Annex 2: Answers to the Questions
Chapter 1. Principles of Analytical Chemistry
-
1.1 . Tick the type of determination corresponding to each of the following examples:
Answer :
Examples
|
Determination of
|
||
---|---|---|---|
Traces
|
Micro components
|
Macro components
|
|
Determination of pesticides in urine
|
X
|
||
Determination of calcium in a milk
sample
|
X
|
||
Determination of proteins in beef
|
X
|
-
1.2 . Tick the correct statements among the following:
Answer :
-
[ ] The word “analysis” refers to the analyte
-
[X] Analysis of traces. Accepted, but incorrect
-
[ ] Microanalysis of copper
-
[X] Qualitative analysis comes before quantitative analysis
-
1.3 . What type of information regarding quality can be assigned to the result for a certified reference material?
Answer :
Information held as true or referential
information, which possesses the highest level of quality that can
be reached with special experimentation: certification of the
analyte content of a sample (a certified reference material, CRM)
through an interlaboratory exercise .
-
1.4 . Explain the two types of quality trade-offs to be made in response to contradictions between aims or objectives in Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
One should distinguish between aims and
objectives here .
Aims: A decision must be made if a high
metrological quality, in the form of high accuracy and low specific
uncertainty, is to prevail over fulfilment of the information
requirements or vice versa .
Objectives: The decision here is whether
to maximize the amount of information and its quality or minimize
the use of sample and reagents, time, effort and risks
.
The laboratory and the client should share
some quality trade-offs .
-
1.5 . What are the most salient differences between Analytical Chemistry and other disciplines of Chemistry?
Answer :
Analytical Chemistry is responsible for
producing reliable (bio)chemical information about natural and
artificial objects and systems. It lies at the third apex of the
basic triangle of Chemistry, which includes Synthesis and
Theory .
-
1.6 . When does analytical knowledge not suffice to solve problems? With what should it be replaced in those cases?
Answer :
A need exists to push boundaries towards
interdisciplinarity and to create new paradigms in order to address
the new problems to be faced by today’s world (e.g., exploring the
Nanoworld) .
-
1.7 . Why are the two classical standards of Analytical Chemistry insufficient? What is the third?
Answer :
Because one of the goals of Analytical
Chemistry is to fulfil (bio)chemical information requirements. This
obviously entails knowing the type and characteristics of the
information to be delivered. Hence, the information required is the
third basic standard of Analytical Chemistry in addition to the
classical (tangible and written) standards .
-
1.8 . Explain with appropriate examples the importance of interdisciplinarity to Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
The future of Chemistry lies in an
interdisciplinary approach linking it to Biology, Medicine,
Physics, Engineering and other scientific and technical areas at
the boundaries of which major innovations can be expected to
arise .
Analytical Chemistry cannot evade this
trend. In order to reach its goals and objectives, it must connect
to other areas of knowledge .
Thus, analysing the Nanoworld requires
cooperating with physicists capable of designing the analytical
instruments needed for this purpose (e.g., transmission electron
microscopes) .
Also, there is a growing trend to using
immunoreagents to detect or determine traces of analytes on the
grounds of their high sensitivity and selectivity. These reagents
are synthesized in close cooperation with biochemists
.
-
1.9 . Explain and exemplify the most salient written standards for Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
Analytical Chemistry uses two major types
of written standards, namely :
-
Official, standard methods issued by government agencies or by prestigious national or international bodies (e.g., AOAC, EU, OECD) .
-
Norms and guides issued by international organizations (e.g., ISO) that are adapted by a competent national body for application in each country. These standards provide the framework for managing analytical quality (e.g., ISO 17025:2010) or implementing Social Responsibility in Analytical Chemistry (ISO 26000:2010) .
-
1.10 . What are the areas influenced by (bio)chemical information? Give an example for each area in Slide 1.26.
Answer :
HEALTH. Enzymatic determination of
creatinine in blood serum to monitor patients with chronic renal
disease .
NUTRITION. Analysis by a customs
laboratory of a batch of bottled Russian liquor in order to
quantify its content in methanol, which is a toxic substance
.
HYGIENE. Determination of the
concentration of hydrochloric acid in harsh cleaning
products .
TRANSPORTATION. Analysis of aviation fuel
for banned polluting additives .
DRESSING. Determination of a marker such
as lithium deliberately added during the production of branded
sportswear in order to fight the growing fraud of
counterfeiting .
SPORTS. Analysis of athletes’ urine to
determine substances banned by the International Olympic
Committee .
CULTURE. Dating of works of art by C-14
radiometry .
NEW TECHNOLOGIES. Determination of the
exact purity of ultrapure silica used in wafers for TIC
equipment .
HOUSEHOLD. Analysis of sofa and carpet
stain removers to ensure that they contain no banned toxic
solvents. Unbranded removers are not guaranteed to be completely
safe .
BUILDING. Determination of the titanium
dioxide content of dirt-repelling nanomodified concrete for use
outdoors .
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT. Determination of
the components of acid rain (sulphur and nitrogen oxides) in air
from thermal power stations. The analytes react with water vapour
in the atmosphere to form nitric and sulphuric acid, which destroy
plants, erode monuments and damage animals’ lungs .
-
1.11 . Relate two hierarchies of analytical terms.
Answer :
In the
analyser–instrument–apparatus–device hierarchy, the analyser is
associated to the process and the instrument to the
technique .
In the data–information–knowledge
hierarchy, instrument signals are data, results constitute
information and reports convey knowledge .
-
1.12 . Rank the following concepts according to representativeness:
Answer :
The particular information requirements
lead to the choice of an analytical process that is applied to a
well-defined object in a specific sample .
Place
|
Concept: representativeness of
|
---|---|
4
|
The sample
|
1
|
The information requirements
|
2
|
The analytical problem
|
3
|
The object
|
-
1.13 . Illustrate the distinction between object availability and sample availability with several examples.
Answer :
A readily available object is a macro- or
microscopically sized entity (e.g., a river) from which samples are
withdrawn for analysis. Objects such as the Nanoworld and the
earth’s outer space are much more difficult to analyse
.
A readily available sample is one that can
be easily withdrawn from a macro- or micro-sized object. Thus,
baby’s blood is less easily available than horse urine. Also, it is
more difficult to date a piece of artwork from Roman times than a
painting from the XV century .
-
1.14 . State the parts (items) of the paper by Whitesides mentioned in Slide 1.42 and recommended as reading. What aspect of Chemistry did you find the most surprising?
Answer :
The paper emphasizes the importance of
(bio)chemical information. Also, it underlines the significance of
Analytical Chemistry in the chemical realm and deems it a
bottleneck for major scientific and technical developments
.
-
1.15 . Give two real-life examples other than those depicted in Slide 1.29 and identify the information requirement, object, sample and analyte in each.
Answer :
Example 1 :
-
Information required: The pesticide concentration, in ppb, of a tomato batch from Almeria, Spain. If the concentration is lower than the maximum tolerated level in the applicable EU Directive, the batch will be fit for export .
-
Object: A tomato batch ready for export .
-
Samples: Aliquots (tomatoes) withdrawn from boxes according to a specific sampling plan .
-
Analytes: The pesticides concerned .
Example 2 :
-
Information required: The point in time a bioreactor should be stopped because more than 95% of the target product (glucose) will have by then been produced .
-
Object: The bioreactor and its contents .
-
Samples: Aliquots of the reactor contents taken at preset intervals .
-
Analyte: Glucose .
-
1.16 . Justify the designation “Trace Analysis”.
Answer :
Technically, the definition is not
strictly correct because the analytes (traces) are not “analysed”
but rather “determined” .
However, the designation “Trace Analysis”
remains widely used, so, for historical reasons, it can be
retained. The term designates special analytical processes for
preventing contamination that are conducted in clean rooms by
operators wearing appropriate apparel (caps, gloves, masks) and
using ultra-pure reagents. Organic and inorganic traces are
analysed with rather different methods .
-
1.17 . Give several examples of real-life situations where the sample and analyte differ in nature.
Answer :
-
Analysis of soils to determine pesticides .
-
Determination of calcium in milk .
-
Analysis of oil crude to determine vanadium .
-
Determination of traces of organic compounds in atmospheric air .
-
Analysis of blood to determine iron .
-
1.18 . Is the designation “Analytical Separation Techniques” correct?
Answer :
Strictly, this designation is incorrect
because a technique uses a measuring instrument. Thus, liquid–solid
extraction and filtration are not “techniques” because they use no
measuring instrument .
Two correct designations for analytical
separations as a whole are “Analytical Separation Systems” and
“Analytical Separation Processes” .
“Analytical Separation Techniques” is
correct when a detector is coupled to a gas chromatograph, liquid
chromatograph or capillary electrophoresis system, for
example .
-
1.19 . What are the differences between the following?
- 1.
(Bio)chemical information and analytical information.
- 2.
Chemical information and biochemical information.
Answer :
- 1.
The two terms are completely equivalent. There is no difference .
- 2.
Differences can arise from the nature of the sample (e.g., a lunar rock and plant tissue) or the analyte (e.g., iron and an enzyme) .
-
1.20 . How many pathways can applied research in Analytical Chemistry follow? Why?
Answer :
Basically, two .
-
The more simple pathway involves using the body of processes, techniques and strategies supplied by basic research as adapted to the sample–analyte pair concerned .
-
The more complex pathway must be followed when an unusual analytical problem that cannot be solved with the means of basic research is addressed and directed, more specific research is required instead .
-
1.21 . When do analytical chemical R&D centres have to contact the clients requiring (bio)chemical information or vice versa? Give some examples.
Answer :
In principle, clients requiring some
(bio)chemical information use routine analytical laboratories to
monitor raw materials, intermediates and end-products. Only rarely
(e.g., when diversifying production) do new information
requirements arise that can only be fulfilled by developing new
analytical processes for use by routine laboratories. In these
situations, a direct connection between clients and research
centres may be advisable .
-
1.22 . What is the meaning of the four general paradigms of today’s and tomorrow’s Analytical Chemistry?
Answer :
The paradigms define the correct way of
approaching Analytical Chemistry today and in the future. In their
light, Analytical Chemistry is defined as the discipline of
(bio)chemical information; one that seeks interdisciplinarity with
other scientific and technical areas, and that possesses
R&D&I of its own where analytical knowledge and technology
transfer plays a prominent role .
Chapter 2. Analytical Properties
-
2.1 . Tick the correct statements in relation to the dynamic range of a calibration curve obtained in the photometric determination of iron in wines:
Answer :
-
[ ] The sensitivity remains constant
-
[X] The lower limit coincides with the limit of detection
-
[X] The sensitivity is always greater than zero
-
[ ] The lower limit coincides with the limit of quantification
-
2.2 . To which analytical properties are the following concepts directly related?
Answer :
![$$ \begin{array}{*{20}l} {\text{TRACEABILITY}} \hfill & {\left[ {\;\;} \right]\,{\text{Precision}}} \hfill & {[{\text{X}}]\,{\text{Accuracy}}} \hfill & {\left[ {\;\;} \right]\,{\text{Sensitivity}}} \hfill \\ {\text{ROBUSTNESS}} \hfill & {\left[ {\;\;} \right]\,{\text{Expeditiousness}}} \hfill & {[{\text{X}}]\,{\text{Precision}}} \hfill & {\left[ {\;\;} \right]\,{\text{Sensitivity}}} \hfill \\ {\text{PRODUCTIVITY}} \hfill & {[{\text{X}}]\,{\text{Expeditiousness}}} \hfill & {[{\text{X}}]\,{\text{Cost-effectiveness}}} \hfill & {\left[ {\;\;} \right]\,{\text{Representativeness}}} \hfill \\ \end{array} $$](A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_OnlinePDF_Equa.gif)
-
2.3 . Distinguish dynamic range from linear range in a calibration curve.
Answer :
Sensitivity as defined according to
IUPAC’s criteria is greater than zero throughout the dynamic range;
however, it differs among zones in the range. In the linear portion
of the dynamic range, the sensitivity is also greater than zero,
but it is a constant value, so the analytical signal (X) is
linearly related to the concentration and the calibration curve is
linear as a result .
-
2.4 . State whether the following statements are true (T) or false (F).
Answer :
-
[T] Precision decreases with increasing standard deviation
-
[F] Accuracy decreases with decreasing relative error
-
[T] Sensitivity increases with decreasing limit of detection and quantification
-
[F] Selectivity increases with increasing interference
-
2.5 . Define the analytical property robustness.
Answer :
Robustness is the resistance of a method
to its results changing by effect of slight changes in the
experimental conditions .
-
2.6 . Define “bias” in relation to errors in Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
In the context of accuracy, bias is the
deviation of the mean result of a method from the value held as
true
. The deviation is a positive or negative
error depending on whether the mean is greater or smaller,
respectively, than
.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9f54c/9f54c9e3067372740ac0b98569bf829c72527b41" alt="$$ (\widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} ) $$"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ea66b/ea66b31f15dc4764eef5f2bc4535ba681b6455d6" alt="$$ \widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} $$"
-
2.7 . Tick the correct statements in the dynamic concentration range of the calibration curve for the photometric determination of calcium in milk:
Answer :
-
[ ] The sensitivity remains constant
-
[X] The sensitivity is always non-zero
-
[X] The sensitivity is not always the same
-
[X] The sensitivity decreases at the end of the range
-
2.8 . Which datum is needed to assess the accuracy of an analytical result?
Answer :
-
[ ] The mean of n results
-
[X] The value held as true
-
[ ] The standard deviation
-
2.9 . State whether the following statements are true (T) or false (F).
Answer :
-
[T] Selectivity increases with decreasing interference
-
[F] Sensitivity increases with decreasing slope of the calibration curve
-
[T] Accuracy increases with increasing precision
-
[F] Precision increases with increasing standard deviation
-
2.10 . Distinguish generic and specific uncertainty.
Answer :
Generic uncertainty is the overall
dubiousness in the composition of a sample or object and arises
from a complete lack of knowledge about it. On the other hand,
specific uncertainty restricts the dubiousness to a specific range
where the result obtained by repeating the analytical process will
fall with a given probability .
-
2.11 . What are the differences between “repeatability” and “reproducibility”?
Answer :
These are two ways of calculating
precision experimentally. Repeatability is assessed by using the
same experimental conditions (time, instrument, operator,
laboratory, etc.) each time the analytical process is performed. On
the other hand, reproducibility is assessed by changing some
experimental condition between replications of the process.
Obviously, reproducibility is a more rigorous statistical concept
than is repeatability .
-
2.12 . What kind of reference is used to calculate (a) the accuracy of the result for a sample and (b) the precision of a method?
Answer :
- (a)
The value held as true
.
- (b)
The mean of a set of results
.
-
2.13 . State whether the following statements about accuracy and precision are true (T) or false (F).
Answer :
-
[F] Both analytical properties can be ascribed to results
-
[F] The two are unrelated
-
[F] Good precision can only be obtained with good accuracy
-
[T] Good accuracy can only be obtained with good precision
-
2.14 . Name the four types of relationships between analytical properties.
Answer :
- 1.
Hierarchical .
- 2.
Foundation .
- 3.
Contradictory .
- 4.
Complementary .
-
2.15 . What are the similarities and differences between systematic errors and gross errors?
Answer :
-
Similarities :
- 1.
Both are associated to accuracy .
- 2.
Both can be positive or negative .
- 3.
Both arise from well-defined changes during the analytical process .
- 1.
-
Differences :In magnitude: systematic errors are typically much smaller than gross errors .
-
2.16 . Two methods A and B are used to determine the same analyte in aliquots of a sample with a certified value of 1.23 ± 0.05 mg/L. The experimental result is 1.27 ± 0.03 mg/L with method A and 1.29 ± 0.01 mg/L with method B. Which method is the more accurate? Which is the more precise? Why?
Answer :
Method A is the more accurate because its
result is closer to the value held as true,
. Thus, e A = 0.04 < 0.06 = e
B
. On the other hand, method B
is the more precise because its uncertainty range is narrower: 0.01
< 0.03 .
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/71870/7187023170d93e01f87e9882797f43e5f0cfc141" alt="$$ \widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} $$"
-
2.17 . Why stating the accuracy of a result is meaningless if its precision is unknown?
Answer :
If the precision is inadequate (too low),
the probability of obtaining the same result when the analytical
process is repeated will also be very low .
-
2.18 . Can productivity-related properties be more important than capital and basic properties?
Answer :
Yes. In fact, the importance of analytical
properties depends on the particular analytical problem. If the
problem requires prioritizing cost-effectiveness, expeditiousness
and safety, it will be at the expense of accuracy and the basic
analytical properties (e.g., precision, sensitivity and
selectivity) .
-
2.19 . What is a “blank”? What is the “blank signal”?
Answer :
A “blank” is a sample not containing the
target analyte. The “blank signal is the signal produced by a blank
subjected to the analytical process .
-
2.20 . Which are the references needed to define the following analytical properties in mathematical and conceptual terms? Tick the correct choices.
Answer :
Set of blanks
|
Value held as true
|
Mean of n results
|
Interferences from other systems
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Accuracy
|
X
|
|||
Precision
|
X
|
|||
Limit of detection
|
X
|
|||
Selectivity
|
X
|
-
2.21 . State whether the following statements as regards accuracy and precision are true (T) or false (F).
Answer :
-
[F] Both analytical properties can be assigned to results
-
[T] The two are mutually related
-
[T] Good precision cannot be obtained without good accuracy
-
[T] Good accuracy cannot be obtained without good precision
-
2.22 . Why does accuracy rest on precision?
Answer :
There can be no accuracy without good
precision. Otherwise, the probability of obtaining identical or
similar results when the analytical process is repeated will be
low .
-
2.23 . Tick the correct boxes in this comparison of precision and robustness.
Answer :
Same sample aliquot
|
Same method
|
Supports accuracy
|
Basic analytical property
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Robustness
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
Precision
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
-
2.24 . How are the facets of sensitivity related?
Answer :
The lower are the limits of detection
( C LOD ) and quantification ( C LOQ ), the higher is the sensitivity (S,
IUPAC) and the greater is the ability of a method to discriminate
between similar analyte concentrations .
-
2.25 . Two methods A and B for determining aflatoxins in milk are compared in terms of sensitivity by analysing two different certified reference materials with certified values of 0.25 ± 0.01 and 0.28 ± 0.01 ppb. Based on method A, both CRMs contain aflatoxins. Based on method B, both CRMs contain aflatoxins and the second CRM contains a slightly greater amount than the first. Which is the more sensitive method? Why?
Answer :
Method B is the more sensitive because it
can discriminate between samples with similar concentrations of the
analyte .
-
2.26 . What is the lower limit of the linear range of the calibration curve?
Answer :
The limit of quantification (C
LOQ
) .
-
2.27 . What is the “maximum tolerated ratio”? To which analytical property does it relate?
Answer :
The maximum tolerated ratio (MTR) is the
highest interferent-to-analyte concentration ratio not altering a
result. MTR is associated to the basic analytical property
selectivity .
-
2.28 . Give an example of analysis (state the sample and analyte) where accuracy is to be favoured over productivity-related properties?
Answer :
The determination of the purity of a gold
batch directly imported from a mining company. Gold is the analyte
and the mined batch is the sample .
-
2.29 . Is it correct to assign accuracy to an analytical process? Why?
Answer :
It is not because accuracy is a capital
analytical property that characterizes results .
-
2.30 . The sensitivity of a method is 1.02 × 10 −3 AU mL ng −1 . What are the units for the following parameters?
Answers :
-
Blank signal: AU
-
Standard deviation of the blank: AU
-
Limit of detection: ng/mL
-
Limit of quantification: ng/mL
-
Analyte concentration: ng/mL
-
2.31 . Complete the following table comparing the analytical properties “accuracy” and “precision”.
Answer :
Accuracy
|
Precision
|
|
---|---|---|
Type of analytical property
|
Capital
|
Basic
|
A typical property of
|
Results
|
The
analytical process
|
Parameters used to measure it
|
Errors
|
Standard deviation
|
An indispensable numerical reference for
calculating the parameters
|
The
value held as true
![]() |
The
mean of a set of results
![]() |
Mutually dependent
|
Depends on precision
|
Does
not depend on accuracy
|
-
2.32 . (1) Discuss the ideal situation and (2) describe the real situation in independently subjecting n aliquots of sample to an analytical process in order to obtain n results.
Answer :
- (1)
The individual results (x i ) are identical with one another, with the mean and with the value held as true
.
- (2)
The individual results (x i ) are different from one another, from the mean and from the value held as true
.
-
2.33 . Classify errors in Analytical Chemistry according to (1) form of expression; (2) direction; and (3) sources, references and magnitude.
Answer :
- 1.
Absolute and relative
- 2.
Positive and negative
- 3.
Random, systematic and gross .
-
2.34 . A method provides accurate results. May it not be precise?
Answer :
No. Properly defining the accuracy of a
method requires knowing its precision. If the precision is poor,
the results can only be accurate by chance .
-
2.35 . Define a parameter representing the analytical property “selectivity”.
Answer :
Selectivity can be assessed in terms of
the highest tolerated interferent-to-analyte ratio not leading to
error :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/51521/515217a104000c1d4f26163b1ce9f08b025a3bfb" alt="$$ \varvec{S} = \left( {\varvec{TR}} \right)_{{\varvec{m{\acute{a}} x}}} = \frac{{\varvec{C}_{{\varvec{int}}} }}{{\varvec{C}_{{\varvec{an}}} }} $$"
-
2.36 . Solve the different parts of the following problems.
-
Problem A
-
An analytical method for determining
copper traces in feed is characterized as follows:
(1) Using the method to analyse
standards of increasing concentrations of analytes provides the
following results:
[Cu 2+ ], ppb
|
0.0
|
1.0
|
2.0
|
3.0
|
4.0
|
5.0
|
Signal, AU
|
0.030
|
0.050
|
0.102
|
0.149
|
0.201
|
0.250
|
(2) Independently subjecting 5
aliquots of a reference standard with a certified concentration of
3.30 ± 0.10 ppb gives the following results, in ppb: 3.40, 3.39,
3.50, 3.27 and 3.35.
Questions:
- (a)
What is the blank signal? What are its units?
Answer :
The blank signal must be expressed in the
same units as the instrument signal. Since the instrument was used
to measure absorbance, the blank signal should be expressed in
absorbance units (AU) .
Based on the definition of “blank”, the
blank signal will be that corresponding to a copper concentration
[Cu 2+ ] = 0 ppb . This datum is contained in the table.
Therefore, the blank signal will be
![$$ \varvec{Signal }\left( {\left[ {\varvec{Cu}^{\mathbf{2} + } } \right] = {\mathbf{0}}\,{\mathbf{ppb}}} \right) = {\mathbf{0.030}}\;{\mathbf{AU}} $$](A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_OnlinePDF_Equc.gif)
- (b)
What is the signal corresponding to the certified copper concentration in the standard?
Answer :
Calculating the signal corresponding to
the analyte concentration of the CRM entails constructing a
calibration curve and using it to calculate the following
parameters :
- 1.
The sensitivity of the method, which will coincide with the slope of the curve. A few data pairs from the table are applied the IUPAC criterion to calculate the corresponding S values. The mean of the more similar values is taken to be the slope of the calibration curve :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b86a5/b86a5bcc93e729f8a8495418c40342d227ade4e4" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{S} & = \frac{{\Delta \varvec{X}}}{{\Delta \varvec{C}}} \\ \varvec{S}_{\mathbf{1}} & = \frac{{\left( {\mathbf{0.050} - \mathbf{0.030}} \right)\;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\left( {\mathbf{1.0} - \mathbf{0.0}} \right)\;{\mathbf{ppb}}}} = \mathbf{0.020}\;{\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}} \\ \varvec{S}_{\mathbf{2}} & = \frac{{\left( {\mathbf{0.149} - \mathbf{0.102}} \right)\;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\left( {\mathbf{3.0} - \mathbf{2.0}} \right)\;{\mathbf{ppb}}}} = \mathbf{0.047}\;{\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}} \\ \varvec{S}_{\mathbf{3}} & = \frac{{\left( {\mathbf{0.201} - \mathbf{0.250}} \right)\;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\left( {\mathbf{5.0} - \mathbf{4.0}} \right)\;{\mathbf{ppb}}}} = \mathbf{0.049}\;{\mathbf{AU/ppb}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
Using S 2 and S 3 , which are the more similar values, allow
one to calculate the sensitivity of the method as their mean
:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2e983/2e983e4d65816ac54bcc7343561fcce805847ad5" alt="$$ \varvec{S} = \frac{{\left( {\mathbf{0.047} + \mathbf{0.049}} \right)\;{\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}}}}{\mathbf{2}} = \mathbf{0.048}\;{\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}} $$"
- 2.
The equation of the calibration curve, which is established from the blank signal and the previously calculated sensitivity, is
![$$ \varvec{Signal }\left( {\varvec{AU}} \right) = \mathbf{0.030} + \mathbf{0.049}\cdot\left[ {\varvec{Cu}^{\mathbf{2} + } } \right] $$](A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_OnlinePDF_Equf.gif)
The signal corresponding to the CRM can
now be calculated by substituting the certified copper
concentration into the previous equation :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/01d6b/01d6bfa0c8cf1b5e066421862d1be7fef08d4a98" alt="$$ \varvec{Signal }\left( {\varvec{CRM}} \right) = \left( {\mathbf{0.030} + \mathbf{0.049}\cdot \mathbf{3.30}} \right)\;{\mathbf{AU}} = \mathbf{0.193}\;{\mathbf{AU}} $$"
- (c)
Can the precision of the method be calculated? Why? If it can, what is it?
Answer :
In fact, the precision of the method can
be calculated from the set of results obtained by applying the
analytical process to aliquots of a CRM sample. Since no confidence
level was provided, the precision is assessed in terms of the
standard deviation of the results :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/efa79/efa79a68fecc4130f797c12dee786a64a5ee3237" alt="$$ \varvec{s}_{\varvec{c}} = \pm \sqrt {\frac{{\sum \left( {\varvec{c}_{\varvec{i}} - \overline{\varvec{C}} } \right)^{\mathbf{2}} }}{{\varvec{n} - \mathbf{1}}}} $$"
The precision of the method is thus
.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa3f7/aa3f7c24db105a6a6f6000bda101394ae3f70ad5" alt="$$ \varvec{s}_{\varvec{c}} = \pm \mathbf{0.09}\;{ \mathbf{ppb}} $$"
- (d)
Can the accuracy of the result be calculated? Why? If it can, what is it?
Answer :
The accuracy of the result can also be
calculated because a certified value that can be taken to be the
value held as true is known. Thus, the accuracy can be defined in
terms of the error of the method, which can be calculated as the
difference between the mean of the results and the certified
value :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4289c/4289c2d6448caa08639a6d797d1c27ce4bff8384" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{e} & = \overline{\varvec{X}} - \widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} = \left( {\mathbf{3.38} - \mathbf{3.30}} \right)\;{\mathbf{ppb}} = + \mathbf{0.08}\;{\mathbf{ppb}} \\ \varvec{e }\left( \varvec{\% } \right) & = \frac{{\overline{\varvec{X}} - \widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} }}{{\widehat{\varvec{X}}^{{\prime }} }}\cdot \mathbf{100} = \frac{{\left( {\mathbf{3.38} - \mathbf{3.30}} \right)\;{\mathbf{ppb}}}}{{\mathbf{3.30}\;{\mathbf{ppb}}}}\cdot \mathbf{100} = + \mathbf{2.43}\varvec{\% } \\ \end{aligned} $$"
The error of the method is thus positive
and equal to 2.43% .
- (e)
If the client’s imposed limit is 0.1 ppb copper, is the method suitable for qualifying (detecting) and quantifying the analyte if the deviation of the blank signal is 2.3 × 10 −3 AU?
Answer :
The sensitivity and deviation of the
blanks can now be used to calculate the limits of detection and
quantification :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f7bd4/f7bd4d7d7e9db97f991085876671e8e2e14fe807" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LOD}}} & = \frac{{\mathbf{3} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} }}{\varvec{S}} = \frac{{\mathbf{3} \cdot \mathbf{2.3} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{3}} \;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\mathbf{0.049} \cdot {\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}}}} = \mathbf{0.14}\;{\mathbf{ppb}} \\ \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LOQ}}} & = \frac{{\mathbf{10} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} }}{\varvec{S}} = \frac{{\mathbf{10} \cdot \mathbf{2.3} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{3}} \;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\mathbf{0.049}\;{\mathbf{AU}}/{\mathbf{ppb}}}} = \mathbf{0.46}\,{\mathbf{ppb}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
Graphically comparing C
LOD
and C LOQ with the stated legal limit, C
LL
,
reveals that both exceed the stated legal
limit. Therefore, the method is not valid for detecting or
quantifying the analyte .
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2836f/2836fd2e2de755c3d61ce49d1347a62dbdfb4903" alt="A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_Figa_HTML.gif"
-
Problem B
An analytical process for determining
pesticides (P) in water is applied through the following
tests:
(1) Subjecting a total of 10 blanks
to the process gives the following results in absorbance units
(AU):
0.031
|
0.033
|
0.041
|
0.029
|
0.035
|
0.037
|
0.040
|
0.032
|
0.030
|
0.037
|
(2) A calibration curve is
constructed from a set of standards of increasing hydrocarbon
concentrations. The equation for the curve is
![$$ Signal \left( {AU} \right) = 0.035 + 1.07 \left[ P \right] $$](A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_OnlinePDF_Equk.gif)
where [
P ] is the pesticide
concentration in ng/mL.
Questions:
- (a)
Can the precision of the method be calculated? Why? Explain your answer.
Answer :
The precision of this method cannot be
calculated because no set of results allowing calculation of its
precision is available. Although the results of the analysis of
blanks cannot be used to assess precision, their standard deviation
allows the actual precision to be estimated .
- (b)
Express the sensitivity of the method through three different parameters.
Answer :
The sensitivity of a method can be
expressed in the form of IUPAC’s parameter (S), and also as the
limit of detection ( C
LOD
) and the limit of
quantification ( C
LOQ
). The sensitivity is directly
proportional to the former parameter and inversely proportional to
the latter two .
The IUPAC sensitivity (S) can be directly
extracted from the statement of the problem as it coincides with
the slope of the calibration curve :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60370/603706f020616c92194a7a9242421817ddb9581d" alt="$$ \varvec{S} = \mathbf{1.07}\;{\mathbf{AU}}\;{\mathbf{mL}}/{\mathbf{ng}} $$"
The limits of detection and quantification
can be calculated from the standard deviation of the blank
signals :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/903af/903af1b48d666db1dd9ee9f3eddb25a6c5538f14" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} & = \pm \sqrt {\frac{{\sum \left( {\varvec{X}_{{\varvec{i},\varvec{B}}} - \overline{\varvec{X}}_{{\varvec{i},\varvec{B}}} } \right)^{\mathbf{2}} }}{{\varvec{n} - \mathbf{1}}}} = \pm \mathbf{0.004}\;{\mathbf{AU}} \\ \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LOD}}} & = \frac{{\mathbf{3} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} }}{\varvec{S}} = \frac{{\mathbf{3} \cdot \mathbf{0.004}\;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\mathbf{1.07}\;{\mathbf{AU}}\;{\mathbf{mL}}/{\mathbf{ng}}}} = \mathbf{0.011}\,{\mathbf{ng}}/{\mathbf{mL}} \\ \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LOQ}}} & = \frac{{\mathbf{10}\cdot\varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} }}{\varvec{S}} = \frac{{\mathbf{10} \cdot \mathbf{0.004}\;{\mathbf{AU}}}}{{\mathbf{1.07}\;{\mathbf{AU}}\;{\mathbf{mL}}/{\mathbf{ng}}}} = \mathbf{0.037}\;{\mathbf{ng}}/{\mathbf{mL}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
In summary, the sensitivity of the method
can be expressed in the following three forms :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e0dc/0e0dcde33ac066553a73fe8907718dd941ae3674" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{S} & = \mathbf{1.07}\,{\mathbf{AU}}\;{\mathbf{mL}}/{\mathbf{ng}} \\ \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LOD}}} & = \mathbf{0.011}\,{\mathbf{ng}}/{\mathbf{mL}} \\ \varvec{C}_{{\varvec{LC}}} & = \mathbf{0.037}\,{\mathbf{ng}}/{\mathbf{mL}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
- (c)
If the legal limit for pesticides in water is 2 ng/mL, is the method useful for their detection and quantification?
Answer :
Graphically comparing the previously
calculated limits of detection and quantification with the legal
limit,
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4d6d8/4d6d8268186543ab9548b57052f4296dc2a6c28a" alt="A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_Figb_HTML.gif"
allows one to conclude that the method is
valid for detecting the analyte but not for quantifying it because
the limit of quantification exceeds the legally tolerated
limit .
-
Problem C
The precision of an analytical
process for determining copper traces in seawater is assessed in
three tests involving different experimental conditions,
namely:
- (1)
Processing a single aliquot of sample and introducing six portions of the treated aliquot into the measuring instrument.
- (2)
Independently processing six aliquots of the same sample and introducing them into the measuring instrument on the same day.
- (3)
As in (2), but having six different analysts perform the analytical process on different days.
- (4)
The results obtained are as follows:
Test
|
Results (mg/L)
|
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1
|
1.32
|
1.31
|
1.32
|
1.33
|
1.30
|
1.31
|
2
|
1.28
|
1.36
|
1.30
|
1.27
|
1.31
|
1.33
|
3
|
1.35
|
1.45
|
1.21
|
1.37
|
1.30
|
1.28
|
Calculate the specific uncertainty at
the 95% confidence level for each test and plot it. Use the
uncertainty values to discuss the precision achieved in each case,
and identify the facet that can be characterized with each
test.
Answer :
The specific uncertainty at the 95%
confidence level is
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e2e0/0e2e00949ba7bb29370cf9547fd464c0a6c5d687" alt="$$ \varvec{U}_{\varvec{R}} = \varvec{k}\cdot\varvec{s}_{\varvec{R}} ,\quad \varvec{where}\quad \varvec{k}\left( {\mathbf{95}\varvec{\% }} \right) = \mathbf{2} $$"
Since the standard deviation is given
by
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b0750/b07508ec8bdc002acb5f836d06b13268f82804d7" alt="$$ \varvec{s}_{\varvec{R}} = \pm \sqrt {\frac{{\sum \left( {\varvec{X}_{\varvec{R}} - \overline{\varvec{X}}_{\varvec{R}} } \right)^{2} }}{{\varvec{n} - \mathbf{1}}}} $$"
the respective specific uncertainties are
as follows :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c117/8c117a23e13fd533422cc7bafd2c1c22afd1b3e5" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} \varvec{U}_{\varvec{A}} & = \varvec{k} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{A}} = \pm \mathbf{2} \cdot \mathbf{0.02}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} = \pm \mathbf{0.04}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ \varvec{U}_{\varvec{B}} & = \varvec{k} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{B}} = \pm \mathbf{2} \cdot \mathbf{0.04}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} = \pm \mathbf{0.08}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ \varvec{U}_{\varvec{C}} & = \varvec{k} \cdot \varvec{s}_{\varvec{C}} = \pm \mathbf{2} \cdot \mathbf{0.09}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} = \pm \mathbf{0.18}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
If the results are expressed in the
form
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e0838/e08386c4a030d14bdf980f3aaf6ef85b1dad0ea5" alt="$$ \varvec{R} \pm \varvec{U}_{\varvec{R}} \quad \varvec{where}\quad \varvec{R} = \overline{\varvec{X}}_{\varvec{R}} , $$"
then :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9b09e/9b09e6f4d4b2e18f3af1f00f37fa5051394a5b54" alt="$$ \begin{aligned} & \varvec{Method}\,\varvec{A}:\mathbf{1.32} \pm \mathbf{0.04}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ & \varvec{Method}\,\varvec{B}:\mathbf{1.31} \pm \mathbf{0.08}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ & \varvec{Method}\,\varvec{C}:\mathbf{1.33} \pm \mathbf{0.18}\,{\mathbf{mg}}/{\mathbf{L}} \\ \end{aligned} $$"
Method A is therefore seemingly the most
precise. However, it was used incorrectly because it was applied to
the whole sample rather than to aliquots. Therefore, the calculated
precision is spurious and should be discarded .
Method B is the most precise after A. The
analytical process was performed correctly, so the calculated
precision can be deemed valid. However, the precision corresponds
to repeatability and is thus scarcely rigorous .
Method C is the least precise. The
analytical process was performed correctly, so its calculated
precision can be deemed valid. Also, it corresponds to
reproducibility and is therefore more rigorous than that of Method
B .
In summary, Method B, which was performed
under repeatable conditions, is the most precise. Method C is less
precise than B but more rigorous because it was performed under
reproducible conditions. Finally, Method A was performed under
neither repeatable nor reproducible conditions, so its results can
hardly be valid .
Chapter 3. Reference Materials
-
3.1 . What are the main purposes of a sample matrix standard with a certified analyte content (a CRM)? Tick the correct answers.
Answer :
-
[ ] Calibrating an instrument
-
[X] Globally assessing an analytical process
-
[ ] Calibrating a method
-
[ ] Standardizing secondary analytical chemical standards
A CRM can also be used to calibrate a
special instrument such as an X-ray spectrometer .
-
3.2 . What is a matrix standard? What is its main use?
Answer :
A matrix standard is a high-quality
material mimicking the composition of a sample and having the value
of an associated quantity certified by a competent body. Matrix
standards are certified reference materials (CRMs) that are
typically used to globally assess analytical methods but can also
be useful to calibrate special instruments .
-
3.3 . What are the essential requirements for establishing the traceability of an instrument?
Answer :
The two basic requirements for
establishing traceability in an instrument coincide with the
notions inherent in traceability, namely :
-
Linking the instrument to its calibration standards, which in turn must be connected to standards of a higher quality (e.g., certified reference materials) .
-
Tracing the “history” of the instrument by recording the time it was installed, its usage and users, its routine calibrations, any servicing or repairs, etc. This facet is closely related to analytical quality .
-
The two are related by the history of the instrument’s calibration .
-
3.4 . Tick the type correct type of standard in each case.
Answer :
Standard
|
||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Basic
|
Chemical
|
Analytical chemical
|
||
Primary
|
Secondary
|
|||
Carbon-12
|
X
|
|||
A 0.1 mol L −1 solution of KMnO
4
|
X
|
|||
Potassium hydrogen phthalate
|
X
|
|||
Ultrapure silver
|
X
|
X
|
||
The faraday
|
X
|
-
3.5 . Describe the traceability network among standards relevant to Analytical Chemistry with emphasis on the connections between basic, chemical and analytical chemical standards.
Answer :
This traceability network comprises linear
and branching links among base (SI) standards, chemical standards
and the analytical chemical standards used in practice
.
There is a linear traceability chain
connecting the mole (a base standard), the mass of carbon-12,
atomic weights (chemical standards), and primary and secondary
analytical chemical standards .
The linear
link backbone branches as follows :
- (1)
The mole is defined in terms of the kilogram, a base (SI) standard .
- (2)
The faraday (an operational chemical standard) is related to the mass of carbon-12 through Avogradro’s number ( N ), and also to the ampere and the second (two base standards) .
-
3.6 . How would you define “traceability of an analytical method (CMP)”?
Answer :
An analytical method or (bio)chemical
measurement process (CMP) is traceable if it can be linked to a
reliable reference. Such is the case, for example, with
-
a certified reference material (CRM) if the results of subjecting it to the CMP coincide with the certified value; and
-
the result of an intercomparison exercise—one managed by a prestigious national or international organization—if the result of the laboratory concerned does not differ substantially from the mean for the body of participating laboratories and its uncertainty .
Proven traceability in the results of a
method can be included in a laboratory’s reports in order to
persuade clients of the quality of the method .
-
3.7 . The total free acid content of a wine sample is determined by acid–based titration with a sodium hydroxide solution previously standardized with potassium hydrogen phthalate. What standards are used in the process?
Answer :
-
Chemical: Atomic weights used in calculations
-
Primary analytical chemical: Potassium hydrogen phthalate
-
Secondary analytical chemical: Sodium hydroxide
-
3.8 . Define “equipment calibration” and relate it to or distinguish it from “method calibration”.
Answer :
Equipment calibration is intended to
assure proper performance of an instrument or apparatus used in the
second step of the analytical process. Equipment is calibrated by
using reference materials not containing the analyte to record
their signals. If the signals depart from the expected values, the
instrument is adjusted as required (e.g., by replacing the lamp in
a spectrophotometer) .
Method calibration differs from equipment
calibration in the following respects :
- (a)
The target is an analytical method rather than an instrument or apparatus .
- (b)
A signal is related to the presence or concentration of the analyte through a calibration curve .
- (c)
A standard containing the analyte is used .
- (d)
It is performed after equipment calibration .
-
3.9 . What are the purposes of equipment calibration (verification)? Tick the correct answer(s).
Answer :
-
[ ] Constructing a calibration curve
-
[X] Adjusting faulty equipment
-
[ ] Globally assessing an analytical method
-
[ ] Distinguishing error types in Analytical Chemistry
-
3.10 . Connect each of the following standards to its type in the column on the right.
Answer :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3f733/3f733c3007bcbb9ed4b0de2a3be5e436a95537af" alt="A431731_1_En_BookBackmatter_Figc_HTML.gif"
-
3.11 . Rank the reliability of the following types of standards with a score from 1 (least reliable) to 4 (most reliable).
Answer :
Standard
|
Reliability
|
---|---|
Secondary analytical chemical
standard
|
4
|
Chemical standard
|
1
|
CRM
|
2
|
Primary analytical chemical standard
|
3
|
-
3.12 . What role do analytical chemical standards play in the traceability of a result?
Answer :
Traceability of results cannot be assured
without analytical chemical standards, which play two crucial
roles, namely :
- (a)
Certified reference materials (CRMs) are the ultimate references .
- (b)
Primary standards are intermediate links in the traceability chain connecting a result to a CRM .
-
3.13 . What type of standard (basic, chemical or analytical chemical) has the greatest associated uncertainty? Why?
Answer :
Uncertainty is greatest in analytical
chemical standards because they constitute the last link in the
traceability (comparison) chain among the standards that are
relevant to Analytical Chemistry .
-
3.14 . A sample of powdered milk with a protein content certified in a document issued by a renowned independent organization is
Answer :
-
[ ] A primary standard
-
[X] A certified reference material
-
[ ] A secondary standard
-
[ ] A reference material
-
3.15 . Name the types of chemical standards, state their differences and give some examples.
Answer: There are two main types of
chemical standards :
-
Non-operational (tabulated) standards such as the mass of Carbon-12, atomic weights, among others .
-
Operational standards (e.g., the Faraday), which are established through experimentation .
-
3.16 . Give an example of each complementary criterion used to classify analytical chemical standards.
Answer :
The standards used in chemical processes
can be classified in a non-excluding manner according to nature
(physical, chemical), stability and/or purity (primary, secondary),
and the certifying authority (reference materials and certified
reference materials) .
-
3.17 . Comment on the tracing facet of traceability of a result. What should it be consistent with?
Answer :
The tracing facet of an analytical result,
which is complementary to the relation to references, requires that
a laboratory result be invariably accompanied by information
allowing questions such as the following to be answered: Who
performed the analysis? When was it performed? How? What tools were
used? Under which environmental circumstances was it conducted?
etc .
This facet is fully consistent with the
quality systems to be implemented in analytical laboratories. One
essential aspect of quality systems is the production of documents
facilitating characterization of past results—in order, for
example, to meet auditors’ requests .
-
3.18 . Describe a procedure for assessing (validating) a new analytical method in terms of its relationship to matrix-type certified reference materials.
Answer :
Ideally, new analytical methods should be
validated with a certified reference material (CRM) whose matrix is
identical with that of the sample to be analysed and comes with a
certified analyte concentration and its uncertainty .
A total of n aliquots of the CRM are subjected to the
analytical process to be validated, and the ensuing result and its
specific uncertainty are compared with those of the CRM. The
following conclusions can be made if they coincide
statistically :
-
the method is validated (that is, deemed valid for the intended purpose); and
-
the method is traceable to the CRM used .
-
3.19 . What is the main limitation of CRMs for establishing the traceability of methods?
Answer :
The greatest constraint of CRMs is their
scarcity in commercial form (only 5–10% of the CRMs required by
analytical laboratories are commercially available). This entails
using alternative procedures to assure traceability in analytical
methods (e.g., participating in intercomparison exercises involving
a large number of laboratories) .
-
3.20 . What types of standards prevail among (a) reference materials (RMs) and (b) certified reference materials (CRMs)?
Answer :
Most RMs are physical or chemical (e.g.,
pure or mixed substances), whereas most CRMs are chemical and of
the sample matrix type .
-
3.21 . Which base standard is the most relevant to Chemical Metrology? Why?
Answer :
The ultimate base (SI) chemical standard
is the mole, which is defined in terms of the kilogram. Several
other base standards are also relevant to Metrology in Chemistry,
however. The importance of the mole arises from the fact that it is
related to the mass of carbon-12, to atomic weights and to primary
and secondary standards, through a traceability chain
.
-
3.22 . Why are secondary standards used even though they have unsuitable properties (e.g., instability, impurity)?
Answer :
Because they possess unique chemical
properties. Such is the case with sodium hydroxide, a very strong
base that is highly suitable for titrating both strong and weak
acids .
-
3.23 . What are the requirements for a matrix-type CRM?
Answer :
-
The material should be homogeneous and stable .
-
It should be very similar to the target sample in composition .
-
It should come with a certified value and its uncertainty or be assigned the two in an interlaboratory exercise (the relational facet of traceability) .
-
The material should come with a detailed history of its origin (natural or artificial), stability and homogeneity, and information about the certifying campaign including the results of all participating laboratories (the tracing facet of traceability) .
-
3.24 . What are the three most salient general uses of analytical chemical standards?
Answer :
- 1.
Equipment and method calibration .
- 2.
Overall assessment (validation) of chemical measurement processes (CMPs) .
- 3.
Standardization of secondary standards with primary standards .
-
3.25 . What are the three principal meanings of traceability of an analytical result?
Answer :
- 1.
Relationship to references (standards)—the most orthodox .
- 2.
Tracing facet: documented history of production .
- 3.
Practical facet: Comparison and harmonization of analytical laboratories .
-
3.26 . How is an analytical method assessed to assure reliability?
Answer :
By subjecting n aliquots of a certified
reference material (CRM) to the method (analytical process) and
comparing the result and its uncertainty with the certified values.
If they coincide, the method can be reliably used for the intended
purpose .
In the absence of an appropriate CRM, the
best choice is to take part in an intercomparison exercise. If the
result obtained by the laboratory concerned is consistent with the
mean for the body of participating laboratories, the method can be
deemed reliable .
-
3.27 . What analytical properties are related to traceability? Explain your answer.
Answer :
Traceability is related to the capital
properties (accuracy and representativeness) .
Accuracy is associated to the relationship
to traceability references and representativeness is associated to
the traceability of the sample aliquot subjected to the analytical
process .
-
3.28 . On what should mutual recognition of the results of two or more laboratories rest?
Answer :
On the comparability of the results
obtained by analysing the same CRM and/or on consistency of their
results with the mean of an intercomparison exercise where the two
have participated .
-
3.29 . What feature and twofold meaning does traceability of the sample aliquot subjected to an analytical process have?
Answer :
Traceability to samples is an unorthodox
concept because it includes the tracing facet but excludes the
relational facet (that is, the linkage to references)
.
Because of the dual nature of
traceability, the sample aliquot should be related to both the
information required and the result of an analytical process
.
Chapter 4. Generalities of the Analytical Process
-
4.1 . What question does the development of an analytical process essentially answer regarding extraction of (bio)chemical information from an object: what, how, when or where?
Answer :
Essentially, it answers the following
question: How is the information extracted?
The other questions are intended to
identify the analyte (what?), and the place (where?) and time
(when?) the sample is obtained .
-
4.2 . Why do analytical processes invariably use measurement standards? How are they used?
Answer :
Analytical Chemistry is the chemical and
biochemical metrological science. In other words, it is the science
of (bio)chemical measurements. Measuring involves comparing and
comparing requires using a reference (e.g., a standard). The
analytical process is therefore meaningless unless appropriate
standards are used for equipment and method calibration
.
-
4.3 . A manufacturing process leads to an error in the quality-related parameters for the product that requires analytical control. What kind of sampling should be done in this situation?
-
[ ] Intuitive
-
[ ] Statistical
-
[X] Directed
-
[ ] Protocol-based
-
Explain why.
Answer :
After the error is identified, only the
samples leading to the error are resampled. Hence the sampling is
of the directed type .
-
4.4 . What is the difference between “dissolution” and “disaggregation” of a solid sample?
Answer :
Both operations are related to the
preparation of solid samples .
Dissolution uses a solvent (e.g., an acid)
to solubilize a solid solute (e.g., a calcareous rock) until none
remains suspended or in the bottom of the vessel. Leaching
(solid–liquid extraction) is used to selectively dissolve a given
component of a solid sample .
Disaggregation is a drastic dissolution
operation used when attack with a solvent proves ineffective. The
sample is mixed with an acid flux such as KHSO
4
or an alkaline one such as
Na 2
CO 3 and melted at a high temperature in a
platinum or nickel crucible. Then, the molten mass is allowed to
cool for easy dissolution in an appropriate solvent .
-
4.5 . Give four definitions of “sampling” or “sample collection”.
Answer :
- (1)
The body of operations used to select a portion (aliquot) of the object from which (bio)chemical information is to be extracted .
- (2)
The first substep in the preliminary operations of the analytical process .
- (3)
The link between the object and the analytical process .
- (4)
The foundation of the capital analytical property “representativeness”, which, together with “accuracy”, characterizes the quality of analytical results .
-
4.6 . How does the availability of materials and equipment (reagents, solvents, apparatuses, instruments, etc.) influence the choice of an analytical process for a specific sample–analyte pair? Use one or more examples.
Answer :
In the following example, the information
required is the content, in ppb, of aflatoxins of whole milk from
cows fed with contaminated feed .
The analytical process will be very
simple, expeditious and reliable—but also very expensive—if a
specific immunoassay is used; also, the sample will require little
processing. In the absence of a direct test, the sample treatment
will be a complex, time-consuming process using a liquid
chromatograph interfaced to a mass spectrometer. This equipment is
unaffordable for many laboratories. In fact, a modest peripheral
laboratory at a dairy cooperative will hardly be able to obtain the
information needed to confirm whether its milk is contaminated with
aflatoxins .
-
4.7 . What factors dictate the choice of an analytical method? What is usually the most important?
Answer :
The most important factor is the
analytical information required (and its characteristics). Thus,
the method of choice will differ depending on whether
-
overall or discriminate, individual information about a mixture of analytes from the same family (e.g., polyphenols in food) is needed;
-
a high accuracy is indispensable (e.g., in the determination of the purity of an imported gold batch);
-
the results are to be obtained within a short time (e.g., determining the fat content of an olive batch in order to establish the price to be paid to members of an agricultural cooperative) .
-
4.8 . Tick the true statements about the preliminary operations of the analytical process:
Answer :
-
[X] They are equivalent to so-called “sample treatment”
-
[X] They typically account for 50–70% of the length of a CMP
-
[ ] They come after measurement and transducing of the analytical signal
-
[ ] They have little impact on the quality of the final result
-
4.9 . Why is sampling important in chemical measurement processes? Tick the correct answers.
Answer :
-
[ ] Because it influences selectivity and sensitivity
-
[X] Because it is essential to assure representativeness in the final result
-
[ ] Because it is a key to robustness in CMPs
-
[ ] Because it has a direct impact on the accuracy of the results of CMPs
-
4.10 . Are equipment and method calibration part of a CMP? Why?
Answer :
Both are in fact essential components of
CMPs. Thus, it is crucial to ensure proper functioning of the
instruments and apparatuses used (equipment calibration) and to
unequivocally relate the presence and/or concentration of the
analyte to an instrumental signal through, for example, a
calibration curve (method calibration) .
-
4.11 . Name at least five features of the preliminary operations of CMPs. Is any of them positive?
Answer :
-
Variable
-
Complex
-
Difficult to automate and control
-
Sources of error
-
Sources of hazards to operators and the environment
-
Slow
In principle, none of these features is
positive .
-
4.12 . What are the positive contributions of the preliminary operations of CMPs?
Answer :
They allow samples to be prepared for
measurement. In fact, most samples cannot be analysed directly—the
ideal situation in Analytical Chemistry as it would allow the
adverse effects of preliminary operations to be circumvented
.
-
4.13 . How are instruments classified according to the nature of the raw signals they provide?
Answer :
Instruments can be
-
Optical (e.g., atomic or molecular absorption or emission spectrophotometers) .
-
Electrochemical (e.g., potentiometers, voltammeters) .
-
Thermal (e.g., thermogravimeters, differential thermal analysers) .
-
Mass (e.g., balances, mass spectrometers) .
-
Magnetic (e.g., nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometers) .
Various other types of instruments are
also used, albeit less commonly, in Analytical Chemistry
.
-
4.14 . What are the two information sources for the third step of the analytical process (data processing and result delivery)?
Answer :
- (1)
Experimental data obtained by subjecting samples, standards and blanks to an analytical process .
- (2)
Tabulated, non-experimental data required for computations (e.g., atomic weights, statistical factors) .
-
4.15 . Name the five factors governing the development of an analytical measurement process.
Answer :
The choice of an existing CMP—and the
development of a new one, if needed—essentially depends on the type
of (bio)chemical information to be obtained from the target object
or sample. The choice may also be influenced by factors associated
to the sample (e.g., availability, nature, state of aggregation),
the analyte (e.g., nature, concentration) and whether absolute or
relative measurements are to be made .
-
4.16 . What are the two main purposes of the preliminary operations of CMPs?
Answer :
- 1.
To facilitate the analytical process (by making the sample ready for measurement) .
- 2.
To improve analytical properties (sensitivity and selectivity, mainly) .
-
4.17 . Why is variability a negative connotation of analytical processes?
Answer :
Because each sample–analyte combination
requires a specific sample treatment. This precludes
generalization, so
-
it entails developing an analytical process and sample treatment suited to each situation; and
-
it precludes the development of affordable all-purpose commercial equipment except for widespread determinations such as that of Kjeldahl nitrogen .
-
4.18 . How is automatability related to the preliminary operations of the analytical process?
Answer :
The mechanical complexity of some
preliminary operations of sample treatment (e.g., precipitation,
disaggregation, extraction) precludes their automation—which would
provide highly interesting advantages such as reduced human
involvement and operator risks. Some techniques such as solid-phase
extraction (SPE) have benefited from the development of
multi-extraction equipment that is highly appreciated by routine
laboratories receiving large numbers of samples each day
.
-
4.19 . What is the most sluggish, labour-intensive and error-prone step of an analytical process?
Answer :
That of preliminary operations (sample
collection and treatment here). According to some authors, sampling
does not belong in the analytical process .
-
4.20 . What should be balanced in designing a sampling plan?
Answer :
The number of samples to be collected from
the object, which should be as small as possible in order to
maximize productivity-related analytical properties, and
representativeness (a capital analytical property), which should be
as high as possible .
-
4.21 . What are the four types of sampling arising from the overall sampling plan?
Answer :
-
Intuitive sampling (designed by an experienced analyst)
-
Statistical sampling (based on statistical probability rules)
-
Directed sampling (when a specific type of information is sought)
-
Protocol-based sampling (established by the client or official regulations)
-
4.22 . What names are samples given according to size and nearness to the object?
Answer :
Bulk sample, aggregate (composite) sample,
laboratory sample and test sample (aliquot) .
-
4.23 . Distinguish “object” and “sample”.
Answer :
The object is the entity about which
(bio)chemical information is required (e.g., a river, a mine, an
agricultural field) .
The sample is an aliquot of the object
that is collected according to a specific sampling plan
.
-
4.24 . When and why must organic matter in a sample be destroyed in the preliminary operations of the analytical process?
Answer :
Organic matter is destroyed by using an
appropriate wet or dry procedure in order to prevent it from
interfering with the determination of inorganic analytes
.
-
4.25 . What basic properties are favourably affected by separation techniques? What capital property is also favoured? What basic property can be adversely affected?
Answer :
- (a)
Sensitivity (through preconcentration) and selectivity (through interference removal) .
- (b)
Accuracy, which rests on sensitivity and selectivity .
- (c)
Precision (random errors increase as more preliminary operations are needed) .
-
4.26 . How are instruments classified according to the nature of the analytes to be determined?
Answer :
There are two types of instruments
according to analyte nature, namely :
Active instruments, which interact with
the analyte to have it respond in some form (e.g., by producing
fluorescence) .
Passive instruments (e.g., a
potentiometer), which receive a response from the analyte without
the need to previously excite it .
-
4.27 . How are sampling and representativeness related?
Answer :
The capital analytical property
“representativeness” rests on the atypical basic property “proper
sampling” .
-
4.28 . What are the main types of analytical separation systems?
Answer :
There are two types of systems,
namely :
-
Batch systems .
-
Continuous systems, which can be chromatographic or non-chromatographic .
Chapter 5. Quantitative Analytical Processes
-
5.1 . The determination of pyrethrins in a food sample gives a concentration of 10 µg/kg. Express it in ppb and as a percentage.
Answer :
Expressing the stated concentration in ppb
entails using a conversion factor. Since 1 ppb is equivalent to 1
µg/kg, then
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/05696/05696ac80e2b73ee3ee51197e2b2606f1215ded4" alt="$$ \mathbf{10}\frac{{{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}}}{{{\mathbf{kg}}}}\cdot \frac{{\mathbf{1}\;\mathbf{ppb}}}{{\mathbf{1}\frac{{{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}}}{{{\mathbf{kg}}}}}} = \mathbf{10}\,{\mathbf{ppb}} $$"
Expressing the concentration as a
percentage requires using the definition of “ppb” (one part per
billion) in order to establish a proportion (a fraction of unity
that is then multiplying by 100 to obtain the percentage) :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e5a46/e5a4684e14f701f598d22d8080a8e69d9c184628" alt="$$ \mathbf{10}\,{\mathbf{ppb }} \equiv \frac{{\mathbf{10}\,\varvec{parts}}}{{\mathbf{10}^{\mathbf{9}} \,\varvec{parts}}} \to \frac{{\mathbf{10}\,\varvec{parts}}}{{\mathbf{10}^{\mathbf{9}} \,\varvec{parts}}} \times \mathbf{100} = \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{6}} \varvec{\% } $$"
-
5.2 . An amount of 0.231 mg of a compound of molecular weight 114 g/mol is added to a volume of 500 mL of water. Calculate the resulting concentration in (a) mol L −1 , (b) ppb and (c) µg/g water.
- (a)
mol L −1
- (a)
Answer :
The mass is divided into the molecular
weight to obtain an amount of substance (mol) and then by the
volume of water used to dissolve it because the resulting solution
volume is assumed to be very similar to the volume of water used to
prepare the solution :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4d436/4d4365279be331fb70cee63a1a1edc12c03c6e4a" alt="$$ \begin{array}{*{20}c} {\mathbf{0.231} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{3}} \;{\mathbf{g}}\cdot\frac{{\mathbf{1}\;{\mathbf{mol}}}}{{\mathbf{114}\;{\mathbf{g}}}} = \mathbf{2.03} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{6}} \;{\mathbf{mol}}} \\ {\varvec{Concentration }\left( {{\mathbf{mol}}\;{\mathbf{L}}^{ - \mathbf{1}} } \right) = \frac{{\mathbf{2.03} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{6}} \;{\mathbf{mol}}}}{{\mathbf{0.5}\;{\mathbf{L}}}} = \mathbf{4.06} \times \mathbf{10}^{ - \mathbf{6}} \;{\mathbf{mol}}\;{\mathbf{L}}^{ - \mathbf{1}} } \\ \end{array} $$"
(b) ppb
Answer :
Since 1 ppb is equivalent to 1 µg/kg and, on the assumption that the solution
will be so highly dilute that is density will virtually coincide
with that of water ( 1
g/mL ), then
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d1ab0/d1ab0137d3b4eada5cb3016c0dcb2ebc76d9c613" alt="$$ \begin{array}{*{20}c} {\mathbf{0.231}\,{\mathbf{mg}} \equiv \mathbf{231}\,{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}} \\ {\mathbf{500}\,{\mathbf{mL}} \equiv \mathbf{500}\,{\mathbf{g}} \equiv \mathbf{0.5}\,{\mathbf{kg}}} \\ {\varvec{Concentration }\left( {{\mathbf{ppb}}} \right) = \frac{{\mathbf{231}\,{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}}}{{\mathbf{0.5}\,{\mathbf{kg}}}} = \mathbf{461}\,{\mathbf{ppb}}} \\ \end{array} $$"
(c) µg/g
Answer :
The concentration in ppb obtained in (b)
is multiplied by an appropriate conversion factor :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/00442/004421f682b0c7d0d22f53ed8355c90b97d0f677" alt="$$ \mathbf{461}\,{\mathbf{ppb}} = \frac{{\mathbf{461}\,{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}}}{{\mathbf{1}\,{\mathbf{kg}}}}\cdot\frac{{\mathbf{1}\,{\mathbf{kg}}}}{{\mathbf{1000}\,{\mathbf{g}}}} = \mathbf{0.461}\;\frac{{{\varvec{\upmu} \mathbf{g}}}}{{\mathbf{g}}} $$"
-
5.3 . How do titrimetries differ from gravimetries? Tick the correct answers.
Answer :
-
[ ] Titrimetries are not classical method of analysis
-
[ ] They are not quantitative methods
-
[X] They use analytical chemical standards (only titrimetries do)
-
[ ] They are not absolute methods
-
[ ] They use no atomic weights as chemical standards
-
5.4 . Which features would you associate with titrimetries and gravimetries? Tick the correct answers.
Answer :
Feature
|
Titrimetries
|
Gravimetries
|
---|---|---|
Absolute methods using no analytical
chemical standards
|
X
|
|
Absolute methods using analytical chemical
standards
|
X
|
|
Relative quantification methods
|
||
Only use atomic weights as standards
|
X
|
|
Use analytical chemical standards
|
X
|
|
Use base standards
|
X
|
X
|
Have the shortest traceability chain
|
X
|
-
5.5 . Briefly describe the foundation of a back-titration.
Answer :
A back-titration must be performed when no
direct titration is possible. Essentially, it involves adding
excess titrant in order to ensure that the whole amount of analyte
present will react and then titrating unreacted titrant with an
appropriate reagent .
-
5.6 . Which of the following methods use no analytical chemical standards?
Answer :
-
[ ] Titrimetries
-
[ ] Relative interpolation methods
-
[X] Gravimetries
-
5.7 . What are the key features of absolute analytical methods?
Answer :
Absolute analytical methods possess two
main features, namely :
-
They use base and chemical standards—and also analytical chemical standards in some cases .
-
They are used in both Classical and Instrumental Analysis .
-
5.8 . Convert the following concentrations into percentages:
Answer :
Concentration
|
%
|
---|---|
1 ppm
|
10 −4
|
1 ppb
|
10 −7
|
1 µg/L
|
10 −7
|
1 mg/L
|
10 −4
|
1 ng/L
|
10 −10
|
-
5.9 . What are the differences between gravimetry and titrimetry in the following respects?
Answer :
Gravimetry
|
Titrimetry
|
|
---|---|---|
Type of analytical method used
|
Absolute calculable
|
Absolute calculable
|
Standards used
|
Base,
chemical
|
Base,
chemical, analytical chemical
|
Analytical properties
|
High
accuracy, short traceability chain
|
Low
accuracy, high simplicity, high expeditiousness
|
-
5.10 . Explain the differences between “absolute” and “relative” quantification methods.
Answer :
Absolute methods use a mathematical law in
combination with a tabulated constant to calculate the amount of
analyte present in a sample .
On the other hand, relative methods
compare experimental signals for standards with that for the
analyte in order to calculate the amount of analyte .
-
5.11 . What analytical properties apply to Quantitative Analysis?
Answer :
The three types discussed in Chap .
2 , namely :
-
Capital properties: accuracy and representativeness .
-
Basic properties: precision, sensitivity, selectivity, robustness and proper sampling .
-
Productivity-related properties: expeditiousness, safety and cost-effectiveness .
-
5.12 . What are the instruments typically used in Classical Quantitative Analysis?
Answer :
Basically, the classical burette in
titrimetries and the two-pan balance in gravimetries .
-
5.13 . Name the two types of calculable methods and give an example (analytical process) of each.
Answer :
Calculable methods
|
Example
|
|
---|---|---|
1
|
Absolute methods using no analytical
standards
|
Gravimetry
|
2
|
Absolute methods using analytical
standards
|
Titrimetry
|
-
5.14 . Describe several ways of expressing the results in Quantitative Analysis.
Answer :
A quantitative result can be expressed in
two different forms, namely :
-
Absolute (as a mass) .
-
Relative: as a proportion (e.g., %, ppm, ppb), a mass–volume ratio (e.g., g/L) or as a mass–mass ratio (e.g., g/kg) .
-
5.15 . What type of quantitative analytical method requires no method calibration? Why? Give an example.
Answer :
Method calibration is unnecessary in
absolute methods using no analytical standards (e.g., gravimetries)
because they have a very short traceability chain and their results
can be directly related to base and chemical standards
.
-
5.16 . What is the gravimetric factor? Tick the correct answer.
Answer :
-
[X] A ratio of molecular or atomic weights.
-
[X] A dimensionless number that is multiplied by the gravimetric weighing to calculate the mass of analyte
-
[ ] A number by which the atomic weight of the analyte is multiplied to express the result
-
[X] A factor calculated from the molecular weight of the weighed form
-
5.17 . What are the five requirements to be fulfilled by a chemical reaction to be useful for titrimetric purposes?
Answer :
- (1)
A well-defined stoichiometry .
- (2)
Developing to completion (that is, having a large product formation constant) .
- (3)
Being fast .
- (4)
Being selective .
- (5)
Having an appropriate end-point indicator .
-
5.18 . Name the three types of visual indication systems in titrimetry.
Answer :
- (1)
Auto-indicators .
- (2)
Chemical substances interacting with the analyte .
- (3)
Chemical substances interacting with the titrant .
-
5.19 . Is Classical Quantitative Analysis possible with a relative method? Why?
Answer :
No. The instruments used in Classical
Analysis produce no signals. Therefore, they do not allow the use
of a relative method to compare the signal for the sample with that
for a standard .
-
5.20 . Why does sensitivity in gravimetries increase with decreasing gravimetric factor?
Answer :
Because the smaller the gravimetric factor
is, the greater is the molecular weight of the weighted form
relative to the analyte—and hence the smaller is the amount of
analyte that can be detected in a given gravimetric weighing
.
-
5.21 . What is a titrimetry? Tick the correct answer.
Answer :
-
[ ] A quantitative method for identifying analytes
-
[ ] A relative interpolation method
-
[X] An absolute quantitative method using analytical standards
-
[ ] An absolute quantitative method using no analytical standards
-
5.22 . Explain the relationship between gravimetric factor and sensitivity in gravimetry.
Answer :
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ddf8f/ddf8fbd614b37913670ddbd107f48ad5924f054f" alt="$$ \varvec{P}_{\varvec{A}} = \varvec{G} \cdot \varvec{P}_{\varvec{g}} $$"
The smaller the gravimetric factor (G) is,
the higher is the sensitivity of a method (that is, the smaller is
the amount of analyte it can detect with a gravimetric
weighing) .
Chapter 6. Qualitative Analytical Processes
-
6.1 . Does the qualitative analysis of samples fit in Classification Analysis?
Answer :
Yes. This is the simplest form of
classification analysis. Samples are classified into two groups
depending on whether they give a YES response or a NO response.
Dubious samples may be included in a third group .
-
6.2 . What name is usually given to qualitative analytical processes?
Answer :
Test (or assay) .
-
6.3 . Tick the analytical properties that are not applicable to Qualitative Analysis.
Answer :
-
[ ] Representativeness
-
[X] Accuracy
-
[X] Precision
-
[ ] Sensitivity (only the limit of detection can be used)
-
6.4 . Two methods for the qualitative analysis of milk samples possibly contaminated with pesticides provide wrong information. Thus, method A gives false positives and method B false negatives. Which would you use? Why?
Answer :
Method A because
- (a)
it gives no false negatives; and
- (b)
any false positives it provides can be ascertained by using an appropriate confirmation technique .
-
6.5 . What are the main differences between Qualitative Analysis and Quantitative Analysis? Tick the correct answers.
Answer :
-
[X] The binary response
-
[ ] A classical method of analysis
-
[ ] The use of analytical chemical standards
-
[X] The analytical property “reliability”
-
[ ] Selectivity
-
6.6 . What are the differences between binary and multiple classification in Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
Binary classification splits the body of
samples into two groups only according to whether they give a YES
response or a NO response. On the other hand, multiple
classification provides more than two groups according to various
criteria (e.g., the origin of wine samples) .
-
6.7 . What are the factors dictating the following parameters?
Answer :
- (a)
Limit of detection (The analytical process, CMP)
- (b)
Cut-off concentration (The laboratory)
- (c)
Threshold concentration (Applicable legislation and the client)
-
6.8 . What is a false positive in Qualitative Analysis? Give an example.
Answer :
A YES response which should have been
NO .
Example: A YES response to an analyte
concentration of 1.5 ppb by a method with C
LOD
= 2 ppb is a false
positive .
-
6.9 . What is a false negative in Qualitative Analysis? Give an example.
Answer :
A NO response which should have been
YES .
Example: A NO response to an analyte
concentration of 2.5 ppb by a method with C
LOD
= 2 ppb is a false
negative .
-
6.10 . An immunochemical test (method A) and a chemical spot test (method B) are used to detect the same analyte in the same sample. The results of analysing 100 samples are as follows:Reliability (%)False positives (%)False negatives (%)Method A9523Method B9460
Which method provides the better
results? Why?
Answer :
Method B. Although it is less reliable,
its proportion of false negatives is 0%, which makes it highly
reliable. Also, any false positives it provides can be ascertained
by using a confirmation technique .
-
6.11 . What analytical properties are applicable to quantitative determinations but not to qualitative tests? Why?
Answer :
Accuracy, precision and two
sensitivity-related parameters (IUPAC’s S and the limit of
quantification, C LOQ ) .
-
6.12 . What are “analytical systems with group separation” in Classical Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
Analytical schemes that are used to
classify analytes experimentally (e.g., by chemical precipitation).
The resulting groups allow the analytes in them to be determined
individually (that is, without interference from the others in the
group) .
-
6.13 . What are the differences between group, identification and masking reagents in Classical Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
Group
reagents allow a
mixture of analytes to be separated into groups where each
individual analyte can be reliable detected .
Identification reagents react with the analyte to produce an
external effect (e.g., a colour change, formation of a gas or
precipitate) that can be identified by the human senses
.
Masking reagents form stable, soluble, colourless chelates
with interfering species .
-
6.14 . Name two identification (Qualitative Analysis) procedures used in dynamic instrumental systems (e.g., chromatography).
Answer :
-
Use of an internal standard to make standardized measurements .
-
Addition of a standard of the analyte to the sample .
-
6.15 . Tick the words directly connected with Qualitative Analysis:
Answer :
-
[X] Detection
-
[ ] Quantification
-
[X] Identification
-
[X] Qualification
-
6.16 . How does a “white” sample differ from a “black” sample?
Answer :
A white sample is a sample whose
properties are quite well-known or predictable (e.g., water from a
spring). On the other hand, a black sample is one whose properties
are completely unknown (e.g., a previously never analysed lunar
rock) .
-
6.17 . Is Qualitative Analysis important to modern Analytical Chemistry? Why?
Answer :
Qualitative Analysis in its classical and
instrumental forms continues to be in wide use today because most
of the analytical information required is of the binary type
.
-
6.18 . What are the three quantitative landmarks for the binary response in Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
The limit of detection (C
LOD
), the cut-off concentration
(C C
) and the threshold
concentration (C L ) .
-
6.19 . One brand of canned tuna fish contains 4 ppm tin. A qualitative test with C LOD = 1 ppm for the metal gave a positive (YES) response. What type of error was made?
Answer :
-
[X] None
-
[ ] A false positive
-
[ ] A false negative
-
6.20 . What type of error is the more crucial in Qualitative Analysis? Why? Give an example.
Answer :
A false negative because a NO response
terminates the process whereas a YES response requires
confirmation .
-
6.21 . Is “specific uncertainty” applicable to Qualitative Analysis? Why?
Answer :
No. It must be adapted to the
singularities of Qualitative Analysis in the form of an unreliable
range around the threshold or cut-off concentration within which
errors (false positives and false negatives) occur .
-
6.22 . What are the three most important limitations of Classical Qualitative Analysis in relation to Instrumental Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
-
A low sensitivity
-
A low selectivity
-
A narrower scope
-
6.23 . What are the three types of reagents used in Qualitative Analysis? What is their purpose? Give an example of each.
Answer :
Name
|
Purpose
|
Example
|
|
---|---|---|---|
Type 1
|
Identification
|
Recognition
|
Detection of Pb 2+ with I –
|
Type 2
|
Group
|
Grouping species to avoid
interferences
|
Separation of Ag + , Pb 2+ and Hg 2
2+
with Cl
–
|
Type 3
|
Masking
|
Avoiding interferences
|
CN – to detect Cd 2+
|
-
6.24 . What are the three main features of so-called “analytical schemes without group separation”?
Answer :
-
They use highly sensitive and selective reagents
-
Their operational sequence must be strictly followed
-
They occasionally require using a separation technique
-
6.25 . What is the difference between a dynamic and a static instrumental system in Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
In a dynamic system, the instrumental
signal is time-dependent; in a static system, it does not change
with time .
-
6.26 . What analytical properties are applicable to Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
-
Capital (accuracy and representativeness) .
-
Basic (sensitivity, selectivity, precision and robustness) .
-
Productivity-related (expeditiousness, cost-effectiveness and safety) .
-
6.27 . Are both types of calibration applicable to Qualitative Analysis?
Answer :
-
Method calibration [X] Yes [ ] No
-
Equipment calibration [X] Yes [ ] No
-
6.28 . What types of instruments does Classical Qualitative Analysis use?
Answer :
It uses the human senses (sight and smell,
mainly) as instruments .
-
6.29 . What are masking reagents? In what context are they used?
Answer :
Masking reagents are substances forming
stable, soluble, colourless chelates with interfering substances
which enable the reliable identification of a species in a group or
a sample without the need for separation. They are typically used
in Classical Qualitative Analysis .
-
6.30 . Define “reliability” in Qualitative Analysis. To which classical analytical properties does it relate?
Answer :
-
The proportion of correct YES/NO answers obtained by subjecting a large number of aliquots from a standard sample to a qualitative process (a test) .
-
A combination of the properties “accuracy” and “precision”, which are used in Quantitative Analysis .
-
6.31 . Instrumental Qualitative Analysis relies on a triple comparison of signals to be subjected to the analytical process. What do the three signals belong to?
Answer :
-
A sample standard containing the analyte .
-
A blank (that is, a sample not containing the analyte) .
-
A sample .
Chapter 7. Analytical Problem-Solving
-
7.1 . Identify the binary interfaces between Analytical Problem-Solving, Analytical Quality and Social Responsibility.
Answer :
Analytical Problem-Solving
|
Analytical Quality
|
Social Responsibility
|
|
---|---|---|---|
Analytical problem-solving
|
×
|
Analytical properties as
indicators
Satisfying information
requirements
|
Satisfying information requirements as an
internal connotation of Social Responsibility
|
Analytical quality
|
Analytical properties as
indicators
Satisfying information
requirements
|
×
|
Quality as a general approach to Social
Responsibility
|
Social responsibility
|
Satisfying information requirements as an
internal connotation of Social Responsibility
|
Quality as a general approach to Social
Responsibility
|
×
|
-
7.2 . What is the third basic standard in Analytical Chemistry? How is it related to the analytical problem?
Answer :
The third basic Standard of Analytical
Chemistry is “required information”, which constitutes the
foundation, core and goal to be fulfilled in order to solve the
analytical problem: the analytical problem delivers the required
information .
-
7.3 . How would you define “fitness for purpose”? To which facet of representativeness is it related? Is it related to chemical metrology?
Answer :
“Fitness for purpose” is the suitability
of the information or results delivered for the intended purpose
and is related to the highest level of representativeness in the
results, which arises in the socio-economic (external) realm.
However, it is completely unrelated to chemical metrology, where
representativeness bears an orthodox, internal meaning, namely:
consistency of the relationship of the results with the sample or
aliquot used to obtain them .
-
7.4 . Describe the roles of the analytical problem in the basic and applied sides of Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
On the basic side, the analytical problem
operates as a support and as an incentive to improve the intrinsic
foundations of Analytical Chemistry (analytical properties,
sampling). Also, it facilitates harmonization and communication
among the different branches of Science for effective transfer of
information and mutual recognition of their results .
On the applied side, the analytical
problem is a means for fulfilling clients’ information needs. In
fact, correctly solving the analytical problem provides a solution
to a real-life socio-economic problem .
-
7.5 . How does the analytical problem relate the analytical chemist to the client?
Answer :
The analytical problem is the
communication interface between clients and analytical chemists,
and the link between the following pairs of elements :
- (1)
The socio-economic problem and the analytical process. The analytical process is designed in accordance with the specificities of the analytical problem, which in turn is conceived with the requirements of the particular socio-economic problem to be solved in mind .
- (2)
The information needs and analytical properties. The information required by clients is converted into objectives to be fulfilled in order to solve the analytical problem—and the objectives contain the analytical properties needed to solve it .
- (3)
External quality and internal (analytical) quality. Internal quality reflects quality in the results and in the analytical process with a view to solving the analytical problem. It should match external quality, which is required by the client to solve the originating socio-economic problem .
-
7.6 . What are the components of the concept hierarchy containing the analytical problem? What place does the analytical problem take in it?
Answer :
The analytical problem is at the top of
the scope hierarchy :
Analytical problem > Object >
Sample/Aliquot > Analyte .
-
7.7 . How would you relate the analytical problem to the leading concepts “reports”, “external quality” and “to analyse” in other hierarchies?
Answer :
The analytical problem requires a solution
that is provided by results that are obtained by analysing and
contained in a report. The quality of the results should match the
external quality needed for the socio-economic problem to be
properly solved .
-
7.8 . Distinguish “orthodox” representativeness from “maximum” representativeness. Which traceability chain does each belong to?
Answer :
“Orthodox representativeness”, which is
that implicit in chemical metrology, is the consistency between the
results and the sample or aliquot analysed to obtain them.
Therefore, it applies to traceability of the results to the sample
or aliquot .
“Maximum representativeness” comprises
consistency between the results and the sample or aliquot used to
obtain them, and also between the analytical problem and the
socio-economic problem. The concept includes fitness for purpose,
which pertains to the applied, socio-economic side of Analytical
Chemistry only. Therefore, maximum representativeness is associated
to the traceability chain results–sample (aliquot)–analytical
problem–socio-economic problem; also, it is the result of a mixed
(orthodox–heterodox) approach to traceability of the sample
(aliquot) .
-
7.9 . A river is suspected to be polluted with toxic organic waste that may be having adverse effects on the nearby population. This hypothesis is verified by collecting 200 samples of water at different depths along the river for analysis. The method used has a limit of detection of 0.7 ppm and a limit of quantification of 2.1 ppm. The effects of the organic waste are felt at concentrations above 3 ppm. The concentration of waste obtained with the chosen method as the average of 200 individual values is 2.7 ppm.
- (a)
Complete the following table.
- (b)
Can the socio-economic problem addressed be correctly solved?
- (c)
Does the analytical method require any corrective actions?
- (a)
Answer :
(a)
Socio-economic problem
|
Checking whether the river is contaminated
with toxic organic waste
|
Analytical problem
|
Detecting and determining organic
compounds with potentially detrimental effects on the
population
|
Object
|
The
river
|
Sample/aliquot
|
Water
from the river as collected at a variable depth at different points
along its course
|
Analyte(s)
|
Toxic
organic compounds
|
Limit of detection ( C LOD )
|
0.7
ppm
|
Limit of quantification ( C LOQ )
|
2.1
ppm
|
Legal limit ( C LL )
|
3
ppm
|
Result ( C obtained )
|
(2.7 ± 0.1)
ppm
|
(b)
Yes. The socio-economic problem can be
solved because the analytical process allows the presence of toxic
organic compounds to be confirmed and their concentration, which is
close to the legally accepted limit, determined .
(c)
No corrective actions are needed because
the limits of detection ( C LOD ) and quantification ( C LOQ ) are valid for detecting and quantifying
the analytes—both are lower than the legal limit (
C LL ) .
-
7.10 . What are the intangible elements of an analytical problem? How do they relate to the steps of the analytical problem-solving process?
Answer :
Intangible elements: planning, design,
evaluation and correction, which are connected to the steps of the
analytical problem-solving process as follows :
- 1.
“planning” to the first and second step (identification, confirmation and definition of the information requirements);
- 2.
“design” to the third step (planning of the analytical strategy);
- 3.
“evaluation” to the fourth step (monitoring and validation of the results); and
- 4.
“correction” to the fifth step (corrective actions) .
-
7.11 . Define and briefly describe the five steps of the analytical problem-solving process. Give an example of socio-economic problem and describe the steps needed to solve it.
Answer :
First step: Identification of the
information requirements, which rests on effective communication
between the client and the analytical chemist in order to define
the characteristics of the information needed. Example: the client
asks the analytical chemist to determine whether a salmon batch is
fit for marketing based on its pinkish colour .
Second step: Specifying the analytical
information required. Conversion of the socio-economic information
requested in the first step into analytical information. Example:
the analytical chemist associates the pinkish colour of salmon to
the concentration of astaxanthin .
Third step: Planning the analytical
strategy. Development of the methodology to be applied (an
appropriate analytical process). Example: The analytical chemist
develops a method by which samples are subjected to solid–liquid
extraction, elution with acetone and liquid–liquid extraction with
hexane in order to isolate astaxanthin free of interferences from
other substances. The pinkish colour is determined by using a
photometer to measure the absorbance at 470 nm of the hexane
extract .
Fourth step: Monitoring the results, which
involves assessing them against internal and external references.
If the results are correct, the analytical process will have been
solved; otherwise, a fifth step will be needed. Example: The
experimental result is compared with a tabulated reference and the
analyte percent recovery as determined by adding a known amount of
astaxanthin as internal standard to a sample .
Fifth step: Corrective actions.
Identifying errors in the previous steps and correcting them. After
each corrective action, the process returns to step 4 until the
analytical problem is solved. Example: if the results are not
acceptable, the solvent used in either or both extractions may have
to be changed with a similar one where astaxanthin is more readily
soluble .
-
7.12 . Why is fluent communication between the analytical chemist and the client important in the first step of the analytical problem-solving process?
Answer :
Because it is the origin of the integral
definition of “required information” and hence the only way in
which the analytical chemist can know what the client needs and how
to supply it .
-
7.13 . Name three essential items of information needed to identify the analytical information required in the second step of the analytical problem-solving process.
Answer :
-
The characteristics of the sample (sampling + sample size) .
-
The type of analyte or measurand sought, and the type of analysis to be performed .
-
The required levels of analytical properties .
-
7.14 . What is the purpose of the third step of the analytical problem-solving process? What are the factors influencing selection and design of a CMP?
Answer :
The third step involves designing and
developing an analytical process suited to the client’s information
needed in order to obtain useful results for the intended
purpose .
The factors influencing the choice of an
existing process or the development of a new one include
-
the type of information required (general or analytical);
-
the specific analyte or measurand;
-
the laboratory’s human, technical and economic resources; and
-
the agreed cost (overall or per analysis) .
-
7.15 . What are the references used to assess the results in the fourth step of the analytical problem-solving process? How are they related to quality?
Answer :
Results are assessed with respect to two
main references, namely :
- (1)
The minimum levels of analytical properties required by the client, which may or may not be fulfilled by the laboratory. This reference is associated to internal (analytical) quality in the results because it pertains to the analytical realm .
- (2)
The information required by the client (the intended purpose). The results must be validated and properly interpreted in order to solve the originating socio-economic problem. This reference is associated to external quality in the results because it falls outside the scope of the analytical laboratory: the analytical information delivered must be interpreted by the client or expert professionals in order to solve the socio-economic problem .
-
7.16 . When is the fifth step of the analytical problem-solving process needed? Why?
Answer :
The fifth step (corrective actions) is
needed when the results of a CMP are not valid (that is, when they
do not meet the required levels of quality and analytical
properties or do not allow the socio-economic problem to be
solved) .
This step is intended to correct errors
made in the previous ones. Such errors may arise from poor
communication between the client and the analytical chemist,
misidentification of the analytical information needed or use of a
CMP whose results do not allow the socio-economic problem to be
solved .
-
7.17 . How can delivered information be in relation to required information? Give an example of each situation.
Answer :
The following situations are
possible :
- (1)
Delivered information = Required information. The two are completely identical. Example: A client requires the content in vitamin C of a given fruit juice and the analytical chemist provides the amount of ascorbic acid (that is, vitamin C) present .
- (2)
Delivered information ≠ Required information. The two are completely different: what is delivered is not what was expected. Example: A client requires the content of vitamin C in a fruit juice and the analytical chemist provides the amount of retinol (vitamin A) in it .
- (3)
Delivered information < Required information. The client is supplied with inadequate information. Example: A client needs the amounts of vitamins A and C in a juice but the analytical chemist only provides the amount of retinol (vitamin A) present .
- 4)
Delivered information > Required information. The client receives more information than is needed for the intended purpose. Example: A client needs the amount of vitamin C but the analytical chemist additionally supplies those of retinol (vitamin A) and cyannocobalamin (vitamin B12), both of which are superfluous for the intended purpose .
-
7.18 . In order to decide whether a person should be pronounced guilty of murder, a laboratory is asked to perform a comparative analysis of a blood sample from the defendant and one containing a mixture of blood from the defendant and the victim blood found in the crime scene. The analysis involves determining the DNA sequence of the defendant, the victim and the mixed blood sample. Please complete the following table by identifying the different elements.
Answer :
Socio-economic problem
|
Whether the defendant is guilty or not
guilty
|
---|---|
Analytical problem (1st step)
|
A
comparative analysis of blood from the victim and the defendant
with that found in the crime scene
|
Analytical information (2nd step)
|
A
qualitative (comparative) characterization of the blood samples for
DNA
|
CMP to be used (3rd step)
|
–
Individual analyses of blood from the victim and the
defendant
–
Analysis of the mixed blood sample found in the crime scene and of
an artificial mixture containing blood from the victim and the
defendant
–
Separation of the two types of blood contained in the mixture for
individual analysis
|
Verification of the results (4th
step)
|
Comparison of the results for the
victim-defendant mixed blood sample and the crime scene
sample
Comparison of the DNA profile for the
defendant with that for the mixed sample not containing blood from
the victim
|
Chapter 8. Analytical Chemistry and Quality
-
8.1 . To what analytical chemical concepts do the basic and applied sides of quality relate?
Answer :
The relationship between Analytical
Chemistry and Quality has two sides: a basic side and an applied
side. On the basic side, Quality is defined as the body of
characteristics, properties, attributes or abilities of an entity
that make it better, worse than or equal to, other entities of the
same type. Consequently, the basic side relates the major
analytical chemical concepts (analytical properties) with Quality
in its broadest sense .
On the applied side, Quality is understood
as the body of characteristics of an entity that allow it to fulfil
specific or implicit requirements of clients or legislation. This
side has to do with the implementation of Quality Systems in
analytical laboratories and is therefore related to the analytical
problem .
-
8.2 . What types of indicators are used to assess quality?
Answer :
The comparisons inherent in the very
notion of Quality can be made by using various types of indicators.
Thus, there are quantitative (numerical data), qualitative (e.g.,
opinions) and integral indicators (combinations of the previous
two). Obviously, the last are the most comprehensive. For example,
properly characterizing a natural environment involves more than
simply checking that the typical parameters (e.g., temperature,
pollutant concentrations in air, water and soil) fall within
acceptable or legally set ranges. The human perception of
well-being is different in technical “clean”, appropriate places.
Also, a given type of agri-food may fulfil all applicable
regulations and yet lack the quality needed for marketing owing to
an unappealing appearance, colour or flavour .
-
8.3 . How are the quality expected and that perceived by the “client” related to the quality planned and designed a body or organization?
Answer :
Achieved quality falls at the boundary
between external and internal quality. The primary aim of an entity
is to have achieved quality fully coincide with designed quality.
On the other hand, clients expect perceived quality to surpass or
at least match expected quality—the former may increase expenses
for the entity concerned. The most critical comparison is that of
expected and perceived quality. Ideally (total quality), the three
types of quality should coincide .
-
8.4 . Distinguish external and internal quality, and relate the two, through two examples: ( a ) a government environmental agency and ( b ) analytical laboratory.
Answer :
Quality can be classified in various ways.
One divides quality into internal and external. Internal quality is
quality in the entity delivering products or services, whereas
external quality is that in the client receiving them
.
Example (a)
In an environmental agency, internal
quality refers to quality of the agency itself, which influences
its management and staff, whereas external quality refers to client
satisfaction. For example, the clients of an environmental
certification agency may be firms seeking certification of their
environmental management and quality, professionals attending
training courses taught by the agency, individuals or firms
commissioning environmental studies, etc .
Example (b)
In an analytical laboratory, external
quality refers to quality of the client or user (e.g., a farmer
needing to have his irrigation water analysed, members of a
residents’ community wishing to have the quality of their pool
water assessed). On the other hand, internal quality coincides with
analytical quality, which is that leading to external quality by
fulfilling information requirements. Internal quality rests on
quality in the results, analytical processes, work and its
organization, and the analytical tools used .
-
8.5 . What are quality trade-offs? Give some examples in various fields.
Answer :
Quality is not utopic. Ideally, a body
should reach a high level of internal properties in an expeditious,
economical and safe manner. In practice, however, internal,
economic, and time- and safety-related features are frequently
contradictory and require adopting some trade-off. Thus, if quality
is to be achieved by maximizing intrinsic properties, costs can be
expected to rise, processes to be slower and staff involvement to
increase .
One clear example in the field of clinical
analysis is that of a patient admitted to the emergency department
of a hospital. The patient will have to be correctly diagnosed
(e.g., with a blood analysis for various parameters) in order to be
properly treated. This situation will require expeditiousness at
the expense of other analytical properties and also greater staff
involvement .
One other example is that of the
determination of inorganic nitrogen in a fertilizer. If a very
large number of samples is to be analysed each day, the laboratory
may seek to minimize costs by using an appropriate tool from a wide
range of choices from a straightforward burette to a sophisticated
neutron activation analyser, for example. The particular tool or
technique of choice will also depend on the intrinsic properties
the results are to have, the availability of staff to implement it
and the time taken by each individual analysis .
Finally, the determination of the gold
content of a jewel in order to assess its purity should prioritize
accuracy because the jewel price will depend considerably on it.
This will entail maximizing intrinsic properties at the expense of
increased costs—the increase may be offset by rising the jewel
price as well, however—longer analysis times and greater staff
involvement .
-
8.6 . What are the structural landmarks in the quality of a body or organization?
Answer :
First, the body or organization should
have a Quality Policy in the form of a document endorsed by the top
decision organ. The Policy materializes in Quality Management
elements and operational systems that are realized in Quality
Assurance, which encompasses all activities performed in order to
assure quality in the body or organization concerned. Such
activities include Quality Control, which involves direct
assessment of the body or organization in terms of quantitative
indicators mainly; Quality Assessment, which involves examining
both the body or organization and its activities; and internal
corrections deriving from the previous two types of
activities .
-
8.7 . Explain some direct or indirect benefits of implementing a Quality System.
Answer :
The direct benefits of a Quality System
are improved characteristics of the product, system or service. The
improvements can be expected to increase client satisfaction, and
also the supplier’s credibility and prestige. For example,
satisfied clients are bound to recommend the services of
laboratories they trust to their acquaintances and their positive
opinions are bound to increase the prestige of the recommended
laboratories as a result .
As regards indirect benefits, implementing
a Quality System can lead to new jobs (e.g., staff for the Quality
Assurance Unity of Good Laboratory Practices). One other potential
benefit is more rational work avoiding superfluous repetitive tasks
by careful planning of laboratory activities in developing the
Quality Manual. Any deficiencies and mistakes arising during
operation will thus be clearly exposed. Also, using a Quality
System makes it easier to establish and clarify goals, helps reduce
indecision and facilitates fluent communication .
-
8.8 . In what way is Analytical Quality related to analytical properties? To which properties are ( a ) quality of results and ( b ) quality of the analytical process related?
Answer :
In its basic definition, Quality is a body
of characteristics or properties. As a result, analytical
properties are directly related to analytical quality and allow its
different facets to materialize. Thus, the quality of analytical
results is related to the capital analytical properties (accuracy
and representativeness), integration of which is
indispensable .
Also, basic and productivity-related
analytical properties are attributes of the analytical process.
Thus, the basic properties (robustness, precision, sensitivity,
selectivity and proper sampling) provide support for the capital
properties, whereas the productivity-related properties
(expeditiousness, cost-effectiveness and safety) characterize
laboratory productivity .
-
8.9 . What is the relationship of quality to analytical quality?
Answer :
Quality can be defined as a body of
properties and is thus related to analytical quality through
analytical properties. Analytical properties play a central role in
the materialization of the characteristics of required analytical
information—a crucial reference for assessing results
.
Also, properly solving an analytical
problem entails fulfilling the client’s information needs and
ensuring consistency between required analytical information and
laboratory-delivered information (that is, ensuring the degree of
analytical quality required to achieve external quality). In the
analytical chemical realm, this entails comparing with standards,
whether written or otherwise, and also with the client’s
information needs .
-
8.10 . Distinguish external and internal corrective actions in the framework of Quality Assurance.
Answer :
Quality Assurance comprises Quality
Assessment, Quality Control and, if needed in view of the quality
of the results, Internal Corrective Actions. Such actions may lead
to partial or total changes in control activities. Quality
Assurance activities of the three types frequently raise the need
for corrective (external) actions initially involving the
laboratory. Such actions must assure quality in the analytical
processes performed by the laboratory through properly organized
and conducted work, and the use of effective analytical tools. In
any case, corrective actions should lead to improved quality in the
laboratory’s analytical results and ability to solve analytical
problems .
-
8.11 . What Quality Assurance elements examine an analytical laboratory?
Answer :
Quality Assurance involves examining both
Quality Control activities and the analytical laboratory—in
addition to the results it produces and its ability to solve
specific analytical problems. Quality Control essentially involves
examining the laboratory and its results .
-
8.12 . Comment on the cyclic nature of Quality Assurance activities in the analytical chemical realm.
Answer :
The activities inherent in the three
elements of Quality Assurance are in fact cyclic in nature. Thus,
Quality Control, which comes into play before and during the
analytical process, involves examining the analytical laboratory
and the results it produces. By contrast, Quality Assessment takes
place during and after the analytical process. Finally, Corrective
Actions are usually performed after the analytical processes if
judged necessary from the outcome of the assessment and can lead to
changes in control activities or the adoption of new ones the next
time the analytical process is conducted .
-
8.13 . On what standards and elements do Quality Systems applied to analytical laboratories rest?
Answer :
The main frameworks for developing quality
systems in analytical laboratories are as follows :
-
The general standard ISO 9000 (Quality Management Systems. Fundamentals and Vocabulary) .
-
The specific standard 17025 (“General Requirements for the Competence of Testing and Calibration Laboratories), which, as implied by its title, applies to testing and calibration laboratories only .
-
Good Laboratory Practices (GLPs), which comprise Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) and the Quality Assurance Unit (QAU) .
Quality systems can also be developed from
combinations of major standards, Total Quality Systems and Critical
Point Systems, among others .
-
8.14 . What are the goals of ISO 17025?
Answer :
The main goals of ISO 17025 are as
follows :
- (a)
To establish a Quality Management System requiring no external recognition .
- (b)
To have technical competence recognized by clients, regulation authorities or accreditation bodies .
-
8.15 . What are Good Laboratory Practices?
Answer :
Good Laboratory Practices (GLPs) are
bodies of rules, operational procedures and practices established
by a given institution such as the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development (OECD) or the European Union (EU) that
are deemed compulsory with a view to assuring quality and
correctness in laboratory results .
GLPs are issued by international bodies
and adopted by national governments through publication in their
official state gazettes and are typically binding for laboratories
performing socially influential analyses such as those of
pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, foodstuffs and products with a
potential environmental impact .
-
8.16 . What are Standard Operating Procedures? Where are they used?
Answer :
A Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) is a
detailed description of each individual activity to be performed by
a laboratory (e.g., sample handling; control of reagents, reference
materials, equipment and methods; archiving) .
-
8.17 . What is the Quality Assurance Unit?
Answer :
The Quality Assurance Unit (QAU) is an
essential element of Good Laboratory Practices. The Unit consists
of staff belonging to the laboratory’s parent body but not to the
laboratory itself and is answerable to the body’s management only.
The QAU’s roles include implementing, controlling and assessing
quality with a view to proposing improvement actions .
-
8.18 . What is a primary method? How does it affect analytical quality?
Answer :
Primary quantification methods are at the
top of the metrological quality ranking. According to the
Consultative Committee for the Amount of Substance (CCQM), a
primary method is “a method having the highest metrological
qualities, whose operations can be completely described and
understood, for which a complete uncertainty statement can be
written down in terms of SI units and whose results are, therefore,
accepted without reference to a standard of the quantity being
measured” .
In summary, a primary method possesses a
high metrological quality, is completely described and understood,
is subject to well-defined uncertainty in terms of SI base
standards and requires no analyte standard .
-
8.19 . What is the difference between an official method and a standard method?
Answer :
An official method is a quantification
method described in detail and issued by a government body such as
the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for legal adoption
with a view to sanctioning the results of laboratories. Some
official methods are used as reference methods, however
.
On the other hand, a standard method is a
method developed, validated and issued by a standardization body
(ISO, CEN) or an association supporting Analytical Chemistry (e.g.,
the AOAC) .
-
8.20 . What activities does quality control involve?
Answer :
Quality Control is a body of planned,
documented actions to be performed by laboratory staff in order to
directly examine the laboratory’s work, the tools it uses and the
results it produces. Such activities typically include the
following :
- (a)
Implementing and using control charts based on reference materials .
- (b)
Examining and correcting instruments and apparatuses to ensure that they operate as they should .
- (c)
Examining the purity and stability of the reagents and solutions used in CMPs .
- (d)
Examining experimental laboratory conditions such as temperature, relative humidity, cleanliness and presence of contaminants .
- (e)
Examining the sample custody system in order to ensure correlation between samples and results .
- (f)
Using RMs and CRMs to examine CMPs at specific points .
- (g)
Examining any changes in the results arising from the use of a CMP to determine specific analytes in a given sample by different staff or with different analytical tools .
-
8.21 . Why is labelling quality assessment activities as external or internal confusing?
Answer :
Depending on the assessor (that is, on the
human factor), Quality Assessment is classified as internal or
external. This classification, however, can be confusing because it
rests on at least two different criteria. Thus, assessors may
members of the laboratory staff, its parent body or an external
entity. It is therefore preferable to classify Quality Assessment
according to the following two alternative criteria :
-
Whether the assessors belong to the laboratory. Their assessment will be of the internal type if they do and of the external type if they do not. In the latter case, Quality Assessment will be external–internal if the assessors are members of the parent body but not of the assessed laboratory and external–external if they belong to another body .
-
Whether the assessors belong to the assessed body. Their assessment will be internal if it is conducted by staff from the laboratory or its parent body, and external if performed by staff from another body .
-
8.22 . What are the goals of interlaboratory exercises? Where do they fall in the analytical quality realm?
Answer :
Interlaboratory exercises constitute a
mode of external–external quality assessment. Each participating
laboratory analyses the same sample to determine the same
analyte(s) in order to have its results quantitatively assessed by
comparison with those of the other laboratories .
The main goal of an interlaboratory
exercise is to compare results and their uncertainty, and its
primary objectives are (a) to have inexperienced laboratories learn
to conduct specific CMPs; (b) to validate CMPs developed in
response to new information needs; (c) to have the values and
uncertainties for a given CRM certified; and (d) to have the
quality of the results produced by the participating laboratories
assessed .
-
8.23 . Why are documentation and archiving activities the bottleneck in implementing quality in a laboratory?
Answer :
Documentation and archiving activities are
in fact the bottleneck of Quality Assurance programmes and the
greatest hindrance to implementing and monitoring Quality Systems
in analytical laboratories. Thus, documentation and archiving are
two time-consuming activities that frequently make laboratory staff
reluctant to adopt a Quality System .
A laboratory having a Quality System must
document and archive everything as stated in a Standard Operating
Procedure (SOP) describing how each laboratory operation is to be
performed. Also, the laboratory must record sample custody chains
and how its equipment performs after it is installed; also, it must
monitor materials, SOPs, primary data, results, reports and
documentation activities themselves, all of which demand a strong
commitment .
-
8.24 . What is external–external assessment? Give some examples and distinguish it from external–internal assessment.
Answer :
External–external assessment is performed
by experts from a body other than that being assessed and hence
doubly external to the laboratory. The activities to be performed
for this purpose are known as “audits” in the realm of Quality.
Audits can be conducted on systems (qualitative, visual and
documental examination), performance (quantitative) or both
(integral audits). In the analytical realm, audits can be of two
main types, namely: (a) direct, which lead to accreditation of
laboratories; and (b) indirect (e.g., proficiency testing)
.
One example of external–external
assessment is that of a laboratory wishing to be accredited for
performing a given type of clinical analysis. The auditors should
belong neither to the candidate laboratory nor to its parent;
rather, they should pertain to a certified national auditing body,
whether public or private .
One other example is that of a laboratory
wishing to assess a method it is using to determine benzene by
participating in an interlaboratory exercise in order to compare
its results with those of other laboratories analysing the same
sample for the analyte. Usually, the body coordinating the exercise
will be independent of the interested laboratory’s parent body.
Therefore, the laboratory will be subjected to external–external
assessment of its results .
In external–internal assessment, the
assessors are staff members of the interested body but not of its
laboratory. One example is that of an agri-food multinational firm
having several factories each with its own quality control
laboratory in the same country. The body’s headquarters may set up
an intercomparison exercise involving the different quality control
laboratories, whose results will be assessed by staff from the body
but not from any of the laboratories .
-
8.25 . Who accredits analytical laboratories? What is laboratory accreditation based on?
Answer :
Laboratories are accredited by a public or
private body from their country using internationally accepted
standards issued by EU, OECD or ISO, for example .
-
8.26 . Define “accreditation”. What are the main features of analytical laboratory accreditation?
Answer :
In the quality realm, “accreditation” is
defined as “the formal recognition in writing that a laboratory is
fit and competent to perform a given analysis or specific group of
analyses” .
The accreditation of analytical
laboratories is (a) voluntary (done at their request), (b)
temporary (it holds for a specified length of time only) and (c)
partial (it applies to specific activities or groups of activities
rather than to the laboratory as a whole) .
-
8.27 . What does the process of accrediting a laboratory involve?
Answer :
A laboratory can be accredited if it has a
Quality System that has materialized in a Quality Manual. The
accreditation process is started by the auditors conducting a
documental and visual (qualitative) inspection and producing a
report. If the report is unfavourable, the laboratory can challenge
it; if it is favourable, the laboratory will be awarded a
Certificate of Accreditation to be paid at its own expense
.
The Certificate carries the twofold
commitment of maintaining the existing quality systems and allowing
the auditors free access to perform periodic controls during its
validity period. Because accreditation is temporary, it must be
renewed after the validity period has expired or if the laboratory
undergoes any substantial changes in the meantime. Renewing
accreditation involves repeating the whole accreditation process;
however, the new audit may be made easier by the auditors’ prior
knowledge of the laboratory to be re-accredited .
-
8.28 . What does analytical quality assurance rest on?
Answer :
First of all, Quality Assurance (QA) in an
analytical laboratory is impossible without human contribution. In
fact, QA requires support from the management of the laboratory’s
parent body and willing acceptance by the laboratory staff. Also,
auditors must have a constructive attitude in their work to
facilitate sustained improvement in the laboratory .
Successfully implementing a Quality System
in a laboratory entails providing it with the required technical
means and training its staff in the new way of working. The
supports for QA in a laboratory include computers, participation in
interlaboratory exercises, and documentation and archiving
activities .
Computer hardware and software play a
crucial role in implementing Quality Assurance. Quality control and
analytical equipment control software can be highly useful for this
purpose. At the boundary of Computers, Chemometrics and Quality is
Qualimetrics, which influences analytical information, and the
optimization of analytical processes and Quality Systems.
Chemometrics enables validation of primary data and comparison of
results—which is the basis for Quality Control and Quality
Assessment systems—whereas interlaboratory exercises facilitate
assessment of laboratory proficiency .
Finally, documenting and archiving all
activities, and having a standard operating procedure (SOP) for
each, is crucial for proper performance in a laboratory possessing
a Quality System. The laboratory should also keep a record of
sample custody chains, equipment performance from installation,
monitoring of other materials, SOPs, primary data, results, reports
and documenting activities themselves .
-
8.29 . Comment on the problems potentially arising in implementing quality assurance in analytical laboratories.
Answer :
Successfully establishing and maintaining
Quality Assurance may require solving various problems such as the
following :
-
Lack of leadership. The laboratory’s parent body should have clear-cut goals (leadership). Also, the laboratory should be committed to quality and the inspiring Quality Assurance principles be supported by a Quality Policy. The body’s management should encourage and support quality-related activities .
-
The human factor. This is one of the cornerstones of effective laboratory quality systems. Motivating laboratory staff is in fact essential to have them accept the burden of some labour-intensive tasks involved in keeping the system working. Although some duties may initially be imposed by management, the system will fail in the long term in the absence of an awareness of the significance of Quality .
-
Costs. Implementing a Quality System requires starting and maintenance investments that should be carefully considered before its establishment is addressed .
-
Abrupt implementation. Abruptly adopting a Quality System may elicit outright rejection from by the staff concerned. Rather, the system should be implemented in a gradual manner in order to give the staff the opportunity to get acquainted with specific activities (e.g., keeping sample custody chains, developing and adhering to SOPs, validating charts) before development of the Quality Manual and subjection to internal audits (creation of the Quality Assurance Unit for Good Laboratory Practices) and external audits (accreditation and intercomparison exercises) are undertaken in a second step .
-
Compatibility with routine work. The tasks involved in implementing a Quality System should be compatible with the laboratory’s primary goal, namely: to produce quality analytical information within the applicable deadline and at the agreed cost .
-
Lack of constancy. Implementing a Quality System is a long-distance race in which the staff should not exhaust their energy at the start if they are to retain their willingness to perform the more labour-intensive tasks (e.g., documentation and archiving). The outcome of internal and external audits can help preserve staff motivation .
-
Complex literature. The literature on Quality is atypical, contradictory, and occasionally plagued with acronyms and rules that may raise a high initial barrier for staff to overcome .
Chapter 9. Social Responsibility in Analytical Chemistry
Answer :
Social Responsibility in Analytical
Chemistry is related to analytical quality because the latter is
essential with a view to the sustainable production of truthful
information .
Social Responsibility in Analytical
Chemistry is also related to analytical problem-solving because
both involve supplying (bio)chemical information to make grounded,
timely decisions .
In other words, SR is the materialization
of the social and environmental connotations of analytical
problem-solving and quality .
-
9.2 . What are the keywords defining Social Responsibility? Which are especially significant because they are shared by many definitions of SR?
Answer :
The keywords for SR are “responsibility”,
“stakeholders”, “quality of life” and “sustainability”, and its
most common dimensions “stakeholders” and “social” .
-
9.3 . Define “stakeholders” in the context of SR, and of ISO guides and norms.
Answer :
Stakeholders are individuals or groups of
individuals that may be affected by the activities or decisions of
a body or area of knowledge but may also influence or take part in
such activities or decisions. Stakeholders constitute a key element
of Social Responsibility .
-
9.4 . Describe the cycle of concepts that provides an integral definition of SR in an individual, an organization and a scientific or technical area.
Answer :
The cycle of Social Responsibility
concepts is a series of mutually connected actions that start and
end at the binding “commitment” of an entity to systematically
support SR .
The commitment comprises the following
sequence of actions :
-
designing and developing an SR implementation strategy;
-
managerial changes;
-
recognizing social and environmental concerns;
-
expanding classic stakeholders with new stakeholders such as NGOs;
-
objectively balancing SR support and the goals of the entity or area of knowledge concerned so that their fulfilment is not hindered by the adoption SR; and
-
ensuring responsibility and sustainability in the entity or area concerned .
-
9.5 . Highlight four of the five principles governing SR. Which is the most important? Why?
Answer :
The most salient principles of SR are
accountability, transparency, ethical conduct and respect for
stakeholders’ interests, the last of which is the most important
because it ensures fulfilment of SR .
-
9.6 . Can marketing SR be
- (a)
positive?
- (b)
negative?
- (c)
neither positive nor negative?
- (a)
Justify your answer.
Answer :
- (a)
Yes. Example: integral SR is systematically publicized by the entity or area of knowledge concerned .
- (b)
Yes. Example: SR is only publicized with anecdotal actions such as stating that each consumer buying a given brand of yoghourt will be thus supporting a humanitarian cause .
- (c)
Yes. Example: when support of SR is not systematically publicized .
-
9.7 . What is the most important element of the cyclic succession of SR concepts? Why is it more important than the others?
Answer :
The commitment that starts and ends the
cyclic succession of concepts leading to the establishment of SR in
a body or area of knowledge. It is more important than the other
elements because no integral SR system can be successfully
established without the commitment of those involved .
-
9.8 . Are the following statements true or false?
- (a)
Ethical principles encompass SR.
- (b)
Implementing SR in a scientific or technical area encompasses quality systems.
- (c)
For many organizations and businesses, SR is merely a window-dressing opportunity.
- (a)
Justify your answers.
Answer :
- (a)
False. SR rests largely on ethical conduct—it encompasses ethical principles .
- (b)
True. SR can be considered an extension of Quality Systems .
- (c)
Unfortunately true. Some organizations and businesses market SR without supporting it systematically and wholeheartedly .
-
9.9 . Why are SR in Analytical Chemistry and SR in (bio)chemical information equivalent?
Answer :
Because the main output of Analytical
Chemistry is (bio)chemical information on objects and systems. If
Analytical Chemistry is socially responsible and sustainable, so
will be the production and dissemination of (bio)chemical
information .
-
9.10 . What are the internal and external connotations of SR in (bio)chemical information? Are they related in any way? How?
Answer :
The internal connotations are the
sustainable production of quality (bio)chemical information (that
is, of information that is consistent with reality) .
The external connotations can be the
summarized as the correct dissemination of such information to
society through reports in order to derive knowledge .
There is an obvious relationship between
the two: the external connotations can never be fulfilled unless
the internal connotations are satisfied. For example, no reliable
knowledge can be produced without quality (bio)chemical
information .
-
9.11 . Explain the differences between the transfer of data (signals), results (information) and reports (knowledge) to society.
Answer :
They key is who interprets them. Thus, if
transferred data and results are interpreted by society or the
media, they may be misinterpreted—and reality distorted as a
consequence—through poor knowledge or disinterest. On the other
hand, the facts behind contextualized transferred knowledge are
bound to be correctly interpreted by society and to help
decision-making .
-
9.12 . Which of the three sources of distortion in the transfer of (bio)chemical information is the most important? Rank them according to significance.
Answer :
Although the significance of each
potential source of distortion differs depending on the particular
situation, the following three are usually the most
important :
- (a)
Malicious external manipulation of the object or sample .
- (b)
The type of information required .
- (c)
A poor knowledge of the required information and its features .
The latter two sometimes exchange their
place in the significance ranking .
-
9.13 . Are the two internal connotations of SR in Analytical Chemistry related? Which is the more important? Why?
Answer :
The internal connotations of SR in
Analytical Chemistry are the reliable, sustainable production of
quality (bio)chemical information. In principle, they are
unrelated. SR provides a relational framework for the two
.
-
9.14 . What is the difference between the two models of quality in (bio)chemical information (the second facet of external connotations of SR in Analytical Chemistry)?
Answer :
The model comprising three facets of
quality (namely, intrinsic, referential or held as true and
routine) is more simple. Also, it constitutes one side of the
tetrahedron including required information (the third basic
standard for Analytical Chemistry) as a fourth facet in addition to
perceived quality as a fifth .
The most salient difference between the
two models is that the latter is much more comprehensive than the
former .
-
9.15 . Why can the type of information delivered be important with a view to facilitating effective communication between analytical laboratories and clients requiring information?
Answer :
Because it is not the same to deliver
primary data, results (information) or knowledge (contextualized,
interpreted data). The probability of clients properly
understanding what they receive from laboratories grows from
primary data to results to knowledge. Therefore, it is more
reliable to transfer knowledge than results .
-
9.16 . Can using a communication office to deliver information from a laboratory have a positive effect on the parent body? Why?
Answer :
The main function of the communication
office of the laboratory’s parent body is to facilitate
communication by delivering a message that can be easily
interpreted by society. The office should therefore avoid
triggering false alarms and raising false expectations. Ultimately,
the communication office is concerned with the tough task of
disseminating analytical science and technology .
-
9.17 . How is the choice of an analytical process dictated by the potential impact of the (bio)chemical information to be delivered?
Answer :
One essential requirement for performing a
given analysis is knowing the potential consequences of the
information or knowledge to be produced, which influence the choice
of the analytical process. In choosing, one should be aware that
specific uncertainty may be highly consequential. For example, a
few tenths in the purity of a 500-kg gold batch can be more
consequential on price than a few units in the percent moisture
content of animal feed .
-
9.18 . Explain the sentence “quality in information transfer depends on both the producer and the receiver of the information”. Discuss the significance of the information required by the receiver.
Answer :
Honesty and professionalism in the
transfer of (bio)chemical information rests both on the producer
(the analytical chemist) and the receiver (the client)—which may or
may not coincide with the requester. This is especially important
when interpreting the information with a view to proposing or
making decisions .
The difference between the information
required and that received falls outside the analytical chemical
realm but is extremely important. The two can be intentionally
mismatched for dishonest purposes. Thus, a firm may be informed
that its vegetable produce contains small amounts of a pesticide
and yet ignore the analytical information and give its produce the
green light for export. This misconduct is not be expected if
effective administrative controls (e.g., certification by an
accredited laboratory) are established .
-
9.19 . How important can experience in the dissemination of science be to transfer (bio)chemical information? Why?
Answer :
It is crucial with a view to avoiding
errors in transferring (bio)chemical information that might lead to
false alarms or expectations. The only limitation arises from the
communication office being pressed to produce information simply
highlighting the importance of its parent body .
-
9.20 . How can SR in Analytical Chemistry be assured?
Answer :
Through the commitment of laboratories and
their parent bodies. Social Responsibility is a voluntary prior
commitment which, however, is indirectly required by public
administrations and society (e.g., NGOs) .
-
9.21 . Explain the “transparency principle” supporting SR in Analytical Chemistry.
Answer :
As per ISO Guide 26000:2010, transparency
is one the principles of SR. Transparency in the conduct of an
analytical chemist or laboratory implies the following :
-
as regards the external connotations of SR in Analytical Chemistry, establishing a Quality System, and ensuring that all activities are sustainable, recorded and easily accessed by auditors;
-
in regard to the internal connotations, ensuring that results and reports are based on objective, easily assessed data .
-
9.22 . Describe the two main ways in which a sample can be tampered with in order to have it give spurious results for fraudulent purposes.
Answer :
- (1)
An extraneous analyte may be deliberately added to the sample so that the object from which it is extracted is spuriously deemed “contaminated”. One example is pollution of a bay with mercury. If mercury is deliberately added to the water from a ship, the coastal environment may be declared polluted and unsafe for bathing and/or fishing. This may boost tourism and fishing in an unpolluted competing area .
- (2)
A harmless substance may be added to the sample in order to conceal the presence of the analyte in either of two ways :
-
By having it interact with the analyte (e.g., to form a compound that will be retained during the preliminary operations and prevented from reaching the measuring instrument) .
-
By having it interact with the object in order to eliminate the analyte (e.g., using a diuretic to remove any traces of anabolic steroids or drugs of abuse taken by an athlete) .
-
Annex 1: Glossary of Terms
Accreditation
Formal written acknowledgement that a
laboratory is fit and competent to perform one or more given types
of analysis. Obtained by subjecting the laboratory to an audit
(accreditation process) conducted by personnel external to the
laboratory and its parent body.
Absolute
error
The difference between the value to be
qualified and its reference.
Absolute
method
A type of calculable quantification method
that uses no analytical standard.
Absolute
method with analytical standards . A calculable method that
uses one or more tangible analytical chemical standards.
Absolute trueness
An ideal analytical feature and an
attribute of chemical information inherent in the target object or
sample. Corresponds to the true value
Accuracy
– An ideal analytical feature and an
attribute of chemical information inherent in the target object or
sample. Corresponds to the true value
– A capital analytical property of a result
or a CMP (the opposite of bias).
Aliquot
A well-defined portion (mass, volume) of a
sample.
Amount
An attribute of an object that can be
qualitatively distinguished and quantitatively determined. Amount
encompasses “measurand” and “analyte”.
Analyse, to
– To subject a sample to an analytical
process in order to extract information about measurands or
analytes.
– To interpret analytical results with a
view to producing a report.
Analyser
An integrated system consisting of
instruments, apparatuses and devices that performs virtually the
whole analytical process (CMP).
Analysis
In a general sense, “analysis” involves
examination, study, acquisition of knowledge to provide information
about objects, facts, systems, performance and attitudes. In the
chemical realm, “analysis” involves subjecting a sample to an
analytical process in order to extract (bio)chemical information
about it.
Analyte
A chemical or biochemical species in a
sample about which qualitative or quantitative information is
required.
Analytical blank
A usually artificial sample containing no
analyte. In theory, a blank should give no signal if it does it is
called the “blank signal”.
Analytical Chemistry
A metrological science that develops,
optimizes and uses measurement processes intended to derive quality
(bio)chemical information about natural or artificial objects or
systems with a view to solving analytical problems.
Analytical error
Broadly speaking, an alteration in
analytical information. Analytical errors can be of the random,
systematic or gross type.
Analytical fundamentals
The cornerstones on which the theoretical
and practical sides of Analytical Chemistry stand. Intrinsic to
Analytical Chemistry or shared with other scientific and technical
areas
Analytical information
– Chemical characteristics of an object or
system, usually ascribed to its components (analytes) or to the
entity as a whole.
– The opposite of “generic uncertainty” and
the primary goal of Analytical Chemistry.
Information
held as true . That obtained through special testing (e.g.,
an interlaboratory exercise) or possessed by a CRM. Corresponds to
referential quality.
Intrinsic
information . That possessed by the object or system to be
analysed. Corresponds to ideal quality.
Routine
information . That ordinarily produced by laboratories.
Corresponds to real quality.
Analytical knowledge
Analytical results (information) that are
discussed, compared with references, contextualized and accompanied
by decision-making proposals. Analytical knowledge materializes in
“analytical reports” and is thus at the highest step in the
data–information–knowledge ranking.
Analytical method
The body of specific operations used in the
qualitative or quantitative characterization of an analyte (or
analyte family) in a given sample. Entails using a technique
(instrument) and is the materialization of a CMP.
Analytical problem
An approach to solving the client’s
information needs by designing and planning a CMP, and interpreting
the ensuing results.
Analytical properties
Attributes ascribed to results and/or a
chemical measurement process (CMP). The quality indicators of
Analytical Chemistry.
Basic
properties . Those that can be ascribed to a CMP and support
capital properties.
Capital
properties . Those that can be ascribed to results.
Productivity-related properties . Those
that can be ascribed to a CMP and define laboratory
productivity.
Analytical quality
The degree of excellence in the chemical
information supplied with a view to solving an analytical problem.
Comprises four components: quality of results, quality of CMPs,
quality of analytical tools and quality of work and its
organization.
Analytical references
Landmarks used in the comparisons inherent
in analytical measurements. Can be materials (standards) or
methods.
Analytical reports
– The body of analytical results (data) and
their interpretation in the light of the analytical problem
addressed.
– The top level in the information
hierarchy.
Analytical results
Qualitative and/or quantitative data
obtained by mathematical (chemometric) treatment of primary data
produced by an instrument in the analytical process.
Analytical schemes
Sequential, orderly processes that use
separation methods (e.g., precipitation) in Classical Qualitative
Analysis to classify species into groups where each analyte can be
reliably identified.
Analytical tools
Material, strategic and methodological
means of varied nature on which chemical measurement processes
(CMPs) rely.
Apparatus
A system consisting of devices that serves
a specific function in a CMP but provides no analytical
information. An apparatus produces secondary data.
Applied research in Analytical
Chemistry
Development of analytical methods based on
the “products” of basic research to extract (bio)chemical
information with a view to fulfilling information demands. If no
effective tool for the intended purpose exists, it must be produced
through new basic research.
Audit
An instance of external–external assessment
conducted by specialists external to the laboratory and its parent
body.
Automation
Partial or total reduction of human
participation in a CMP.
Avogadro’s number
A chemical standard defined as the number
(6.023 × 10 23 ) of atoms or molecules contained in one
mole of any chemical substance.
Balance
An instrumental tool primarily used to
measure the initial mass of the test sample to be subjected to a
CMP or that of the weighed form in gravimetries.
Basic research in Analytical
Chemistry
Development of new analytical tools (e.g.,
reagents, solvents, equipment, sensors) and approaches for no
specific purpose other than advancement of the discipline
Bias
A systematic or determinate error equal to
the positive or negative difference between the mean of
n results and the value
held as true,
, that can
be ascribed to an analytical method and is related to its
accuracy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/65c17/65c17d6ef72eb66f39c347d32dd43fbabfb933f4" alt="$$ \overline{X} - \widehat{X}^{{\prime }} $$"
Binary response
– The result (YES or NO) of a qualitative
analysis.
– The answer to various questions the most
crucial of which are “is it the analyte?” and “is it in the
sample?”
Black sample
A sample whose composition is completely
unknown before analysis.
Blank signal
The signal produced by a blank
sample.
Blind sample
A sample of well-defined composition that
is interspersed for quality control purposes with those to be
routinely analysed by a laboratory.
Burette
An instrumental tool used to measure the
volume of titrant solution used in titrations. Burettes can be
manual or automatic in operation.
Calculable method
One that provides results based on
mathematical calculations involving both tabulated data and
measurements made during the CMP. May use some or no analytical
standard.
Calibration curve
A two-dimensional graphical plot showing
the variation of the analytical signal with the amount or
concentration of analyte (standard). See also “Linear calibration
graph”.
Capillary electrophoresis
A separation process occurring within a
capillary under a high electric field. Because the system is
equipped with a detector, it can be considered an instrument.
Certified reference material (CRM)
A reference material with certified values
(specific uncertainties included) for one or more of its properties
that are obtained by special procedures (e.g., interlaboratory
exercises) under the supervision of a competent, independent body.
A CRM should be accompanied by comprehensive documentation.
Characterize, to
To identify distinct features in an object
or system from analytical results.
Chemical analysis
A process by which chemical measurement
processes (CMPs) are used to extract information from objects or
systems.
Chemical measurement process (CMP)
See “Analytical process”.
Chemical metrology
The science of (bio)chemical
measurements.
Chromatograph
An analytical system that performs
chromatographic separations in a column (gas or liquid
chromatography) and includes an on-line detector for continuous
monitoring of the fluid emerging from the separation column.
Because it provides analytical information, a chromatograph is an
instrument.
Chromatography
A word that describes a broad range of
highly efficient analytical separation techniques based on multiple
mass transfer between a mobile phase and a stationary phase.
Gas
chromatography . A chromatographic technique where the
mobile phase is a gas (into which the sample aliquot is inserted)
and the stationary phase is a solid or a liquid supported on an
inert solid that is placed in a column.
Liquid
chromatography . A chromatographic technique where the
mobile phase is a liquid (into which the sample aliquot is
inserted) and the stationary phase is a solid or a liquid that is
either supported on an inert solid for placement in a column or
spread onto a thin layer of a support (in Thin Layer
Chromatography).
Classical analysis
A type of qualitative or quantitative
analysis based on chemical reactions in solution and involving the
use of human senses for identification and a balance or burette for
quantification.
Classification analysis
Classification of samples of similar
composition into groups (clusters) that can be distinguished by
analysis. Samples can be classified into two groups (e.g., positive
and negative samples) by qualitative analysis or into more than two
by multiple classification analysis.
Clean-up
The process by which interferents in a
sample are removed using a separation technique to indirectly
enhance selectivity.
Client
A general designation applied to an
individual or body requiring (bio)chemical information with a view
to solving a socio-economic problem.
Coefficient of variation
The relative standard deviation in percent
form.
Comparative method
A type of relative quantification method in
which the final result is obtained by comparing the sample signal
with that for a sample standard.
Concentration
An form of expressing a relative
quantitative result: the amount of analyte contained in a given
volume or mass of sample.
Cut-off
concentration . The concentration chosen by the analyst in
establishing a given probability level that a binary response will
be correct.
Limiting
concentration or threshold
concentration . Highest or lowest level, established by the
client or legislation, to be used in deciding whether a sample or
object warrants assignation of a given attribute (e.g., toxic or
non-toxic).
Confidence interval
A value (concentration) range within which
the result of an analytical process can be expected to fall with a
given level of confidence. Related to specific uncertainty in the
context of precision of a method.
Data processing
The body of mathematical calculations
leading to the expression of the analytical result from tabulated
data (chemical standards, constants, conversion factors) and
experimental data produced by a CMP applied to the sample and
standards.
Detect, to
Of an instrument: To produce a signal and
transduce it into an easily measured physical quantity (a primary
datum).
Detection
The action of detecting. The process of
measuring for qualitative purposes.
Determinate error
See “Systematic error”.
Determination
The process by which the amount or
concentration of an analyte (or analyte family) in a sample is
established.
Deviation
The difference between an individual result
( x i ) in a set and the mean for the
set (
, the random error).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b68bc/b68bca8da0aa79778c2dbca902530946ab77a008" alt="$$ \bar{X} $$"
Device
A part of an apparatus, instrument or
analyser that can serve one or more of a wide variety of possible
functions.
Dialysis
The process by which mass transfer between
two miscible liquid phases separated by a membrane permeable to the
analytes or their interferents takes place.
Disaggregation
A substep of the preliminary operations of
a CMP involving the fusion of an insoluble solid sample mixed with
an acid or alkaline solid reagent.
Dissolution
A substep of the preliminary operations of
a CMP where a solid (or semi-solid) sample is completely dissolved
by treatment with a solvent.
Electrodeposition
A gravimetric method performed by an
electrochemical device in order to deposit the analyte
quantitatively onto one electrode (usually the cathode) that is
weighed before and after the process.
End-point
In a titration, the volume of titrant added
to the solution containing the analyte or standard by the time the
indicator system produces a signal in response to which the
titration should be stopped.
End-point indicator
A system of the visual or instrumental type
that exposes the end-point of a titration.
Equipment calibration
The process by which a standard containing
no analyte is used to check that an instrument (or apparatus)
operates as expected. Otherwise, corrections are introduced until
the instrument response (or the indication of an apparatus) reaches
the value held as true for the standard used.
Equipment verification
Equivalent to “Equipment
calibration”.
Equivalence point
In a titration, the theoretical volume of
titrant required to react in a quantitative, stoichiometric manner
with the analyte or a standard
Error accumulation
In a multi-stage process (e.g., the
analytical process), the overall error is the arithmetic sum of the
variances (standard deviations squared) arising at each stage
(sub-process).
Errors in qualitative analysis
Deviations from true YES/NO responses. See
“False positive” and “False negative”.
External manipulation of (bio)chemical
information
In the context of Social Responsibility in
Analytical Chemistry, fraudulent alteration of the composition of a
sample in order to obtain spurious results for unethical purposes
(e.g., by directly adding a harmless substance to “conceal” the
analyte in order to alter a sample and/or an analytical
process).
Extraction
The process by which one or several
substances are separated from a solid or liquid sample.
Liquid–liquid extraction . Treatment of a
liquid sample with an immiscible solvent intended to separate the
analytes or their interferents.
Liquid–solid
extraction . Use of a solid sorbent to retain the analytes
or interferents in a liquid sample. Usually called Solid-phase extraction (SPE).
Solid–liquid
extraction . Treatment of a solid sample with a suitable
solvent to dissolve the target analytes. Also called leaching .
Supercritical fluid extraction .
Treatment of a solid sample with a supercritical fluid to separate
the soluble fraction.
False negative
An error in Qualitative Analysis that
results when a NO response is obtained from a sample that should
have yielded a YES response.
False positive
An error in Qualitative Analysis that
results when a YES response is obtained from a sample that should
have yielded a NO response.
Faraday
A chemical standard defined as the amount
of electricity (96 487.3 C) needed for one equivalent of a redox
substance to be electrochemically converted at an electrode.
Generic uncertainty
Dubiousness in the chemical composition of
an object or sample, that is named “black sample”. The opposite of
“information”.
Good Laboratory Practices (GLPs)
The body of rules and procedures that are
held as mandatory with a view to assuring quality and correctness
in the results produced by laboratories engaged in the analysis and
evaluation of substances with direct social implications and as
such necessitating regulation.
Gravimetric factor
– The ratio of the formula weight of the
analyte to the molecular weight of the weighed form in gravimetry
(a dimensionless number by which the result of a gravimetric
weighing is multiplied in order to determine the analyte
weight).
– A combination of chemical standards
(atomic weights).
Gravimetry
A type of calculable analytical
quantification method that uses no analytical standards and is
based on measurements of the mass of an analyte or a chemical
derivative of the analyte.
Green analytical methods
Ecological, environmentally friendly
methods of analysis intended to avoid contaminating air, water,
soil, etc., by effect of operations of the analytical
process.
Grey sample
A sample whose composition is known only
approximately.
Gross error
A large systematic error.
Heterogeneity
A property of an object or sample in space
or time that poses a problem which must be solved during sample
collection if the results produced by the ensuing CMP are to be
representative.
Hyphenated techniques
Those using a powerful dynamic analytical
separation system (e.g., a gas or liquid chromatograph) in
combination with an instrument possessing a high information
capacity (e.g., a mass spectrometer).
Identification
A qualitative analytical process by which
the presence of an analyte is ascertained on the basis of chemical
or physico–chemical properties of the analyte or a reaction product
of the analyte.
Indeterminate
error
See“Random error”.
Information
consistency
In regard to “analytical problem”,
suitability of data and results to the client’s information
requirements.
Instrument
– A measuring system that produces raw
(primary) data that can be processed in order to be related to the
presence or concentration of one or more analytes in a
sample.
– The materialization of an analytical
technique.
Instrumental analysis
A type of qualitative, quantitative and
structural analysis based on the use of instruments other than the
balance, burette and human senses.
Interferences
Chemical or physical perturbations of
various types that systematically alter one or more steps of a CMP
and hence the analytical result in terms of selectivity.
Interlaboratory exercise
A series of CMPs performed by different
laboratories under the supervision of a competent body to analyse
aliquots of the same sample for the same analytes. Used to check
the results (and their uncertainties) for a variety of purposes
(e.g., preparing a CRM).
Internal representativeness
In regard to the analytical problem, degree
of consistency between the results obtained in the analytical
process and the analysed sample, the object from which the sample
was taken and the analytical problem addressed by the analytical
chemist.
Ion exchange
A process by which dissolved ionic species
are separated by using an active solid called an “ion-exchange
resin”.
ISO 17025
A 2005 standard specific to testing
laboratories that is entitled “General requirements for the
competence of testing and calibration laboratories”.
ISO 9000
A general standard for quality entitled
“Quality management systems—Fundamentals and vocabulary”.
Leaching
See “Solid–liquid extraction” under
“Extraction”.
Limit of detection
The analyte concentration yielding an
analytical signal that can be statistically distinguished from an
analytical blank.
Limit of quantification
The analyte concentration yielding a signal
that is taken to be the lower limit of the linear range of the
calibration curve.
Linear calibration graph
A linear (first-order) mathematical
function relating the signal with the concentration of standards
containing a known analyte concentration that are subjected to the
analytical process. It allows the sample signal to be related to
the signals for standards in order to calculate the analyte
concentration by extrapolation.
Linear range
The linear portion of the calibration curve
where the sensitivity (slope) remains constant.
Macroanalysis
A type of chemical analysis where the
initial size of the sample aliquot subjected to the CMP is greater
than 100 mg.
Macrocomponents
Analytes whose proportions in the sample
exceed 1% of their masses.
Masking
The use of a reagent to interact chemically
in solution with interfering species in a sample in order to avoid
their perturbation without the need to physically separate the
reaction products from the medium ( pseudo -separation).
Maximum representativeness
In regard to the analytical problem,
highest degree of consistency between the results obtained in the
analytical process, which is reached when the results are
significant both internally (that is, consistent with the sample,
object and analytical problem) and with the client’s socio-economic
problem
Maximum tolerated ratio
A parameter that describes the influence of
an interfering species in the context of selectivity. The highest
interferent-to-analyte concentration ratio that results in no
perturbation to a CMP.
Measurand
The quantity measured in a CMP, which may
be the analyte or some quantity such as pH.
Measurement
The process by which a signal yielded by
the analyte or a reaction product of the analyte is compared with
one produced by a standard.
Method calibration
The process by which an analytical standard
is used to characterize the response of an instrument in terms of
the properties of an analyte or analyte family. Method calibration
entails unequivocally relating the signal to the presence or
concentration of the analyte.
Method-defined parameter
An analytical result that can only be
obtained by using a well-defined protocol that constitutes a
reference established by law or custom because using another method
leads to a different result.
Metrology
The science of physical, chemical,
biochemical and biological measurements. See “Chemical
metrology”.
Microanalysis
A type of chemical analysis where the
initial size of the sample aliquot subjected to the CMP ranges from
10 to 1 mg.
Microcomponents
Analytes whose proportions in the sample
range from 0.01 to 0.1% of their masses.
Miniaturization
A term defining a technological trend to
considerably reducing the size of analytical tools, integrating
modules of a CMP or both.
Mole
A base standard and a base unit of the
International System (SI) defined as the amount of substance
containing as many elemental units (atoms, molecules, ions,
electrons or other individual particles or particle groups) as are
in 0.012 kg of the isotope carbon-12.
Nanoanalysis
See “Nanoworld analysis”.
Nanoworld analysis
Extraction of (bio)chemical information
(identity, differences, concentration, structure) from objects of
nanometric size (1–100 nm).
Negative error
A negative difference between the value to
be qualified and the reference used to establish it.
Object
A system from which chemical information is
required and samples are collected for analysis.
Official method
A method endorsed and issued by an official
body that is to be strictly adhered to.
Outlier
A datum not belonging to a set obtained
under reproducible or repeatable conditions that exhibits a
significantly greater or smaller difference from the mean of the
set than do the other data in the set.
Paradigm
A body of essential, crucial, unarguable
notions that set the guidelines for some activity. Analytical
chemical paradigms are thus essential landmarks of Analytical
Chemistry and, as such, change with time.
Positive error
A positive difference between the value to
be qualified and the reference used to establish it.
Precision
The degree of mutual agreement of a set of
results. The opposite of dispersion of the results around their
mean, which is the reference used to calculate individual
deviations (random errors).
Preconcentration
A process by which sensitivity is
indirectly enhanced through a separation. Involves reducing the
original volume of a sample containing the analytes at low
concentrations.
Preconcentration factor
A dimensionless number greater than unity
that is obtained by dividing the original volume into the reduced
volume obtained upon application of an analytical separation
technique to a sample. Multiplying by the original analyte
concentration gives the final concentration of the aliquot
subjected to the second step of the CMP.
Preliminary operations
– The body of actions performed in the
first step of an analytical process (CMP).
– The link between the uncollected,
unmeasured, untreated sample and the principal measuring
instrument.
– The first step in a CMP.
Primary data
– Those produced by instruments in
measurement processes.
– The most elementary form of information
and the foundation of the results.
– The third step in the analytical
information hierarchy.
– The results of detecting and
sensing.
Primary method
The type of method with the highest
metrological quality.
Procedure
A detailed specification of an analytical
method.
Productivity
A characteristic of a laboratory defined as
the combination of its productivity-related analytical properties
(expeditiousness, cost-effectiveness, and personnel safety and
comfort).
Proficiency testing
A form of external assessment of quality in
the results of an analytical laboratory that involves participation
in a specially designed interlaboratory exercise in order to
compare its results with those of the other participating
laboratories.
Qualimetrics
The triple interface where Computers,
Chemometrics and Quality in the laboratory converge.
Qualitative analysis
– A type of chemical analysis by which the
analyte or analytes in a sample are identified.
– The result is a YES/NO binary
response.
Quality
The body of characteristics or abilities of
an entity that make it better, equal to or worse than others of the
same kind. In practice, quality is identified with client
satisfaction.
Quality assessment
Specific activities (audits) carried out by
personnel from outside a laboratory to examine both the results
produced and the laboratory as such and in regard to its quality
control systems.
Quality assurance
The body of activities performed in order
to assure quality in the results produced by an analytical
laboratory. Involves specific control, assessment and correction
activities.
Quality assurance unit (QAU)
A unit associated to GLPs that is
independent of the laboratory, answerable to the president or
manager of the parent body, and responsible for implementing,
controlling and assessing quality in addition to proposing
improvement actions.
Quality control
The body of specific activities carried out
by laboratory personnel in order to—basically—examine, in a direct
manner, the results obtained and tools used by the
laboratory.
Quality indicator
A qualitative and quantitative aspect into
which some characteristic or ability of an entity meeting a
client’s requirements materializes.
Quality manual
A detailed written description of a
laboratory and its activities (particularly quality control and
assessment).
Quality system
A series of coordinated activities
performed on various elements (procedures, documents, structures)
in order to assure quality in the products or services delivered by
a given organization.
Quantitative analysis
A type of chemical analysis by which the
proportion (concentration) or amount of each analyte in a sample is
determined. The result is a numerical response.
R&D&T in Analytical
Chemistry
Research, development and transference of
analytical knowledge and technology.
Random error
– An error that can be ascribed to positive
or negative (random) fluctuations typical of experimental
operations.
– The basis on which precision and specific
uncertainty are established.
– Also called “indeterminate error”.
Reagent
A chemical species that is added to a
sample or standard in order to yield a reaction product with the
analyte(s).
Group
reagent . One that separates a small number of analytes from
those present in the sample. Used in the framework of analytical
schemes in Classical Qualitative Analysis.
Identification reagent . One that reacts
with the analyte to produce an external effect that can be readily
identified by the human senses (e.g., in Classical Qualitative
Analysis) or detected by an instrument.
Masking
reagent . One that reacts in solution with species
accompanying the analyte in the sample in order to cancel their
interferences.
Reference material
A material or substance one or more
properties of which are sufficiently uniform and well known for use
to calibrate an instrument or apparatus, assign values to materials
and systems or assess CMPs.
Reference method
A method that is used to compare the
accuracy and uncertainty of routine methods.
Relative error
The ratio of an absolute error to the
reference value used to calculate it. Multiplying a relative error
by 100 gives a percent error.
Relative interpolation and extrapolation
methods
Relative quantification methods based on a
signal–concentration relation (a calibration curve).
Relative method
In Quantitative Analysis, a method based on
comparisons between measurements of the sample and of one or a set
of analytical standards. The output of such comparisons is the
result.
Relative standard deviation
An expression of the standard deviation in
relative terms (as a fraction of unity with respect to the mean for
the set of results).
Reliability
– A characteristic of a method (CMP)
defined as its ability to retain its accuracy and precision over
time. Related to robustness and transferability.
– The proportion of correct identifications
in individual qualitative tests performed on aliquots of the same
sample.
– A capital property in Qualitative
Analysis that combines accuracy and precision, and is assigned to
binary responses.
Repeatability
A manner of expressing precision. Defined
as the dispersion of the results of mutually independent tests
using the same method as applied to aliquots of the same sample, at
the same laboratory, by the same operator, using the same equipment
over a short interval of time.
Representativeness
A capital analytical property related to
consistency between the results, the samples received, the object,
the analytical problem and the socio-economic problem
addressed.
Reproducibility
A manner of expressing precision. Defined
as the dispersion of the results for mutually independent tests
performed by applying the same method to aliquots of the same
sample under different conditions: different operators, equipment,
days or laboratories.
Robustness
An analytical property of a CMP that
reflects its resistance to slight changes in the experimental
conditions under which it is performed.
Safety
An attribute of a laboratory or CMP related
to the absence of hazards to human health and/or the
environment.
Sample
A part (aliquot) of an object potentially
containing the analyte.
Bulk
sample or primary
sample . The result of the first selection from the object.
Usually of a large size.
Composite
sample . The result of combining several portions of a bulk
sample.
Convenience
sample . One selected in terms of availability,
cost-effectiveness, efficiency, etc.
Laboratory
sample . A portion of the object that is submitted, in an
appropriate container, to the laboratory for analysis.
Random
sample . One selected in such a way that any portion of the
object will have a specified probability (e.g,. 95%) of being
withdrawn.
Representative sample . A portion of the
object that is selected by applying a sampling plan consistent with
the analytical problem addressed.
Selective
sample . A sample that is collected by following a guided
sampling procedure.
Stratified
sample . One withdrawn from a stratum or well-defined zone
of the object.
Test
sample or aliquot .
The object portion that is eventually subjected to the analytical
process.
Sample collection
See “Sampling”.
Sample custody chain
The action or series of actions that
ensures an unequivocal relationship between the sample aliquot
subjected to a CMP and the result it produces (sample
traceability).
Sample matrix
Structure and chemical composition of the
sample to be analysed. Includes the analytes and all other
components.
Sample throughput
A measure of expeditiousness of CMPs. The
number of samples that can be processed per unit time (e.g., hour,
day).
Sample treatment
A general term used to refer to the
substeps of the preliminary operations of the CMP performed in
order to prepare the test sample or aliquot for measurement of the
analytical signal (second step of the CMP).
Sampling
An operation by which one or more portions
(aliquots) of an object are chosen for individual or joint
subjection (following size reduction) to a CMP. Sampling can be of
the intuitive, statistical, directed or protocol-based type.
Sampling error
A deviation in the representativeness of
the collected sample. Sampling errors can be accidental, systematic
or random in nature
Sampling plan
The strategy to be used in order to ensure
that the analytical results will be representative of the
analytical problem addressed.
Screening of analytes
A process used to systematically identify
analytes or analyte families in samples.
Screening of samples
Classifying a set of samples into two
groups according to (bio)chemical composition.
Secondary data
– Items of non-analytical information that
characterize the performance of apparatuses and instruments in the
analytical process.
– The lowest level in the information
hierarchy.
Selectivity
A basic analytical property of an
analytical method that is defined as the ability of the method to
produce results exclusively dependent on the analyte for its
identification or quantification in the sample.
Selectivity factor
A parameter describing the selectivity of a
method with respect to another. Defined as the quotient of the
tolerated interferent-to-analyte ratios obtained by using the two
methods to determine the same analyte in the same sample.
Semi-microanalysis
A type of chemical analysis where the
initial size of the sample aliquot subjected to the CMP ranges from
100 to 10 mg.
Sense, to
To use a device responding to the presence
or concentration of an analyte in a sample. Entails interacting
with an instrument proper.
Sensitivity
– A basic analytical property defined as
the ability of a method (CMP) to detect (qualify) and determine
(quantify) small amounts of analyte in a sample.
– The ability of a CMP to distinguish
between similar concentrations (amounts) of analyte.
Sensor
A portable, easy to use miniature device or
instrument that responds to the presence or concentration of an
analyte (or analyte family) in a sample. Usually connected to or
integrated in an instrument.
Separation
An operation involving mass transfer
between two phases. A crucial element of the preliminary operations
of a CMP. Discrete or continuous in nature.
Chromatographic separation . One where
distribution between phases reaches equilibrium many times (e.g.,
in a column, thus significantly enhancing the separation
efficiency.
Non-chromatographic separation . One
where mass transfer between phases reaches equilibrium only once or
a small number of times.
Simplification
A technological trend to reducing the
number of steps traditionally involved in CMPs in order to increase
expeditiousness and decrease costs.
Social responsibility (SR)
– Awareness of organizations (e.g, private
and public bodies) and individuals of the impact (consequences) of
their actions and decisions, which may directly or indirectly
affect stakeholders—who can in turn influence such actions and
decisions or those who make them.
– The next step to ultimate Quality: a
perfect mankind.
Social responsibility in Analytical
Chemistry
The impact of (bio)chemical knowledge
resulting from the analysis of objects and systems on society at
large, and on human and animal health, the environment, nutrition,
industry, etc.
Social responsibility principles
Cornerstones of Social Responsibility:
answerability, transparency, ethical conduct, meeting stakeholders’
expectations, and complying with national and international laws
and norms.
Socio-economic problem
– A question posed by the client that is to
be answered by delivering appropriate information.
– The origin of the analytical
problem.
Spatial analysis
Extraction of (bio)chemical information
from different zones of an object or system or from objects and
systems in outer space.
Speciation
A type of analysis that provides
qualitative and quantitative information about the different forms
in which an analyte may occur in a (usually environmental)
sample.
Specific uncertainty
The range of values where a result, a mean
of such values and the value held as true may fall with a given
probability. Similar to, but not the same, as precision. Can be
absolute, partial or zero.
Stakeholders
In the context of Social Responsibility
(applicable ISO norms), the individuals, groups, NGOs, etc.,
potentially affected by the decisions and actions of a body, in
which they can participate through ordinary procedures.
Standard
A tangible or intangible reference used to
support or perform analytical chemical measurements.
Base
standard . A standard that coincides with one of the seven
SI base units. Only the kilogram prototype is of the tangible type,
however.
Chemical
standard . A standard that can acts as a traceability link
between base (SI) standards and analytical chemical
standards.
Analytical
chemical standard . Any of the standards used in ordinary
analytical practice. Of the primary or secondary type.
Standard deviation
A statistical parameter that reflects the
precision of a set of results according to the theory of
Gauss.
Standard method
A method that is developed, validated and
specified in detail by a competent body.
Standard operating procedure (SOP)
A detailed description of how each
individual laboratory activity should be conducted. Each activity
should have an associated SOP. SOPs are related to Good Laboratory
Practices (GLP).
Standard sample
An artificial, naturally occurring or
modified natural material intended to simulate as closely as
possible an actual sample that possesses the properties of a
reference material or certified reference material.
Structural analysis
A type of chemical analysis by which the
structure of a sample (viz., the spatial distribution of its
constituents) or a pure analyte is established
Sustainable development
That meeting current needs without
compromising the ability of future generations to fulfil their
own.
Systematic error
An error ascribed to well-defined
operational alterations in a CMP that has the true value or the
value held as true as reference. Consistently positive or negative
in sign. Can be assigned to a result or a CMP.
Technique
A scientific principle used to obtain
analytical information by using an instrument.
Titrant
A reagent solution containing a referential
concentration (that is, one prepared from primary and analytical
standards) which is used in a titrimetry.
Titration
See “Titrimetry”.
Titration curve
A logarithmic or linear plot of the
monitored signal as a function of the titrant volume used in a
titration.
Titrimetry
A classical quantification technique
involving an absolute method based on the use of analytical
standards that relies on accurate measurements of the volume of
titrant solution required to react, in a quantitative manner, with
the analyte present in a sample. Can be of the direct or indirect
type and performed in a manual, semi-automatic, automatic or
automated manner.
Total index
A measurand describing the presence and/or
concentration of a family of analytes (e.g., total polyphenols in
tomatoes).
Trace analysis
An analytical process especially suitable
for the identification or quantification of analytes present in
proportions lower than 0.01% (100 ppm) in the sample.
Traceability
An attribute that characterizes various
analytical concepts. An abstract concept that integrates two
notions: tracing (the history of production or performance) and
relationship to standards.
Traceability
of an aliquot . An unequivocal relationship of a sample
aliquot subjected to a CMP to both the socio-economic problem
(representativeness) and the result (sample custody chain) which
thus assures consistency between the problem and the result (cyclic
traceability).
Traceability
of an instrument . The documented history of the performance
of an instrument (installation, malfunctioning, repairs, servicing,
calibration, correction, hours of use, samples processed, etc.).
Through calibration, the relationship to standards implicit in
traceability is established.
Traceability
of a result . A property of a result or of the value of
standard through which the result or value is related to
well-established national or international references via an
unbroken chain of comparisons characterized by their respective
uncertainties.
Traceable method
A method whose results (and uncertainties)
are linked to a well-known standard (e.g., a CRM).
Traces
A word used to designate analytes present
in proportions lower than 0.01% (100 ppm) in the sample.
Transducing
The process by which a raw signal produced
by an instrument is transformed into a (usually electrical)
measurable signal.
Transfer in Analytical Chemistry
The process by which basic and applied
knowledge and technology developed at Analytical Chemistry R&D
centres is supplied to routine analytical laboratories.
Transfer weights
Objects of fixed mass used to calibrate
balances. Available in various classes dependent on their
uncertainty and issuer.
Transferability
An attribute of a CMP that reflects its
ability to provide consistent results on application to the same
samples in different laboratories. Related to robustness and
reliability.
True value
The value corresponding to absolute
trueness: the analyte concentration in a sample with zero
uncertainty. Corresponds to ideal quality.
Ultra-microanalysis
A type of chemical analysis where the
initial size of the sample aliquot subjected to the CMP is less
than 1 mg.
Uncertainty range
A concept used in Qualitative Analysis
instead of specific uncertainty (Quantitative Analysis) even though
it has a different meaning. A feature of binary responses defined
as the concentration range around the threshold value where errors
(false positives and negatives) are made.
Validated method
A method whose properties have been
thoroughly studied and specified
Validation
– The experimental, documented
demonstration that an overall process (CMP) or a particular step
(e.g., sampling, data processing) has developed and will continue
to develop as expected.
– The experimental, documented
demonstration that an object (e.g., an apparatus, an instrument)
possesses and will continue to possess specific properties.
Value held as true
A datum (accompanied by its uncertainty)
derived by chemometric treatment of the results obtained by having
many different laboratories process aliquots of the same sample (a
CRM) to determine the same analyte. Corresponds to referential
quality.
Volatilization
A separation technique occasionally used
for gravimetric purposes that relies on the mass difference of the
sample prior to and after controlled heating in the presence or
absence of a reagent.
Volumetric factor
A dimensionless number by which the
approximate concentration of a titrant solution prepared from a
secondary standard is to be multiplied in order to calculate the
actual concentration. Obtained by experimentation and
computation.
White sample
A sample with well-defined properties
which, with few exceptions, remain virtually constant on the
whole.