CHAPTER ONE
Marriage
and Surprises

MARRIAGE IS A FRIENDSHIP RECOGNIZED BY THE
POLICE.
--Robert Louis
Stevenson
Late one afternoon in the summer of 2006, I found
myself in a small village in northern Vietnam, sitting around a
sooty kitchen fire with a number of local women whose language I
did not speak, trying to ask them questions about marriage.
For several months already, I had been traveling
across Southeast Asia with a man who was soon to become my husband.
I suppose the conventional term for such an individual would be
"fiance," but neither one of us was very comfortable with that
word, so we weren't using it. In fact, neither one of us was very
comfortable with this whole idea of matrimony at all. Marriage was
not something we had ever planned with each other, nor was it
something either of us wanted. Yet providence had interfered with
our plans, which was why we were now wandering haphazardly across
Vietnam, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, and Indonesia, all the while
making urgent--even desperate--efforts to return to America and
wed.
The man in question had been my lover, my
sweetheart, for over two years by then, and in these pages I shall
call him Felipe. Felipe is a kind, affectionate Brazilian
gentleman, seventeen years my senior, whom I'd met on another
journey (an actual planned journey) that I'd taken around the world
a few years earlier in an effort to mend a severely broken heart.
Near the end of those travels, I'd encountered Felipe, who had been
living quietly and alone in Bali for years, nursing his own broken
heart. What had followed was attraction, then a slow courtship, and
then, much to our mutual wonderment, love.
Our resistance to marriage, then, had nothing to
do with an absence of love. On the contrary, Felipe and I loved
each other unreservedly. We were happy to make all sorts of
promises to stay together faithfully forever. We had even sworn
lifelong fidelity to each other already, although quite privately.
The problem was that the two of us were both survivors of bad
divorces, and we'd been so badly gutted by our experiences that the
very idea of legal marriage--with anyone,
even with such nice people as each other--filled us with a heavy
sense of dread.
As a rule, of course, most divorces are pretty
bad (Rebecca West observed that "getting a divorce is nearly always
as cheerful and useful an occupation as breaking very valuable
china"), and our divorces had been no exception. On the mighty
cosmic one-to-ten Scale of Divorce Badness (where one equals an
amicably executed separation, and ten equals . . . well, an actual
execution), I would probably rate my own divorce as something like
a 7.5. No suicides or homicides had resulted, but aside from that,
the rupture had been about as ugly a proceeding as two otherwise
well-mannered people could have possibly manifested. And it had
dragged on for more than two years.
As for Felipe, his first marriage (to an
intelligent, professional Australian woman) had ended almost a
decade before we'd met in Bali. His divorce had unfolded graciously
enough at the time, but losing his wife (and access to the house
and kids and almost two decades of history that came along with
her) had inflicted on this good man a lingering legacy of sadness,
with special emphases on regret, isolation, and economic
anxiety.
Our experiences, then, had left the two of us
taxed, troubled, and decidedly suspicious of the joys of holy
wedded matrimony. Like anyone who has ever walked through the
valley of the shadow of divorce, Felipe and I had each learned
firsthand this distressing truth: that every intimacy carries,
secreted somewhere below its initial lovely surfaces, the
ever-coiled makings of complete catastrophe. We had also learned
that marriage is an estate that is very much easier to enter than
it is to exit. Unfenced by law, the unmarried lover can quit a bad
relationship at any time. But you--the legally married person who
wants to escape doomed love--may soon discover that a significant
portion of your marriage contract belongs to the State, and that it
sometimes takes a very long while for the State to grant you your
leave. Thus, you can feasibly find yourself trapped for months or
even years in a loveless legal bond that has come to feel rather
like a burning building. A burning building in which you, my
friend, are handcuffed to a radiator somewhere down in the
basement, unable to wrench yourself free, while the smoke billows
forth and the rafters are collapsing . . .
I'm sorry--does all this sound
unenthusiastic?
I share these unpleasant thoughts only to
explain why Felipe and I had made a rather unusual pact with each
other, right from the beginning of our love story. We had sworn
with all our hearts to never, ever, under any circumstances, marry.
We had even promised never to blend together our finances or our
worldly assets, in order to avoid the potential nightmare of ever
again having to divvy up an explosive personal munitions dump of
shared mortgages, deeds, property, bank accounts, kitchen
appliances, and favorite books. These promises having been duly
pledged, the two of us proceeded forth into our carefully
partitioned companionship with a real sense of calmness. For just
as a sworn engagement can bring to so many other couples a
sensation of encircling protection, our vow never to marry had cloaked the two of us in all the
emotional security we required in order to try once more at love.
And this commitment of ours--consciously devoid of official
commitment--felt miraculous in its liberation. It felt as though we
had found the Northwest Passage of Perfect Intimacy--something
that, as Garcia Marquez wrote, "resembled love, but without the
problems of love."
So that's what we'd been doing up until the
spring of 2006: minding our own business, building a delicately
divided life together in unfettered contentment. And that is very
well how we might have gone on living happily ever after, except
for one terribly inconvenient interference.
The United States Department of Homeland
Security got involved.

The trouble was that Felipe and I--while we
shared many similarities and blessings--did not happen to share a
nationality. He was a Brazilian-born man with Australian
citizenship who, when we met, had been living mostly in Indonesia.
I was an American woman who, my travels aside, had been living
mostly on the East Coast of the United States. We didn't initially
foresee any problems with our countryless love story, although in
retrospect perhaps we should have anticipated complications. As the
old adage goes: A fish and a bird may indeed fall in love, but
where shall they live? The solution to this dilemma, we believed,
was that we were both nimble travelers (I was a bird who could dive
and Felipe was a fish who could fly), so for our first year
together, at least, we basically lived in midair--diving and flying
across oceans and continents in order to be together.
Our work lives, fortunately enough, facilitated
such footloose arrangements. As a writer, I could carry my job with
me anyplace. As a jewelry and gemstone importer who sold his goods
in the United States, Felipe always needed to be traveling anyhow.
All we had to do was coordinate our locomotion. So I would fly to
Bali; he would come to America; we would both go to Brazil; we
would meet up again in Sydney. I took a temporary job teaching
writing at the University of Tennessee, and for a few curious
months we lived together in a decaying old hotel room in Knoxville.
(I can recommend that living arrangement,
by the way, to anyone who wants to test out the actual
compatibility levels of a new relationship.)
We lived at a staccato rhythm, on the hoof,
mostly together but ever on the move, like witnesses in some odd
international protection program. Our relationship--though
steadying and calm at the personal level--was a constant logistical
challenge, and what with all that international air travel, it was
bloody expensive. It was also psychologically jarring. With each
reunion, Felipe and I had to learn each other all over again. There
was always that nervous moment at the airport when I would stand
there waiting for him to arrive, wondering, Will I still know him? Will he still know me? After
the first year, then, we both began to long for something more
stable, and Felipe was the one who made the big move. Giving up his
modest but lovely cottage in Bali, he moved with me to a tiny house
I had recently rented on the outskirts of Philadelphia.
While trading Bali for the suburbs of Philly may
seem a peculiar choice, Felipe swore that he had long ago grown
tired of life in the tropics. Living in Bali was too easy, he
complained, with each day a pleasant, boring replica of the day
before. He had been longing to leave for some time already, he
insisted, even before he'd met me. Now, growing bored with paradise
might be impossible to understand for someone who has never
actually lived in paradise (I certainly found the notion a bit
crazy), yet Bali's dreamland setting honestly had come to feel
oppressively dull to Felipe over the years. I will never forget one
of the last enchanting evenings that he and I spent together at his
cottage there--sitting outside, barefoot and dewy-skinned from the
warm November air, drinking wine and watching a sea of
constellations flicker above the rice fields. As the perfumed winds
rustled the palm trees and as faint music from a distant temple
ceremony floated on the breeze, Felipe looked at me, sighed, and
said flatly, "I'm so sick of this shit. I can't wait to go back to
Philly."
So--to Philadelphia (city of brotherly potholes)
we duly decamped! The fact is we both liked the area a lot. Our
little rental was near my sister and her family, whose proximity
had become vital to my happiness over the years, so that brought
familiarity. Moreover, after all our collective years of travel to
far-flung places, it felt good and even revitalizing to be living
in America, a country which, for all its flaws, was still interesting to both of us: a fast-moving,
multicultural, ever-evolving, maddeningly contradictory, creatively
challenging, and fundamentally alive sort of place.
There in Philadelphia, then, Felipe and I set up
headquarters and practiced, with encouraging success, our first
real sessions of shared domesticity. He sold his jewelry; I worked
on writing projects that required me to stay in one place and
conduct research. He cooked; I took care of the lawn; every once in
a while one of us would fire up the vacuum cleaner. We worked well
together in a home, dividing our daily chores without strife. We
felt ambitious and productive and optimistic. Life was nice.
But such intervals of stability could never last
long. Because of Felipe's visa restrictions, three months was the
maximum amount of time that he could legally stay in America before
he would have to excuse himself to another country for a spell. So
off he would fly, and I would be alone with my books and my
neighbors while he was gone. Then, after a few weeks, he'd return
to the United States on another ninety-day visa and we'd recommence
our domestic life together. It is a testament to how warily we both
regarded long-term commitment that these ninety-day chunks of
togetherness felt just about perfect for us: the exact amount of
future planning that two tremulous divorce survivors could manage
without feeling too threatened. And sometimes, when my schedule
allowed, I would join him on his visa runs out of the
country.
This explains why one day we were returning to
the States together from a business trip overseas and we
landed--due to the peculiarity of our cheap tickets and our
connecting flight--at the Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport.
I passed through Immigration first, moving easily through the line
of my fellow repatriating American citizens. Once on the other
side, I waited for Felipe, who was in the middle of a long line of
foreigners. I watched as he approached the immigration official,
who carefully studied Felipe's bible-thick Australian passport,
scrutinizing every page, every mark, every hologram. Normally they
were not so vigilant, and I grew nervous at how long this was
taking. I watched and waited, listening for the all-important sound
of any successful border crossing: that thick, solid,
librarian-like thunk of a welcoming
visa-entry stamp. But it never came.
Instead, the immigration official picked up his
phone and made a quiet call. Moments later, an officer wearing the
uniform of the United States Department of Homeland Security came
and took my baby away.

The uniformed men at the Dallas airport held
Felipe in interrogation for six hours. For six hours, forbidden to
see him or ask questions, I sat there in a Homeland Security
waiting room--a bland, fluorescent-lit space filled with
apprehensive people from all over the world, all of us equally
rigid with fear. I had no idea what they were doing to Felipe back
there or what they were asking from him. I knew that he had not
broken any laws, but this was not as comforting a thought as you
might imagine. These were the late years of George W. Bush's
presidential administration: not a relaxing moment in history to
have your foreign-born sweetheart held in government custody. I
kept trying to calm myself with the famous prayer of the
fourteenth-century mystic Juliana of Norwich ("All shall be well,
and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well"), but
I didn't believe a word of it. Nothing was well. Not one single
manner of thing whatsoever was well.
Every once in a while I would stand up from my
plastic chair and try to elicit more information from the
immigration officer behind the bulletproof glass. But he ignored my
pleas, each time reciting the same response: "When we have
something to tell you about your boyfriend, miss, we'll let you
know."
In a situation like this, may I just say, there
is perhaps no more feeble-sounding word in the English language
than boyfriend. The dismissive manner in
which the officer uttered that word indicated how unimpressed he
was with my relationship. Why on earth should a government employee
ever release information about a mere boyfriend? I longed to explain myself to the
immigration officer, to say, "Listen, the man you are detaining
back there is far more important to me than you could ever begin to
imagine." But even in my anxious state, I doubted this would do any
good. If anything, I feared that pushing things too far might bring
unpleasant repercussions on Felipe's end, so I backed off,
helpless. It occurs to me only now that I probably should have made
an effort to call a lawyer. But I didn't have a telephone with me,
and I didn't want to abandon my post in the waiting room, and I
didn't know any lawyers in Dallas, and it was a Sunday afternoon,
anyhow, so who could I have reached?
Finally, after six hours, an officer came and
led me through some hallways, through a rabbit warren of
bureaucratic mysteries, to a small, dimly lit room where Felipe was
sitting with the Homeland Security officer who had been
interrogating him. Both men looked equally tired, but only one of
those men was mine--my beloved, the most
familiar face in the world to me. Seeing him in such a state made
my chest hurt with longing. I wanted to touch him, but I sensed
this was not allowed, so I remained standing.
Felipe smiled at me wearily and said, "Darling,
our lives are about to get a lot more interesting."
Before I could respond, the interrogating
officer quickly took charge of the situation and all its
explanations.
"Ma'am," he said, "we've brought you back here
to explain that we will not be allowing your boyfriend to enter the
United States anymore. We'll be detaining him in jail until we can
get him on a flight out of the country, back to Australia, since he
does have an Australian passport. After that, he won't be able to
come back to America again."
My first reaction was physical. I felt as if all
the blood in my body had instantly evaporated, and my eyes refused
to focus for a moment. Then, in the next instant, my mind kicked
into action. I revved through a fast summation of this sudden,
grave crisis. Starting long before we had met, Felipe had made his
living in the United States, visiting several times a year for
short stays, legally importing gemstones and jewelry from Brazil
and Indonesia for sale in American markets. America has always
welcomed international businessmen like him; they bring merchandise
and money and commerce into the country. In return, Felipe had
prospered in America. He'd put his kids (who were now adults)
through the finest private schools in Australia with income that
he'd made in America over the decades. America was the center of
his professional life, even though he'd never lived here until very
recently. But his inventory was here and all his contacts were
here. If he could never come back to America again, his livelihood
was effectively destroyed. Not to mention the fact that I lived
here in the United States, and that Felipe wanted to be with me,
and that--because of my family and my work--I would always want to
remain based in America. And Felipe had become part of my family,
too. He'd been fully embraced by my parents, my sister, my friends,
my world. So how would we continue our life together if he were
forever banned? What would we do? ("Where will
you and I sleep?" go the lyrics to a mournful Wintu love song.
"At the down-turned jagged rim of the sky?
Where will you and
I sleep?")
"On what grounds are you deporting him?" I asked
the Homeland Security officer, trying to sound authoritative.
"Strictly speaking, ma'am, it's not a
deportation." Unlike me, the officer didn't have to try sounding
authoritative; it came naturally. "We're just refusing him entrance
to the United States on the grounds that he's been visiting America
too frequently in the last year. He's never overstayed his visa
limits, but it does appear from all his comings and goings that
he's been living with you in Philadelphia for three-month periods
and then leaving the country, only to return to the United States
again immediately after."
This was difficult to argue, since that was
precisely what Felipe had been doing.
"Is that a crime?" I asked.
"Not exactly."
"Not exactly, or no?"
"No, ma'am, it's not a crime. That's why we
won't be arresting him.
But the three-month visa waiver that the United
States government offers to citizens of friendly countries is not
intended for indefinite consecutive visits."
"But we didn't know that," I said.
Felipe stepped in now. "In fact, sir, we were
once told by an immigration officer in New York that I could visit
the United States as often as I liked, as long as I never
overstayed my ninety-day visa."
"I don't know who told you that, but it isn't
true."
Hearing the officer say this reminded me of a
warning Felipe had given me once about international border
crossings: "Never take it lightly, darling. Always remember that on
any given day, for any given reason whatsoever, any given border
guard in the world can decide that he does not want to let you
in."
"What would you do now, if you were in our
situation?" I asked. This is a technique I've learned to use over
the years whenever I find myself at an impasse with a dispassionate
customer service operator or an apathetic bureaucrat. Phrasing the
sentence in such a manner invites the person who has all the power
to pause for a moment and put himself in the shoes of the person
who is powerless. It's a subtle appeal to empathy. Sometimes it
helps. Most of the time, to be honest, it doesn't help at all. But
I was willing to try anything here.
"Well, if your boyfriend ever wants to come back
into the United States again, he's going to need to secure himself
a better, more permanent visa. If I were you, I would go about
securing him one."
"Okay, then," I said. "What's the fastest way
for us to secure him a better, more permanent visa?"
The Homeland Security officer looked at Felipe,
then at me, then back at Felipe. "Honestly?" he said. "The two of
you need to get married."

My heart sank, almost audibly. Across the tiny
room, I could sense Felipe's heart sinking along with mine, in
complete hollow tandem.
In retrospect, it does seem unbelievable that
this proposition could possibly have taken me by surprise. Had I
never heard of a green card marriage before, for heaven's sake?
Maybe it also seems unbelievable that--given the urgent nature of
our circumstances--the suggestion of matrimony brought me distress
instead of relief. I mean, at least we'd been given an option,
right? Yet the proposition did take me by surprise. And it did
hurt. So thoroughly had I barred the very notion of marriage from
my psyche that hearing the idea spoken aloud now felt shocking. I
felt mournful and sucker punched and heavy and banished from some
fundamental aspect of my being, but most of all I felt caught. I felt we had both been caught. The flying
fish and the diving bird had been netted.
And my naivete, not for the first time in my life, I'm afraid,
struck me across the face like a wet slap: Why
had I been so foolish as to imagine that we could get away with
living our lives as we pleased forever?
Nobody spoke for a while, until the Homeland
Security interrogation officer, regarding our silent faces of doom,
asked, "Sorry, folks. What seems to be the problem with this
idea?"
Felipe took off his glasses and rubbed his
eyes--a sign, I knew from long experience, of utter exhaustion. He
sighed, and said, "Oh, Tom, Tom, Tom . . ."
I had not yet realized that these two were on a
first-name basis, though I suppose that's bound to happen during a
six-hour interrogation session. Especially when the interrogatee is
Felipe.
"No, seriously--what's the problem?" asked
Officer Tom. "You two have obviously been cohabiting already. You
obviously care about each other, you're not married to anyone else
. . ."
"What you have to understand, Tom," explained
Felipe, leaning forward and speaking with an intimacy which belied
our institutional surroundings, "is that Liz and I have both been
through really, really bad divorces in the past."
Officer Tom made a small noise--a sort of soft,
sympathetic "Oh . . ." Then he took off his
own glasses and rubbed his own eyes. Instinctively, I glanced at
the third finger of his left hand. No wedding ring. From that bare
left hand and from his reflexive reaction of tired commiseration I
made a quick diagnosis: divorced.
It was here that our interview turned
surreal.
"Well, you could always sign a prenuptial
agreement," Officer Tom suggested. "I mean, if you're worried about
going through all the financial mess of a divorce again. Or if it's
the relationship issues that scare you, maybe some counseling would
be a good idea."
I listened in wonder. Was a
deputy of the United States Department of Homeland Security giving
us marital advice? In an interrogation
room? In the bowels of the Dallas/Fort Worth International
Airport?
Finding my voice, I offered this brilliant
solution: "Officer Tom, what if I just found a way to somehow
hire Felipe, instead of marrying him?
Couldn't I bring him to America as my employee, instead of my
husband?"
Felipe sat up straight and exclaimed, "Darling!
What a terrific idea!"
Officer Tom gave us each an odd look. He asked
Felipe, "You would honestly rather have this woman as your boss
than your wife?"
"Dear God, yes!"
I could sense Officer Tom almost physically
restraining himself from asking, "What the hell kind of people
are you?" But he was far too professional
for anything like that. Instead, he cleared his throat and said,
"Unfortunately, what you have just proposed here is not legal in
this country."
Felipe and I both slumped again, once more in
complete tandem, into a depressed silence.
After a long spell of this, I spoke again. "All
right," I said, defeated. "Let's get this over with. If I marry
Felipe right now, right here in your office, will you let him into
the country today? Maybe you have a chaplain here at the airport
who could do that?"
There are moments in life when the face of an
ordinary man can take on a quality of near-divinity, and this is
just what happened now. Tom--a weary, badge-wearing, Texan Homeland
Security officer with a paunch--smiled at me with a sadness, a
kindness, a luminous compassion that was utterly out of place in
this stale, dehumanizing room. Suddenly, he looked like a chaplain
himself.
"Oh no-o-o . . . ," he said gently. "I'm afraid
things don't work that way."
Looking back on it all now, of course I realize
that Officer Tom already knew what was facing Felipe and me, far
better than we ourselves could have known. He well knew that
securing an official United States fiance visa, particularly after
a "border incident" such as this one, would be no small feat.
Officer Tom could foresee all the trouble that was now coming to
us: from the lawyers in three countries--on three continents, no
less--who would have to secure all the necessary legal documents;
to the federal police reports that would be required from every
country in which Felipe had ever lived; to the stacks of personal
letters, photos, and other intimate ephemera which we would now
have to compile to prove that our relationship was real (including,
with maddening irony, such evidence as shared bank
accounts--details we'd specifically gone through an awful lot of
trouble in our lives to keep separated); to
the fingerprinting; to the inoculations; to the requisite
tuberculosis-screening chest X-rays; to the interviews at the
American embassies abroad; to the military records that we would
somehow have to recover of Felipe's Brazilian army service
thirty-five years earlier; to the sheer expanse and expense of time
that Felipe now would have to spend out of the country while this
process played itself out; to--worst of all--the horrible
uncertainty of not knowing whether any of this effort would be
enough, which is to say, not knowing whether the United States
government (behaving, in this regard, rather much like a stern,
old-fashioned father) would ever even accept this man as a husband
for me, its jealously guarded natural-born daughter.
So Officer Tom already knew all that, and the
fact that he expressed sympathy toward us for what we were about to
undergo was an unexpected turn of kindness in an otherwise
devastating situation. That I never, prior to this moment, imagined
myself praising a member of the Department of Homeland Security in
print for his personal tenderness only highlights how bizarre this
whole situation had become. But I should say here that Officer Tom
did us one other kind deed, as well. (That is, before he handcuffed
Felipe and led him off to the Dallas county jail, depositing him
for the night in a cell filled with actual criminals.) The gesture
that Officer Tom made was this: He left me and Felipe alone
together in the interrogation room for two whole minutes, so that
we could say our good-byes to each other in privacy.
When you have only two minutes to say good-bye
to the person you love most in the world, and you don't know when
you'll see each other again, you can become logjammed with the
effort to say and do and settle everything at once. In our two
minutes alone in the interrogation room, then, we made a hasty,
breathless plan. I would go home to Philadelphia, move out of our
rented house, put everything into storage, secure an immigration
lawyer and start this legal process moving. Felipe, of course,
would go to jail. Then he would be deported back to Australia--even
if, strictly speaking, he wasn't being legally "deported." (Please
forgive me for using the word "deported" throughout the pages of
this book, but I'm still not sure what else to call it when a
person gets thrown out of a country.) Since Felipe had no life in
Australia anymore, no home or financial prospects, he would make
arrangements as quickly as possible to go somewhere cheaper to
live--Southeast Asia, probably--and I would join him on that side
of the world once I got things rolling on my end. There, we would
wait out this indefinite period of uncertainty together.
While Felipe jotted down the phone numbers of
his lawyer, his grown children, and his business partners so that I
could alert everyone to his situation, I emptied out my handbag,
frantically looking for things I could give him to keep him more
comfortable in jail: chewing gum, all my cash, a bottle of water, a
photograph of us together, and a novel I had been reading on the
airplane titled, aptly enough, The People's Act
of Love.
Then Felipe's eyes filled with tears and he
said, "Thank you for coming into my life. No matter what happens
now, no matter what you decide to do next, just know that you've
given me the two most joyful years I've ever known and I will never
forget you."
I realized in a flash: Dear
God, the man thinks I might leave him now. His reaction
surprised me and touched me, but more than anything it shamed me.
It had not crossed my mind, since Officer Tom had laid out the
option, that I would not now marry Felipe
and save him from exile--but apparently it had crossed his mind that he might now be ditched. He genuinely
feared that I might abandon him, leaving him high and dry, broke
and busted. Had I earned such a reputation? Was I really known,
even within the boundaries of our small love story, as somebody who
jumps ship at the first obstacle? But were Felipe's fears entirely
unjustified, given my history? If our situations had been reversed,
I would never have doubted for a moment the solidity of his
loyalties, or his willingness to sacrifice virtually anything on my
account. Could he be certain of the same steadfastness from
me?
I had to admit that if this state of affairs had
taken place ten or fifteen years earlier, I almost certainly would
have bailed out on my endangered partner. I am sorry to confess
that I possessed a scant amount of honor in my youth, if any, and
behaving in a flighty and thoughtless manner was a bit of a
specialty of mine. But being a person of character matters to me
now, and matters only more as I grow older. At that moment,
then--and I had only one moment left alone with Felipe--I did the
only right thing by this man whom I adored. I vowed to
him--drilling the words into his ear so he would grasp my
earnestness--that I would not leave him, that I would do whatever
it took to fix things, and that even if things could not somehow be
fixed in America, we would always stay together anyhow, somewhere,
wherever in the world that had to be.
Officer Tom came back into the room.
At the last instant, Felipe whispered to me, "I
love you so much, I will even marry you."
"And I love you so
much," I promised, "that I will even marry you."
Then the nice Homeland Security people separated
us and handcuffed Felipe and led him away--first to jail and then
off to exile.

As I flew home alone that night to our
now-obsolete little existence in Philadelphia, I considered more
soberly what I had just promised. I was surprised to find that I
was not feeling weepy or panicky; somehow the situation seemed too
grave for any of that. What I felt, instead, was a ferocious sense
of focus--a sense that this situation must be addressed with the
utmost seriousness. In the space of only a few hours, my life with
Felipe had been neatly flipped upside down, as though by some great
cosmic spatula. And now, it seemed, we were engaged to be married.
This had certainly been a strange and rushed engagement ceremony.
It felt more like something out of Kafka than out of Austen. Yet
the engagement was nonetheless official because it needed to
be.
Fine, then. So be it. I would certainly not be
the first woman in my family's history who ever had to get married
because of a serious situation--although my situation, at least,
did not involve accidental pregnancy. Still, the prescription was
the same: Tie the knot, and do it quickly. So that's what we would
do. But here was the real problem, which I identified that night
all alone on the plane back home to Philadelphia: I had no idea
what marriage was.
I had already made this mistake--entering into
marriage without understanding anything whatsoever about the
institution--once before in my life. In fact, I had jumped into my
first marriage, at the totally unfinished age of twenty-five, much
the same way that a Labrador jumps into a swimming pool--with
exactly that much preparation and foresight. Back when I was
twenty-five, I was so irresponsible that I probably should not have
been allowed to choose my own toothpaste, much less my own future,
and so this carelessness, as you can imagine, came at a dear cost.
I reaped the consequences in spades, six years later, in the grim
setting of a divorce court.
Looking back on the occasion of my first wedding
day, I'm reminded of Richard Aldington's novel Death of a Hero, in which he ponders his two young
lovers on their ill-fated wedding day: "Can
one tabulate the ignorances, the relevant ignorances, of George
Augustus and Isabel when they pledged themselves together until
death do us part?" I, too, was once a giddy young bride very much
like Aldington's Isabel, about whom he wrote: "What she didn't know included almost the whole range of human
knowledge. The puzzle is to find out what she did know."
Now, though--at the considerably less giddy age
of thirty-seven--I was not convinced that I knew very much more
than ever about the realities of institutionalized companionship. I
had failed at marriage and thus I was terrified of marriage, but
I'm not sure this made me an expert on marriage; this only made me
an expert on failure and terror, and those particular fields are
already crowded with experts. Yet destiny had intervened and was
demanding marriage from me, and I'd learned enough from life's
experiences to understand that destiny's interventions can
sometimes be read as invitations for us to address and even
surmount our biggest fears. It doesn't take a great genius to
recognize that when you are pushed by circumstance to do the one
thing you have always most specifically loathed and feared, this
can be, at the very least, an interesting
growth opportunity.
So it slowly dawned on me on the airplane out of
Dallas--my world now turned back-to-front, my lover exiled, the two
of us having effectively been sentenced to marry--that perhaps I
should use this time to somehow make peace with the idea of
matrimony before I jumped into it once again. Perhaps it would be
wise to put a little effort into unraveling the mystery of what in
the name of God and human history this befuddling, vexing,
contradictory, and yet stubbornly enduring institution of marriage
actually is.

So that is what I did. For the next ten
months--while traveling with Felipe in a state of rootless exile
and while working like a dog to get him back into America so we
could safely wed (getting married in Australia or anywhere else in
the world, Officer Tom had warned us, would merely irritate the
Homeland Security Department and slow down our immigration process
even more)--the only thing I thought about, the only thing I read
about, and pretty much the only thing I talked about with anybody
was the perplexing subject of matrimony.
I enlisted my sister back home in Philadelphia
(who, conveniently, is an actual historian) to send me boxes of
books about marriage. Wherever Felipe and I happened to be staying,
I would lock myself up in our hotel room to study the books,
passing untold hours in the company of such eminent matrimonial
scholars as Stephanie Coontz and Nancy Cott--writers whose names I
had never heard before but who now became my heroes and teachers.
To be honest, all this studying made me a lousy tourist. During
those months of travel, Felipe and I fetched up in many beautiful
and fascinating places, but I'm afraid I didn't always pay close
attention to our surroundings. This stretch of traveling never had
the feeling of a carefree adventure anyhow. It felt more like an
expulsion, a hegira. Traveling because you cannot go back home
again, because one of you is not legally allowed to go home again,
can never be an enjoyable endeavor.
Moreover, our financial situation was worrisome.
Eat, Pray, Love was less than a year away
from becoming a lucrative best seller, but that welcome development
had not yet occurred, nor did we anticipate its ever occurring.
Felipe was now completely cut off from his income source, so we
were both living off the fumes of my last book contract, and I
wasn't sure how long that would hold out. A while, yes--but not
forever. I had recently begun working on a new novel, but my
research and writing had now been interrupted by Felipe's
deportation. So this is how we ended up going to Southeast Asia,
where two frugal people can feasibly live on about thirty dollars a
day. While I won't say that we exactly suffered during this period
of exile (we were hardly starving political refugees, for heaven's
sake), I will say that it was an extremely odd and tense way to
live, with the oddness and tension only heightened by the
uncertainty of the outcome.
We wandered for close to a year, waiting for the
day when Felipe would be called to his interview at the American
Consulate in Sydney, Australia. Flopping in the meantime from
country to country, we came to resemble nothing more than an
insomniac couple trying to find a restful sleeping position in a
strange and uncomfortable bed. For many anxious nights, in many
strange and uncomfortable beds indeed, I would lie there in the
dark, working through my conflicts and prejudices about marriage,
filtering through all the information I was reading, mining history
for comforting conclusions.
I should clarify right away here that I limited
my studies largely to an examination of marriage in Western
history, and that this book will therefore reflect that cultural
limitation. Any proper matrimonial historian or anthropologist will
find huge gaps in my narrative, as I have left unexplored entire
continents and centuries of human history, not to mention skipping
over some pretty vital nuptial concepts (polygamy, as just one
example). It would have been pleasurable for me, and certainly
educational, to have delved more deeply into an examination of
every possible marital custom on earth, but I didn't have that kind
of time. Trying to get a handle on the complex nature of matrimony
in Islamic societies alone, for instance, would have taken me years
of study, and my urgency had a deadline that precluded such
extended contemplation. A very real clock was ticking in my life:
Within one year--like it or not, ready or not--I had to get
married. That being the case, it seemed imperative that I focus my
attention on unraveling the history of monogamous Western marriage
in order to better understand my inherited assumptions, the shape
of my family's narrative, and my culturally specific catalogue of
anxieties.
I hoped that all this studying might somehow
mitigate my deep aversion to marriage. I wasn't sure how that would
happen, but it had always been my experience in the past, anyhow,
that the more I learned about something, the less it frightened me.
(Some fears can be vanquished, Rumpelstiltskin-like, only by
uncovering their hidden, secret names.) What I really wanted, more
than anything, was to find a way to somehow embrace marriage to
Felipe when the big day came rather than merely swallowing my fate
like a hard and awful pill. Call me old-fashioned, but I thought it
might be a nice touch to be happy on my wedding day. Happy
and conscious, that is.
This book is the story of how I got there.
And it all begins--because every story must
begin somewhere--in the mountains of northern Vietnam.