4
FAME AND FRIENDSHIP
Kafirs? [said Oom Schalk Lourens] Yes, I know
them. And they’re all the same. I fear the Almighty, and I respect
His works, but I could never understand why He made the kafir and
the rinderpest.
‘Makapan’s Caves’, from the collection of short
stories entitled
Mafeking Road by Herman Charles Bosman, Central News
Publishers, 1947
Mafeking Road by Herman Charles Bosman, Central News
Publishers, 1947
![005](/epubstore/M/G-Marinovich/The-bang-bang-club/OEBPS/greg_9780465024483_oeb_005_r1.jpg)
April 1991
The phone rang at about ten that night, waking me
from a deep sleep. I heard the distinctive click of an overseas
line. It was the AP photo boss, Vin Alabiso, to tell me that I had
won the Pulitzer Prize for Spot News. Less than four months after
turning away from the Danube’s frigid waters, I had joined that
journalistic elite - I was a Pulitzer Prize-winner, but right then
I did not have a clue as to its significance. I wondered if there
were money involved, but I was soon to discover what all the fuss
was about. The next call was from the Johannesburg office - they
needed pictures of me celebrating as soon as possible. They had the
champagne ready. A sense of the importance of the prize was taking
shape: they had not asked for pictures of me when I had won any of
the other prizes. I became excited as I got dressed to drive to
Johannesburg through the night.
My new-found fame was awkward. The fact that I was
winning prizes for shooting Tshabalala’s gruesome death troubled
me, but when
I passed a huge newspaper billboard proclaiming ‘SA Lensman Wins
Pulitzer’, I could not but feel a surge of pride. While a few
photographers resented my quick success, most seemed genuinely
pleased for me. We had a party to celebrate the prize at the new
home I shared with my old housemates. The house was packed with
friends and journalists, some of whom I had never met before. I was
already drunk when photographer Ken Oosterbroek stood on a table in
the livingroom and gave a speech. Ken was taller than anyone else
in the room anyway, but he wanted to make sure people paid
attention. He was like that: when he wanted to be noticed, he would
straighten out of his normal, easy-going slouch and get a stern,
commanding air about him. I recall Ken recounting how, three years
before, I had come up to him in the daily newspaper The
Star’s newsroom and complimented him on a picture that had been
splashed across the front page. ‘I wish I could shoot pictures like
that!’ I had said. The picture that I so admired had won Ken South
Africa’s leading photographic award in 1989. Ken, truly a very
talented photographer, and a perfectionist, had also struggled to
gain a foothold in the industry. He had gone from paper to paper
trying to get a job on the strength of pictures he had illegally
taken of his fellow-conscripts during his military service.
He had kept a diary while serving as a soldier in
southern Angola, where the South Africans were fighting against
Angola’s socialist government and southern African guerilla armies
from their bases in the then South African colony of South West
Africa. When I read those diaries years later after his death, I
was appalled that Ken came across as a typical English-speaking
white South African who easily referred insultingly to blacks as
peckies. On 16 June 1981, for example, he had spent a long time
looking at the bodies of six guerrillas that were lying piled in a
heap. Ken had been fascinated by ‘the kill’. One fighter had been
shot right in the centre of his forehead. Ken assumed that he had
been the first killed, shot by a sniper. They were all wearing
People’s Liberation Army of Namibia (PLAN - the armed wing of the
banned Namibian liberation movement SWAPO, South West African
People’s Organization) uniforms, except for one who was naked. The
naked
guerrilla’s legs had been hacked by pangas. Some of them looked
young, perhaps no more than 15 or 16, Ken estimated. The scene
bothered him, but he rationalized that they had chosen to don
guerrilla uniforms: ‘they slipped up’, he wrote. The next day he
added a further note in his journal, one which suggests a much more
unpleasant scenario. ‘I have been thinking about the terr
(terrorist) who was shot in the centre of his forehead. He had wire
wrapped around him, which puzzled me. Tied up against a tree and
shot?’ In yet another entry he described, with neither reservation
nor distaste, how his unit had wired up a young Angolan villager to
a field telephone and tortured him for information. As for the vast
majority of whites, it was ‘them’ against ‘us’ for Ken.
When I had first met Ken, I knew nothing about his
border experiences or his politics, but the newsroom abounded with
snide jokes about the chip on his shoulder. He was defensive and
had a brittle arrogance. He was always very aware of his appearance
- he had quite beautiful brown eyes and a charming smile, though he
usually had a serious, intense look on his face. He was very aware
of how he looked in pictures and I had never seen a photograph of
Ken in which he was not mindful of the camera. Pictures taken of
him over the years show a tall, thin man with long hair, inevitably
wearing jeans and T-shirt, sometimes a droopy bandito moustache. He
had perfected the image of the biker-rebel he so wished to
cultivate.
Years after his stint in the army, Ken would return
to keeping an occasional journal. When he achieved his first
success as a photographer in 1989, he wrote: ‘I won the Ilford
Award (South African Press Photographer Of The Year) on Wednesday
the 19th of April, exceeding my wildest expectations but fulfilling
my ultimate ambition.
‘One excellent night followed, full of cheers and
smiles and congratulations & all, and a cheese slice (-shaped)
trophy ... i didn’t put the thing down for hours. And then in the
morning this kind of emptiness or what-now feeling and it just
wasn’t so important anymore.
‘I’ve got it, it’s history, it’s on record and now
my head is free of a single-minded one-stop goal. Now i can really
let rip. Will somebody please give me a gap to let rip?
‘BUT, give me a break to shoot the real thing.
Real, happening, life. Relevant work. Something to get the
adrenaline up & the eyes peeled, the brain rolling over with
possibilities and the potential for powerhouse pictures. I am a
photographer. Set me free.’
By the time we were celebrating my Pulitzer in
April of 1991, Ken had had his wish come true. The country was
awash with real pictures - passion, excitement and dreadful
violence - and Ken had been named South African Press Photographer
of the Year for the second time. Once he was the photographer he
had dreamed of becoming, he matured into a generous and
self-possessed man. His professional life was on track and he was
in love with a vivacious journalist, Monica Nicholson. They had
just returned from a working holiday to Israel, where they had
spent the first two months of 1991 covering the Iraqi Scud-attacks
on Israel. One night he and Monica were in bed in their Jerusalem
hotel room when they were interrupted by a Scud-attack warning.
Before going off to the shelters, Ken took a picture of himself and
Monica. The photograph shows his hand reaching for Monica’s exposed
breast; they are both wearing gasmasks. He scrawled a note about
the incident on hotel notepaper: ‘A moment of passion and love -
destroyed by War 23/01/91. A moment’s tenderness. The first few
moments of shared warmth. The opening joy, the quiet love felt as
we lie together, giving over shared love to the physical. The
promise of more, closeness, commitment and co-passion. The moon
rising, sirens around us, the hostile hint, grim realization as
speakers blurb a Hebrew emergency order.’
Ken and Kevin Carter, another young photographer,
had become friends when they first started working for newspapers
in the mid 80s. In that period, Kevin had witnessed the first known
public execution by necklacing. Necklace was township slang for the
barbaric practice of killing a person by placing a tyre filled with
petrol around the neck and setting it alight. Maki Skosana, whose
necklacing Kevin witnessed and photographed, had been accused of
being a policeman’s girlfriend. Her necklacing was the ritual,
public execution of a person who had betrayed the community, a
punishment reserved for those who collaborated with the state,
traitors.
Kevin had watched and photographed as the mob
kicked and beat her, and then they poured petrol on her and set her
alight. She was still alive and screaming, but eventually she did
die. Kevin wrote about that horrific incident years later: ‘I was
appalled at what they were doing. I was appalled at what I was
doing. But then people started talking about those pictures; they
created quite a stir. And then I felt that maybe my actions hadn’t
been all bad. Being a witness to something this horrible wasn’t
necessarily such a terrible thing to do.’
The state had its own form of the necklace,
ritualized murder no less barbarous for its legitimization by law.
The death penalty was frequently used against political opponents -
hanging was the white regime’s ultimate display of power. Both were
equally abhorrent to me. The necklace was a warped symbol of
liberation, and became known as shisanyama or burnt meat, three
cents, which was then the price of a box of matches, and finally,
savagely, Nando’s after a popular flamegrilled chicken
franchise.
Kevin’s childhood had been difficult. His parents
had found his moods and outbursts impossible to deal with. Years
later, he wrote about what he felt then, during the years he lived
at home with his parents, Jimmy and Roma Carter, in their
middle-class white neighbourhood. The occasional police raids, to
arrest blacks who were illegally in the whites-only neighbourhood,
was the closest Kevin, as a child, got to seeing apartheid being
implemented: ‘We weren’t racist at home of course, coming from a
supposedly “liberal” family. We were brought up in a Christian way,
to love our neighbours, and that included all humans, but I do now
question how my parents’ generation could have been so
lackadaisical about fighting the obvious sin of apartheid.’
After high school, Kevin made a stab at studying to
be a pharmacist but soon dropped out and was drafted into the army.
He hated it, and to escape from the infantry he rashly signed up
for the professional air force. He soon realized that four years in
the military - even in the air force - was a serious mistake, but
he was trapped. In 1980, after an incident in which he was badly
beaten up by fellow soldiers for
defending a black mess-hall waiter who was being insulted, he went
AWOL and tried to start a new life as ‘David’, a radio disc-jockey
in the coastal city of Durban. But he soon ran into difficulties,
as he could not open a bank account in the false name he was using.
He gave up this plan within a month and became increasingly
depressed. He felt trapped; years later he would write about that
dark period of his life.
‘Somewhere along the line, suicide became the
option. I began to think of it more and more, and the more I
thought of it, the more appealing it sounded. It was only a
question of how really, and when. I had decided to do it. I
wandered from chemist shop to chemist shop, accumulating a large
quantity and variety of sleeping tablets and painkillers. For the
cherry on the top I bought some rat poison, and I took the stash to
my room. Then I went out, and spent my very last few Rands on a
Wimpy burger and a milkshake.
‘Back in my room I went ahead with my plans. I
remember being amazed by the calm I felt. I had a two-litre bottle
of Coke in the room, and I proceeded to wash down the tablets.
There must have been hundreds in total. Down they went, four or
five at a time, until they were all gone. I lay on the bed, waiting
to die. I looked forward to it as an upcoming relief, a total
escape from my solution, my problems, and the mess I felt I had
made of my life. Why had I failed so miserably?
‘Hell, I didn’t believe in heaven or hell. I
couldn’t believe I was about to stand judgement on anything. Either
it was all about to end abruptly, and that’s that; or I was going
to achieve a new form, free of physical restraint, and with a far
higher understanding. Free of earth and free of money, free of need
and pain, and free of people’s expectations.
‘Thinking of dying, however, I began to wonder why
I wasn’t feeling sleepy or drowsy, which I wasn’t, and which was
really strange under the circumstances. I decided to go down to the
beachfront, and take a walk around. The world seemed very surreal
to me that night. I went into one of those amusement arcades, and
played a few video games with what were really now my last few
coins.
‘Slowly I was becoming aware of the drowsiness. Now
it started to seem real. I was ready to die, or was I? Staggering
back to my room, I
passed a hotel, and in a total daze I walked into a phone booth. I
wanted to say goodbye to someone. I don’t know why it only occurred
to me then, but I couldn’t die without saying just one
goodbye.’
But Kevin did not die and came to in a hospital
ward. For him, surviving may have been the worst of that awful
episode: ‘I shall never forget facing my mother again. It is living
through a suicide that is the hardest part.’
Soon after the suicide attempt, Kevin decided he
had to see his military commitment through without creating more
trouble. One Friday afternoon in 1983, while on guard duty in
Pretoria, he spotted a car recklessly turning across four lanes of
traffic; he wrote: ‘It came screeching to a halt in the loading
zone outside the Air Force headquarters, it didn’t even straighten
out. The front doors sprang open, and two men leaped out. They were
hardly out of the doors when my eyes were blinded by an intense
explosion of blinding light, and I was hit by a blast of tremendous
force, that hurled me off my feet into the window behind me.’
The ANC had detonated a car bomb outside one of the
military headquarters buildings and as soon as his initial panic
subsided Kevin began to assist the dozens of wounded. It was only
afterward that he realized that he too had been injured by flying
glass and shrapnel. The incident was one of the ANC’s most
successful attacks on a military target. Kevin’s sense of being
involved in history at that point seems to have given him the idea
of wanting to record history. He decided to be a
news-photographer.
By 1984 Kevin had worked himself in to a staff job
at The Star. While he was photographing outside the
Johannesburg Supreme Court he met a striking, wild-haired
photographer named Julia Lloyd and immediately asked her out.
Within two weeks of their meeting, they were living together. Julia
was soon pregnant. Kevin wanted them to get married, but Julia
refused - she had been married twice before and did not want
another husband. On the night his daughter was born, Kevin recalled
the awe he felt at witnessing Megan’s birth, at being allowed to
cut the umbilical cord. Megan became the focus of all that was best
about Kevin - loyalty, intense passion, infectious enthusiasm and
love. But he and Julia soon broke up and Kevin found himself
missing his daughter terribly.
I had met Kevin before I had any plans to be a
photographer, through my older brother Bart, who was a sports
writer. I would see Kevin when I visited Bart at work, and at
parties. Kevin was a tall, thin and good-looking guy, with a quick
and winning smile. He had a rakish, mischievous way about him that
many women found quite irresistible. He usually wore his hair long
and had a diamond stud earring; he usually dressed in jeans and a
T-shirt and wore leather-thonged Jesussandals. He always seemed
pretty crazy to me, up and down like a yoyo, but I liked him. By
the time I took up the same line of work in 1990, he had become
chief photographer at the anti-apartheid Weekly Mail
newspaper. Kevin was one of the few people in the business that I
knew and I would see him regularly in the townships. We began to
team up to lessen the dangers of working alone.
It was some months later that I first met Joao
Silva. In March of 1991, a lot of fighting was taking place in
Johannesburg’s Alexandra township. Alex is a tiny crowded slum just
one kilometre square that had survived several forced removals,
and, unlike all the other townships, is next to the heart of white
Johannesburg. It was an unique place, where the lively South
African music style kwela had originated: Alex had soul. But it was
also a place teeming with criminals who preyed on the wealthy white
areas that surrounded the township; a risky place to work.
I was walking up a road in Alex when I saw a
helmeted rider getting off a motorbike. I had heard about this guy
who was working in the townships on a bike. I had also heard that
he was shooting hot pictures. It was dangerous enough working in
the townships in a car, but doing it on a bike was not a good idea
- the guy had to be a little crazy, I thought to myself. I smiled
as I approached and he reciprocated with a friendly greeting. He
was dark-skinned, unshaven and short, and he wore glasses, but he
seemed sane enough to me. I was taller than him and heavy-set, with
a marked physical presence - typical of a sportsman gone slightly
to seed (it would get worse). In those days, I still had a
mop of dark-brown curly hair. We met in Alex again a week later
and worked together. We got on well and a warmth immediately
developed. From that day on, Joao was my first choice as a cruising
partner. It would not be long before I would discover Joao’s
predominant characteristics: he was tenacious and could be pretty
aggressive, but above all, his watchword was loyalty-a friend would
later say of him that when the ship went down, the last thing you
would see would be Silva’s glasses.
For Joao, photography started out simply enough: he
wanted to cover war. He was living in the coal-and-steel industrial
town of Vereeniging, south of Johannesburg, where his father was a
welder. In his second last year of high school he told his parents
that he was dropping out of school. School had nothing more to
teach him, he felt. Joao had come to South Africa when he was nine
years old. Before that, he had spent ten months in Portugal with
his godfather after his parents had sent him out of war-torn
colonial Mozambique. Once his parents had re-settled in South
Africa, they sent for Joao. He was put into an English-medium
school, but spoke only Portuguese. He did not fit in at first and
felt intimidated, but eventually started making friends by drawing
dragons on his classmates’ arms - that only got him into trouble
with his teachers. He entered his teens angry and rebellious. After
leaving school, Joao went from job to job, lying about having
completed his military obligations, and made up details of where he
had served. He and his parents had used a grey area in the law with
respect to immigrants to avoid the army, but that was not something
to admit in the rabidly patriotic atmosphere then prevailing in
white South Africa. During the day he worked as a signwriter and at
night he worked clubs, but nothing satisfied Joao.
In late 1988, a friend of Joao’s had to take a
series of pictures on motion for a course on graphic design and he
joined Joao when he went to watch motor car racing at the track.
Even then, Joao was an avid motor-sport fan; a speed junkie. The
idea of taking pictures appealed to Joao, and he used his friend’s
camera to shoot a few rolls of his own. He was immediately hooked.
He gave up the club job as well as the
signwriting and bought a camera, studying black-and-white
photography at night school. A year later, in late 1989, he moved
to Johannesburg and began to establish himself as a
photographer.
Joao remembers that the first time he saw Ken - at
Thokoza’s Phola Park squatter camp towards the end of 1990 - was
also his first experience of photographing violence. By then, he
had already landed his first job shooting car-crashes and Rotary
meetings for a small newspaper in the industrial town of Alberton,
east of Johannesburg. It didn’t pay much. The only reliable working
camera he had was the Alberton Record’s beat-up old
screw-mount Pentax, which had an annoying little hole in the cloth
shutter, that left a white dot burnt on to all his pictures, in the
top left corner. Joao tried to frame his pictures in a way that he
could crop the dot out later.
Joao had convinced the paper’s news editor to let
him cover the escalating violence in nearby Thokoza, arguing that
the township was right next door to Alberton, the white town which
the newspaper served. At Phola Park squatter camp, he had
photographed some Xhosa warriors wrapped in blankets and holding
sharpened steel rods. They were sitting on their haunches, staring
at three corpses lying beneath grey blankets. The warriors directed
Joao and his increasingly nervous Afrikaans reporter-colleague
toward a cluster of shacks. The two of them had to step carefully
to bypass a shrouded corpse in a narrow alley and entered a dark
shack to find another covered body. The squatter camp had been
attacked earlier that day by Inkatha hostel dwellers in one of the
massive assaults that marked the beginning of the Hostel War. His
colleague was urging him to return to the office and Joao
reluctantly agreed.
As they emerged from the shacks, they ran into
another photographer. Joao immediately recognized Ken Oosterbroek,
the fastrising photographer with the distinctively long hair and
lanky frame, from articles he had seen in newspapers and magazines.
Ken looked at Joao, a short, unknown photographer carrying an
outdated camera, and dismissed him with a disdainful nod. ‘What an
arsehole,’ Joao thought.
While driving out along Thokoza’s main road,
Khumalo Street, Joao
spotted a group of women chasing another, younger woman. She was
bleeding from her head and losing ground fast. In seconds they had
caught her, hacking at her with whatever weapons they had,
including a sickle. Joao leapt out of the still-moving car and ran
towards the crowd. The low cries of pain from the woman on the dirt
pavement were almost drowned out by the attackers’ triumphant
ululating. Joao was scared, confused. This was not the kind of war
photography he had imagined himself doing - this was too weird, but
he shot off frame after frame as he retreated. Just then a man
walked into the right-hand side of his frame, patronizing the
female killers with a broad smile. Joao instinctively felt he had
the shot as he pressed the shutter, for once heedless as to where
the little black spot would appear on the negative.
That night he had to cover the Alberton Rotary
Club’s annual general meeting. It was the last meeting before
Christmas and like everyone at the dinner table, he had a cracker
to pull. Inside Joao’s was a toy machine-gun. He saw it as an omen;
within weeks he put together a portfolio of his best pictures and
approached Reuters, Britain’s global wire service, persuading them
to let him submit pictures on spec. For a few months he balanced
the two: shooting the dull pictures that earned his salary at the
paper and covering the burgeoning township war after hours and on
the weekends, selling the pictures to Reuters. One day, the
Alberton Record’s editor called him in to ask why the
paper’s car had been seen in Soweto. Realizing he could no longer
balance both jobs, Joao quit the paper to freelance full-time for
Reuters.
Joao’s pictures on the wire were earning him a name
as a conflict photographer, but a new picture editor for Reuters
was coming in and the word was that he was going to get rid of the
present stringers to set up his own network. Joao took his
portfolio in to The Star to try to get a full-time job.
While the Sunday picture editor was rather distractedly paging
through the prints, Ken came over and looked over his shoulder and
on seeing the picture of the woman being attacked in Thokoza, said,
‘Hey, I heard about that!’ though he seemed not to recall bumping
into Joao on the day that the picture had been taken. Joao began to
string for the Sunday Star and was still selling pictures to
Reuters.
In August 1991, Ken was named chief photographer at
The Star; one of the first things he did was hire Joao, the
hotshot young photographer who was bringing great pictures back
from the war in the townships. It had taken Joao just nine months
to move from covering Rotary meetings to being The Star’s
most exciting photographer. Ken and Joao became close friends as
Joao became Ken’s ally in his struggle to improve the paper’s
moribund photographic department.
Joao’s beat was almost exclusively the political
violence in the townships. His eager recklessness to go into any
situation for a picture and his custom of not shaving for days on
end, as well as treating management and danger alike to his ‘fuck
you’ attitude, ensured he fitted the part of conflict photographer
well. But he maintained a certain equilibrium. He had made a home
with an acerbically witty girl three years his junior - Vivian
Innes. She was just 17 when they first met in a nightclub where he
was a bouncer. She had come from her matric party and looked sexy
in a short black sleeveless dress. Some time later, Joao received a
Valentine’s card from Viv. He sent her flowers a few days later;
from then on they were a couple and she moved in with him some time
after he moved to Johannesburg. Over the years, they had
accumulated a collection of orphaned cats which they both doted on.
A friend once described Joao as ‘Mr War-photographer who just melts
all over his cats.’
Johann Greybe ran a small hole-in-the-wall camera
shop in Hillbrow. Because he was always willing to give good prices
and technical advice to struggling young photojournalists, we all
ended up buying second-hand cameras from him - the cameras that I
had used to shoot the execution pictures came from him. Johann
remembers Joao as the most enthusiastic young photographer he has
ever met; extremely energetic and driven to have his picture on the
front page. Ken was the ultimate professional. The camera dealer’s
impression of Kevin was that he was too sensitive for this world:
‘He was one of the photographers who got nightmares and saw
spooks.’ And me? I was level-headed, he said, the one who had his
shit the most together.