Chapter 6
My newfound sense of freedom opened the door to
emotions I had not realized I still had. Though I’d thought I was
beyond such things as infatuation, it felt as if my whole world
stopped when I followed Danny into the station house and found
myself within a few inches of his new partner. Maggie was sitting
at my old desk, scrutinizing a case folder opened before her. She
had showered and changed clothes. Her hair was wet and pulled back
carelessly in a ponytail. She had been in too much of a hurry to
get back to work to bother to dry it.
Something new infiltrated my existence as I stood
near her. At first I did not realize what it was. Then I had it: I
could smell again. Maggie smelled of citrus.
I inhaled the air around her deeply, thinking how
fitting it was that she smelled of oranges and sunshine. She did
not look as if she had stayed up all night processing a crime
scene. She was clean and alert, busily cross-checking items, so
absorbed she barely glanced up when Danny sat down beside
her.
“Got held up,” he explained and I heard the old
familiar slur in his voice. Had I been like that, that clueless
about how I appeared to others? Deluded into thinking that no one
would notice what a mess I was?
“I gathered as much,” she answered, without
emotion. I winced. Danny was as dead to her as I was. I felt a stab
of sympathy for my old partner.
“Anything I can do to help?” he asked, as if it
were perfectly natural for a nineteen-year veteran to be looking to
his younger female partner for the lead.
“Not until we know who she is.” Maggie took in his
disheveled appearance. “You want to head down to Missing Persons
and light a fire under their tail? Maybe check the college
registrar after that to see if a coed’s gone missing?”
“Will do,” Danny said, shuffling off. I knew he was
relieved to be leaving her. Her refusal to judge him was more awful
than contempt might have been. It meant he was not even worth her
appraisal.
I sat in Danny’s chair and watched Maggie work. She
had astonishing concentration. After a few minutes staring at the
list of evidence that had been collected at the crime scene, she
picked up the phone. I knew she was calling the lab. I had done it
myself many times, usually because of a lack of inspiration on my
end.
“How long?” she asked into the phone. She looked so
disappointed at the answer that I could not bear to simply
watch.
I would help her.
I made my way through the halls of the law
enforcement building, my senses hyperalert. I had gained more than
my sense of smell back. Everything around me appeared in
ultra-relief. I could see the brushstrokes in the green paint
slapped haphazardly on the walls. Every piece of grit on the floor
twinkled as if it were diamond dust. And every person that passed,
from clerk to perpetrator, exuded a distinct smell that triggered a
visual composite consisting of random images from their lives. It
was fascinating and horrifying at the same time to read each person
who passed me by.
I learned that Morty, who had walked a beat
downtown for twenty-eight years, had discovered loneliness in his
advancing years. A crack addict was hauled past by a pair of
uniformed officers and I knew at once that he had been scalded with
hot water by his mother as a child, the memory now hidden under a
callus of near-constant unconsciousness. And my old lieutenant, a
man I had thought of as rigid and impenetrable, was in love, but
afraid of telling the woman—who worked in the public relations
department—for fear of being thought old and foolish. That made me
the saddest of all. I wanted to tell him to at least try, before it
was too late, but of course he could not see or hear me.
By the time I reached the laboratory, I felt like
an empty vessel that had been filled with the lives of others. I
was connected to every person who breathed in that building at that
moment, a keeper of their hopes and fears. It left me both stunned
and determined.
I knew I could find a way to get through to Maggie.
I knew that she would be the one who could help me set things
right.
I recognized the figure on a stool near the front
door of the lab, peering through a microscope. Peggy Calhoun had
been perched on that stool for the past twenty-five years. She was
many pounds overweight and had long since grown too old for anyone
to give her a second glance. Her red hair was obviously dyed, piled
high and pinned haphazardly in a bun that listed to one side. Her
black glasses had slid down to the tip of her nose and her lipstick
was smeared, as always. Danny and I had made fun of Peggy
ceaselessly when I was alive, speculating that she lived with a
dozen cats and celebrated Christmas alone with a bottle of Ama
retto and takeout from Nikko’s. How cruel we were to have rejoiced
in someone else’s loneliness when all we had to show for our own
sorry lives was an unceasing ability to cause the ones who loved us
pain.
There had been a time, many years ago, when Peggy,
in her own clumsy way, had let me know that she had a thing for me
and was willing to prove it. But that had been lifetimes ago, for
both of us, and I had not considered her offer seriously, knowing
even then that she believed me to be far better than I would ever
be. I had caused her pain, I could feel it in her still, but I had
not caused her that pain out of indifference. Not back then. The
truth was I’d been afraid of letting her down by who I really was.
Now I realized that her belief in the best of others had been all
the reaching out that she could manage in the solitary life she had
chosen for herself. And that her belief in the best of me would
have been a gift had I been able to accept it. I felt as if I owed
her an apology of sorts. But I did not know where to start.
Instead, I watched her work while a new
understanding of her opened before me. Peggy’s real world came
alive in her microscope. It was her window to discovering magical
landscapes on the most ordinary of surfaces. Peggy not only shunned
the wider world, she longed to live among the miniscule wonders of
the objects she searched each day. She saw beauty in the rough
surfaces she examined for evidence. She saw each grain, each ridge,
every imperfection, as evidence of divine creation, proof positive
that a greater hand was at work. Perhaps it was this certainty that
made it impossible for her to truly be a part of the human race,
with all of its folly. And, if so, was it so bad that she had
reached out to others only when the basic needs of her heart made
it necessary? She was truer to herself than most. Why had I not
seen that before?
Maybe Peggy could help me.
After all, she saw beyond the ordinary every day.
Maybe she could guide Maggie toward reopening the Alissa Hayes
case. I knew all Maggie had to do was glance at the file and she
would instantly see the connections between the two murders—though
she’d have nothing but contempt for Danny once she realized he had
either chosen to stay silent about the connection or, worse, not
seen the similarities at all.
Evidence bags from last night’s crime scene were
stored in a cardboard box on the counter by Peggy’s elbow. She was
funneling them to the proper specialist for examination. She had
placed three small bags to her left, awaiting her own scrutiny, and
had processed nearly a dozen more, separating them into piles for
further analysis. I stared at the bags, searching my memory, trying
to identify something among the evidence that would make it obvious
that this latest murder was connected to Alissa Hayes. I remembered
so little beyond the initial crime scene.
Why had I not paid more attention when I was
alive?
What had we nailed Alissa’s boyfriend on? It would
have been something obvious as Danny and I had been incapable of
spotting more. Bobby Daniels had been a student, just like Alissa.
He’d also been a real Poindexter, neat and clean in his pressed
jeans and starched flannel shirts and shiny work boots. Who the
hell starched their flannel shirts? His hair was clipped short and
his little glasses had sat on his nose so precisely that I had
loathed him on sight. It was as if his very being was there to mock
my own sloppiness, to make it more obvious that I clawed through
each day barely managing to hold it together.
I had let my self-loathing and dislike of him
interfere with my judgment. That had been the first step I took
down the wrong path. Where had it led me?
I remembered a little more. He had been a geology
major and classmate of Alissa’s. That was how they had met. When we
first tied the crime to him, it was simply because it was an easy
connection. There had been fingerprints on her belongings found at
the scene, plus his hair and fibers from his hiking jacket were
found on her body—though that could have been explained by their
relationship had he bothered to try. His DNA, too, was present, but
the boy had not denied that the two of them had slept together the
night before Alissa’s death. What other evidence was there? I tried
to remember more.
Maybe a look at the evidence from the new murder
would help. I moved closer to the box and Peggy looked up abruptly,
as if sensing me there. I froze, but she returned to her
microscope. That was when I saw it. A plastic bag of sandy granules
collected from underneath the dead girl’s foot, a glittering
mixture of fine grains that did not belong at the scene. Maggie had
discovered the substance and directed the techs to bring the grains
back to the lab.
Similar granules had been on the few items of
clothing found at the Alissa Hayes crime scene. I knew it with
certainty. I just needed Peggy to realize it.
“Detective Gunn,” Peggy said, looking up at the
doorway.
Maggie Gunn? Her name was Maggie Gunn. It was so
perfect for her.
She entered the lab with a smile. “Hey, Peggy.
How’s Mr. Whiskers?”
“Better. Antibiotics helped.”
“How does one give a mouse antibiotics
anyway?”
“Very, very carefully.”
As the two women laughed, I joined in their
delight. Of course—Peggy raised mice, not cats. Cats would be too
big. Mice would be just right for her, with the perfection of their
precise whiskers and tiny paws.
People, too, were fascinating, I realized, so
perfect in their own way.
“How’s your dad doing?” Peggy asked.
Already they had exchanged more personal
information than Peggy and I had exchanged in twenty years of
working together.
“Okay. It’s hard on him,” Maggie said. “They were
married a long time.”
“I know. Did you know I was sitting at a table next
to them the night they had their first date?”
Maggie seemed surprised. “You’re kidding!”
Peggy’s eye twinkled. “Sal’s. Far right corner.
Your mother ordered linguine with clam sauce. Your father had veal
chops. Neither one of them saw anyone else in the restaurant but
each other. I knew your father from his beat, and I knew your
mother from the beauty shop. But most of all—I knew they’d be
together from that night on. You could just see it.”
Maggie pulled up a stool and sat. “You never told
me that.”
“It was one of the most romantic moments of my
life,” Peggy admitted, and then, she had the great, good grace to
laugh at herself.
As the women laughed together, I was filled with
the knowledge that all people were connected by a great web of
comings and goings, moments of passing through each other’s life,
moments of touching one person, who then touched another, and on
and on through the years, an ongoing, never-ending river. I could
have been a part of it, if only I had been able to see beyond my
own miserable shell. My ripples could have mattered. I could have
been a part.
“Find anything good?” Maggie asked.
Peggy shook her head. “Got a name for the
victim?”
“Not yet. Danny’s with Missing Persons. Maybe he’ll
get a hit.”
Peggy glanced at her, not saying anything.
“He can’t do any harm down there,” Maggie said in
his defense. “After that, he’s heading over to the college to see
if anyone’s been reported missing.”
They were silent until Maggie asked, quietly, “Was
he always like that? So . . . disheveled and sad?”
“Oh, no,” Peggy said. “Not always. He and Kevin
were a real pair when they came out of the academy. Full of
themselves. Cocky like every single other person who came through
there back then. And they were something else to look at.
Good-looking. Smart. Both of them. They were quite the pair. The
women clerks would fight to be the one to help them.” She looked
around for a moment, then focused her attention on a small shelf
tucked in the darkness underneath her computer keyboard. “Let me
show you something.” She rummaged behind some stacks of phone books
and technical manuals, then produced an old framed photograph of
Danny and me, before the bottle got us both. Dust covered its
surface. She used a chamois cloth to wipe the photo clean. “Take a
look. You’ll see what I mean.”
Maggie took the photo from her and brought it into
the light. It was like being scalded, knowing that her incredible
scrutiny was now focused on me. “God, Danny is like, what, half his
size? And he has all of his hair.”
“It was a long time ago.”
“What’s with the rifles and hunting vests?”
“They helped track down a triple-homicide suspect
who got loose in Ronkonkoma State Park and was terrifying the local
campers.”
“That’s not what I think it is, is it?”
“It is.” Peggy laughed, but Maggie looked horrified
and I knew then what photograph Peggy had given her. Five years
into the job, Danny and I had helped bring down a true psychopath.
Well, we had helped flush him out of the woods and then hung out
along the edges while the real snipers brought him down with a shot
to his left calf. After he had been handcuffed and bound by the
ankles, Danny and I had had the bad taste to pose above him, guns
held aloft, my booted foot hovering an inch above his torso, as if
he was a deer we had just brought down. It had become a famous
photo in the department, or an infamous one, depending on your
reaction to it. I’d stopped looking at it a good ten years ago,
unable to decide what made me more ashamed: that I had ever been so
cocky or that I had long since stopped having any reason to be
cocky at all.
“You had to know the two of them to understand that
photo,” Peggy said. “Things were different back then.”
“I guess so.” Maggie sounded distracted. She was
staring intently at my image and my body felt as if it were filling
with embers. I glowed with the knowledge that she was thinking of
me.
“Not bad, eh?”
Maggie smiled. “Not bad at all. Just my type.” She
looked up at Peggy. “Tall, dark, and handsome. And full of
himself.”
Peggy’s face turned suddenly sad. “He could have
been a legend,” she said more softly.
“What happened?” Maggie asked, still staring at my
photo.
“Life.” Peggy started to return the photo to its
hiding place at the back of the shelf, but stopped. “Life happened.
Here—you take the photo.”
“Me?”
“Yes,” Peggy decided. “I think he would have wanted
you to have it.”
Maggie looked puzzled, but took the photograph
anyway. “Thanks. I find it, well, I guess strangely
compelling.”
“He had that effect on people. For a while. But I
think the job got to him. That happens to some people. They just
aren’t equipped. You see so many terrible things. The things people
do to one another.”
Maggie thought about that without comment and I
felt her attention slipping away from me. I wanted to jump in her
face, to scream that I was there, to prove that I was still worthy
of her notice, if only as a fleeting thought.
I didn’t matter to her. “Nothing unusual?” she
asked Peggy, who had turned back to the comfort of her microscope.
Their minds were back on the case.
Peggy shook her head. The rhinestone chain that
clipped her glasses to her collar danced in the light, reminding me
of the tiny crystals that linked the two murder cases.
I had to move now. The box sat between them on the
counter. It didn’t weigh more than a couple of pounds, but I had
never moved a physical object in my present state before. I didn’t
even know if I could.
I stationed myself on the far side of the counter,
reached over, and pushed. The box did not move. I could feel it,
the cardboard walls had substance, but my pushing produced no
resistance. I closed my eyes and concentrated, begging anyone and
anything that might be there to help me, to give me the power to
make the box move.
Nothing.
I thought of all I had failed to do in my life, all
I had not even tried to do. I thought of Alissa Hayes, wandering
the earth, appearing to me, asking me for my help, and of her
boyfriend, who sat alone in a prison cell somewhere, having lost
the woman he loved and then his life as he knew it. I thought of
the young girl whose body had been dumped in the weeds and the old
man who had knelt next to her, praying while his little dog waited
obediently.
I was part of them. I was one of them. I was
connected still, I told myself, or I would not be here. I still had
a right to play my part.
The box moved. It slid over the edge of the counter
and tumbled to the floor. Neatly sealed bags of evidence spilled
onto the tile. And, instantly, I was overcome with a wave of pain
so acute that I cannot describe it. Every fiber of my being
throbbed with an agony so intense that it brought me to my
knees.
I had violated the boundaries of my world. And I
would pay the price.
I leaned my head against the counter, enduring the
pain, telling myself that it would be worth it, as the two women
dropped to their knees, frantic to preserve the evidence.
“What the ever-loving hell was that?” Maggie asked
as she scooped up the bags and placed them back in the box.
“Nothing broke, thank god.”
“I don’t know.” Peggy was old, but her fingers were
nimble as she plucked bags from the floor. “I didn’t touch it. Did
you?”
“I wasn’t even close to it . . .” Maggie’s voice
trailed off. She leaned back on her heels and held up the small
plastic bag of granules, examining the label. A bolt of exultation
ran through me. Yes. “Did you get to this yet?”
Peggy shook her head. “Let me see.” She held the
bag up to the light and scrutinized its contents. “Sand?”
“That’s your call, not mine. But I did think it was
out of place. I found it near her right foot. I think it came out
of a shoe, a shoe the killer probably took with him when he left.
Maybe she was killed on a golf course?”
Peggy examined the bag more intently. “I see purple
and black granules. This isn’t sand, but it sure is
something.”
Think, I willed Peggy. Think back to the
Alissa Hayes case. You’ve seen this before, you must
remember.
I closed my eyes and tried to imagine Peggy the way
she had been when she had testified at the trial. Had she held the
bag of evidence in her hand? Had she been asked about the granules?
I searched my imperfect memory for guidance, willing Peggy to
remember, too.
“What is it?” Maggie asked, hearing something in
Peggy’s voice that was going unsaid and noticing the stillness of
her posture.
“I don’t know exactly.” Peggy struggled to her feet
and slid back onto her stool, removing the slide that was under her
scope and labeling its contents for further study. “I think I’ve
seen this stuff before.”
“Where?”
“I don’t remember. But I will. It was another case.
I just need some time to remember.”
I leaned against the wall, eyes closed, still
throbbing with a pain that threatened the equilibrium I had grown
accustomed to over the last six months. But pain could not kill me.
I was already dead. And if I had done something to help, anything
at all, it would be worth it in the end.
I willed Alissa Hayes to appear in my memory,
trying to send the image to Peggy’s mind. If I could not cross the
boundaries of the physical world, I would use what power I had to
affect her thoughts and guide her emotions.
A cool draft brushed my cheek. I opened my eyes.
Alissa Hayes stood next to me, looking at me solemnly. I smiled at
her and her mouth twitched, just a little, as if she wanted to
smile back, but could not.
There was something different about her face. I
tried to piece it together. Then I had it: the horrible bruises
that had bloomed beneath her eyes and across her cheekbones were
gone. Her skin was smooth.
Somehow, her existence in the plane we shared had
been altered.
I think I was the one who had done it.