Chapter 1

Midway into the fifth round the kid in the blue trunks rocked his opponent with a solid left to the jaw. He followed it with a straight right to the head.

“He’s ready to fall,” Mick Ballou said.

He looked it, too, but when the kid in blue waded in the other boy slipped a punch and groped his way into a clinch. I got a look at his eyes before the referee stepped between the two fighters. They looked glazed, unfocused.

“How much time is there?”

“More than a minute.”

“Plenty of time,” Mick said. “Watch your man take the lad right out. For a small man he’s strong as a bull.”

They weren’t that small. Junior middleweights, which I guess would put them somewhere around 155 pounds. I used to know the weight limits for all the classes, but it was easy then. Now they’ve got more than twice as many classifications, with junior this and super that, and three different governing bodies each recognizing a different champion. I think the trend must have started when someone figured out that it was easier to promote a title bout, and it’s getting to the point where you rarely see anything else.

The card we were watching, however, was strictly non-title, and a long way removed from the glamour and showmanship of championship fights staged in Vegas and Atlantic City casinos. We were, to be precise, in a concrete-block shed on a dark street in Maspeth, an industrial wasteland in the borough of Queens bordered on the south and west by the Greenpoint and Bushwick sections of Brooklyn and set off from the rest of Queens by a half-circle of cemeteries. You could live a lifetime in New York without ever getting to Maspeth, or you could drive through it dozens of times without knowing it. With its warehouses and factories and drab residential streets, Maspeth’s not likely to be on anybody’s short list for potential gentrification, but I suppose you never know. Sooner or later they’ll run out of other places, and the crumbling warehouses will be reborn as artists’ lofts while young urban homesteaders rip the rotted asphalt siding from the row houses and set about gutting the interiors. You’ll have ginkgo trees lining the sidewalk on Grand Avenue, and a Korean greengrocer on every corner.

For now, though, the New Maspeth Arena was the only sign I’d seen of the neighborhood’s glorious future. Some months earlier Madison Square Garden had closed the Felt Forum for renovations, and sometime in early December the New Maspeth Arena had opened with a card of boxing matches every Thursday night, with the first prelim getting under way around seven.

The building was smaller than the Felt Forum, and had a no-frills feel to it, with untrimmed concrete-block walls and a sheet-metal roof and a poured concrete slab for a floor. It was rectangular in shape, and the boxing ring stood in the center of one of the long walls, opposite the entrance doors. Rows of metal folding chairs framed the ring’s three open sides. The chairs were gray, except for the first two rows in each of the three sections, which were blood red. The red seats at ringside were reserved. The rest of the arena was open seating, and a seat was only five dollars, which was two dollars less than the price of a first-run movie in Manhattan. Even so, almost half of the gray chairs remained unoccupied.

The price was low in order to fill as many of the seats as possible, so that the fans who watched the fights on cable TV wouldn’t realize the event had been staged solely on their behalf. The New Maspeth Arena was a cable phenomenon, thrown up to furnish programming for FBCS, Five Borough Cable Sportscasts, the latest sports channel trying to get a toehold in the New York metro area. The FBCS trucks had been parked outside when Mick and I arrived a few minutes after seven, and at eight o’clock their coverage began.

Now the fifth round of the final prelim fight was ending with the boy in the white trunks still on his feet. Both fighters were black, both local kids from Brooklyn, one introduced as hailing from Bedford-Stuyvesant, the other from Crown Heights. Both had short haircuts and regular features, and they were the same height, although the kid in blue looked shorter in the ring because he fought in a crouch. It’s good their trunks were different colors or it would have been tough to tell them apart.

“He should have had him there,” Mick said. “The other lad was ready to go and he couldn’t finish him.”

“The boy in the white has heart,” I said.

“He was glassy-eyed. What’s his name, the one in blue?” He looked at the program, a single sheet of blue paper with the bouts listed. “McCann,” he said. “McCann let him off the hook.”

“He was all over him.”

“He was, and punching away at him, but he couldn’t pull the trigger. There’s a lot of them like that, they get their man in trouble and then they can’t put him down. I don’t know why it is.”

“He’s got three rounds left.”

Mick shook his head. “He had his chance,” he said.


HE was right. McCann won the remaining three rounds handily, but the fight was never closer to a knockout than it had been in the fifth. At the final bell they clung together briefly in a sweaty embrace, and then McCann bopped over to his corner with his gloves raised in triumph. The judges agreed with him. Two of them had him pitching a shutout, while the third man had the kid in white winning a round.

“I’ll get a beer,” Mick said. “Will you have something?”

“Not right now.”

We were in the first row of gray chairs over on the right-hand side of the ring as you entered. That way I could keep an eye on the entrance, although I hadn’t been looking anywhere much outside the ring. I looked over there now while Mick made his way to the refreshment stand at the far end of the hall, and for a change I saw someone I recognized, a tall black man in a well-tailored navy pinstripe suit. I stood up at his approach and we shook hands.

“I thought it was you,” he said. “I ducked in before to watch a couple minutes of Burdette and McCann from the back, and I thought I saw my friend Matthew over here in the cheap seats.”

“They’re all cheap seats in Maspeth.”

“Isn’t that the truth.” He put a hand on my shoulder. “First time I saw you was at the fights, wasn’t it? The Felt Forum?”

“That’s right.”

“You were with Danny Boy Bell.”

“You were with Sunny. I don’t remember her last name.”

“Sunny Hendryx. Sonya, her name was, but nobody ever called her that.”

I said, “Join us, why don’t you? My friend’s getting a beer, but the whole row’s empty, or almost. If you don’t mind sitting in a cheap seat.”

He grinned. “I got a seat,” he said. “Over by the blue corner. Got to cheer my man to victory. You remember Kid Bascomb, don’t you?”

“Of course I do. He was on the card the night we met, he beat some Italian kid that I don’t remember at all.”

“Nobody does.”

“He took the heart out of him with a body punch, I remember that. The Kid’s not fighting tonight, is he? He’s not on the program.”

“No, he’s retired. He hung ’em up a couple of years ago.”

“That’s what I thought.”

“He’s sitting right over there,” he said, pointing. “No, my man in the main event’s Eldon Rasheed. He ought to win, but the boy he’s fighting is sitting on eleven wins and two defeats, and one of those they stole the decision from him. So he’s not just an opponent.”

He was talking about fight strategy when Mick came back carrying two large paper cups. One held beer, the other Coke. “In case you get thirsty,” he said. “I wouldn’t care to stand in that long a line for a single beer.”

I said, “Mickey Ballou, Chance—”

“Chance Coulter.”

“A pleasure,” Mick said. He was still holding on to both drinks, so they couldn’t shake hands.

“Here comes Dominguez now,” Chance said. The fighter came down the aisle flanked by his retinue. He wore a royal-blue robe with navy piping. He was good-looking, with a long, square-jawed face and a neat black mustache. He smiled and waved at fans, then climbed up into the ring.

“He looks good,” Chance said. “Eldon may have his hands full.”

“You’re supporting the other one?” Mick asked.

“Yes, Eldon Rasheed. Here he comes now. Maybe we can all have a drink afterward.”

I said that sounded good. Chance made his way over to his seat near the blue corner. Mick gave me both cups to hold while he settled himself in his seat. “ ‘Eldon Rasheed versus Peter Dominguez,’ “ he read. “Where do they get their names?”

“Peter Dominguez is a pretty straightforward name,” I said.

He gave me a look. “Eldon Rasheed,” he pronounced, as Rasheed climbed through the ropes. “Well, if it was a beauty contest, you’d have to hand it to Pedro. Rasheed looks as though God hit him in the face with a shovel.”

“Why would God do a thing like that?”

“Why does God do half the things He does? Your friend Chance is a good-looking man. How do you come to know him?”

“I did some work for him a few years ago.”

“Detective work?”

“That’s right.”

“I thought he looked like a lawyer. Dresses the part.”

“Actually he’s a dealer in African art.”

“Carvings, like?”

“That sort of thing.”

The announcer was in the ring, ballyhooing the coming bout and doing what he could to hype next week’s card. He introduced a local welterweight who’d be fighting in next week’s main event, then called up a few other celebrities seated at ringside, including Arthur “Kid” Bascomb. The Kid got the same lackadaisical round of applause that had greeted everyone else.

The referee got an introduction, and the three judges, and the timekeeper, and the guy whose job it was to count in the event of a knockdown. He figured to get some work tonight; the fighters were heavyweights, and both had knocked out most of their previous opponents. Eight of Dominguez’s eleven wins were by knockout, and Rasheed, undefeated in ten professional bouts, had only had one fight that had gone the distance.

Dominguez got a big hand from an Hispanic contingent at the far end of the arena. Rasheed’s ovation was more restrained. They huddled together in the center of the ring while the referee told them nothing that they didn’t already know, then touched gloves and went back to their corners. The bell rang and the fight got under way.

The first round was largely exploratory, but both fighters landed some shots. Rasheed worked nicely off a strong left jab and went to the body effectively. He moved well for a man his size. Dominguez was awkward in comparison, an ungainly fighter, but he had a straight overhand right that was very sudden, and he caught Rasheed over the left eye with it with thirty seconds to go in the round. Rasheed shook it off, but you could see he felt it.

Between rounds Mick said, “He’s strong, that Pedro. He might have stolen the round with that punch.”

“I never know how they’ll score it.”

“A few more blows like that last and there’ll be no need to keep score.”

Rasheed had the edge in the second round. He stayed away from the right and landed some solid body shots. During the round I happened to notice a man sitting at ringside in the center section. I’d noticed him before, and something made me look at him again.

He was around forty-five, balding, with dark brown hair and prominent eyebrows. He was cleanshaven. He had a lumpy sort of a face, as though he might have been a fighter once himself, but if so I figured they would have introduced him. They were not exactly awash in celebrities, and anybody who’d gone three rounds in the Golden Gloves stood a good chance of being called up to take a bow for the FBCS cameras. And he was right at ringside; all he’d have had to do was climb over the ropes and bask in the applause.

There was a boy with him, and the man had one arm around him, his hand resting on the boy’s shoulder while he gestured with the other hand, pointing things out in the ring. I assumed they were father and son, although I couldn’t see much resemblance; the boy, in his early teens, had light brown hair with a sharply defined widow’s peak. Any widow’s peak the father might have had was long gone. The father wore a blue blazer and gray flannel slacks. His tie was light blue, with black or navy polka dots, big ones, close to an inch in diameter. The boy wore a red plaid flannel shirt and navy corduroy pants.

I couldn’t think how I knew him.


THE third round looked even to me. I didn’t keep count, but I had the impression that Rasheed landed more punches. Dominguez hit him a few good shots, though, and they had more authority than the ones Rasheed got in. When the round ended I didn’t look over at the man with the polka-dot tie because I was looking instead at another man.

This one was younger, thirty-two to be exact. He stood about five-eleven and he was built like a light heavyweight. He had shucked his suit jacket and tie and was wearing a white button-down shirt with a blue stripe. He approached the sort of handsomeness you see in menswear catalogs, a combination of chiseled features and attitude, spoiled by a little too much fullness in the pouty lower lip and a brutish thickness to the nose. A full head of dark hair, styled and blown dry. A tan, a souvenir of a week in Antigua.

His name was Richard Thurman, and he was producing the telecast for Five Borough Cable Sportscasts. He was standing on the ring apron now, outside of the ropes, talking to a cameraman. The girl with the placard came around, showing us that the fourth round was coming up next, and showing us a bit more than that in her abbreviated costume. The audience at home would miss that part of the show. They’d be watching a beer commercial while she showed the world what she had. She was a tall, leggy girl with a lush figure, and she was displaying a lot of skin.

She came over to the camera and said something to Thurman, and he reached out a hand and gave her a pat on the fanny. She didn’t seem to notice. Maybe he was used to touching women and she was used to being touched. Maybe they were old friends. She was all pink, though, so it seemed unlikely that he’d taken her along to Antigua.

She got out of the ring and he climbed down and they rang the warning bell. The fighters got off their stools and it was time for Round Four.

In the first minute of the round Dominguez got the straight right in and opened up a cut over Rasheed’s left eye. Rasheed jabbed a lot and hammered Dominguez with body punches, and toward the end of the round snapped his head back with a good uppercut. Dominguez landed another good right at the bell. I had no idea how to score the round, and said as much to Mick.

“No matter,” he said. “It’ll never go ten.”

“Who do you like?”

“I like the black fellow,” he said, “but I don’t care for his chances. Pedro’s too fucking strong.”

I looked over at the man and the boy. “That fellow over there,” I said. “First row, sitting next to the kid. Blue jacket, polka-dot tie.”

“What about him?”

“I think I know him,” I said, “but I can’t place him. Do you recognize him?”

“Never saw him before.”

“I can’t think where I know him from.”

“He looks like a cop.”

“No,” I said. “Do you really think so?”

“I’m not saying he’s a cop, I’m saying he has that look. You know who he looks like? It’s an actor who plays cops, I can’t think of his name. It’ll come to me.”

“An actor who plays cops. They all play cops.”

“Gene Hackman,” he said.

I looked again. “Hackman’s older,” I said. “And thinner. This guy’s burly where Hackman’s sort of wiry. And Hackman’s got more hair, doesn’t he?”

“Jesus help us,” he said. “I didn’t say he was Hackman. I said that’s who he looks like.”

“If it was Hackman they’d have made him come up and take a bow.”

“If it was Hackman’s fucking cousin they’d have made him take a bow, desperate as they are.”

“But you’re right,” I said. “There’s a definite resemblance.”

“Not that he’s the spitting image, mind you, but—”

“But there’s a resemblance. That’s not why he looks familiar. I wonder where I know him from.”

“One of your meetings, maybe.”

“That’s possible.”

“Unless that’s a beer he’s drinking. If he’s a member of your lot he wouldn’t be drinking a beer, would he now?”

“Probably not.”

“Although not all of your lot make it, do they?”

“No, not all of us do.”

“Well then, let’s hope it’s a Coke in his cup,” he said. “Or if it’s a beer, let’s pray he gives it to the lad.”


DOMINGUEZ got the better of it in the fifth round. A lot of his big punches missed, but a couple got through and hurt Rasheed. He rallied nicely at the end but the round still clearly belonged to the Latin fighter.

In the sixth, Rasheed took a straight right to the jaw and went down.

It was a solid knockdown and it brought the crowd to its feet. Rasheed was up at five and took the mandatory eight count, and when the ref motioned for them to resume fighting Dominguez rushed in swinging for the fences. Rasheed was wobbly but he showed a lot of class, ducking, slipping punches, playing for time in clinches, fighting back gamely. The knockdown came fairly early in the round, but at the end of the three minutes Rasheed was still on his feet.

“One more round,” Mick Ballou said.

“No.”

“Oh?”

“He had his chance,” I said. “Like that fellow in the last bout, what was his name? The Irishman.”

“The Irishman? What Irishman?”

“McCann.”

“Ah. Black Irish, that would be. You think Dominguez is another one who doesn’t know how to pull the trigger?”

“He knows how, he just didn’t have what he needed. He threw too many punches. Punching tires you, especially when you don’t hit anything. I think the round took more out of him than it did out of Rasheed.”

“You think it’ll go to the judges? They’ll give it to Pedro then, unless your man Chance put the fix in.”

You wouldn’t fix a fight like that. There’s no betting. I said, “It won’t go to a decision. Rasheed’ll knock him out.”

“Matt, you’re dreaming.”

“You’ll see.”

“Do you want to bet? I don’t want to bet money, not with you. What shall we bet?”

“I don’t know.”

I looked over at the father and son. Something was hovering at the edge of thought, nagging at me.

“If I win,” he said, “we’ll make a night of it and go to the eight o’clock mass at St. Bernard’s. The butchers’ mass.”

“And if I win?”

“Then we won’t go.”

I laughed. “That’s a great bet,” I said. “We’re already not going, so what would I be winning?”

“All right then,” he said. “If you win I’ll go to a meeting.”

“A meeting?”

“A fucking AA meeting.”

“Why would you want to do that?”

“I wouldn’t want to do it,” he said. “Isn’t that the fucking point? I’d be doing it because I lost the bet.”

“But why would I want you to go to a meeting?”

“I don’t know.”

“If you ever want to go,” I said, “I’ll be happy to take you. But I certainly don’t want you to go on my account.”

The father put his hand on the boy’s forehead and smoothed his hair back. There was something about the gesture that hit me like a hard right hand to the heart. Mick said something but I’d gone momentarily deaf to it. I had to ask him to repeat it.

“Then I guess there’s no bet,” he said.

“I guess not.”

The bell rang. The fighters rose from their stools.

“It’s just as well,” he said. “I think you’re right. I think that fucking Pedro punched himself out.”


THAT’S how it turned out. It wasn’t that clear-cut in the seventh round because Dominguez was still strong enough to land a few shots that got the crowd cheering. But it was easier to get the crowd on its feet than to knock Rasheed off his, and he looked as strong as ever, and confident in the bargain. Late in the round he landed a short stiff right to the solar plexus and Mick and I looked at each other and nodded. Nobody had cheered, nobody had shouted, but that was the fight, and we knew it and so did Eldon Rasheed. I think Dominguez did, too.

Between rounds Mick said, “I got to hand it to you. You saw something in the round before that I never saw. All those body punches, they’re money in the bank, aren’t they? They don’t look like anything at all, and then all at once your man has no legs under him. Speaking of legs.”

The placard girl was letting us know that Round Eight was next.

“She looks familiar, too,” I said.

“You met her at a meeting,” he suggested.

“Somehow I don’t think so.”

“No, you’d remember her, wouldn’t you? A dream, then. You were with her in a dream.”

“That’s more like it.” I looked from her to the man with the polka-dot tie, then back at her again. “They say that’s one of the ways you know you’re middle-aged,” I said. “When everybody you meet reminds you of somebody else.”

“Is that what they say?”

“Well, that’s one of the things they say,” I said, and they rang the bell for the eighth round. Two minutes into it Eldon Rasheed staggered Peter Dominguez with a brutal left hook to the liver. Dominguez’s hands fell and Rasheed dropped him with a right cross to the jaws.

He was up at eight, but it must have been pure machismo that got him on his feet. Rasheed was all over him, and three shots to the midsection put Dominguez on the canvas again. This time the ref didn’t even bother to count. He stepped between the fighters and raised Rasheed’s arms overhead.

Most of the same people who’d been rooting for a Dominguez knockout were on their feet again now, cheering for Rasheed.


WE were standing next to Chance and Kid Bascomb, over by the blue corner, when the ring announcer quieted the crowd and told us what we already knew, that the referee had stopped the fight after two minutes and thirty-eight seconds of the eighth round, that the winner by a technical knockout was Eldon “the Bulldog” Rasheed. There were two more four-round bouts to follow, he added, and we wouldn’t want to miss a minute of the nonstop boxing action here at the New Maspeth Arena.

The boxers competing in those two four-rounders had a thankless task ahead of them, because they were going to be playing to a near-empty house. The fights were on the card as insurance for FBCS. If the prelims had finished early, one of them would have been shoehorned in before the main event; if Rasheed had kayoed Dominguez in the second round, or been knocked out himself, there would be a bout or two left to fill up the television time slot.

But it was almost eleven now, so neither of the remaining bouts would make it onto the screen. And just about everybody was heading for home, like baseball fans streaming out of Dodger Stadium in the seventh inning of a tie game.

Richard Thurman was in the ring now, helping his cameraman pack up his gear. I didn’t see the placard girl anywhere. I didn’t see the father and son team from ringside, either, although I looked for them, thinking I’d point them out to Chance and see if he recognized the man.

The hell with it. Nobody was paying me to figure out why some doting father looked familiar. My job was to get a line on Richard Thurman, and to find out whether or not he had murdered his wife.

Matthew Scudder #09 - A Dance at the Slaughterhouse
titlepage.xhtml
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_000.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_001.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_002.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_003.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_004.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_005.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_006.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_007.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_008.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_009.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_010.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_011.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_012.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_013.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_014.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_015.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_016.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_017.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_018.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_019.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_020.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_021.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_022.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_023.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_024.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_025.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_026.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_027.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_028.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_029.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_030.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_031.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_032.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_033.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_034.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_035.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_036.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_037.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_038.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_039.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_040.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_041.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_042.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_043.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_044.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_045.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_046.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_047.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_048.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_049.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_050.html
A_Dance_at_the_Slaughterhouse_split_051.html