Chapter 3
I had no answer to that. Not without yelling my
own questions at her, like “Why didn’t you do something to fix this
as soon as you knew about it?” As much as I hated to pretend to be
cordial, I shook her hand so briefly that it might as well have
been the swipe of an angry cat.
“This way, Bethany,” I heard from behind us.
Bethany grabbed my hand again as she turned and posed us—for a
couple of the news photographers who’d invaded the yard.
I yanked myself away and pretended that my
attention had been grabbed by another wave of Animal Services folks
exiting the house with filled crates—not much of a stretch. They,
fortunately, also shooed the media vultures back outside.
I had in fact heard of Bethany Urber and her Pet
Shelters Together organization. I belong to a different, unofficial
network, one where pet rescue administrators trade data informally,
and I visit its Web site frequently. It’s called, not especially
creatively, Southern California Rescuers. The shelter directors I’d
already contacted also monitored the site.
Bethany and PST had been mentioned and dissected in
its discussion group recently. Apparently some fellow rescuers
considered Bethany’s network a superb idea, where administrators
shared not only ideas and information, but also banded together for
fund-raisers and more.
Others considered it intrusive, with its
requirement of ceding control . . . and I gathered that the
majority of this group had met Bethany. Even so, no one said
anything especially terrible about it.
Judging by this first experience with Bethany,
though, I wondered if the organization was all about her, and not
so much about saving animals. Otherwise, why would she have
hesitated to call in official help right away? Had she been trying
to create leverage to get Mamie to join? But why?
“I’m so glad that the Animal Cruelty Task Force and
Animal Services are here,” Bethany said from behind me, loud enough
that a couple of those in uniform carrying the crates looked in our
direction and smiled.
I chose not to respond. Instead, I turned toward
Mamie, now standing beside me, also not looking at Bethany. She
watched with tears once more streaming down her lined cheeks as
Herman, too, was loaded into one of the official vans, among a
bunch of other similar-looking terriers.
“Oh, Herman, I’m so sorry,” she cried. She turned
to me. “Don’t you think I could get them to leave just one dog
right now?” Her voice was so soft that I barely heard it over the
shouts of the rescuers and the people who watched the show.
Not to mention barks from some of the frightened
dogs, including Herman. Even cat cries and hisses. I wished I could
explain to them what was going on.
Or not. I couldn’t make promises to them, or even
to Mamie. But I could to myself. I wouldn’t stop until as many as
possible—hopefully all of the animals—were healthy and well fed and
placed in new, loving homes.
“I don’t know,” I began gently, only to be
interrupted by Bethany.
“Why? So you could only mistreat just that poor
animal instead of a hundred?” She spoke loudly enough that I
glanced around but saw no reporters filming her.
“It’s not like that.” Mamie sounded as tormented as
the pets she had crammed into such terrible quarters. “I loved them
all. If I didn’t take them in, who would?”
“Now, that’s the question, isn’t it?” Bethany
taunted. “If you’d done as we’d discussed, worked with me and with
Pet Shelters Together, we might have been able to fix things around
here, and done it much faster.”
“There were other ways of getting it done faster,”
I muttered, glowering at the woman. “Like as soon as you learned
about the situation.”
“Oh, but that wouldn’t have taught Mamie anything.
Anyway, I need to go talk to someone. See you later, Mamie, dear.”
Instead of walking off, though, Bethany took another step toward
me. “We’ll talk soon, okay, Lauren?”
I didn’t have time to answer before she hurried out
the gate. She stopped at a parked van—one from a TV station, not
Animal Services.
“She did this,” Mamie cried, gesturing toward the
chaotic scene in front of us. “She ruined everything.”
Maybe, to some extent, Bethany was right. Her
timing and rationale might have stunk as badly as the interior of
Mamie’s house, but her discussions with Mamie had in fact spurred
my old mentor to call me, and thus, eventually, saved some animals’
lives. I didn’t want to throw that into the face of the distraught
woman in front of me, though.
Which felt weird, upside down somehow. I was used
to confronting people who abused animals, leveling threats and
accusations of my own. I couldn’t fault what was happening here,
but I also wasn’t going to rub Mamie’s nose in it. Not now, at
least. I don’t like to see any creature suffering, not even someone
who’d made such terrible mistakes, and that was definitely the case
with Mamie.
“Oh!” Mamie cried again as a cart stacked with
crates filled with cats was being maneuvered out to the street, to
another Animal Services van. “My babies!”
I wanted to shake some sense into her but realized
it would be futile. Plus, I didn’t know how delicate her mental
state really was. Maybe if I got her talking . . .
I turned and gestured for Mamie to follow me back
in the direction of the house, a little farther from the chaos. She
complied, though she looked reluctant.
“Do you want to tell me more about what happened?”
I asked when we stopped. “I gathered that Bethany twisted your arm
in an attempt to get you to join Pet Shelters Together, right?”
Mamie nodded. “That’s how she threatened you?” She nodded again.
“What did she say?”
Mamie’s smile was full of irony. “That she’d call
in Animal Services if I didn’t join and they’d arrest me.”
Which still could happen. She might be hauled in
for animal cruelty or some other charges, but I wasn’t sure. I’d
have to check with Matt about how this kind of situation was
usually handled.
“So why didn’t you just join?” I asked Mamie.
She shook her head, bouncing her red curls. “I
considered it. It sounded wonderful at first, but I needed to know
more. I began to look into Pet Shelters Together, and Bethany. She
had an amazing business background—did you know?” I shook my head.
“Well, she did. I thought she knew what she was doing, running
organizations and all, and that the animals would benefit. But when
I started asking people who’d already joined some questions about
what was good and bad about Pet Shelters Together, I wasn’t so
sure. Besides . . . I wasn’t really ready to give up on my own
shelter, you see?”
I did. Getting that kind of help would have meant
ending her hoarding sooner. Bethany’s threats or not, Mamie hadn’t
been ready to give up on her lifestyle.
“Have you considered joining Pet Shelters Together,
Lauren? I mean, having HotRescues join it?”
I blinked at the unanticipated question. The answer
was, of course, no. But my situation was unusual—ideal
circumstances for a pet rescue administrator. I didn’t need to band
together or coordinate with anyone to get the funds HotRescues
needed, thanks to its rich benefactor, Dante DeFrancisco.
Sure, we held fund-raisers now and then. But they
were intended to publicize animal rescue in general, and HotRescues
in particular—and not because we were hurting for money.
“No,” I told her. “I haven’t.”
“Good. You’d only regret even considering it, like
I do now. I told Bethany very politely that I appreciated her
invitation but I’d decided to decline. That’s when she started
threatening to expose me. She said she’d save these animals anyway,
and I’d be the one to suffer. She got so loud and mean that I
started trying to avoid her, but she kept calling and coming here
and making more threats—” And not saving the animals, damn her.
“—and that’s why . . .”
“That’s why you decided to call me?”
She nodded.
I’d thought Mamie looked aging and frail before,
but now, as she stared at me solemnly, then turned back to watch
the loading process, I had the sense she was thinking about how her
life had just ended, even though she was still alive.
Or maybe she was even considering how to terminate
that part, too.
I felt so torn inside that I almost wished I could
sever my own painful, ambivalent feelings from my heart. No matter
how ill-treated the animals had been, abusing them hadn’t been her
intention.
Only the result.
I noticed another Animal Services car double-park
along the street. It looked familiar, but many of the cars looked
alike. The person who got out definitely looked familiar, though.
It was Captain Matt Kingston.
He didn’t seem to see me at first, or maybe he
wasn’t looking for me. He talked initially to a couple of the
Animal Services folks while patting some dogs on the head, then
conversed with a few uniformed cops who were apparently part of the
Animal Cruelty Task Force. One of those cops turned and pointed
toward me. The group headed in our direction.
What was going on?
“Hi, Lauren,” Matt said when he reached where I
stood with Mamie, at the side of the yard. “Is this Ms. Spelling?”
He nodded toward Mamie.
He was wearing his official Animal Services
uniform. He was also wearing his official Animal Services attitude.
His expression, as he watched me for an answer, was remote, not at
all the fond way he’d come to look at me when we visited each other
at our respective rescue facilities or even got together for dinner
or drinks or more.
I kept my own demeanor strictly professional, too.
“Yes. Captain Matt Kingston, I’d like you to meet a long-time—”
Well, former. “—friend of mine, Mamie Spelling. Mamie, this is Matt
Kingston of Los Angeles Animal Services.”
“And this is Officer Truax of the Los Angeles
Police Department,” Matt said. “He’s a member of the Animal Cruelty
Task Force.”
A burly, uniformed man stepped from behind Matt. He
didn’t seem to pay much attention to the introduction. Instead, he
neared Mamie—like a giant hawk approaching a mouse.
“Will you come with me, ma’am?” Though he phrased
it as a question and his tone was soft, he clearly expected Mamie
to comply.
I aimed a questioning glance of my own at Matt. He
nodded. Softly, he said, “I’d asked that no one start talking to
the owner of this property until I arrived, and everyone involved
was kind enough to agree.”
In other words, he’d done it for me. He didn’t
understand exactly what my relationship was, or wasn’t, with Mamie,
but even though he had encouraged the city’s forces to come and
rescue the abused animals, he’d been sweet enough to make sure he’d
talked to me before anyone started dealing with her.
“That’s very nice.” My tone was a bit warmer than
before. But I couldn’t let go of my professionalism—or my concern
about Mamie. “Matt, could I talk to you?”
“Sure.” He looked at the others. “Officer Truax,
why don’t you hold off for a few minutes? Just keep Ms. Spelling
company for now.”
Fortunately, the guy didn’t seem surprised by the
request. Or maybe it was a command, since Matt was a captain in
Animal Services—although he wasn’t a cop.
“Let’s go over here,” Matt said, and we went around
the corner of the house. I noticed that the yard that had been so
full of animals before was empty, except for the myriad of filthy
enclosures.
“What’s going to happen to Mamie now?” I asked as
soon as I thought we were beyond her hearing.
“I understand your concern for your friend,
Lauren.” Matt reached out to clasp my hands in his. I hung on, but
needed answers before I could feel reassured. “We treat hoarders
different from most abusers, though. We consider hoarding largely a
mental disease. The condition of Mamie’s place wasn’t the worst
I’ve seen, but—What do you think? How does her mental state seem to
you?”
“Awful!” I took a deep breath and stared into his
brown eyes. They appeared full of sympathy. “I came here because I
was afraid, from what she’d said on the phone, that she was
suicidal. Now, I’m not sure . . . but I can’t say that she isn’t,
either. She seems to be changing moment by moment, from flakiness
to sadness to anger.”
“That’s helpful for us to know. Here’s what’s
likely to happen.” He described briefly how Mamie would be taken in
for a psychological evaluation. “The hold is likely to be for a
maximum of seventy-two hours, and then she’ll probably be released.
Most hoarders, at a minimum, suffer from obsessive-compulsive
disorder, but there may be even more to Mamie’s situation. Let’s
get that process started, and I’ll explain to you later how the way
she acts will affect how we deal with the animals. We’ll keep them
safe in any event, of course, and have them checked by a
vet.”
“Will Mamie be prosecuted for animal cruelty or
something?” I asked.
“Yes, but she’ll most likely wind up on probation.
Incarcerating hoarders, with their mental conditions, is usually
counterproductive—but we can monitor how well they comply with the
terms of their probation.”
“Most likely?”
“You know I can’t give absolute assurances.”
“I get it. And I will want to learn more later. But
for now . . .” I squeezed Matt’s hands, then let them go.
I returned to where we had left Mamie and the
officer.
“I think things will be all right,” I told her. She
smiled and took a few steps away from the police officer. “The
animals will be well cared for. But there are possible consequences
for you. Mamie, do you happen to know any lawyers?”
She stared from the cop, to Matt, to me, looking
confused. “My niece, but—”
“What’s her phone number?” I withdrew my BlackBerry
from my pocket, ignoring the glares from both men.
“I . . . I’m not sure.”
I got her name, at least, from Mamie, did a search
on my smartphone, and made the call—noticing, as I pushed in the
number, that Bethany still stood near one of the media vans. She
was pointing in our direction.
Obviously, she’d noticed the uniformed cop standing
by Mamie, too.
Fortunately, I reached Janice Spelling immediately.
I told her what was going on with her aunt. “Are you local—in
L.A.?” I asked, since her law firm had a couple of offices.
“Yes, but I haven’t seen my aunt in . . . Never
mind. I’ll be there in half an hour. Please tell her not to answer
any questions.”
“Okay,” I assured her, then hung up. “Don’t say
anything till she’s with you, okay, Mamie?”
“Okay, but—”
“Fine. Let’s wait over here.” I’d spotted a cement
bench in what had once probably been Mamie’s garden and led her
over to it. We both sat.
I suspected what was coming. It was entirely
appropriate. Psych evaluation and likely probation or not, Mamie
might be questioned about whether this was her property, how long
the animals had been under her care and control, and whatever else
it might take to determine whether there was enough evidence to
arrest her for animal cruelty.
I was certain what the answer would be.