21
Detective Chief Inspector Flight was far
from amused. He personally had spent more than an hour trudging
across the dark, muddy track, looking for the horse, while wearing
his best leather shoes, and, if that wasn’t bad enough, he was also
soaked to the skin. As he explained to me at length and rather
loudly, his coat was meant to have been waterproof but, on that
count, it seemed to have failed rather badly.
“I’m tempted to put you in a cell and throw away
the key,” he said.
We were in one of the interview rooms at the
Cheltenham Police Station.
“How is Viscount Shenington?” I asked, ignoring his
remark.
“Still alive,” he said. “But only just. They’re
working on him at the hospital. The ambulance paramedics got him
breathing again, but it seems his heart is now the problem.”
Just like his brother.
“And the doctor is also saying that even if he does
survive, his brain is likely to have been permanently damaged due
to being starved of oxygen for so long.”
Shame, I thought. Not!
“You say that you simply rugby-tackled him and you
didn’t see that his nose and mouth were lying in the water?”
“That’s right,” I said. “I just thought he was
winded by the fall. Only after I’d checked that Claudia was all
right did I discover he was facedown in a puddle. Then, of course,
I rolled him over onto his back.”
“Did you not then think of applying artificial
respiration?” he asked.
I just looked at him.
“No,” he said. “I can see the problem.”
“Exactly,” I said. “The man had come there to kill
me. Why would I try and save him? So that he could have another
go?”
“Some people might argue that you were
negligent.”
“Let them,” I said. “Whatever happened to
Shenington was his own fault. You saw the gun. He wasn’t there
making a social call.”
He looked up at the clock on the wall. It showed
that it was well after midnight.
“We’ll have to continue this in the morning,” he
said, yawning.
“I have to be at the Paddington Green Police
Station by eleven,” I said.
“So do I,” Flight replied. “We can talk on the
way.”
The meeting at Paddington Green lasted for
more than two hours. In addition to me, there were four senior
police officers present: Detective Chief Inspectors Tomlinson and
Flight; a detective inspector from the City of London Police
Economic Crime Department—the Fraud Squad; and Superintendent
Yering, who chaired the meeting by virtue of his superior
rank.
At his request, I started slowly from the
beginning, outlining the events in chronological order, from the
day Herb Kovak had been gunned down at Aintree right through to the
previous evening at Cheltenham racetrack and at my mother’s cottage
in Woodmancote. However, I decided not to include the finer details
of how I had forced Shenington’s head down into the puddle on the
gravel driveway.
“Viscount Shenington,” I said, “seems to have been
desperate for money due to his gambling losses and clearly provided
the five million pounds from the Roberts Family Trust in order to
trigger the grants from the European Union. It appears that he even
gave his brother the impression that he had needed to be convinced
to make the investment.”
“Perhaps he did, to start with,” said DCI Flight,
“until he discovered the availability of the grants.”
“Maybe,” I said. “But I think it’s far more likely
that the idea for stealing the EU grants came first and Shenington
was simply brought in as the necessary provider of the priming
money.”
“So he wasn’t the only one involved?” Tomlinson
said.
“Not at all,” I said. “I’ve seen e-mails between a
Uri Joram in the office of the European Commission in Brussels and
a Dimitar Petrov in Bulgaria—”
“How did you see them?” Tomlinson
interrupted.
“On Gregory Black’s computer,” I said. “He was
copied on their correspondence.”
“And who is Gregory Black?” asked the detective
inspector from the Fraud Squad.
“He’s one of the senior partners at Lyall and
Black, the firm of financial advisers where I work.” Or where I
used to work.
“And what do you think he has to do with this?” he
asked.
“I’m only guessing, but I believe that Gregory
Black probably found Shenington for Joram and Petrov. They would
have needed someone with five million pounds to invest to trigger
the much larger sum from the EU. Shenington was a client of
Gregory’s, and who could be better, a man who controlled a wealthy
family trust but was himself broke and in dire need of lots of
ready money to pay his gambling debts. And Gregory would have known
that. Financial advisers are aware of all their clients’ most
intimate financial secrets.”
“But what has all this to do with the death of
Herbert Kovak?” asked DCI Tomlinson. That was his major
concern.
“Herb Kovak had accessed the file with the e-mails
between Joram and Petrov just a few days before he was killed. And
Gregory Black would have known he had because Herb’s name appeared
on the recently accessed list. I saw it there. Perhaps Herb had
asked some difficult questions about the project, questions that
got him killed.”
I could see that I was losing them.
“Remember,” I said, “we are talking about a huge
amount of money here. A hundred million euros. Even split four
ways, it’s a handsome sum, and worth a bit of protecting.”
I could see them doing the simple math in their
heads.
“And,” I went on, “in the last week or so, every
time Gregory Black knew where I was, someone tried to kill me
there. I now think that Shenington only changed his mind about
wanting to talk to me, then asked me to the races, because I hadn’t
been turning up at my office. He as good as admitted it yesterday.
He said I was a difficult man to kill because I usually didn’t turn
up when I was expected. Well, I was expected at a meeting with
Gregory Black on Monday morning and I’m now certain that I would
have been killed if I’d gone to it. I probably wouldn’t have even
reached the office front door. I’d have been shot down in the
street. Murdered in a public place, just like Herb Kovak was at
Aintree.”
“I think it’s time I spoke again to Mr. Gregory
Black,” said DCI Tomlinson. “I remember him from my previous
encounter.”
Yes, I thought, and I bet he remembers you.
There followed a brief discussion as to who had the
proper jurisdiction to arrest and on suspicion of what charges.
Finally, it was agreed that the honor would fall to DI Batten, the
detective inspector from the Fraud Squad. After all, the City of
London was his patch. However, we all wanted to be present, and a
total of three police cars made the trip across London to 64
Lombard Street, where we were joined by a fourth from the uniformed
branch.
It was quarter past two by the time we arrived at
my office. Gregory should be just back from his usual substantial
lunch at the restaurant on the corner. I hoped he’d made the most
of it. There would be no more foie gras and filet mignon
en croûte where he was going.
“Can I help you?” Mrs. McDowd asked as the
policemen entered. Then she saw me with them. “Oh, Mr. Nicholas,
are these men with you?”
DI Batten ignored her. “Can you tell me where I
might find Mr. Gregory Black?” he said rather grandly.
“I’ll call him,” she said nervously, clearly
slightly troubled by the mass of people crowding into her reception
area.
“No,” said DI Batten, “just tell me where he
is.”
At that point Gregory walked down the
corridor.
“There he is,” said Mrs. McDowd, pointing.
The detective inspector wasted no time.
“Gregory Black,” he said, taking hold of Gregory by
the arm, “I arrest you on suspicion of conspiracy to defraud and
also on suspicion of conspiracy to murder. You do not have to say
anything, but it may harm your defense if you do not mention when
questioned something which you later rely on in court. Anything you
do say may be given in evidence.”
Gregory was stunned. “But that’s ridiculous,” he
said. “I’ve done nothing of the sort.”
Then he saw me.
“Is this your doing?” he demanded, thrusting his
face belligerently towards mine. “Some kind of sick joke?”
“Murder is never a joke,” said DI Batten. “Take him
away.”
Two uniformed officers moved forward and handcuffed
Gregory, who was still loudly protesting his innocence. The
policemen ignored his pleas and led him out of the glass door and
onto the lift.
I knew all too well what that felt like.
“What the hell’s going on?” Patrick had appeared in
the reception, obviously summoned by the noise. “What are these men
doing here?”
“It seems they are here to arrest Mr. Gregory,”
said the unflappable Mrs. McDowd.
“Arrest Gregory? But that’s ridiculous. What
for?”
“Conspiracy to defraud and conspiracy to murder,”
DI Batten said.
“Fraud? Murder? Who has he murdered?” Patrick
demanded, turning towards the policeman.
“No one,” said DI Batten. “Mr. Black has been
arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to murder.”
Patrick wasn’t to be deterred.
“So who, then, is he suspected of conspiring to
murder?”
“Me,” I said, stepping forward.
Patrick said nothing. He just stared at me.
Later in the afternoon, life in the offices
of Lyall & Black at 64 Lombard Street returned to some sort of
normalcy, if having one of the senior partners arrested for
conspiracy to defraud and murder could ever be considered
normal.
I went into my office for the first time in almost
two weeks to find that Rory had moved himself into Herb’s desk by
the window. Diana was still where she had always been.
“By rights, that should have been Diana’s,” I said
to Rory. “She’s the more senior.”
“She had yours until half an hour ago,” Rory
replied with a sneer. “Patrick said you weren’t coming back.” His
tone implied that he was sorry I had.
Diana, meanwhile, remained silently resentful as I
opened the window to let in some of the warm spring day. Perhaps
the weather had changed for the better as well.
Maybe Diana wouldn’t have to wait too much longer
to get back to my desk anyway. That is, if my desk remained at all.
At the moment, I couldn’t see Lyall & Black surviving as a firm
beyond next week. Once news of a fraud investigation got out, our
clients would desert us quicker than rats from a sinking ship.
Everything in financial services comes down to client confidence,
and confidence in a firm involved in fraud would be close to
absolute zero.
The quickest way to create a run on a bank was to
publicly warn that there might be one. Depositors would quickly
lose confidence in the institution and would queue around the block
to get their money back. But of course no bank leaves cash lying
around in its vaults just in case of such an eventuality. The money
will have been lent out to other customers as mortgages and
business loans. Hence the bank can’t pay. As word spreads that the
bank is in trouble, even more depositors come looking for their
money, and the whole crisis self-perpetuates and then crashes down
like a house of cards. The bank’s credibility, which might have
taken several hundred years to establish, can be destroyed in as
little as a day. As it had been with Northern Rock in the UK and
Indy-Mac in the U.S., and so would be with us. But, in our case,
there would be no government bailout.
Yes, indeed, we had all better start looking for
new positions by another firm’s window. But what chance would we
have with a reference from Lyall & Black? Not much.
There were nearly a hundred unanswered e-mails for
me on the company server, plus twenty-eight messages on my office
voice mail, including quite a few from irate clients with whom I
had missed meetings. There were also two from the Slim Fit Gym,
reminding me again that they wanted Herb’s locker back.
“Where’s the key?” I asked Rory.
“What key?” he said.
“The key that was pinned to Herb’s bulletin
board.”
“Still on it, I expect,” Rory said. “I swapped the
whole desk cubicle.”
I went over to one of the empty cubicles and
checked. The key was still pinned to the board. I took it off and
put it in my pocket.
I sat down again at my desk and started going
through the mass of e-mails but without really taking in any of the
information contained in them. My heart simply wasn’t in this job
anymore.
If and when Claudia beat this cancer, we would do
something different, something together.
Something more exciting. But maybe something a
little less dangerous.
“I’m going out,” I said to Rory and Diana, as if
they cared.
As I walked down the corridor I had to step over
some big tied-up polyethylene bags stacked full of files and
computers. The Fraud Squad was busily packing up the stuff from
Gregory’s office. I was quite surprised they hadn’t thrown us all
out of the building to pack up the whole firm. That would come
later, no doubt, when they had discovered a little more.
The receptionist at the Slim Fit Gym was
really pleased to see me.
“To be honest,” she said in a broad Welsh accent,
“it’s beginning to smell a bit, especially today in this warm
weather. It’s upsetting some of our other clients. There must be
some dreadfully sweaty clothes in there.”
The key from Herb’s desk fitted neatly into the
hefty padlock on the locker, and I swung open the door.
The receptionist and I leaned back. It smelled more
than a just a bit.
There was a dark blue bag in the locker with a pair
of off-white training shoes placed on top, and I think it was the
shoes, rather than the clothes inside the bag, that were the
culprits as far as the smell was concerned. Perhaps Herb had
suffered from some sort of foot-fungal problem that had spread to
his shoes and then clearly festered badly there over the last three
weeks. But whatever the cause, the smell was pretty rank.
“Sorry about this,” I said. “I’ll get rid of it
all.”
I tucked the offending shoes into the bag on top of
the clothes and left the receptionist tut-tutting about having to
disinfect all the lockers.
I walked back towards Lombard Street and dumped the
whole thing, together with all the contents, into a City of
London–crested street litter basket. I didn’t think Mrs. McDowd
would be very happy if I took that smell back into the
office.
I had walked nearly a hundred yards farther on when
I suddenly turned around and retraced my steps. I had searched
everything else of Herb’s. Why not that blue bag?
Neatly stacked, in a zipped-up compartment beneath
the clothes, was over a hundred and eighty thousand pounds wrapped
in clear plastic sandwich bags, three thousand in twenty-pound
notes in each bag. There was also a list of ninety-seven names and
addresses, all of them in America.
Good old Herb. As meticulous as ever.
Mr. Patrick would like to see you,” Mrs.
McDowd said to me as I skipped through the door with the bag of
loot over my shoulder. “In his office, right now.”
Patrick was not alone. Jessica Winter was also
there.
“Ah, Nicholas,” said Patrick. “Come and sit down.”
I sat in the spare chair next to the open window. “Jessica and I
have been looking at how things stand. We need to implement a
damage-control exercise. To maintain the confidence of our clients
and to assure them that it’s ‘business as usual’ at Lyall and
Black.”
“And is it business as usual?” I asked.
“Of course,” he said. “Why wouldn’t it be?”
I thought that was pretty obvious. Members of the
Fraud Squad were still in the room next door, bagging up
evidence.
“No,” Patrick went on, “we mustn’t let this little
setback disrupt our work. I will write to all of Gregory’s clients,
telling them that for the time being I will be looking after their
portfolios. It will just mean we all have to work a little harder
for a while.”
But for how long, I wondered?
The maximum sentence for conspiracy to murder was
life imprisonment.
“So how about the Bulgarian business?” I
asked.
“Jessica and I have just been looking at it,”
Patrick said. “Or what is left to look at after those damn police
have been in here taking stuff away.”
“And?” I asked.
“It’s rather inconclusive,” Jessica said.
“What’s inconclusive?” I asked, somewhat
surprised.
“There seems to be no evidence to show if the
original investment was obtained by fraudulent means, or whether
there was any purposeful deception by anyone in this firm,” Jessica
said.
She’s covering her back, I thought.
“But how about the European Union grants?” I
said.
“They are not our business,” Patrick said sharply.
“Neither Gregory individually nor Lyall and Black as a firm can be
held responsible for the actions of people in Brussels, those who
may have issued EU grants without due diligence. The only matter
that affects this firm is the original Roberts Family Trust
investment and then only if we were knowingly negligent in
brokering it. As far as we can establish, the investment idea was
put forward by the senior trustee of the trust.”
I had to admit, it was a persuasive argument,
especially as Viscount Shenington was unlikely to be in any state
to refute it. Perhaps I had been a tad premature in writing off the
future of Lyall & Black.
But that didn’t explain what had happened to Herb
Kovak, and it didn’t explain Shenington’s comment about me being
difficult to kill and not turning up where I was expected. The only
place I’d been expected had been the offices of Lyall & Black
and the only people who had known where I’d been expected had been
the firm’s staff. Gregory must have at least discussed the matter
of my murder with Shenington. That alone would have been enough to
convict him.
“What about the photographs that Gregory showed to
Colonel Roberts?” I said. “The ones that purported to prove that
the factory and houses had already been built.”
“Gregory told me this morning that he’d been sent
those by the developer in Bulgaria and in good faith,” said
Patrick. “He’d had no reason to doubt their authenticity.”
“Not until Jolyon Roberts asked about them,” I
said. “What did he do then?”
“Gregory told me that Colonel Roberts didn’t
exactly say that he questioned whether the photos were accurate or
not. In fact, Gregory said that Roberts kept contradicting himself
and changing his mind throughout their final telephone conversation
and he kept apologizing all the time for wasting Gregory’s time. In
the end, Gregory wasn’t quite sure what to think.”
I could believe it. Jolyon Roberts had done exactly
the same with me at Cheltenham. I thought it strange that a man who
had clearly been so decisive on the battlefield could have been so
befuddled and incoherent when it came to accusing a friend of lying
and of stealing from him. I suppose it was all about family honor,
and not losing face.
“Thank you, Jessica,” Patrick said. “You can be
getting back to your office now.”
Jessica stood up and left. I remained where I
was.
“Now, Nicholas,” said Patrick when the door was
shut, “I have decided to overlook your rather strange behavior over
the past three weeks and to wipe the slate clean. Your job is still
yours if you want it. To be honest, I don’t know how we would
manage at the moment if you weren’t here.”
So was that a vote of confidence in my ability, I
wondered, or a decision born simply out of necessity?
“Thank you,” I said. “I’ll think about it.”
“Don’t take too long about it,” Patrick said. “It’s
time to put other things out of your mind and get back to
work.”
“I’m still not happy about things,” I said.
“Especially the fraud.”
“Suspected fraud,” he corrected. “If you ask me, it
is a shame you ever went to see Roberts’s nephew in Oxford.”
“Maybe,” I said.
“Well, go now and get on with your work, I have
things to do.”
It was a dismissal, so I stood up and went back to
my desk.
I was still greatly troubled by Patrick’s and
Jessica’s seeming brush-off of such a serious situation.
Herb had accessed the file and then he was
killed.
Shenington and his gunmen knew more about my
movements than they could have done without someone in the firm
passing on the information.
Something wasn’t right. I could tell because the
hairs on my neck refused to lie down. Something definitely wasn’t
right. Not right at all.
I took out a sheet of paper from a drawer and wrote
out again a copy of the note I had found in Herb’s coat
pocket.
YOU SHOULD HAVE DONE WHAT YOU WERE
TOLD. YOU MAY SAY YOU REGRET IT, BUT
YOU WONT BE REGRETTING IT FOR LONG.
TOLD. YOU MAY SAY YOU REGRET IT, BUT
YOU WONT BE REGRETTING IT FOR LONG.
I wrote it out in capital letters, using a black
ballpoint pen, so that it looked identical to the original.
I picked up my mobile phone and the note and went
down the corridor. I walked into Patrick’s office, closing the door
behind me.
“Yes?” he asked, showing some surprise at my
unannounced entrance.
I stood in front of his desk, looking down at him
as if it was the first time I had ever seen him properly.
“What did you tell Herb to do?” I asked him
quietly.
“What do you mean?” he replied with a quizzical
expression.
“You told him that he should have done what he was
told,” I said.
I laid the note down on the table, facing him, so
that he could read the words.
“What was it you told Herb to do?”
“Nicholas,” he said, looking up at me and betraying
a slight nervousness in his voice, “I don’t know what you’re
talking about.”
“Yes, you do,” I said with some menace. “It was you
all along, not Gregory. You devised the fraud, you found Shenington
to put up the five million from his family trust, and you saw to it
that you weren’t found out.”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” he said
again, but his eyes showed me he did.
“And you had Herb killed,” I said. “You even wrote
this note to him as a sort of apology. Everyone liked Herb,
including you. But he had to die, didn’t he? Because he had
accessed the Roberts file and he’d worked out what was going on.
What did you do? Offer him a piece of the action? Try and buy his
silence? But Herb wasn’t having any of that, was he? Herb was going
to go to the authorities, wasn’t he? So he had to die.”
Patrick sat in his chair, looking up at me. He said
nothing.
“And it was you that tried to have me killed
as well,” I said. “You sent the gunman to my house in Finchley and
then, when that didn’t work, you sent him to my mother’s cottage to
kill me there.”
He remained in his chair, staring at me through his
oversized glasses.
“But that didn’t work either,” I said. “So you
arranged for me to come here on Monday for a meeting with you and
Gregory.” I laughed. “A meeting with my Maker, more like. But I
didn’t come, although you tried hard to convince me to. Then I saw
you on the train, and you said, ‘Come home with me now, and we’ll
sort this out tonight.’ But I’d have been dead if I had, wouldn’t
I?” I paused and stared back at him. He still said nothing. “So
then Shenington changed his mind about talking to me and invited me
to be his guest at the races in order to complete the job.”
“Nicholas,” Patrick said, finally finding his
voice, “what is all this nonsense?”
“It’s not nonsense,” I said. “I never told you that
I’d been to see Mr. Roberts’s nephew in Oxford. In fact, I’d
purposely not told you because I didn’t want anyone knowing
my movements. I just told you that I’d spoken to him. For all you
knew, it could have been on the telephone. But Shenington told you
that I went to Oxford to meet his son, didn’t he? And you repeated
it to me just now.”
“You have no proof,” he said, changing his
tune.
“Did you know that you can get fingerprints from
paper?” I asked, picking up the note carefully by the corner.
He wasn’t to know that the original had already
been tested by the Merseyside Police forensic department and found
to have only my and Herb’s prints on it.
His shoulders sagged just a fraction, and he looked
down at the desk.
“What did Herb say he regretted?” I asked.
“He said he regretted finding out,” Patrick said
wistfully with a sigh. “I was careless. I stupidly left a document
under the flap of the photocopier. Herb found it.”
“So what did you tell him to do?” I asked for a
third time.
“To accept what he’d been offered,” he said,
looking up at me. “But he wanted more. Much more. It was too
much.”
Herb had clearly not been as much of a saint as I’d
made out.
“So you had him killed.”
He nodded. “Herb was a fool,” he said. “He should
have accepted my offer. It was very generous, and you can have the
same—a million euros.”
“You make me sick,” I said.
“Two million,” he said quickly. “It would make you
a rich man.”
“Blood money,” I said. “Is that the going rate
these days for covering up fraud, and murder?”
“Look,” he said, “I’m sorry about Herb. I liked
him, and I argued against having him killed, but the others
insisted.”
“Others?” I said. “You must mean Uri Joram and
Dimitar Petrov.”
He stared at me with his mouth open.
“Oh yes,” I said. “The police know all about Joram
and Petrov because I told them. I told them everything.”
“You bastard,” he said with feeling. “I wish Petrov
had killed you at the same time he shot Herb Kovak.”
Throughout the encounter I’d been holding my mobile
phone in my left hand. It was one of those fancy new do-anything
smart phones, and one of its functions was the ability to act as a
voice recorder.
I’d recorded every word that had been said.
I pushed the buttons and played back the last bit.
Patrick sat very still in his executive leather chair, listening,
and staring at me with a mixture of hatred and resignation in his
eyes.
“I wish Petrov had killed you at the same time he
shot Herb Kovak.”
It sounded rather metallic out of the telephone’s
tiny speaker, but there was no doubt that it was Patrick Lyall’s
voice.
“You bastard,” he said again.
I folded the note, turned away from him and walked
back along the corridor to my desk to call Chief Inspector
Tomlinson. But I’d only just picked up the telephone when there was
a piercing scream from outside the building.
I stuck my head out through the window.
Patrick was lying faceup in the middle of the road,
and there was already a small pool of blood spreading out around
his head.
He had taken the quick way down from our
fourth-floor offices.
Straight down.
And it had been the death of him.