania, where a flight on its way to destination
unknown—White House? Camp David?—met its fate. Bob had died well
before that terrible day, his statistics never figuring hijacks or
security fuss at airports. Mein lieber. She had lived under
his protection, a stranger in the national landmark of his house,
his history of good family with names of teachers, bankers,
ministers recorded in the Waite Bible never consulted, their worth,
worthiness—Wert, erhaben haunting the purity of Federal
rooms. The stale breath of humankind is heavy in the cabin. After
her marriage Sylvie flew first class to visit her mother in one
extravagant new house or another, improbable as pictures in slick
magazines. Inga Meyer, channeling Ingrid Bergman with a touch of
Zsa Zsa Gabor, had made her fortune by way of husbands. The silver
mine, a brave if failed start; then on to the rewards of Hollywood
and Texas—movies, born again oil—a true American story. The Baroque
mansion in Houston, where she finally came to rest, was fitted out
in Secessionist glamour, Austrian bentwood chairs, a mantel clock
(Adolf Loos) that flung the minutes away with a sleek brass
pendulum, all said to be like if not the very treasures confiscated
from the villa. The depressing Dürer woodcuts were banished from
Inga’s story. The dining room in River Oaks displayed George
Grosz’s decadent posturing, while her daughter, the prim
translator, cut into a bloody steak.
Louise laughed, An improvement over The
Crucifixion? She was, let’s recall, an artist, or had been
when she first met Sylvie. Something wistful about her quick
judgment, the pleasure she took dwelling on Grosz’s dark romance,
the arrogance of many self-portraits.
And pricey Paul Klees. My mother’s claim to a
life never lived in the Tyrol.
Sylvie’s account depends on doubtful stories told
by Inga. As a student, late nights in the Public Library would
never reveal that her father was called Herr Professor, a title he
sharply rejected as he did the von. He came back to Innsbruck from
his studies to run the family silver mines, and there Inga was, a
village girl with aspirations. The mines’ picture-book village sat
at the bottom of a valley below the Neisswongers’ hunting lodge,
and at every turn there was Inga radiantly pious at Sunday Mass,
flirtatious in the tavern where she washed up the steins, his with
the family crest, eagle rampant. He came upon her each day on the
path going down into the village, or at the bend in the one narrow
street. She seemed always to be in his way that first season. He
was reviewing the accounts, learning to manage the workers in the
mine. This lovely girl’s smile distracted him from the reality that
times were already bad, quite bad, that he may never go back to the
University, listen to the arguments of his scientific betters. Inga
had been once to Innsbruck with her confraternity for a
procession—Immaculate Conception, Epiphany? The feast day was
movable when Inga told of her meeting young Neisswonger on such an
excursion. And wasn’t he surprised to see her in town looking
smarter in her loden jacket than any village girl? Her “professor”
became more than he ever could be, her Ulrich, who published one
paper discrediting the uncertainty principle in a popular
scientific journal. Why would Sylvie, a child transported to New
York, not believe in this legend, yet still believe that her father
followed the news of the brilliant men who practiced Jewish
Science, as the Reich would name it. Sylvie telling Louise the
story of her father’s great learning, his degrees, a man so
certain—isn’t that odd?—that National Socialism with its diseased
anti-Semitism, its anti-Christian program would never take hold in
Catholic Austria. In going back over her father’s
miscalculations about the fate of his country, his silence, then
his defense of the Jews, she avoided his lonely pursuit of
mathematics, knowing Louise fears that her husband might never run
the course, that Artie’s makeup exam may prove to be a layman’s
fiddling with numbers, much like her father’s.
Oh, how Papa lectured Inga and Otto that the
failed artist with the comic mustache would never . . . I was too
young to fully understand what might never in Catholic Austria. It
happened right in front of Papa’s nose.
And on another day Louise turned the page of a
coffee-table book sent years back to Sylvie, gift from Inga to her
daughter intended to enforce her tale of Bauhaus good taste. A
glamour shot of a slim crystal carafe (Otto Wagner, date uncertain)
faced off with a silver broach set with moonstones (Josef Hoffmann,
1919).
You understand I was shamed by my mother’s claim
that such objects were part of our life. I was ten years old when
we finally left the villa, escaped through the garden wall huddled
in Inga’s fur coat, the two of us linked together like kids in a
three-legged race. Kinderspiel. Martha latched to her
brother. Gerald.
Gerald?
The other Waite child, not my son.
But the story not told—one woman to another,
working girls who found their way in the big city—was of Sylvie’s
lonely investigations of the vanished life on the river Inn. She
had wanted more than a postcard world of cuckoo clocks, a lost
realm of kitsch and personal memory—Otto in lederhosen. When she
was well enough grown in New York, Inga took off, made her way out
to the émigré movie crowd in sunny California. Then Sylvie designed
a course of study outside the curriculum at Hunter College,
carefully tracing the marriages and bloody wars that redrew the
borders of Austria again and again, adding and subtracting Venetia,
Dalmatia, Lombardy, Bohemia. Her father had turned the page in his
atlas back to the Holy Roman Empire. Poor Papa: the borders he
finally believed in were erased. His repeated claims for the honor
of Catholic Austria now seemed more than an annoyance to his
daughter, more than a scratch in the record of his wife’s favorite
Strauss waltz stuck in three-quarter time. It was far too late when
he changed his tune. That is what she presumed, too late defending
the Jewish bankers, and Rosen, who sat on a high stool over his
ledgers, green shade sheltering his eyes as he once figured the
ounces of silver mined by the elder von. The mines now property of
the Reich. She further imagined that her father spoke up for his
teachers at the University who were relieved of their posts, that
he defended his café companions not practicing Aryan science. Now
he became the elder; the line had run out save for his son, Otto,
and why, she would ask, taking notes in the Reading Room of the New
York Public Library, why turn through pages and pages of the
Nuremberg Trials, the verdict clear as to crimes against humanity,
but with no hope of the answer? Why take a boy? A miscalculation
from hell, his name set down with his father’s, by a simpleton
following rules? Simple is evil, is death by paperwork, damnation
filed away. By the year Papa Neisswonger’s daughter graduated with
honors from a city college in New York, the map he honored, give or
take a slice of northern Italy, was in place once again. But his
lectern by the study window was no longer in her dreams.
She had taken to the books. March 12, 1938, the
date on which Austria was annexed by the Reich. The players who led
to Austria’s downfall—Chancellors Dolfuss, Schuschnigg, the German
ambassador, Papen—could not answer her question: when did Papa wake
to the nightmare of Catholic compliance? Did he speak against the
very prelate who laughed at his Dürer story? They ordered him to
work his mines for their benefit two years before the
Polizei led him out the front door with his son. The camp
where she presumed her father and brother were taken was enlarged
early, December of ’39. She worked on in the library at 42nd Street
until the lights dimmed, then took the subway uptown to a rented
room, the maid’s room in a big drafty apartment. The accounts of
the war were not sorted into the arguments and fables of history.
She discovered a portrait, Marie Elizabeth of Austria, radiant
child who, disfigured by smallpox, became an abbess, d. Innsbruck,
1808; Emperor Ferdinand I required a yellow patch to be worn by all
Jews, 1551. Protestants denied citizenship, their lives endangered
with the punishment of heresy, 1527, according to Catholic state
law.
Searching for a family story, Sylvie copied down
notes in her neat hand: the operation of silver mines, Hapsburg
political marriages, the Vienna Boys’ Choir (est. 1498, held in
contempt by Otto, an athletic boy). Her ledger was thick as a
poultice to sooth the pain of her father’s fate. Had she really
expected to discover a record of that meeting in the Silver Chapel,
the nature of the documents passed to the old priest? The chapel
with the luminous silver altar was carefully preserved in
memory. She went to mass every Sunday, obedient to her
father’s political belief. There came one night when she discovered
that titles were passed out liberally by the Hapsburgs long before
they settled into their palace in Innsbruck. Best not pass that
item to Inga, or that von, often a mere honorific, was now
prohibited by the Austrian government.
Want these books put aside?
She had turned back three volumes on the Treaty of
Versailles and a rant claiming Hitler was indebted to Nietzsche,
and to Descartes’s Meditations in which the philosopher
questions if we can ever come up with the answers. Bright Sylvie
said clearly—No thank you. She walked the long block to
Broadway, took the bus uptown. A couple with theater programs,
flirting madly, just out of a show, or perhaps, in the heat of
desire, they’d left during intermission. Cut out to make out at
home. Well, her home was that narrow maid’s room in the apartment
of an old refugee couple. Each week, she paid twenty dollars in
cash, passing an envelope to them before sunset on the Sabbath.
They had little to say to their boarder with a cross on her neck in
search of a family story, reading history to solve yesterday’s
crimes when any day she might see that Solomon’s watchband did not
fully conceal the numbers on his wrist. Inga had discovered their
vacant maid’s room through a friend of a classy friend, then gone
off to California, where yet another friend dealt her secretarial
work for swank émigrés. Later Sylvie would understand that she took
a page from her mother’s book, Inga writing her own script, a quick
read that instructed: get on with your life.
Wo, o wo ist der Ort—ich trag ihn im
Herzen—,
wo sie noch lange nicht konnten, noch von einander
wo sie noch lange nicht konnten, noch von einander
Study your languages, pass the exam to
translate.
Oh where is the place—I carry it in my
heart—,
where they still were far from mastery, still fell apart
from each other, like mating cattle that someone
has badly paired;—
where they still were far from mastery, still fell apart
from each other, like mating cattle that someone
has badly paired;—
The UN was plain and sturdy, no mirror tricks of
Versailles. No more fiddling with lines of Rilke, better treaties
securing the here and now. Her inner ear could not connect with the
poet’s feeling. It was a sort of deafness that plagued her, more
troubling than the deafness that would come upon her late in
life.
The altar of the Silver Chapel with its shimmering
zodiac was not revealed to Louise on the day she flipped the pages
of an extravagant book, a storybook really: how superb the Austrian
designers before the First World War at the modernist game, how
their artifacts—beautifully photographed—vases, candlesticks, gems
worked into silver, each crafted with the vision of the maker upon
it—predicted a future unburdened with the sodden bourgeois
trappings of the past.
The villa, you see, was as my father must have
it, as it had always been in his time. Biedermeier curves of each
sofa, his ashwood desk. My room of the spoiling was kitsch,
Tyrolean cute. He had no anger against his privilege or trappings
of his class, not a dollop of sour schlag. Not a worthless
Austrian mark. Turning now to the page with: Silver clip in
the form of a maple leaf for a fräulein’s hair, and: a slim
Wiener Werkstätte mirror. Unburdened with a view of the
past. Meine Mutter so clever—refurnishing memory. How we do
live the life set forth by our tables and chairs.
Sylvia Waite is on her way to JFK, then on to the
white house on a hill in Connecticut. Her late husband, an airline
executive, had been a pilot in the war—their war, she calls it. He
led his squadron of Spitfires halfway to Dresden. Then we turned
back.
Turned back?
We had only enough fuel to escort the bombers
off on their mission. Escort them through dog fights. I lost half
my squadron one night. Bob Waite gave no personal details,
which she found troubling, the way the firebombing of a city could
be no more than an order carried out. It’s all in the books,
he said.
In time she came to believe in her husband’s
reserve, though answers she sought were not in the books. She had
married something of a hero, a widower with a ready-made family,
enjoyed his gentleness in the old bed with creaking wooden slats.
Passion would not come until she met Cyril O’Connor, shared a cab
on a rainy day at the UN. Cyril had served in the Korean Conflict.
Their emotional extravagance might have been shot as a war
movie—lovers on Waterloo Bridge, tearful parting. They
returned to their dutiful married lives until Sylvie, of all the
unimaginable things, came back into his life. The sleeping
prince—ailing eyesight, sparse white hair—was kissed back to life.
Not her boldest move; that would always be the flight through the
garden wall with Mommi. Still, finding their loved ones had
passed, she took a chance that in matters of the heart there might
be a second chance duty-free. Now their caresses were tender, the
way kids courted a millennium ago. Sylvie runs the story off. Her
visions—the love of her men in varying degrees. Of her father who
she mourns in the full knowledge of his folly.
Soon after they met, Bob Waite took Sylvie to his
house listed as a historic treasure. She raised his kids, lives on
there in comfort though carpenter ants are back at their mischief.
It is not truly her house: never can be. Wer jetzt kein Haus
hat, baut sich keines mehr. Translate to the language you live
in. Whoever has no house now, will never have one. How her
beautiful mother of the grun-grau eyes came to quote Rilke
with ease though she had no education to speak of. But that was in
California, where Inga took tea with Thomas Mann, did more than
frolic with Peter Lorre by the pool. Then Inga Meyer, moving on,
was married to Billy Ray Boots by a Baptist minister in Houston and
must be put to rest with many artifacts of genuine beauty, forgiven
at last by her daughter. Wer jetzt allein ist . . .
Translate: Whoever is alone will stay alone.
As they prepare for descent, Jed tells all, fesses
up. He’s not on his way home to the baby girl on the laptop screen.
Going to visit the teenage boy he left behind. Sylvie, pert with an
encouraging smile, yes, the fairy god-mother with a halo of white
hair, is comfortable hearing his familiar story of ambition gone
wrong, midlife crisis, the office affair. She has listened
carefully to the security guards at Martha’s Institute, how one
Perez son is premed, the other hijacks cars. Lola visits him in
prison. Bonfilio must keep at the course in bookkeeping to get on
with his life. His heart is invested in tango. Weekends he
competes. Mrs. Waite has seen the head shot, hair slicked, throat
gleaming with sweat in the passion of the dance. Jed has no picture
of his boy left behind—a moody dropout, will not welcome this visit
from his father. Below the clouds now, ordered to turn off all
electronic equipment. Jed back to business. His personal story now
seems impersonal. Sylvie recalls the name of the actor he
resembles, a sentimental fool in old movies, eyes tearing up, the
flesh wobbling on his moon face. Jed cutting her off, scribbling
numbers on a scratch pad, reminds her of Gerald Waite, never her
son. She feels the flight has been a waste of her seatmate’s time,
not finishing his thriller, chatting up an old lady, movie out of
mind before the credits run. Perhaps it will never come right,
these awkward visits with his son. Gerald Waite has written himself
out of his stepmother’s life, that little prince of his private
school who never took to Sylvie. Each year on the Christmas card,
he covets the Rhode Island highboy, though inappropriate for his
high-rise in Hong Kong. Gerald is corporate, self-posted to
Asia.
Martha put it simply: Gerald needs money the way
we need air. The whole nine yards. You know the
expression?
I know it. Gerald needs more than his
father’s considerable salary, more than his grandfather’s take from
a distinguished legal practice in the city.
The little plane has nibbled to the very end of its
trail on the screen. Pressure pops in her ears, and for a moment
Sylvie’s hearing seems restored, that same baby crying above the
pilot’s landing instructions—advice for descent, Bob called
it.
Offering a stiff apology, Jed’s jowls quiver.
Sorry for the personal stuff, laying it on.
Not at all, carry-on baggage.
Returned to the strained silence of her deafness,
she thinks this is what we have, perhaps it is all—the telling,
telling each other our stories. In the quarter hour that remains,
she sets her watch to Eastern Daylight Time, flips pages in the
airline magazine that offers, for a price, comforts never imagined:
a robot vacuum, an electric corkscrew and a miniature trident, the
three prongs of Neptune’s weapon to spear lint. Lint? Your
clothes dryer may be clogged. Are you aware of this danger? Now
the darkening sky wavers through Sylvie’s tears. It is too foolish,
this fear of fluff, yet she finds it so sad, the claims of this
product offering a life free of weightless debris. She remembers he
was called Cuddles, the Hungarian actor who made you laugh when you
should have cried. The plane is waiting for a runway, circling the
city. She sites the Triborough, Ran dall’s Island, buildings along
the East River—the towers of New York Hospital, the brick of old
Bellevue and in between the UN, where she worked as a young woman,
a translator double-speaking the principles and arguments of
international agreement. In that upended matchbox of hope, she met
both her husband and her lover. She can’t remember which committee
Cyril, still in uniform, reported to, but she was translating areas
of dispute between French and German fisheries. She must tell
Martha: the commission was called Law of the Sea.
The neighbors have turned on the porch light, left
the door off the latch. The mail of the last two weeks lies in the
Chinese export platter on the hall table—catalogs pushing Christmas
before the first frost, Doctors Without Borders, Coalition for the
Homeless and Peace Folk, as Louise calls the many organizations
begging money, as well they should, given the headlines Sylvie
glanced wheeling her suitcase through the airport. FAMINE,
GUANTÁNAMO TORTURE. DEATH TOLL RELEASED.
She is suddenly bone tired, speaks the
phrase aloud to the heavy silence of the house. Now, what does
that mean? It’s the spirit that’s tired; still, she must call
the neighbors who doused the plants to death, thank them for their
kindness. They have turned up the thermostat, set her tea mug next
to the electric kettle, propped up a card of a smiley
cat—Welcome! Sylvie sits by the fireplace where the Waite
cradle resumed its proper place. A pale patch on the floor reveals
where the Connecticut clock stood for nearly two hundred years, a
grandfather clock that now ticks its inaccuracies in California.
Alas, the finials have been taken off to accommodate the low
ceiling in Martha’s cottage. Gerald Waite, the banker still
building his firm’s business in Hong Kong, is the only one who
gives a damn about the antiques, in particular their value. Last
Christmas card went beyond the highboy to the Pilgrim hutch and
Dun-can Phyfe chairs. In a frivolous moment Sylvie sent Gerald the
Canton punch bowl, never heard if it arrived back home in one
piece. She’d as soon ship him every spindle and scrap, the sampler
ill stitched by some long-forgotten girl, the coverlet sturdy as
the day it was woven pre- Jacquard loom. Her very life is
overfurnished. Alone in the house, deafness her companion, she
listens to herself through worn bone. Well, there is not much flesh
on her though the limbs are sturdy; didn’t she make it uphill with
a spring in her step, up from the parking lot to Perez and
Bonfilio, to their courtesy each day? Now she must call Louise. She
gets Artie. Maisy is ill again. Each night plagued with that cough.
His voice—low-pitched, solemn.
Sylvie in a whisper: Tomorrow I will drive into
the city. I should never have gone away.
She prepares a tray of white toast and tea. For the
first time, the stairs are not easy. She sets the tray on the
lowboy next to the pencil-post bed. Oh, it has a verified date,
this uncomfortable bed where she slept beside her late husband and
with her lover, Cyril O’Connor. The call to Martha’s A-drive is not
forgotten.
I’m in the lab, Martha says, making up
for lost time. She does not say time lost with Sylvie’s visit,
their weekend jaunts up to the mission in Santa Barbara, down to
the Baja Peninsula. Martha is working on a pet project, classifying
sea cucumbers that thrive in a frigid canyon deep down in the
sea.
Sylvie says, Well, it’s cold here, too. The
leaves are turning.
Remember? Martha asks. Home again, home
again, jiggity jig.
The last line of a ditty she chanted to the Waite
children when they came from the beach in wet bathing suits, sand
in their shoes. They were beyond such nursery jingles, but what did
she know?
Yes, she remembers. Home again, home again, all
in a day.
BUG BOX
And so Gregor did not leave the floor, for he
feared that his father might take as a piece of peculiar wickedness
any excursion of his over the walls or the ceiling.
—Franz Kafka, The Metamorphosis
On Riverside Drive the wind whips up from the
Hudson. Artie takes his son’s hand. First real Fall
day!
His exuberant words blow away. The boy looks
puzzled. Dad walking on air? They are both on their way to school:
that’s Cyril’s delight. His father will leave him off, go on to his
classroom, where he writes numbers and squirrelly letters on the
blackboard. His father has homework most nights. Sometimes Cyril
pretends he has homework. Last night he wrote his name on his
backpack, wrote it all out—Cyril Moffett Freeman, a name like no
other kid at his school. Cyril is the name he comes by from the
grandfather who is dead. His father had no father. He was not
supposed to know that. When he asked, his mother said, You’re
ours. Well, of course. What did that have to do with the man
who disappeared off the face of the earth? Moffett was in there
because his mother must not leave out her parents in Wisconsin.
They lived on a farm he visited every year of his life. That
grandfather had almost no hair and a loud voice like a man his
parents watched every night on the news. Too loud when he came to
New York, showed a movie at school telling about the rows and rows
of cows hooked up to his milking machines. A calf sucked milk from
its mother’s udder. Direct Delivery, his grandfather said,
laughing in case you didn’t get it. Milk was pumped into a big
steel tanker to travel to the next machine, boil it up and ship it
to market. He knew more than anyone in his class about pasteurizing
when Grandfather Moffett ladled milk from a can for every teacher
and student. The farm was cleaner than anything in New York City,
so Grandpa said. He taught dairy. That was just weeks ago when
Professor Moffett passed out ice cream cups for the whole lower
school. For some days Cyril was made much of, then taunted by older
kids—Cyril 2%, Fat Free. Well, he was skinny, and besides,
his teacher, after a conference with his mother, advanced him to
reading and math with the second grade. It was still early in the
school year, and one day he broke from his class line after recess,
to watch a chess game, to advise a third-grader how a pawn could
block a bishop. Before he fully understood the kid’s mockery, much
mooing was what he put up with. Now the best part of the day was
walking hand in hand with his father.
There’s a kid wearing a black mask on the steps
leading up to school, sweater tied round his neck for a cape.
Captain Marvel, looks like maybe he’s got a sore throat. Now that
his father sees the black mask, he goes on about the calendar, how
we should respect it, not let the merchants take over. By merchants
he means all the shops on Broadway with plastic pumpkins and ghosts
in the windows, and all the creepy ads on TV.
A full week till Halloween. Why blow it before
the real day?
Five nights, Cyril corrects his father. It
will be night when he goes out to spook the world. He is going to
be a beetle, in fact. Today he has a ladybug in with his snack and
a note to the teacher. The note says that they, the
Moffett-Freemans, may be moving away within the school year, so
save all records as to his progress to be transferred. Cyril had
tipped a beetle into his bug box when they were in Connecticut
looking at property. It was already dead on the doorsill of a dusty
house where someone had died (not supposed to know that), just
tipped it with a touch of his pinkie into the plastic box, which
has a magnifying glass set into the lid so the bug looks larger
than life, a monster black beetle with sharp horns. The hard wing
case is unbroken. Too bad he never saw it fly and might not see a
live one now that there’s frost, his mother says, but when they
visited Sylvie in her old house, she showed him a chair which had
been eaten by beetles, little holes in the wood.
Tells you how very old, she said. Please,
not to sit in that chair.
Which made sense, because the beetles could still
be in there chomp ing. He plans to be the black beetle in his box.
His mother must make horns out of cardboard, but he has not figured
the carapace, how it must cover his wings, how he can scare the
kids at school and still carry a bug looking bucket, a nest or hive
for the treats the merchants sell.
He’s Artie to his students, often theatrical, over
the top today. They have finished the problem in linear algebra
according to plan, but he does not plod on with the syllabus.
Today your teacher will turn back the
clocks. Turn to his antic self, more likely, to Freeman who got
kicked out of Yale for posting answers to the difficult calculus
exam on primitive e-mail. Because it is the process, he
wrote back then, not the answer. The rush is working it out.
No longer a smart-ass, just wanting to say to these engineering,
business majors, tech-masters-to-be, that they must take care with
time. In a short time, the up-and-coming time of this November,
Congress has decreed that they will walk to class in the dark. They
will play, let’s say Frisbee, an educated guess, in daylight saved
for that purpose. He hops to the blackboard, the old miscreant
Artie, to begin his lecture that has nothing to do with the job
market, the one which is suddenly less healthy, the market he’s in,
though how could they guess from this acrobatic instruction that
leaps from Daylight Saving Time back to long shadows cast at Stone
henge to the Aztec calendar and the Julian, to leap year and the
missing half minute of time, to Mark Twain who marked time in a
paddleboat on the Mississippi? When he doles out Heisenberg, he
gets a groan from the sharpest girl, the loveliest, who never lets
him walk her home when she baby-sits the kids: We cannot know,
as a matter of principle, the present in all its details.
I’m down the rabbit hole late, late for a very important date,
stop-watch and all. I come to rest, ladies and gentlemen, at the
commercial countdown to Halloween, to the politics of time, the
principle being that we have one more hour of sunlight to stop at
the mall, so Congress has decreed. Meanwhile the alarm clock, do we
use them anymore? But time being personal, I will hold you no
longer. There’s a war on. It is evening in Baghdad. As a matter of
principle, we wait in the dark for the morning news.
Late-night comic spinning off script, or a karaoke
assault on the captive audience, he bops on to the abuse of
constitutional powers, Bible study in the White House, or just
another peace rally, war protest, one of how many? Their teacher
ranting, bringing it down, the uncomfortable day-to-day problems
they must either solve or leave unanswered in all their details.
Artie, in self-destruct, is running late. They look at the time on
their cells. What’s the next assignment? Patient, amused at his
apology, which they accept as no apology at all. Class
dismissed.
In the cavernous hall below, Artie is faced with
Gottschalk having a good laugh, a hearty rumble off the old tile
walls. He’d thought our leader never laughed, just meted out
sourballs to children with the indulgent smile. Gott, waylaying him
at the door of his office, I see that you were amusing in class
today.
Artie reckons the half minute it takes to run down
the spiral staircase. Telepathy?
Texting. It did give me a laugh, a student
sending your tangent. You’ve been critical—pause for mock
harrumph—of my insistence upon pencil and paper. It’s too easy
to take answers off the screen, post them, send them about, as a
miscreant just now broadcast your performance. We had to figure, in
my day. In my day, the answer was inked on the palm of the
culprit’s hand. In any case, an enjoyable excursion. Time, you old
gypsy—
Artie dare not look at his watch. The hands of the
old clock affixed to the wall are stopped in Western Union Time,
five-fifteen of a day or night long gone.
In my day goes on with good humor; then
Ernst Gottschalk strikes a serious note. In that moment Arthur
Freeman understands that his leader, grudging as ever with his
slant smile, will deal him another chance to pick himself up, brush
himself off as in his grandmother’s hope invested in God and Fred
Astaire. Gott—it’s only a spec—has a job up his sleeve. Artie must
remember to tell Lou that this kindest of men was wearing a mixed
message, bush jacket and cargo pants, perhaps working his sartorial
way toward Halloween.
He’s late to pick up Cyril, the last child in the
bright kindergarten room. The harvest is in place, cornstalks and
pumpkins, humongous gourds. Cyril is counting, slow and steady, to
a thousand.
Mrs. Goldberg tells Mr. Freeman once again, He
does this to see how far he gets until you arrive. She does not
say, Late as you often are.
Artie damns his performance, time lost in
Mathematics Hall.
Seven hundred twenty-five, seven hundred
twenty-six, twenty-seven . . .
Sorry Mrs. G.
No need to be sorry. Not closing the
shop.
Course not. She tidies up after the children the
many days he’s been late, never as late as seven hundred and
twenty-eight. She gathers the scraps of construction paper,
collects the blunt scissors, clamps the paste pot left open. She’s
a pro—brisk, not motherly, a comfort to the children in her care.
In the world of her room, each child’s name is spelled out in
capital letters, numbers envisioned as red apples and golden pears.
Amusements blend into Mrs. G’s lessons as she tracks the daily
progress of every child, so particular in its triumphs and
failures.
Such a bright boy, I am sorry you’re moving
away.
Spoken clearly, it comes as a shock to him. Not
really. They have nearly settled on a house in Connecticut not far
from where he lived as a small boy before his mother drowned in
that boating accident, before he preserved her in legend, her
mahogany hair without a streak of silver, her voice uncertain in
song, folksy strumming.
Mrs. G going on about Cyril, her brightest student
in years, how the Freemans must be careful with their gifted
boy.
Pacing himself now—seven hundred and
thirty-five.
Oh, come off it, his father says.
On the way home, it’s not OK. His father doesn’t
reach for his hand at the crossing. Cyril digs in his backpack for
the bug box. How much bigger does the magnifier make my
beetle?
His father is somewhere else. Hard to
tell.
Late to pick him up at school not surprising, but
the brush-off Cyril will remember, the chill of his father’s
silence as they headed round the corner to Riverside Drive. His
fear that he must not say it: Seven hundred and
thirty-six.
Beetle was the best, better than the fright wig of
mad scientist last year. A pizza pan painted by his mother became
his rusty black shell, jaws and legs black, belly of bubble wrap,
Ping-Pong balls bulged with the many facets of insect eyes. The
Beetle won “Most Original.” He carried a trick-or-treat hive, brown
paper totally incorrect. Spider-Man, “Most Popular,” was everywhere
in school, on Broadway, on the block, nothing like a spider, just a
costume merchants sold in the shops. His mother soothing: Comics
trump Insects for Girls and Boys. Cyril had better get used to
that. He tore the antenna from his head. Late enough now to be
dark. He dodged between taxis honking, braking with a screech. In
Riverside Park, he burrowed down between rocks, sucked three Milky
Ways before his father found him, a dung beetle weeping chocolate
from his sticky mouth.
FAMILY TREE
Louise makes ginger tea, splits a bagel with
Sylvie. Mother and daughter scene, but they are nothing to each
other. Their odd circumstantial connection prompts Louise Moffett
to draw a tree as she listens once again to Sylvie’s adventures in
California, great tacos in Santa Barbara, Bonfilio stomping his
solo on the steps of the Institute, Martha’s softness this year,
never too late for the girlish gleam in her eye, heavy equipment
fellow on the plane. Drawing: Louise is drawing on the newsprint
pad that belongs to her boy, says his name in bold caps. She has
flipped past Cyril’s airplanes, rockets, a spaceship to Mars, finds
a blank page. Maisy sleeps on the couch. Sylvie, head bobbing,
trails off in midsen tence. She was saying about a cave under the
sea, how like a story she read to the children, Waite’s children.
She never suspected that the caves in the story might be real. Now
Martha may go down many leagues to measure a dark pit with her
mentor. Sylvie repeats her stories. Her sentences lose words, but
today Martha’s sea adventure comes with a fable for children.
The charcoal pencil feels strange in Lou’s hand,
but the tricks of dimension and line—the smudge and shading
reliable. The sketch comes along. It’s a tree. Not a tree she might
bring into focus when sighting a bird. Those trees she observes in
detail, each node, crook of a limb to harbor a nest, bark broken
where woodpeckers dig for their grub. This tree is puffy and
perfectly round, a simplified picture-book tree. She believes she
is drawing it for Sylvie, who must insist once again that Martha
and Gerald are not her children. Louise has seen their photos
displayed on a sideboard, sturdy girl in cap and gown,
conventionally handsome boy, blazer and school tie. She writes
Family Tree on top of the page, big page so a kid can draw
freely. When the tree is finished, she inscribes a bold line under
it, writes the names of Ulrich von Neisswonger and his wife, Inga,
from which dangle Sylvia and Otto. Then Sylvie affixed to Bob Waite
(deceased), from which, on a slant, Martha and Gerald, from Gerald
a wife and two children unnamed, a second offshoot from Sylvia to
Cyril O’Connor (deceased), from which Fiona with mate unknown, the
begetter of Arthur Freeman, impossible to place as a piece of white
cloud in a jigsaw puzzle, from which sprouts their boy connecting
to Louise Moffett, from which Cyril and Maisy with side line to Pop
Moffett and Shirley out there in Wisconsin, to her brothers so
often deleted and a firm sidebar to Pop’s sister, Aunt Bea. Now the
tree which spreads above must have leaves, and caught in the crotch
of the branches, a corporate jet, powerful as Bob Waite might will
it, then Fiona’s pleasure boat, the death vehicle, upended in
turbulent waves. $$$ fluttering for both Gerald and Inga, and why
not the stockbroker, Cyril? A moo cow for her father and an
equation—here the artist is out on a limb—a problem, might have
been solved by the von or by Artie, two guys who share the math
gene. The cheap newsprint does not take to fine lines, but she must
have the speckled ruff of a wise owl, as though she could go back
to her bird, the one she drew as a girl, the owl that won her first
prize. She has left out, quite by accident, Artie’s sainted
grandmother, Mae.
Lou turns the page. With a stroke she gets Maisy
wheezing in perfect peace, lips slightly parted, the gentle curve
of her cheek, the scramble of pale curls. Gets the humpback of the
old couch, the stick figure of Sylvie in her proper gray suit,
mouth slack as in death, as though words might not come again. Lou,
alone with these sleepers, feels she’s never been so alive, not
even on the bus she flagged down to leave the farm, not even in her
first studio apartment in this city. Back then she was fearless,
her intentional distortions sharper than binocular blowups, than
the camera’s eye. Alone with pencil on paper, she sweeps a line
cross page, pure pleasure. She’s forgotten her work’s
satisfactions. Call it art, the intentional smudge, lump of clay,
streak of acrylic. Making something out of nothing.
Was I saying about the cave? Sylvie’s voice
a soft whisper. I am not sure what Martha . . . now she
speaks up . . . what they are looking for, Martha and her
mentor, but in the story, a man is kept in a cave under the
sea. Eine Fabel, a spell, you see. This drunkard, not worthy
of the King’s daughter.
Maisy smiles at some turn of events in a
dream.
I changed the story for the children. That I
remember. He smelled of dead fish, but when the spell broke, the
princess married him. His eyes crusted with salt, her wedding
dress, seaweed. I was saying about Martha and her friend exploring
caves under the sea. I’d never tell them the bitter end as it was
written.
Seems right. Lou closes the pad. We do
tend to make nice. The family tree intended for Sylvie now
seems sentimental. So she takes the hard path, says what she must
finally say. On this day Louise announces they are leaving the
city. I wish it could be different.
Sylvie touches a trembling hand to the useful aids
in her ears, first one, then the other. I know about moving
on.
I think you invented it.
No, that would be my mother, the beautiful
Inga.
Lou has never quite believed the legend of that
woman’s beauty, sees only the silver delicacy of Sylvie’s old age.
We will have a house, she says, with a shed. Cyril claims
it. Enter at your peril.
Wunderhaus.
I’ll have a barn, size of a garage, nothing like
my father’s setup in Wisconsin. A barn nevertheless with a loft, a
few stalls.
Für der Kinder?
No.
For your work, then? About time. She has
never let up urging Lou to go back to her art. And the boy?
A slip of the tongue, but so Artie Freeman was tagged when his
grandfather was alive. He has finished his studies?
He may or may not—finish.
As though just another cup of tea, a repeat of
Sylvie’s travels—the best tacos and the old Mission in Santa
Barbara, another day in which deflating birthday balloons (Maisy’s)
begin one by one by one to fall to the carpet; in which the hamster
rests beneath the wheel in his cage; in which Louise Moffett
Freeman, just another night, turns to the end of her mystery to
find out who fired the antique rifle point-blank at the Colonel,
thereby missing the pages that told her why. Why kill off the old
gentleman, so decent to his servants in Singapore?
Arthur Freeman discovers the family tree in the
trash. Though it is signed Moffett, dated this day in November, it
seems a relic of what his wife used to do, make sense of their
world in scrapbook art—here’s where we came from, some of us
intact, some children of disconnect and misfortune. The paper tears
as he hides it in the drawer of his grandfather’s desk. He will
find it again when they are about to move out of the city, when the
children have their valuables packed, Maisy’s doll of mixed race
with its infant paraphernalia, Cyril’s bugs labeled, his
butterflies pinioned under glass. For weeks the children have been
ready to go, waiting for their parents to get it together. In the
future they will have their own rooms, a backyard, a dog—think of
that. The backyard is a ruin, not cared for in years, but the
property goes back, back to a small barn, nothing like the Moffett
spread in Wisconsin.
Looking over the property, Cyril spotted a horned
caterpillar, a sphinx eating the first fresh leaves of a birch, and
a turquoise beetle not documented in Insects for Girls and
Boys. It is his last night in the bunk bed, staring at the
ceiling. He will never again hear his sister’s soft mewing in a
dream, her phlegmy cough that begins the fevers once again, though
who knows what lies ahead in the white house with a wreck of a
shed, KEEP OUT OR ELS painted on its side by a child who died in
that house. He is not supposed to know that. He will take
possession of that shed—chess table, specimen cabinet, pincers and
slides. He can see himself peering through a lens, the slight
flutter of wings as he measures the thorax of a queen bee. He
imagines a cot set up under the window facing the quiet street
where he will be allowed to ride his bike, but never gets to the
sad story of carpenter ants. If he could read the Latin words in
his book, he might know why they have eaten his shed at the
foundation. When you touch the doorframe, there at the bottom, what
looked like wood crumbles to dust. He hears his mother in the
kitchen packing dishes with gold rims, never used.
Artie Freeman has left the desk for last. The usual
records, household insurance, bank statements, marriage
certificate, last will and testament of one Cyril O’Connor, photo
of his grandmother, Mae, in a white linen dress now yellowed with
age, the tree he’d forgotten. It’s flimsy, like the list of the war
dead Lou discontinued in the kitchen. He folds the sketch of the
family tree in with past taxes, not his wife’s best work, still,
not worthy of the trash.
So—musical chairs. A game Sylvie knows. She
had, indeed, thought to move into New York, help care for those
children, though never to hover. To teach them to pray, not as she
prayed as a child, kneeling, crossing herself with belief in
Catholic Austria, just pray, or something like it, as she prayed
time would reverse itself after they ordered her father and Otto
out the front door. Not a bad thing; call it wishing, simple
enough, to wish the Alps would be snowcapped as ever, that the seas
would withdraw in their assault on the shores. She would like to
hear the crashing waves of the Pacific once more, can’t hear the
gentle waves lapping the Connecticut shore.
Moving on became clear on the day when, making her
bed, she discovered a little rip in the quilt at the center of the
big star where all the scraps of the quilter’s remnants come
together. She will patch it before she goes, leave everything in
this house museum perfect. Sell up. Move back to the city, Upper
West Side, where she first lived with Inga, studied English grammar
at night, read books meant for kids half her age. It will be the
third edit of the life she has made for Sylvia Neisswonger, a
Catholic girl of good family. She showers, puts on fresh clothes,
buttons up a warm sweater, recalling at this moment the snowflakes
on her Alpine ski sweater as the mantle of a survivor. There had
been that argument about the Jacquard loom, repetition of pattern,
something to do with Otto. That memory had lost its power. This
evening’s sweater—cold end of day—scratches at the neck and wrists,
a cheap thing bought at the mall in Stamford where, during the
winter Cyril was with her, they had gone on an errand that seemed
urgent, but the lights of the pleasure palace were further blinding
to him. Piped-in Muzak clotted her ears.
When the music stops, you must find a chair. She
will sit on a bench in Central Park with a book she always meant to
read. It concerns the triumphs and failures of the great scientists
trained at Vienna and Göttin gen, but she will not find her
father’s name among them, not even in the record of their exuberant
youth in the cafés, arguing late into the night. So best close the
book, for he may have been an everyday alchemist, extracting silver
from veins of Alpine schist. And looking up at the tree above, she
will be still when she sees the birds, for her friend has said you
see more when you look from one point, one steady view, see the
fluttering contraction of the tail as they alight—the warblers, the
hawks, old owls with aging feathers—but she will not hear their
song, natürlich. She will sign her name, Sylvia Neisswonger
Waite, in the book at Goethe House upon the occasion of the
anniversary of Bertolt Brecht’s death fifty years ago when she was
translating documents at the UN. She takes her seat in the
auditorium, is given the wireless device that will broadcast his
Jungle of Cities into her ears. Auf deutsch, no need
of the translation, yet she will hear, pretty much hear, a staged
reading in English, Brecht’s dark laughter and brutal mockery of
Hollywood despair, while dreaming back to the days when her mother
was with Meyer, a cameraman who worked with Lubitsch and Billy
Wilder. Inga, having married into that aristocracy, bronzed and
charming in yet another costume of a survivor—white linen slacks,
the striped jersey of a sailor. Living at the crest of a hill on
the Pacific Palisades, Inga had experienced vertigo looking down at
the sea. Her grandest role, serving contraband Riesling to the
likes of Thomas Mann. Mutter living it up with this
distinguished crew, her day in the sun. Sylvie, her girl now on
Fifth Avenue listening to Brecht’s jovial despair, one old lady
among an audience of mostly students brought to this improving
event. They laugh in the wrong places. But will you still be
here when we come back? Would the play-wright have been amused?
Could they imagine the audience eager for his work fifty years ago,
for the political passion of his theater? Or might they learn it?
Perhaps today they will be startled into listening, really
listening, when the shot goes off in his cultural jungle, though it
is only a play with gangland debauchery, a simple parable compared
to the Götterdämmer ung of nightly TV. Frau Waite will straighten
the electronic apparatus on her head; Sylvia, who remembers the
plain girl, Inga’s daughter come on a visit from her studies in New
York, remembers the scrunched little Brecht in his workman’s
jacket, his sly squint of a smile, the ash trembling at the end of
his cigar flipped onto the plate she was clearing. At home—that is,
her sparsely fitted-out apartment on Columbus Avenue—she will now
and again miss the empty house in Connecticut gone to the highest
bidder, a quick sale much like her mother’s unloading the villa on
the river Inn. The lesser pieces of Waite furniture stored for
Gerald when and if he comes back to this country, the finer pieces
auctioned at Sotheby’s. Sylvia, yearning for her language, will
take Brecht’s early work off a shelf, find Jungle of Cities
in the original. Sind Sie nock hier, wenn wir zuruckkomen?
She will read, then begin to translate with ease, as in her working
life long ago—the remnants of a family, a pretty moth eaten
family, recalling Inga’s bold strokes of survival and at last,
long last, Sylvia will admit undeniable love for her mother who she
so readily mocked, made her endurance into a skit, a poor show.
Translates: To be alone—that’s a good thing to be. The chaos has
been used up. And it was the best time. Es war die beste
Zeit.
REVISION
I never blame failure—there are too many
complicated situations in life—but I am absolutely merciless about
lack of effort.
—The Crack-Up, F. Scott Fitzgerald to his
daughter
—Fritsch, Sketchbook
That night I could not sweep my dreams into an
easy narrative. Midlife (when was that!) I learned to make sense of
these fragments, to translate my sorrows and the gold sticker of
triumph into subtitles running at the bottom of the screen. Why
so hard on yourself? he asked when we were first together, my
husband sleeping soundly beside me. What would that be like, the
sleep of the just? He’s entitled, the good man who rescues me daily
from the brink with his dose of reality, but I’m given to
self-drama—to mockery of my ambition, the little life I will soon
leave behind. That’s the subplot left out in reporting my trek in
the Park, the exhaustion as I climbed the slope up to the hippo
playground. Had I ever told myself, as I looked long at the façade
of the refurbished El Dorado, that this day might well have served
up my last adventure? Throwing off the quilt, I pad into the back
room where work confronts me—half written, half told—yet another of
my stories offering a little love, a taste of war like a sampler
box of dark chocolates, a harsh reviewer once noted, some
chewy, all bittersweet. Looking down at the bare floor littered
with postcards and yellowed clippings, curling with age—anniversary
of D-Day, uranium 235, a note on the owl, mine as I now see him,
from The Audubon Guide: Well into Autumn and Winter the big bird
perches by highways and may be sighted in parks. From a mile away,
its tufted ears pick up the faint rustle of the small creatures it
preys on.
Shuffling in the bits scattered among my own
discarded pages, I do wonder if my mother ever read that rug woven
with scraps of the past. Bill’s old tweed jacket worn only on
weekends. When he presented state’s evidence in the courtroom, it
was in three-piece suits, seat of the pants shiny with age. The
cuffs could no longer be turned. My own Spring coat of robin’s-egg
blue, a hand-me-down-from the neighbors, was cut into coarse
ribbons. The checked riding skirt, rescued from better days when my
grandfather’s workers boosted Loretta Burns up into the saddle to
ride the trails of Beardsley Park. Yet somehow the strands in the
rug came pleasantly together in my mother’s craft of making do; and
there it lay on the bedroom floor for Mimi, alias Maureen, to trip
over when she took up her post to skim Tolstoy’s novel, consigning
the Napoleonic Wars to delay of the love story, passion to settle
for domesticity, while ten thousand men had just died on the
beaches of Normandy.
Still in search of that ultimate honesty, I look
round my back room at the shelves and toppling stacks of books as
though the landscape is new to me, yet I work day after day in this
disorder, my fortress against reality. Often, as now, I get up in
the middle of the night to mark down a word, a phrase that might be
useful come morning. The streetlamp lights my way through the
litter of journals and notebooks. Next to the phone a novel, my
own, Liebestraum, love story with a slick jacket. Next to
the chair that holds the imprint of my plump body: the reading
lamp. Tonight: unfinished business. Long, too long delayed. I pick
up the book, switch on the lamp, open to an earmarked page.
Levin lifts a shattered hand to his throat where
the dog tag covers his Star of David. Against regulations. As death
takes over, he thinks how he wore it on the landing craft no safer
than a boxcar he built in the garage, that the star’s magic would
save him. Paper stars, flannel stars pasted on the Jews by the
Reich. His star is gelt, a gift from his mother. Blood
mixing with sand and grit covers the metal tags of his identity.
His mother had given him the star the day he read from Torah in the
little synagogue by the Housatonic River. All those memorized
Hebrew words and a new suit. His father drew a prayer shawl round
his shoulders, thin white wool with a fringe the Rabbi called
tzitzit. The word stuck in his teeth like the knots of the
fringe which had rules and prayers tied in them. What were the
rules? He would ask the Captain, the Captain knows everything
though he is not a Jew. He knew that the star or the cross should
not be worn with the dog tag, against regulations. The right side
of Levin’s face was hot and cold; how could that be all at once? He
would ask his father, the only pharmacist in town, or he’d know
when he studied biology in college. He had lied himself into the
army by a half year he never lived. There was noise from the
constant bombardment. There was wet from the landing. Private Levin
had lost his jaw on the right side of his face. Miriam, his tough
little sister who beat boys at kickball, cried when he made his bar
mitzvah speech on the wooden platform in the temple. He read slowly
in Hebrew to the few chosen on a Saturday morning in 1940. The
Germans had just then invaded Holland. He had explained the
parable, Ezekiel 37:15, “Then take two sticks and write upon them
and join the sticks together that they may become one in your
hand.” It is about the tribes of Israel, the boy said to the
lawyers, the shopkeepers, schoolteachers, to their families and to
Miriam, who cried tears of envy and admiration.
You gave me that scene, though your bar mitzvah was
far from Levin’s. You did not read from Scripture. All those
memorized Hebrew words and a new suit. You had signed on early
as a dedicated nonbeliever. Your gold star lives with tarnished
cuff links, pearl buttons, a Kennedy half-dollar, and the wedding
ring of my first marriage in a Florentine box bought for just such
tokens we can’t part with, can’t throw away.
Chill in her workroom. A shawl covers the back of
the reading chair. I wrap myself in it. Old lady in a flannel
nightgown, Mother Goose with her tales. Those geese, if that is
what they are, skimming about on the water with their proprietary
air. In all the years taking in the view of the city from the
Reservoir, I’ve never seen one falter in flight, never seen a dead
bird in the growth around the shore. But then, I had never seen a
soldier dying except—a big exception it seems to me this night—in
the movies back when I invented Levin’s story—the battlefield as on
D-Day littered with bodies—oldies, Red Badge of Courage, Paths
of Glory, Platoon. I was never sure how long it would take him
to die of his wounds, only that I must get on with the Captain’s
story, confident that in my scheme of things he had answers for the
boy beyond those of his own father, the trusted pharmacist in the
Berkshires. In the aftermath of that bloody invasion, Captain
Warner would find the body of the kid, which was near impossible,
and clip the chain from round Levin’s bloody neck, send the gold
star back to a drugstore on a generic Main Street in Massachusetts.
Old Mother Goose when she wanted to wander . . . My Captain
suffered superficial wounds to take him out of action, transfer him
to the army of occupation. The German of his student days was
useful, assigned Warner to reading page upon page of documents
supporting evidence that “Hitler’s Bomb” in the works, was two
years behind the Project at Los Alamos. Writing on, I had known
this much—how unlikely a leap from the slaughter of Omaha Beach to
a desk job. The Captain requested the transfer for the sake of my
story, for the curtain to go up on the opera singer in Bayreuth
he’d fallen for, lost his head completely when a student in
Leipzig, where the talk had been all uncertainty, not isolating
heavy waters that might make the bomb. The novel optioned before
the general acclaim, but Hollywood was in a brief period of
denazifica tion, one might say, coasting with gangster epics
homegrown, turned on by dazzling possibilities of special effects.
The script, rewritten—less war, more sex, bodies wrestling in the
sheets, a persistent achtung, in scenes never shot. The
soprano with flaxen hair, what was she up to after the war? Taping
whatever the Captain discovered about Nazi scientists while she
mourned the defeat of her country. Sleeping with the enemy, the
American officer who spoke with enthusiasm of Einstein’s
Relativity. Everything she learned from Warner was passed to her
German lover, a detainee with the true secrets tucked away, the
sorry information they never achieved the critical mass. Procuring
the components, could not assemble them, to become death, the
destroyer of worlds. Deutsche Science had failed. But how do
you cast a Wagnerian soprano, one that is slim with cupcake
breasts, with a delectable ass pumping smoothly as she positions
herself above her American lover? How confuse such sport with the
soaring Wagnerian score? Reads like a treatment. There was, of
course, the Captain’s all-innocence wife and two little boys in New
Jersey, a treat for the reader, dark chocolate to flavor the
tolerably happy end.
Adjusting my shawl, Mother Goose would fly
through the air on a very finegander, crone with a silver voice
spewing out words to readers who might as well be children. That’s
my thought as I flip through the book in hand. The pages are marked
with a system of elisions and stops, the better to read it time and
again, clear and loud to an audience. Shamelessly. I filch a yellow
legal pad that belongs to my husband, to write as I did before the
secondhand Remington, a black office machine with the question mark
and brackets missing. The rewrite comes quickly with scratch-outs
of deletion. In reparation I will scribble my way to a redemptive
conclusion. My handwriting, no longer schoolgirl, is illegible,
damaged by years at the computer. This night and the next, I steal
out of bed. Undoing is not daytime work—that’s the Park with its
wide-awake stories of pantomime lovers, the mathematician and his
artist wife, of an old lady born in Innsbruck, the Elysian Fields
of Frederick Law Olmsted, the chill splash of Bethesda Fountain on
a wind-whipped day. This is night work, a Penelope task, not
dreamtime, far from it. No reward, no penance. Plain personal,
though not confessional, my yellow pages must stand as my
defense.
The basement of the house in Somerset is fitted out
as a game room—dartboard, pool table, hoop set low for little kids
now grown taller than their father, desktop IBM from the Dark Ages.
On one wall the shelf with trophies from prep schools the boys
attended. The playroom runs the length of the house, which is
large. Seen from the road, we are struck by its Georgian Brick
grandeur. Look at that one, we say, preferring it over Tara or the
Renaissance Castle. Get the circular drive, the Monticello
lampposts. Yes, it’s late, the lights are timed to go off. In a
moment there will be only the dim illumination in one basement
window. Above, every room lies in darkness.
Doc Warner has come down to the game room, finding
his way through the house he has known for half a century. One son
sleeps in his boyhood room. He has scheduled his flight back to
California by way of Newark to visit his father. He thinks the old
man should sell the place, settle into a retirement community, stay
at the Harvard Club when he goes to town, town being, for Doc,
always and only New York. He has been taught to make little of his
father’s awards. Doc, he doesn’t know incus from Inca, dorsal from
dormouse, so the jokes went when he and his brother were kids.
Until recently, Doc has been an honored physicist at Bell Labs from
the early days of his work on high-speed memory to his late paper
on fractional quantum effects, his home away from home which we
might call AT&T, but he prefers the old name, the old days,
prefers to live alone in this house, his wife of many years dead,
his boys long gone to their professional lives. This visiting son
lives in Marin County. He is a pediatrician with a wife who cares
about the suffering out there in the world, with a grown daughter
currently reinventing the druggie indulgences of the Sixties. He
sleeps in this mausoleum of his parents’ marriage under the slant
ceiling of an eave, well out of the way of family life, which is
how he always liked it, far above the flowery chintz, the soothing
greens and cheerful gold that never graced the big house with the
warmth his mother yearned for. He wakes when he hears his father’s
stumbling footfalls below as Doc heads for the stairs known to be
slippery, known since his mother turned her nose up at the idea of
carpet over the beveled lip, the lovely oak rise of each step. Doc
has a knee prone to collapse, a fractured disk in his lower spine.
The real doctor knows that the banister wobbles, not sturdy as it
was when he slid down it to his mother’s annoyance. His father is
going to the rec room, an old ritual that he will honor. He will
wait till he hears Doc slapping back down the hall in his slippers,
then sleep again in his room with the premed textbooks, photos of a
trivial first love and tennis teams left far behind, nothing that
matters.
Doc Warner is still in the game . . . faint praise
for the old man when he drops in at the Labs. The elevator is no
longer where it should be, security a nuisance. Recently he
suffered the insult of a uniformed kid demanding his visitor’s
pass. He’s made it to the kitchen stooping through the low door
leading down to the playroom. Heat from the furnace, new in 1982,
is trapped, not rising this first cold night. He thinks of his son
who has delayed his trip home from a conference on attention
deficit disorder to check him out. Does the boy remember his mother
stored the extra blankets in the chest at the bottom of her bed?
His son is a proper pediatrician who can take care of himself. In
any case the old Doc’s made it down two flights of stairs to the hi
fi, a turntable hooked up to a dusty black speaker. He takes the LP
out of its sleeve with the profile of Wagner on the cover faded to
a ghostly negative, the composer facing off with a bare-breasted
Rhine maiden, her thick thighs straddling a golden horse. How
carefully he places the record on the turntable, lifts the arm with
the needle.
Here the revision reads like liner notes. . . .
Much like the broken promise to Freia, goddess of youth, love is
denied, the treasure lost, and so forth with dwarfs and the
deadly curse that doesn’t play well in the game room.
Doc’s waxy eyelids close tight as green twilight
rises in the Festspielhaus in Bayreuth just as the composer
dictated each and every aspect of the production. Then darkness,
deep slashes of the coming light. He finds his way to the chair,
the one and only taken from the back terrace, placed here for his
purpose. His purpose is to listen to Das Rheingold, to hear
the maidens’ mocking laughter . . . hei-a! hei-a! hei-a!. .
. till Freia swims upward toward the watery spill on the
rocks.
Varner, she called him, one letter short of genius,
but maybe he was a genius, the student who came from America to
study Deutsche Physik. “Secure then are we and free from
care. . . .” The flowers, the wine, the long train ride from the
University at Leipzig all paid for with his small stipend. He was
her prize, a young lover to stick like a flower behind her ear. And
when he returned to her not long after the war, it was with combat
ribbons and medals of victory pinned to his chest. He carried with
him the picture of a little boy with his mother, a common pie-faced
girl, pretty enough in an apron over a maternity frock. There is
this in his favor: the medals and ribbons were only on display when
he first went to visit his soprano still in Bayreuth. She was now
teaching, but there were few students. At night she sang in a
cabaret, cynical lyrics dodging defeat. He brought her food, not
flowers, brought her news of his discoveries, ongoing intelligence,
poor foolish man no longer a student telling her that Hitler never
had a go at the bomb, never had the magician’s pot of uranium 235,
implying the Science Volk never had the wit or the nerve,
not even the man he had studied with, the great Heisenberg. And
when the Captain went back to his work on the secrets that would
never be fully disclosed, just bandied about in biographies and
thoughty plays, Mother Goose who flew through the air on a very
fine gander, sits this night in her workroom above Central Park
turning the page while the Rhine maiden—ha . . . ha .
. . ha . . . ha—accuses he who the sway of love
for-swears. . . .