Chapter 12
THE MEASURE OF A FOOL
SILENCE AWAKENED HUONG Van Nguyen. He sat up in
the pitch darkness from the mat where he had lain, covered by a
thin wool blanket. Bao sat up, too. The sudden lack of sound
outdoors had stirred him from his sleep as well. The elder Nguyen
brother snapped his fingers for the dog to come to him, but Turd
had long since gone from the thatched-roof house, following Mau Mau
Harris as he had slipped away while the two cowboys slept.
The American tried to make the motley pooch go back
to the farm, but the rotten cur would have none of it. He chose
James Harris the day he met him in Dogpatch, and he stubbornly
stuck by his friend. While the mutt liked Huong well enough, he
devoted himself to Harris. The black man could not make the animal
return to the dwelling without risking that the noise he made
urging the mongrel to stay home would awaken his two Vietnamese
cohorts. So with a shrug, he allowed the pet to tag along.
Mau Mau knew that if he had awakened Huong, and the
cowboy saw him trying to slip out, he might put a bullet in his
head. On the other hand, if he returned from his mission holding an
ear or finger along with James Elmore’s gold front tooth, proof
that he had killed the traitor, Huong might very well scold him for
his disobedience, but would likely congratulate him, too, for his
success in exacting revenge.

With Turd sniffing the ground close at his heels,
James Harris had sneaked out of the farmhouse, down the two steps
to the bare-earth front yard, and slipped into the forest. However,
as he stepped through the tall grass and into the trees, the
incessant, loud croaking and buzzing of the thousands of frogs that
lurked there went silent, spooked by his motion. The sudden
quietness made the Marine deserter jump. He knew that as lightly as
Huong slept, he might notice the change in the night sound and
awaken. Anxiety sent Harris running, with Turd loping at his
side.
After awakening and finding the dog and his master
missing, Huong walked outside, leaned against one of the front
porch’s four support columns, and lit a cigarette.
“He’s gone after that rat Elmo,” Bao said in
Vietnamese to his brother, spitting as he said the traitor James
Elmore’s name, and then lighting a cigarette. “Will you try to stop
him?”
“What do you think?” Huong asked, looking at
Bao.
“I say let the fool go,” Bao said, blowing out a
breath of smoke. “Maybe he can kill Elmo.”
Both men stood on the front porch, saying nothing
and thinking as they looked into the morning darkness and listened
as the voices of the frogs slowly returned.
“I think maybe the Marines that patrol the fences
at Chu Lai may very likely kill our foolish friend,” Huong said,
clenching his cigarette in his lips as he spoke to his brother in
their native language. “If Mau Mau remains lucky, though, the
Americans may only capture him. That troubles me. I worry that he
may talk of our plans and our money.”
“Then we should go after him,” Bao said, flicking
his spent butt onto the ground in front of the two steps that led
onto the wooden porch where he stood by his older brother.
“We have no hurry,” Huong said, and flicked his
cigarette onto the barren yard, too. “I know where he is going. He
told us yesterday, you may recall. Even if he runs the entire
distance it will take him several hours to travel forty kilometers.
We can drive near that place in thirty minutes, and maybe get a
shot at the fool before the guards capture him. For now, I think I
would like to drink some tea and eat a nice breakfast. It will take
us a good while to drive to Saigon, once we finish our business
here.”
Nearly an hour had passed before James Harris ever
slowed his fast jog to a more comfortable shuffle. The sense that
Huong may pursue him only moments away left his anxiety level
high.
Finally the Chicago native stopped to catch his
breath, and took several short chugs from a flat, round canteen of
water that he had filled from the farm’s well and had thrown across
his shoulder after he found it in the tool shack that morning. As
he left the house, he had sneaked into the shed to retrieve a bolo
knife with a foot-long inwardly curved blade that he had spotted
several days earlier. When he had first examined the razor-sharp
weapon, he considered that with one deft whack he could lob off
James Elmore’s head with it. So as he departed that morning, he
grabbed the canteen along with the knife and slipped it through his
belt opposite the .45-caliber Colt pistol he had hanging on his
other hip.
While in the shed, Harris had noticed a dusty,
oil-stained, olive green tarpaulin covering what he had thought
were only machine parts and other junk belonging to a dilapidated
mechanical rice thrasher that sat next to the pile. At first he
started not to look under the canvas, but then he thought that
Huong’s Viet Cong relatives who lived there might have hidden some
worthwhile weaponry there, too. As he folded back the cover he
found a grit-caked gallon can of thirty-weight motor oil and a
large wooden box filled with greasy parts to the thrashing machine.
Next to them, however, he also discovered two dusty cases of
sixty-millimeter mortar rounds and a wooden box with half a dozen
dirt-covered fragmentation hand grenades nestled on a heap of
corroded .30-caliber rifle rounds, their dingy brass casings turned
green with age. Mau Mau had smiled as he grabbed one of the
fist-size green bomblets and dropped it in the cargo pocket on the
right leg of his utility trousers.
“Why you always on my ass?” Harris whispered to the
dog as he knelt on the narrow trail that he followed south toward
Chu Lai, and poured water in his cupped hand for the mutt to drink.
Turd lapped the liquid with great thirst, and then shook a shower
of slobber onto Mau Mau’s face.
“Damn, you dumb motherfucker,” the deserter said,
wiping the splatter off his brow and cheeks with his upper sleeve
and shoulder. “That’s some nasty shit, Turd.”
Screwing the lid back on the canteen, James Harris
let it drop again to the rear part of his hip, where it rode
suspended by its green webbed-canvas shoulder strap. Then he gave
the bolo knife a tug to make sure it still held tight beneath his
belt, patted the hand grenade in his cargo pocket, and set off
jogging again as the new day’s gray light began to show color and
expose form where moments earlier shadows and blackness had
surrounded him. Ahead, he could now see a greater distance of the
trail he followed.
While he ran, he tried not to think of the Viet
Cong and North Vietnamese patrols that haunted this stretch of
countryside north of Chu Lai. Would they shoot a lone American
deserter and his dog should he cross the kill zone of their ambush?
Why waste all that on one man and a mutt? He considered the logic
and pressed onward, gambling his safety on his Chicago street
instincts and Turd’s innate sense of avoiding danger.
“FOR THE RECORD, please state your name,” Terry O’Connor said, standing behind the lectern between the defense and prosecution tables in the courtroom.
“Lance Corporal Wendell Carter,” the witness
recited, speaking with a clear voice, just as the defense lawyer
had instructed him to do.
“I see that you have recently been promoted from
private first class to lance corporal. Congratulations,” O’Connor
said, smiling at his leadoff witness.
“Yes, sir, thank you,” Carter answered, and beamed
a smile, too. “My squadron CO pinned it on me the day before
yesterday.”
“How long have you been on legal hold, Lance
Corporal Carter?” O’Connor asked, stepping from behind the lectern
to allow a barrier-free discourse of conversation to develop
between him and the star defense witness.
“Three months now, sir,” Carter answered, and
frowned.
“You miss your family, too, don’t you?” O’Connor
asked.
“Oh, sir, I miss them real bad,” Carter said,
shaking his head. “My mama, she pray for me every day, and just
about everyone else I know in Houston, too. They all wanting me
home.”
“So these three months on legal hold have taken
their toll,” O’Connor said, shaking his head, too.
“I want to go home, sir, but I keep my attitude
squared away. You know, I do what I got to do,” Carter said, and
nodded at the captain to put emphasis to his words.
“It’s easy to let go and have your attitude slide
downhill at times like this, isn’t it,” O’Connor said, nodding,
too.
“Well, sir, my mama taught me to do my best,
always, and let the good Lord sort out the difficulties,” Carter
said and smiled.
“You got yourself promoted, even on legal hold,”
O’Connor said, and walked back to the defense table and picked up
his notepad, glancing at the top page. “Says here that your
proficiency and conduct marks are 4.7 and 4.9 out of a possible
5.0, so you’re a pretty good Marine.”
“Sir, I pride myself at being a good Marine,”
Carter said, puffing out his chest.
“I think if the prosecution wanted to investigate
your record they would only find exemplary conduct, would they
not?” O’Connor said, laying his legal pad back on the table. Then
he walked back to the witness stand and put his hands on the rail
surrounding the plywood platform.
“How many security patrols have you gone on during
your tour?” O’Connor asked, and turned toward the jury as he
spoke.
“More than I care to count, sir,” Carter answered,
his eyes following the captain as he now stepped so that the
witness’s face looked at the six men seated in the side gallery
deciding the case.
“One a month?” O’Connor asked, crossing his
arms.
“No, sir, more like five, sometimes six a month,”
Carter answered.
“These patrols last how long?” O’Connor asked,
holding the witness’s face toward the jury.
“Mostly overnight, but sometimes we get tagged with
patrols that stay out for a week,” Carter said.
“You stand fire watch and guard duty, too?”
O’Connor asked, now leaning his hand on the rail that surrounded
the jury box.
“Yes, sir, that and perimeter watch, too,” Carter
said, nodding at the captain.
“Oh, yes, that, too,” O’Connor said, glancing back
at the jury.
“You’re a skilled radio repairman as well as a
communicator, are you not?” the captain then asked.
“Yes, sir, me and PFC Anderson, we work together in
the same shop over at Group Seventeen,” Carter answered.
“Well, if you’re on guard duty, fire watch,
perimeter watch, and half a dozen security patrols a month, when do
you work on radios?” O’Connor asked, and looked at the jury.
“I don’t get to do a whole lot of radio work, sir,”
Carter said, shaking his head.
“Do the white Marines pull the extra duty that you
do?” O’Connor asked, crossing his arms and frowning at the
witness.
“Sir, I don’t worry about what the white Marines
do. That’s how a guy ends up with a bad attitude,” Carter said, and
shook his head. “It’s tough enough just pulling the tour and
getting home. I don’t need to get my head all messed up thinking
about what the other Marines get.”
“Your mama taught you that, too?” O’Connor asked,
and smiled.
“Yes, sir, she did, as a matter of fact,” Carter
said, and held his head up. “We live pretty poor. Just about
everybody got lots more than we got. Times be I didn’t have shoes.
Never had them in summer anyway. Save them for school. Then they be
too little for my big old feet, so I take out the laces and try to
get a few more miles out of them. Anyhow, my mama taught all us
kids not to look at what other folks got, but thank God and my Lord
Jesus that we got what we do. We had food, and we had a house. Not
much more, but we did get by.”
“How well do you know the defendant, Private First
Class Celestine Anderson?” O’Connor asked, walking toward the
defense table where his client sat bound by chains.
“He my pea,” Carter said, looking at his
buddy.
“Pea?” O’Connor asked and shrugged.
“Like peas in a pod, you know what folks say,”
Carter said, trying to explain the colloquial term. “We close.
Always do stuff together, live in the same hooch, come from the
same hometown and all.”
“Buddies,” O’Connor offered.
“Yes, sir,” Carter nodded.
“So you know the defendant as well as anyone could
know him?” O’Connor asked, walking behind Anderson and putting his
hands on Celestine’s shoulders.
“He’s my brother,” Carter said and sighed.
“Not by blood but by friendship,” O’Connor said,
offering clarification.
“In the larger sense we have the same blood,”
Carter said, nodding his head. “Our African blood. Our slave blood.
So we have a term we call each other, Blood. For that
reason.”
“Right,” O’Connor said, walking from behind the
defense table and approaching the witness stand as he spoke. “Pride
in your heritage. Your common roots.”
“The struggle of our people to overcome
oppression,” Carter followed.
“Do you feel oppressed?” O’Connor asked, and looked
at the jury, focusing on the black staff sergeant seated on the
end.
“You can’t be black and not feel oppressed,” Carter
said, and looked at the staff sergeant, too, who nodded back at the
witness. Then Carter looked at the captain. “Sir, we fight a war
here to save these South Vietnamese people from oppression by the
Communists, yet we brothers fighting in this war have to deal with
oppression from our own country. You read the newspapers. You know
what’s going on back home.”
“Yes, I do, Lance Corporal Carter,” O’Connor said,
and looked at Charlie Heyster, who had his head down, writing
furiously on his yellow legal pad.
“How often did PFC Anderson stand the same duties
you described earlier to us?” the captain then asked, walking back
toward the jury so they could see Carter’s face as he answered the
question.
“I don’t think he ever get off duty,” Carter said,
and laughed. “He stood more than me or any of the other black
Marines in our unit.”
“Why did he stand more duty?” O’Connor asked.
“Objection!” Heyster spat, kicking his chair back
as he jumped to his feet. “Your Honor, he is asking the witness to
speculate.”
“Your Honor, I will rephrase my question,” O’Connor
said before the judge could overrule him.
“Lance Corporal Carter, did your work section
assign duty in an even distribution among all Marines?” O’Connor
asked.
“No, sir,” Carter said, and looked at Charlie
Heyster, “the gunny and I think the captain, too, they assign duty
as punishment. A guy mouth off, he get shit detail for a week.
Stuff like that.”
“Did Private Anderson have a problem mouthing off?”
O’Connor asked, walking back toward the defense table.
“No problem at all,” Carter said, and laughed.
“Celestine, he mouth off just about anytime he want. He never had a
problem mouthing off. Controlling his mouth, well, sir, he did have
a problem there.”
“As a result, he got every duty quota that came
through the door,” O’Connor said, looking at the jury.
“Objection, your honor, speculation,” Heyster said,
slamming his hand on the table where he sat.
“The witness can have firsthand knowledge of why
Anderson was assigned duties, so I will allow it. As long as he
testifies to what he has witnessed firsthand, then it is not
speculation,” the judge said in his ruling. Then he took off his
glasses and looked at Captain Heyster. “Could you please come here,
Captain? I have a question.”
Charlie Heyster scowled at Terry O’Connor and
walked to the judge’s bench, where he joined the defense lawyer in
a private conversation with Colonel Richard Swanson.
“I’ve had enough of your surly attitude this
morning, Captain Heyster. When you voice an objection, a clearly
spoken word not shouted will suffice. We happen to be in the same
room, and my hearing is excellent,” Swanson whispered to the
prosecutor. “What’s going on with you?”
“Sir, I apologize,” Heyster said, and then curled
his lips at Terry O’Connor. “The defense informed me yesterday that
he would lead off with Private Anderson’s testimony, and I had
prepared for his appearance this morning. The defense counsel’s
trickery has left me somewhat unprepared for the current
witness.”
“So you’re pissed off at the defense?” Swanson
said, looking at Terry O’Connor, who fought to keep a smile off his
face.
“Deceitful trickery!” Heyster hissed.
The judge looked at the papers on his desk, and
then back at Heyster.
“According to the witness list that the defense has
provided, Lance Corporal Carter’s name appears with two other
witnesses before Private Anderson. Captain, you had ample notice.
If you based your preparations on the order that the defense
presents its witnesses, I think you should revisit your
methodology,” the judge said, chiding the prosecutor.
“Sir, he told me yesterday that Private Anderson
would lead off this morning,” Heyster pled, now leaning toward the
judge for help.
“As far as I know, Private Anderson may or may not
testify,” Swanson said, and looked at O’Connor.
“Sir,” the defense lawyer said, “I apologize for
misleading Captain Heyster. He spoke to me after you adjourned
yesterday’s session, and said some unkind remarks, using very
brutal language. I have to admit that I responded in anger to his
challenge against my client and what he would do to him once he got
on the stand. I do apologize, sir.”
“Gentlemen,” the judge said, frowning at both
captains, “as difficult as this may seem for you to understand,
this is no game. We have no prize for the winner, no points or
pennant to award. We only have losers if you let your petty,
personal differences interfere with the justice we must strive to
achieve in this man’s trial. Captain Heyster, I know your
reputation, so don’t act so innocently violated. Captain O’Connor,
I admonish you for lying to the prosecution, even in an unofficial
manner through casual conversation. From here forward, you both
will conduct yourselves with civility in my court. You will present
your cases in a professional manner, respectful of all parties
present. Is that clear?”
“Yes, sir,” Heyster said, and turned his eyes
downward.
“Sorry, Charlie,” O’Connor said, and offered his
hand for the prosecutor to shake. After a hesitation and a cool
glance from the judge, Heyster accepted the defense lawyer’s
gesture and then returned to his seat.
Terry O’Connor walked back to the jury and then
looked at Wendell Carter.
“Private Anderson stood the majority of duty
because he vocalized his frustrations?” the lawyer asked the
witness.
“Yes, sir, to put it one way, he did,” Carter
answered.
“Put it your way then,” O’Connor said,
shrugging.
“Celestine he mouthed off at the gunny every time a
brother caught shit,” Carter said, and looked at Anderson. “Most
times it was none of his business, but he’d make it his business
because most times a brother caught shit was because of his
blackness.”
“Your Honor,” Captain Heyster said, standing from
his seat, “the witness is speculating as to the reason why a
brother caught shit, specifically because of his blackness. It’s
clearly his opinion, and not a statement of what he
witnessed.”
“Captain, I disagree and will allow the question
and answer to stand,” the judge said, leaning forward and looking
at the prosecutor. “The witness is testifying as to his perception
of what occurred. Our truths are based on what we perceive to be
true. Granted, the gunny’s motivations for dealing the extra duty
to black Marines may have been different from what the witness
perceived, but his own perceptions are what constitute the
witness’s reality. What the witness represents as honest beliefs
commonly held among himself and his peers as to his gunny’s
motivations behind assigning the extra duty to black Marines are
relevant.”
During the objection and ruling, Terry O’Connor had
returned to the defense table and scanned his notes. Then he walked
back to where Wendell Carter sat.
“Lance Corporal Carter, did you at any time believe
that Celestine Anderson intended to kill Harold Rein?” the defense
attorney asked, and stepped toward the jury box.
“No, sir,” the witness responded, following the
captain with his eyes.
“The prosecution would like us to believe that you
knew that Private Anderson meant to kill Private Rein, thereby
using your actions to imply a sense of premeditation on the part of
the defendant. They have presented several witnesses who say that
you tried to stop Private Anderson from killing Private Rein. Why
did you step in front of Private Anderson then, if you did not
believe that he intended to kill Private Rein?” O’Connor asked,
leaning against the jury box rail, waiting for another objection
from Major-Select Heyster, this time for leading the witness with
his question, but no objection came. Charlie the shyster busily
scribbled notes on his legal pad and let the question stand.
“Those boys, Buster Rein, Laddie Cross, and the
other two white Marines, they was trying to pick a fight with us,”
Lance Corporal Carter said, glancing at each juror’s face. “I knew
Celestine’s temper, and he would not back off a fight if somebody
threw down on him. I figure that Buster going to walk up and sock
Celestine in the nose, and that start a big fight. So I try to get
Celestine to just ignore those boys. I step in front of him, so I
can turn him around. Stop it from being a fight. I never dream he
kill that boy.”
“What did Private Rein and the others do to try to
start the fight?”
O’Connor then asked, still leaning against the
rail that surrounded the jury box.
“They be calling us niggers, and porch monkeys, and
coons, and stuff like that,” Carter responded, still looking at the
defense lawyer and the jury. “They say they ain’t afraid of black
power, and that when Buster Rein put that cigarette in his teeth
and walk at us hollering, ‘Any you niggers got a light?’ ”
“What is your attitude about racial epithets and
such slurs as they were using?” O’Connor asked, walking toward the
witness stand.
“I don’t like hearing none of that stuff,” Wendell
Carter said, shaking his head.
“Do you use any of those words?” O’Connor asked,
resting his hands on the rail surrounding the witness stand.
“Some black people, they say them,” Carter said,
shaking his head and looking at the jury, “especially the word,
‘nigger.’ I hate that coming out anybody’s mouth, black or white. I
never say them names. The sooner people forget words like that life
be getting a whole lot better for everybody.”
“What about Private Anderson?” O’Connor said, and
walked toward the defense table. “He ever use those words?”
“Not as I recall, sir, no, sir,” Carter said,
looking at his pal seated next to Wayne Ebberhardt.
“Before the incident, you and Private Anderson had
made some plans, had you not?” O’Connor said, picking up his yellow
legal pad and looking at notes he had written on it.
“Yes, sir,” Carter said, turning his face,
following the defense lawyer as he walked back to the jury. “We
supposed to get released from active duty a couple of months after
we go Stateside. That was before that day at the chow hall last
November. Anyway, we was going to take our bus fare home, and pool
our pay and go join the Reverend Doctor Martin Luther King and his
crusade for civil rights.”
“You were going to just show up on Doctor King’s
doorstep?” O’Connor asked, resting his hand on the jury box
rail.
“No, sir,” Carter answered, looking at the jury.
“One of Doctor King’s assistants, a preacher named Andrew Young, he
wrote me back a letter after I wrote to them last summer when
Celestine and I first talked about doing something for civil
rights. Reverend Young said that we be welcome to join up. He said
they could sure use a couple of good Vietnam veteran
Marines.”
“So today, had this unfortunate event not occurred,
you and Private Anderson would be with Doctor King’s campaign on
this very Wednesday morning, isn’t that correct?” O’Connor said,
wagging his legal pad in his hand as he spoke.
“Yes, sir,” Carter said, smiling. “We was supposed
to get released from active duty on March first, so today being
April third, we would have been with him at least a couple of weeks
by now.”
“Do you dislike white people?” O’Connor asked,
walking toward the witness stand.
“No, sir,” Carter said and smiled. “I know lots of
white guys that’s real decent. I don’t dislike nobody unless they
give me a reason.”
“What did you think of Private Harold Rein and
Private Leonard Cross?” O’Connor asked, crossing his arms.
“I didn’t think much of those boys at all,” Carter
said, frowning.
“You did know them before the incident,” O’Connor
said, still holding his arms crossed, the yellow legal pad dangling
from his hand.
“We seen them around, and heard plenty from them,”
Carter said, still frowning.
“Care to explain that?” O’Connor asked, and walked
back toward the jury.
“They always making trouble around black Marines,”
Carter said and shook his head. “They see black Marines talking,
dapping, or what have you, and they always looking to start some
trouble.”
“Dapping?” O’Connor asked, looking back at the
jury. “Please explain dapping.”
“That’s just a greeting, like when white people
shake hands,” Carter said and looked at the jury. “It symbolizes
friendship and unity among black brothers.”
“So it is not a symbolism of black power, meant to
degrade white people, as the prosecution has asserted with its
witnesses yesterday,” O’Connor said, smiling at Charlie Heyster and
then at Wendell Carter.
“If it meant to degrade anybody, I wouldn’t do it,”
Carter answered.
“So you would dap with a white Marine, too?”
O’Connor asked, and walked to the witness stand.
“If he want to dap with me, sure I do it,” Carter
said and smiled. “It’s a symbol of friendship, like I said.”
“Would you show the court by dapping with me?” the
captain then said, putting out his fist for the witness.
“Yes, sir,” Carter said, and then put his closed
hand above the lawyer’s. “My knuckles up here means that you’re not
above me. Then when I put my fist under yours, it means that I’m
not above you either. Then we rap on this side and that side, like
this, and that means we are equal. We bang our knuckles like this,
says we brothers. Then we put our fists across our hearts, pledging
our friendship to each other.”
“What about when you put your fists in the air?”
O’Connor said, raising his clenched hand above his head.
“We are brothers, united,” Carter said, raising his
fist, too.
“Would you recommend that all Marines dap?”
O’Connor asked, lowering his hand and walking back toward the
jury.
Wendell Carter smiled.
“Yes, sir, I certainly would recommend it,” the
witness said, and looked at the jury. “Marines are warriors. Great
warriors. This salute come from the Masai, who are great warriors,
too, in Africa. They kill a lion with a spear. This how they greet
each other. I think it be a good thing for Marines to have
something like that to use, too.”
“Thank you, Lance Corporal Carter,” O’Connor said,
and walked back to the defense table.
“Do you have any questions for this witness,
Captain Heyster?” Judge Swanson said, looking at the prosecutor
flipping through several pages of notes he had taken during the
defense examination.
“Yes, Your Honor,” Heyster said, and walked to the
tabletop lectern, where he leaned across it and stared coldly at
the witness.
“ ‘Chuck,’ ‘honky,’ ‘white bread,’ ‘cracker,’ ”
Heyster began, “these terms mean anything?”
“I hear some guys say them, yes, sir,” Carter said,
gripping the rail around the witness stand.
“What would you say if I told you I had witnesses
who heard you and Private Anderson saying some of these very
words,” Heyster said, still gripping the lectern and leaning over
it.
“I don’t use those words, sir,” Carter answered,
and then looked down. “They bad as saying ‘nigger.’ ”
“Yes, they are,” Heyster said, and stepped from
behind the lectern. “Equally offensive. Now, will you categorically
state for the record that you have never uttered these offensive
racial slurs?”
“No, sir, because I have said some of them a time
or two,” Carter said, still looking down. “Maybe when I got
mad.”
“So what makes you different than Private Rein,
when he called you a nigger?” the prosecutor asked, walking toward
the witness.
“When I call him a Chuck, I guess nothing, sir,”
Carter shrugged and shook his head.
“Did you see Private Celestine Anderson kill
Private Harold Rein?” Heyster said, folding his arms. “Just a yes
or no answer please.”
“Yes, sir,” Carter said, squinting his eyes
closed.
“No more questions,” Heyster said, and walked back
to the prosecution table and sat down behind it.
MIDMORNING SUN COOKED the ground brick hard where James Harris jogged, raising a cloud of dust around his feet. He had drank the last of his water, tossing the canteen in the weeds just before he crossed through the layers of fencing, tanglefoot, German tape and razor wire that ran along the perimeter of the American military compound and air facility at Chu Lai. Now he wished that he had refilled the can when he had the chance as he jogged past a well at a farm he crossed. However, the stop might have cost him his life had Huong caught up with him there. So he ran on, and made it clean through the fence at Chu Lai, but he was still very thirsty.
While Harris had fretted much of his journey,
worrying about how he could sneak through the wire at Chu Lai, the
task proved almost too easy for him. Spring rains had washed a low
place along the ground, just deep enough so he slid on his belly
beneath much of the barrier, out of sight of the bunkers and guard
stations keeping watch. While Mau Mau crawled through the fencing,
Turd sat in the weeds, watching him. Then when his master stood,
and dusted off his clothes, the dog bounded under the barrier,
carefree and his tail wagging happily.
Ahead, through the dancing mirage, the deserter
could see the white hangar at the far end of the flight line where
he felt certain that James Elmore now secretly worked, fabricating
metal parts for airplanes. He knew this hangar well. Late last
summer, while a newbee in Da Nang, Mau Mau’s gunny had sent him and
three other airframe mechanics to Chu Lai to work for three weeks,
helping out a shorthanded friend. Harris knew from that brief stint
that this was the only maintenance hangar outside the main stream
of traffic where CID could keep James Elmore working secretly. He
smiled confidently, looking at the red and white checkerboard roof
on the building, knowing well that the traitor worked inside.
As he ran, Mau Mau saw a familiar black
Mercedes-Benz pull through an opening in the trees less than five
hundred yards away, drive along a dirt road outside the fence line,
and then park, hidden behind some tall bushes. Turd saw the car,
too, and stopped to look at it. As the driver stepped out and
walked to the front of the automobile, wading through the
underbrush, the dog wagged his tail. He thought nothing of the
rifle that Huong carried in his hands.
Behind and ahead of where Mau Mau Harris ran along
the perimeter road, skirting the far end of the base’s runways and
taxiways, red signs eight feet tall stood at the edge of the dirt
track that ran parallel to the airfield’s boundary and read in
great white letters, Restricted Area—Keep Out, in both
English and Vietnamese. Maybe Huong would think twice before
opening fire, the deserter hoped. Surely his old comrade knew that
the shooting would draw attention from the guard posts overseeing
this remote part of the compound. At the sound of rifle fire, they
would come rolling like gangbusters, their guns blazing.
Then Harris considered that Huong could easily
shoot him anyway and still make a run for it. Whether or not the
reaction force that would doubtless pursue the pair ever caught
Huong and Bao, he would still suffer the brunt of the bullets that
the cowboy managed to launch at him. With no place to take cover,
Harris leaned forward and ran hard.
From the corner of his right eye, Mau Mau saw Huong
raise the rifle to his shoulder and aim at him. He clenched his
jaws as he pumped his legs, waiting for the first bullet to strike.
Then he noticed that the cowboy had taken the rifle out of his
shoulder and now hurried back behind the weeds and bushes where he
had hidden the car. A second later, he heard the whine of a GMC
pickup truck’s engine and the clanking and banging of its body
against its frame as it bounced across the ends of the runways and
open terrain between them.
The deserter smiled as he saw the dirty green M880
truck with a three-foot-wide orange and white checkered flag
flapping on a stick mounted to the rear corner of its cargo bed, an
M2 .50-caliber machine gun stationed above its cab and a Marine
wearing goggles holding on for dear life behind the gun. When the
truck bounced onto the well-traveled dirt trail that ran along the
airfield’s fence, it slid sideways and raised a cloud of
calcium-rich dust from the crushed oyster shells packed onto the
road’s surface.
At first sight of the pickup truck speeding
cross-country toward them, Turd wheeled on his tail and made a mad
scramble for the place in the fence where he and his master had
crossed a few moments ago.
As the truck slid to a stop ten feet from where Mau
Mau Harris stood, the Marine behind the big machine gun opened fire
at the fleeing dog, sending geysers of dirt twenty feet in the air
all around the mutt but nowhere near him.
“Cease fire, motherfucker!” a staff sergeant
dressed in a jungle utility uniform screamed as he leaped from the
passenger side of the M880 truck.
“Why you want to waste a fucking dog anyway, you
stupid son of a bitch?! Besides, you shoot like Little Stevie
Wonder. You ain’t ever hit Jack shit!”
“Now, I like Little Stevie Wonder,” Mau Mau Harris
said, smiling and wiping sweat off his face with a blue bandana
that he pulled from his pocket and then tied around his head like a
sweatband. “Don’t be insulting my favorite singer just cause he
blind and your man can’t shoot worth shit, Sergeant.”
“What the fuck do you think you are doing out
here?” the staff sergeant said to Harris, who kept smiling at him.
“What part of Restricted Area—Keep Out do you not
understand?”
“Hey, chill out, man,” Harris said, walking to the
truck and pushing his thumb on the silver button at the base of a
green water canister strapped to the side of the pickup bed,
sending out a stream into his mouth and over his face. “I thought
that meant people outside the base. Military is cool, isn’t
it?”
“You’re lucky those guys over in that bunker
between the parallel runways didn’t blow you away,” the staff
sergeant said, walking to the water can and squirting out a drink,
too. “Let’s see some identification.”
“Hey, man, I’m new here, I didn’t know,” Harris
said, smiling and shrugging his best act, pulling his fake
identification card from his wallet and handing it to the staff
sergeant while the staff NCO examined his dog tags. “My name’s
Sergeant Rufus Potter. I just got transferred down here from Da
Nang Air Base. I’m over at Group Seventeen, working up yonder in
that hangar in the fabrication shop. I came out for a little
morning run, keep myself fit for the commandant, you know, and this
looked like a pretty good spot for PT, so I went jogging up here. I
didn’t mean nothing. Sorry to get anybody upset.”
“We can maybe let you slide, Sergeant Potter, since
you’re new,” the staff sergeant said, wiping his mouth with his
sleeve. “Just let me hold on to your pistol and that knife you got
in your belt while we haul your ass up to that hangar and check you
out. I want you to introduce me to your gunny, and let me talk to
him.”
“That’s cool, man,” Mau Mau said, handing the
weapons to the staff sergeant and then climbing in the back of the
pickup next to the errant machine gunner.
“That your dog?” the Marine asked Harris as he
saddled up next to him.
“Shit no, man,” Harris lied. “He probably belong to
some gooners living outside the wire, and he just wanted to come
run along with me, I guess.”
Suddenly Mau Mau slammed his hands on the roof of
the truck’s cab just as the driver had pulled forward.
“Stop! We got Viet Cong over there!” Harris
screamed, and began pushing the barrel of the machine gun toward
the bushes where Huong and Bao had hidden in their black car.
“How you know they VC?!” the Marine lance corporal
behind the machine gun screamed back, pulling Harris’s hands off
the weapon’s barrel. “We can’t just go shooting at people outside
the wire.”
“The dude got a rifle, man! You didn’t see it?”
Harris said, looking down at the staff sergeant, who jumped out of
the truck with an M16 rifle, raised it to his shoulder, and took
aim at the bushes where Huong and Bao hid.
“I ain’t seen shit, Sergeant Potter!” the staff
sergeant shouted, looking for the enemy.
“Two dudes over there!” Harris screamed, pointing
at the bushes. “I seen one of them with a rifle. They VC, man. Open
fire with this machine gun. We find that rifle when you kill the
motherfuckers!”
Mau Mau then tried to push the lance corporal from
behind the machine gun and open fire with it. The young Marine,
with his goggles now askew, fought back, trying to hold control of
the heavy weapon.
“Back the fuck off, ass wipe!” the staff sergeant
screamed, climbing in the back of the truck and pulling Harris’s
hands off the tailpiece of the machine gun before he could release
a burst of fire.
“Look, motherfucker, now they getting away!” Harris
whined in a loud voice as he watched Huong tromp the gas on the
Mercedes and speed down the dirt road.
“Radio the reaction squad, Corporal O’Brien!” the
staff sergeant shouted, leaning over the truck cab and looking
inside the driver’s window.
“Shit, man, they be long gone now,” Harris said,
shaking his head and seeing the black car disappear.
HUONG AND BAO had lain in the bushes, watching the guard vehicle stop Mau Mau Harris. In a few seconds Turd had jumped in the brush with them. When the two cowboys saw their former cohort swing the machine gun their way, Bao leaped inside the car as Huong threw Turd in the backseat and then jumped behind the steering wheel, stomping the accelerator pedal to the floorboard, and punctuating their departure from the scene with a rooster tail of dirt flying through the air.
They had packed ample food and water, and all of
their belongings and money, but to Huong’s dismay he had badly
underestimated Mau Mau Harris’s ability to traverse forty
kilometers of countryside crosshatched with rice canals, fields,
hedges, and fence lines, not to mention dodging Communist and
American patrols. The cowboy had hoped to ambush Mau Mau as he
crossed the road outside the military base, and then speed off to
Saigon with his brother.
Although disappointed that he had missed killing
his former comrade, Huong felt good that the dog had escaped. He
liked Turd, and seeing him again flee well ahead of danger,
outrunning the erratic bullets, he regarded him as a powerful
carrier of good fortune. However, with Harris now a matter of the
past, Huong decided to change the name of this good dog to
something better. Even for a no-account cur, the cowboy certainly
would not insult him by calling him a name like shit.
ALREADY, THE MIDMORNING heat sent a mirage boiling up from the tarmac outside the hangar where Lance Corporal James Elmore stood near a window, working on a thick, flat square of metal. A man-sized electric fan mounted on a five-foot-tall stand droned in the heat, blowing hot air toward the building’s massive, open doorway.
While he fashioned the hunk of steel, the
slack-minded Marine gazed across the runways at the flight line
where A-4 attack jets sat, parked between high stacks of oil
barrels that protected the planes from enemy rockets and mortar
shells. Their bird-shaped bodies shimmered, taking on an almost
liquid appearance in the distorting mirage generated by the
scorching sun. As Elmore dreamily watched the heat waves dance
across the runway matting, asphalt, and concrete that covered the
ground, he noticed a speck of a person and a dog plodding along the
perimeter road toward the aircraft maintenance and fabrication
hangar where he worked.
Elmore had begun boring holes in the flat metal
plate for a helicopter gun mount when he first noticed the ambling
gait of the Marine and the mangy brown mutt lumbering at his side.
Even at more than a quarter of a mile distance, the jogger had a
haunting look about him that made the tattletale nervous.
His heart started to beat more quickly as his mind
began to place this gangly black Marine who drew closer and closer.
Could it be him? James Mau Mau Harris?
Then, when the guard vehicle slid to a stop by the
running man, and the men had their brief conversation, followed by
the runner casually getting a drink of water and then climbing
inside the back of the guard vehicle, hitching himself a ride, all
of the Marines acting friendly to each other, Elmore relaxed. He
focused his attention back to the square hunk of metal and bored
more holes where he had drawn red ink marks, laid out from a master
template. To him these days, nearly everyone at first looked like
James Mau Mau Harris, or worse yet, Brian Snowman Pitts.
Anymore, with so many weeks of worrying about the
two notorious deserters finding him, and each time he thought that
he saw one of the deadly duo and it always turned out to be just
another Marine, he began to more easily discount his fears. He
reassured himself as he bored the hole in the steel that had Mau
Mau Harris shown his face on the flight line—or at any other
American base in the Da Nang and Chu Lai areas, for that
matter—military police would have descended on him like a cloud of
locusts and clapped him in chains. They certainly would not have
had a casual conversation on the flight line with the fugitive, nor
would they have offered the scoundrel a ride, much less given him a
drink of their water.
“JUMP OUT, SERGEANT Potter, let’s go and get your gunny,” the staff sergeant said, walking into the shade just inside the hangar door.
As James Harris jumped from the back of the truck,
he held his hand firmly against his cargo pocket to keep the hand
grenade from bouncing out. Then as he walked through the entrance,
too, he shoved his hand inside the pouch on his leg and wrapped his
fingers around the small fragmentation bomb.
James Elmore stood at the drill press, next to one
of the hangar’s large, multipane side windows, the light streaming
on him. Mau Mau Harris saw the traitor’s eyes grow wide and his
mouth drop open, a high-pitched scream echoing through the high
building.
“Grenade!” a voice behind Mau Mau shouted, and
Marines everywhere dove for cover. All except James Elmore, who
stood wide-eyed, his mouth agape and still screaming.
Mau Mau Harris laughed as he yanked the pin from
the hand grenade and threw it like a fast-pitched baseball straight
at the pigeon who had ratted him and Brian Pitts out, and had
caused the death of Wild Thing.
Instinctively, James Elmore put up his right hand
just as the green, explosive ball hurtled at him. The smooth metal
stung the palm of his hand as he caught the object, and the sharp
edge of the fuse end of the grenade cut two of his fingers as he
closed them around it.
For several seconds the shocked Marine stood
paralyzed in fear with the explosive device wrapped by his hand.
Then his senses came to him and he shrieked.
“Motherfucker!” Elmore screamed, and threw the hand
grenade through a glass windowpane behind the drill press and dove
flat on the concrete floor.
Seconds passed and nothing happened. Then Marines
in the hangar began to stand up and dust off their trousers. The
staff sergeant ran full force at Mau Mau Harris, who now fled
toward the open door, and knocked the fugitive to the ground while
his two assistants wrestled the deserter’s hands behind him.
“Tie this goofy motherfucker up, and somebody call
the provost marshal!” the staff sergeant growled.
“Don’t you know who that son of a bitch is?” James
Elmore cried, dancing on his toes, pointing at the prisoner.
“He says his name is Sergeant Rufus Potter, and so
do his dog tags and ID card,” the staff sergeant said, and looked
at Elmore. “What do you know that I don’t?”
“That’s Mau Mau Harris, man,” Elmore wailed. “He
come here to murder my ass. Throw that grenade at me. CID look all
over Da Nang for him and a dude name Brian Pitts. Pitts be the
Snowman, and kill people and sell dope and shit. This guy here,
that his main man. He want kill me to shut me the fuck up.”
“Fucking dud grenade,” Harris grumbled with his
cheek pressed against the concrete floor. “Someday I still kill
your ass, you rat weasel motherfucker. If I don’t do it, Snowman,
he do it. Maybe even one his cowboys. You ain’t safe no more,
nowhere, Elmore.”
“How you know I be here, man?” James Elmore
squealed, still dancing on his toes. “They rat me out?”
“Yeah, man,” Harris laughed. “They tole me you down
here in da Chu Lai, fabricating metal. What else they be doing with
your rat ass no way?”
“Who tole you that, man? Who they?” Elmore
cried.
“Cops, man, they tole it all,” Harris said with a
laugh, the side of his face against the concrete and the staff
sergeant’s boot standing squarely between his shoulder blades.
“They take payoff like anybody else. Money open doors, show the
way. I got me this nice Viet Cong bolo knife that this staff
sergeant done took. I sharpen it all up to cut me some pigeon. I
guess now Snowman or his buddy Huong be cuttin’ that pigeon. Pigeon
name Elmore. Give you what they tole you they do, pull your traitor
tongue out your throat. Ain’t no place anybody keep you that we
ain’t gonna find your rat ass, you turncoat motherfucker.”
Suddenly a deafening boom erupted outside and blew
the entire frame of panes inward from the big window behind the
drill press, sending glass shards spraying across the concrete
floor. The staff sergeant dove on top of Mau Mau Harris, while
everyone else jumped for cover where they could find it.
“Shit, man,” Harris grumbled. “Slow-ass, greasy,
nonworking, Viet Cong fuse on that grenade, I guess. You one lucky
motherfucker, Elmore, you know that? Only that luck run just so
deep. Nobody be forgetting what you done. Ever.”
“Mau Mau!” James Elmore now pled, rising from the
concrete to his hands and knees and spreading a wide smile at his
prostrate nemesis, his gold front tooth sparkling as his lips
quivered around it. “I ain’t saying shit, man. Not now, not no
more. You gots to tell Snowman I ain’t saying shit.”
With the culprit’s hands tightly bound with nylon
parachute cord, the staff sergeant yanked James Harris to his feet
and shoved him at the two Marine guards, who each took an arm. As
they led him out the hangar door, Mau Mau looked back at James
Elmore and laughed.
“You one dead-rat-motherfucker,” the deserter
snarled, and then he hawked a mouthful of spit at the cowering
snitch. The glob sailed in a high arc but fell short of the target,
splattering on the floor.
For a while, James Elmore only stared at the wet
splotch on the concrete. Then his stomach turned from the shock of
the morning’s ordeal, and he raced to the head to upchuck his
breakfast.