Chapter 11
DOMINANCE AND SUBMISSION

 

1. Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection or the Preservation of Favored Races in the Struggle for Life (New York: The Modern Library, n.d.) (originally published in 1859) Chapter XV, “Recapitulation and Conclusion,” p. 371.

2. From George Seldes, The Great Thoughts (New York: Ballantine, 1985), p. 302.

3. E.g., Natalie Angier, “Pit Viper’s Life: Bizarre, Gallant and Venomous,” New York Times, October 15, 1991, pp. C1, C10.

4. Snakes certainly fight over territory as well—rat snakes, for example, over knotholes in trees where birds nest. The loser looks for another tree.

5. David Duvall, Stevan J. Arnold, and Gordon W. Schuett, “Pit Viper Mating Systems: Ecological Potential, Sexual Selection, and Microevolution,” in Biology of Pitvipers, J. A. Campbell and E. D. Brodie, Jr., editors (Tyler, TX: Selva, 1992).

6. B. J. Le Boeuf, “Male-male Competition and Reproductive Success in Elephant Seals,” American Zoologist 14 (1974), pp. 163–176.

7. C. R. Cox and B. J. Le Boeuf, “Female Incitation of Male Competition: A Mechanism in Sexual Selection,” American Naturalist 111 (1977), pp. 317–335.

8. E.g., Peter Maxim, “Dominance: A Useful Dimension of Social Communication,” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (3) (September 1981), pp. 444, 445.

9. Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex (New York: The Modern Library, n.d.) (originally published in 1871) Part II, “Sexual Selection,” Chapter XVIII, “Secondary Sexual Characters of Mammals—continued,” p. 863.

10. Paul F. Brain and David Benton, “Conditions of Housing, Hormones, and Aggressive Behavior,” in Bruce B. Svare, editor, Hormones and Aggressive Behavior (New York and London: Plenum Press, 1983), p. 359.

11. Ibid., Table II, “Characteristics of Dominant and Subordinate Mice from Small Groups,” p. 358.

12. Dominance in a one-on-one encounter and dominance rank within a hierarchy are not necessarily the same and cannot always be predicted from one another. See Irwin S. Bernstein, “Dominance: The Baby and the Bathwater,” and subsequent commentary, Behavioral and Brain Sciences 4 (3) (September 1981), pp. 419–457. Some animals distinguish only between those lower and those higher in rank. Others—baboons, for example—behave differently to those of very distant rank than to those nearly co-equal in rank (Robert M. Seyfarth, “Do Monkeys Rank Each Other?” ibid., pp. 447–448).

13. W. C. Allee, The Social Life of Animals (Boston: Beacon Press paperback, 1958), especially p. 135 (originally published in 1938 by Abelard-Schuman Ltd.; this revised edition published in hardback in 1951 under the title Cooperation Among Animals With Human Implications).

14. V. C. Wynne-Edwards, Evolution Through Group Selection (Oxford: Blackwell, 1986), pp. 8–9.

15. Neil Greenberg and David Crews, “Physiological Ethology of Aggression in Amphibians and Reptiles,” in Svare, op. cit., pp. 483 (varanids), 481 (crocodiles), 474 (Dendrobates [dendratobids]), and 483 (skinks).

16. B. Hazlett, “Size Relations and Aggressive Behaviour in the Hermit Crab, Clibanarius Vitatus,” Zeitschrift fur Tierpsychologie 25 (1968), pp. 608–614.

17. Patricia S. Brown, Rodger D. Humm, and Robert B. Fischer, “The Influence of a Male’s Dominance Status on Female Choice in Syrian Hamsters,” Hormones and Behavior 22 (1988), pp. 143–149.

18. One of many other examples: Bart Kempenaers, Geert Verheyen, Marleen van den Broeck, Terry Burke, Christine van Broeck-hoven, and Andre Dhondt, “Extra-pair Paternity Results from Female Preference for High-Quality Males in the Blue Tit,” ?ature 357 (1992), pp. 494–496.

19. Mary Jane West-Eberhard, “Sexual Selection and Social Behavior,” in Michael H. Robinson and Lionel Tiger, editors, Man and Beast Revisited (Washington and London: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1991), p. 165.

20. In 1857, Elizabeth Cady Stanton wrote: “[H]ow perfectly [woman’s dress] describes her condition. Her tight waist and long, trailing skirts deprive her of all freedom of breath and motion. No wonder man prescribes her sphere. She needs his aid at every turn. He must help her up stairs and down, in the carriage and out, on the horse, up the hill, over the ditch and fence, and thus teach her the poetry of dependence.” (J. C. Lauer and R. H. Lauer, “The Language of Dress: A Sociohistorical Study of the Meaning of Clothing in America,” Canadian Review of American Studies 10 [1979], pp. 305–323.) Stunning change has occurred since 1857, although the poetry of dependence is still widely recited in the women’s fashion industry.

21. Owen R. Floody, “Hormones and Aggression in Female Mammals,” in Svare, op. cit., pp. 51, 52.

 
Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors
titlepage.xhtml
dummy_split_000.html
dummy_split_001.html
dummy_split_002.html
dummy_split_003.html
dummy_split_004.html
dummy_split_005.html
dummy_split_006.html
dummy_split_007.html
dummy_split_008.html
dummy_split_009.html
dummy_split_010.html
dummy_split_011.html
dummy_split_012.html
dummy_split_013.html
dummy_split_014.html
dummy_split_015.html
dummy_split_016.html
dummy_split_017.html
dummy_split_018.html
dummy_split_019.html
dummy_split_020.html
dummy_split_021.html
dummy_split_022.html
dummy_split_023.html
dummy_split_024.html
dummy_split_025.html
dummy_split_026.html
dummy_split_027.html
dummy_split_028.html
dummy_split_029.html
dummy_split_030.html
dummy_split_031.html
dummy_split_032.html
dummy_split_033.html
dummy_split_034.html
dummy_split_035.html
dummy_split_036.html
dummy_split_037.html
dummy_split_038.html
dummy_split_039.html
dummy_split_040.html
dummy_split_041.html
dummy_split_042.html
dummy_split_043.html
dummy_split_044.html
dummy_split_045.html
dummy_split_046.html
dummy_split_047.html
dummy_split_048.html
dummy_split_049.html
dummy_split_050.html
dummy_split_051.html
dummy_split_052.html
dummy_split_053.html
dummy_split_054.html
dummy_split_055.html
dummy_split_056.html
dummy_split_057.html
dummy_split_058.html
dummy_split_059.html
dummy_split_060.html
dummy_split_061.html
dummy_split_062.html
dummy_split_063.html
dummy_split_064.html
dummy_split_065.html
dummy_split_066.html
dummy_split_067.html
dummy_split_068.html
dummy_split_069.html
dummy_split_070.html
dummy_split_071.html
dummy_split_072.html
dummy_split_073.html
dummy_split_074.html
dummy_split_075.html
dummy_split_076.html
dummy_split_077.html
dummy_split_078.html
dummy_split_079.html
dummy_split_080.html
dummy_split_081.html
dummy_split_082.html
dummy_split_083.html
dummy_split_084.html
dummy_split_085.html
dummy_split_086.html
dummy_split_087.html
dummy_split_088.html
dummy_split_089.html
dummy_split_090.html
dummy_split_091.html
dummy_split_092.html
dummy_split_093.html
dummy_split_094.html
dummy_split_095.html
dummy_split_096.html
dummy_split_097.html
dummy_split_098.html
dummy_split_099.html
dummy_split_100.html
dummy_split_101.html
dummy_split_102.html
dummy_split_103.html
dummy_split_104.html
dummy_split_105.html
dummy_split_106.html
dummy_split_107.html
dummy_split_108.html
dummy_split_109.html
dummy_split_110.html
dummy_split_111.html
dummy_split_112.html
dummy_split_113.html
dummy_split_114.html
dummy_split_115.html
dummy_split_116.html
dummy_split_117.html
dummy_split_118.html
dummy_split_119.html
dummy_split_120.html
dummy_split_121.html
dummy_split_122.html
dummy_split_123.html
dummy_split_124.html
dummy_split_125.html
dummy_split_126.html
dummy_split_127.html